Recent content by mike of mass

  1. No Nazis but continued antisemitism on the European Continent, what happens?

    Why is there an assumption that without the Nazis political antisemitism would be business as usual rather than escalate? Some of these scenarios indicate Jews willing to be slave labour and penal battalions. I would think the prospect would send them looking for anywhere but Europe...
  2. Mandate of Syria and the Lebanon joins Free France in 1940

    Why would this eliminate the Iraqi Pro Nazi revolt? This was instigated by the Nazis not the Vichy regime. Were the rebels counting on Vichy France to aid or secure their flanks? I have not read anything about their strategic thinking. Most likely the revolt would still go on but be crushed...
  3. No Nazis but continued antisemitism on the European Continent, what happens?

    Is the POD no nazis or no WW2? If there are no nazis but WW2 still occurs do the Germans get crushed again with out a Hitler messing up the army's plans? If they do then the Russian advance throughout eastern Europe , Stalin's desire to oust the British from the mid east and his own hatred...
  4. Would there be a mass genocide against Israelis if Israel lost the 1948 War?

    The assumption that the Arab/Muslim leaders would care about Western opinion enough to spare the Jews is projection. The concept of world opinion is a construction of late 20th century media. Information did not travel that fast. Furthermore it projects late 20th century/early 21st century...
  5. What if no 1990s invasion of Kuwait?

    We likely won't see the post gulf war regional conference which spawned the Oslo peace process. Arafat remains marginalized. This may allow the local leadership to take a more prominent role in starting negotiations with the Israelis. Anti missile systems get delayed as the example of SCUDs over...
  6. What if Jordan's monarchy was overthrown in 1958?

    If the coup transforms Jordan into Palestine the Israelis may actually be pleased with the outcome
  7. Would there be a mass genocide against Israelis if Israel lost the 1948 War?

    No the point is everyone Arab and Israeli thought of it as a zero sum game and the fact that the Arab / Palestinian group overestimated themselves and lost does not make them sympathetic figures in any way.
  8. Would there be a mass genocide against Israelis if Israel lost the 1948 War?

    No one forced the Arab world to give him that opportunity
  9. Would there be a mass genocide against Israelis if Israel lost the 1948 War?

    Just as the Druze, Circassians and Muslim Bedouins allied with the Jews
  10. Would there be a mass genocide against Israelis if Israel lost the 1948 War?

    This would be the same Jordanian legion that blew up EVERY synagogue in Hashemite occupied Jerusalem.
  11. Would there be a mass genocide against Israelis if Israel lost the 1948 War?

    I would be interested in reading your source
  12. Would there be a mass genocide against Israelis if Israel lost the 1948 War?

    The Arab side was actively boasting that the war in '48 would be a massacre to rival the Mongol invasions. Given how effective the Nazis were in bringing European style antisemitism to the Arab world, a massacre would have been inevitable had they won.
  13. AHC: Israel keeps the Sinai Peninsula

    Sadat get's "retired" when he tries to send home his Soviet Advisors. His successor selected by Moscow, initiates the Yom Kippur war with the same mistakes made on both sides. However, this time around the US has no interest in saving the Egyptian third army after Sharon's counter crossing...
  14. Arab oil boycott would have resulted in a real breakthrough in renewable energies

    The reason it ended was that the Saudis quickly learned that if they don't sell their oil to the West they don't eat. It didn't help that it spurred the exploration of North sea oil, Alaskan oil, Mexican gulf oil places that were not commercially viable until the embargo raised the price of oil.
Top