Of Rajahs and Hornbills: A timeline of Brooke Sarawak

Nice timeline here. I really dig the weirdness. :D

By the way before you go further about Sulu (I guessed it already) just a heads up: in OTL 1876, the Spanish launched a successful invasion and occupation of Jolo - Sulu's capital (it lasted roughly until the end of the Philippine Revolution). It was where things started to go downhill for the sultanate.
 
GUEST POST: The Third war of Independence (Part II)
The Third war of Independence Part II



The Naval Forces
While on the paper, the new expansion program wanted by the Count had created a Navy with ships more modern than that of Austria-Hungary, the great majority of them were built in different foreign yard, as Italy for the moment was incapable to produce modern ships. Naturally acquiring new ships was just one of the problems of the Regia Marina; there was also the need to integrate men and officers of the various pre-unitary navies, especially the Piedmontese and the Bourbon whose rivalry was many time crippling.

The refusal to confirm the various promotion given by Garibaldi during the conquest of the Bourbon Kingdom, due to the fear of Republican feeling of the officers in question was another morale problem for the newly created Navy; one that greatly augmented the tension among the personnel.
Among the other problems for the Italians there were a general scarcity of trained technical personnel and officers, not counting the fact that many don’t spoke Italian but a series of dialect sometime barely recognizable; finally many of the new ships had various technical problem or had been built with subpar material.

At the beginning of April, the government decided to form a naval force with the assignment to wage war against the Austrian Empire. The officer assigned to lead it Admiral Carlo Pellion of Persano, after an inspection at the base of Ancona, reported to the King and Prime Minister the condition of the Navy and declared that at least three months were needed to bring it in fighting condition; in the end Cavour gave him only two. (1)

Persano was a Sardinian officer that many in the Navy and in the political circles considered mediocre and whose advancements were obtained more due to ‘friends in high place’ than true talent. Cavour himself years before had expressed the intention to bring him to the court martial for almost sinking of the Royal yacht, while the royal family was on board and even the King never forget or really forgive that accident. Unfortunately for both the ruler and the Minister he was the only naval officer with experience and politically reliable; at least Persano obtained as Chief of Staff Captain Amilcare Anguissola, a trusted friend. (2)

Guided by Wilhelm Von Tegettoff, a veteran of the recent Danish conflict, the K.u.K Kriegsmarine, on the other side, while inferior numerical and for tonnage, had her ships built by national yards, so tuned to her necessity, and in general more reliable. Even the crew were more uniform and have a better training thanks to the Naval School at Venice, nevertheless in the weeks before the conflict, the Admiral augmented the numbers and the intensity of the drills.

The Initial Naval Activity
As previous order, the 18th June the Fleet left Taranto and headed towards Ancona, her new base of operation for the duration of the conflict. The ships arrived 4 days later, with a cruise speed of only 5 knots so to not put too much strain in the engine. The port of Ancona were too little to hold all the ships, so the great part of them were forced to stay out in the harbor, moored at buoys.

Without specific order and in need to continue the maintenance of his fleet and the training of the men, Admiral Persano decided to remain at his base only sending some scout to keep an eye on the Austrian activity.

The first encounter with the enemy happened 27 June, when the scout Messaggiere discovered a 12 ship strong Austrian squadron in route to Ancona. Persano, using the Re D’Italia as flagships and with nine other armored unit, all the combat worthy ships in his possession, sailed from his base to intercept it. Tegetthoff decided in the end to not engage the enemy and ordered at the squadron to return at the base. The only shoots fired during this action were the three round from the armored frigate Regina Maria Pia against the steamwheeler Greif, but all missed their target and later Persano order the cease-fire. (3)
Later in a reunion with his officers, Persano decided to not follow the enemy and go back at Ancona.

After he created a tight surveillance service while continuing the training of the crew and the maintenance of the ships, so to bring all at the most high level of efficiency possible.

Consequence of Sadowa
After the initial battle at Custoza, the situation on the Italian front had become relative quiet, neither La Marmora (even if prodded by both the King and Cavour to be more aggressive) or the Archduke desired another engagement on open field at the moment. The only action of the Italian forces was to start the siege at the ‘Quadrilatero Fortress’ and the Austrian used the time for further fortify their position.

The Prussian victory at Sadowa soon changed this dynamic.

