I'm really interested in this TL but I'm having a hard time following (no offense to the detail level!). Anybody care to summarize?
Also, anything about Sherman?
Is there anything I can do with my present to help keep things clear?
I'm really interested in this TL but I'm having a hard time following (no offense to the detail level!). Anybody care to summarize?
Also, anything about Sherman?
Is there anything I can do with my present to help keep things clear?
Today's question: should Lee abandon Richmond or fight street to street/house to house?
If Lee abandons the city he will finally be free of having to defend/screen the city. He can add the garrison troops to his army. He also doesn't have to worry about policing a difficult population. The city fathers will be happy and the civilian population will be spared the horror of an urban battleground. Kearny will then have to leave troops behind to garrison the city (and Petersburg) and ties him down to screening the city. Lee however looses him main supply base (all be it an unreliable one), the President will go apeshit, and it will be a major morale defeat for the Confederacy.
If Lee stays and fights the city will certainly be laid waste whoever wins. The population of the city will suffer tremendously (they already hate Davis). It will be brutal street fighting over which Lee will have little control. Onces that kind of fighting starts it maybe difficult to withdraw - large pockets of troops may be cut off. The President may order the city's defence. The South will struggle if they loose Richmond's industry.
What should Lee do? Fight or flight?
Today's question: should Lee abandon Richmond or fight street to street/house to house?
If Lee abandons the city he will finally be free of having to defend/screen the city. He can add the garrison troops to his army. He also doesn't have to worry about policing a difficult population. The city fathers will be happy and the civilian population will be spared the horror of an urban battleground. Kearny will then have to leave troops behind to garrison the city (and Petersburg) and ties him down to screening the city. Lee however looses him main supply base (all be it an unreliable one), the President will go apeshit, and it will be a major morale defeat for the Confederacy.
If Lee stays and fights the city will certainly be laid waste whoever wins. The population of the city will suffer tremendously (they already hate Davis). It will be brutal street fighting over which Lee will have little control. Onces that kind of fighting starts it maybe difficult to withdraw - large pockets of troops may be cut off. The President may order the city's defence. The South will struggle if they loose Richmond's industry.
What should Lee do? Fight or flight?
If the Confederacy loses Richmond, there are several key points. Having lost its "capital", it loses whatever overseas political legitimacy it might have left at this point. This also means that even within the unoccupied CSA the value of Confederate currency drops with rampant inflation. The Tredegar works are the only large foundry in the CSA, lose that and the ability of the CSA to manufacture cannon, rails, armor for ironclads, etc is reduced from small to almost nil. Lastly, the CSA's bureaucracy is dispersed and rendered totally ineffective. No matter that the "central government" was weak compared to the Union, absent some sort of functioning central authority coordination of military activity and especially any sort of rational distribution of the already scarce military supplies goes away. Some units may be awash (relatively) in food or boots or whatever while another unit elsewhere is rendered ineffective due to lack of same.
The reality is that fighting house to house in Richmond will impose a terrible cost on both armies, but the Union can afford those losses if the ANV is effectively destroyed then game over. Even if Lee "wins" a "Stalingrad" in Richmond, his army is trashed as is the city - a Pyrrhic victory at best - IMHO the ANV can't win a battle in Richmond, all they can do is bleed the AoP while destroying themselves and the city. Unlike the Soviets at Stalingrad, the CSA is on the wrong end of the manpower pool equation.
FWIW a city battle will be very ugly - you'll see a slave insurrection (with ugliness from the slaves against the whites and brutality the other way) & the presence of armed Negro units in the fight......
It's a lose-lose for Lee but militarily if he can retreat and keep the ANV intact he can at least hope. If the ANV is wrecked, game over. Lee will elect to retreat to fight again another day - but will Davis let him or will he be ordered to fight in the city, or even be relieved & replaced by a general willing to do that....
No matter that the "central government" was weak compared to the Union....
I'm surprise Kearny doesn't go for the siege - no house-to-house, but he can starve out Lee and take away the AoNV's fighting capability.
MORE!!!