The day after the defeat, the Austrian government asked the mediation of Napoleon III, proposing to give to him Veneto (so to later give it to the Italians) if Italy accepted a ceasefire and left the war.
The French Emperor, accepting the Austrian request, sent a telegram to Vittorio Emanuele II, explaining the proposal.
This was one of the rare occasion were both the King and the Prime Minister perfectly agreed on a line of action, even for different reason.
The two men were on the same side regarding refusing the offer, the King because he found it not honorable besides he found Napoleon meddling too intrusive. Cavour instead thought that give up an ally in this manner will have dire future consequence for the diplomatic position of Italy and he had further plan for the war and the French mediation attempt were an obstacle.

La Marmora under heavy political pressure, even Bismarck have complained about the Italian war effort or better the lack of it, decided to finally send two division to Garibaldi (lead by Medici and Bixio, two of Garibaldi former adjutant) in Trentino and to start the full invasion of Veneto, leaving just 6 division (commanded by Cadorna) to continue the block of the Quadrilatero fortress.
Now the general situation were more favorable to Italy, as many Austrians troops were moved north to fight against the Prussian.

Even Persano was strongly encouraged to take action otherwise another will have took his place, this fixation of Cavour for some naval action were a great source of attrition between him and the Army leaderships. In fact many general in fact thought that the resources spent in ‘vastly overprized toys’ were wasted instead to be correctly used to support the real backbone of the Kingdom. The Prime Minister instead was a firm believer of naval power and the importance of possessing a strong Navy, so he felt that a naval victory was the only way to be vindicated.

The Italian Army Advance.
La Marmora rapidly advanced in all Veneto, with just the occasionally but hard fight against the remainder Austrian forces and by the time of the cease-fire, the first units were a couple of km from the Isonzo.

The harshest fights of the second part of the campaign happened in Trentino, were the renewed offensive by Garibaldi was supported by two division sent by La Marmora (4); the latter probably sent to demonstrate some initiative and make the politicians and the King stop, at least for a moment, the strong demand for action.

General Khun attempted some counterattack, but were initially too weak to stop the enemy. This was part of the General plan; he wanted to concentrate his forces in an attempt to launch an attack when the volunteers finally started their assault at Trento. While this counterattack was successful and the Garibaldini were unable to encircle the Austrian position being beaten in the Battle of Condino, the Austrian lacked the forces to follow the enemy and launch their offensive, so Khum was forced to order at his men to just retake their position and remain there.

The final straw for the Austrian come the 10th when Bixio and Medici division started their assault on Trentino, forcing Khum troops to fight a two front war. Khum, after having received just three regiment from Verona as reinforcement, attempted to block the Italian southern advance at the beginning, blocking the Primolano Pass.
The 12th after the position had been taken and retaken by either side many times, the Italian definitely conquered Primolano, forcing Khum to a total redistribution of the troops, so to be prepared at the Siege of Trento.

At the same time, the General had obtained the permission from the Archduke to leave the Italian Tyrol and concentrate over the protection of Bozen. Khum was intentioned to not leave the city without a fight, so he prepared his troops for a battle right in front of Trento and for a general retreat. He was sure that the Italians will have let him go away as they seemed that their objective was occupy as much of Trentino they can and not destroy him.

The battle of Trento was short, hard fought and bloody, with the numerical superior Italians lead by relatively inexperienced Generals, fighting against troops lead by one of the best Austrian commander. Khum in a couple of occasion almost succeeded in encircle the Italians but the enemy sheer number and the menace of Garibaldi forced plus a little luck for Medici (a cavalry unit attacked without permission alerting the Italian of the presence of a larger force) forced the Austrian to leave the terrain quickly.

Sunday 15th June 1866 Italian troops finally enter in Trento.

BATTLE OF LISSA
Choosing the objectives
The Prime Minister, the King and other politicians and military commander pressed Persano to take the fleet out and engage the enemy. The moment was critical both politically and military and the indecision, some said even cowardice, of the Navy was a stain on Italy honor, with the menace of being dismissed looming over him, Persano finally decided to launch an operation directly against the Hapsburg territory, hoping to lure out the enemy fleet.

He proposed the attack and the conquest of Lissa, an island of Dalmatia were a naval base was present; Persano requested at least 6.000 soldiers for the effective conquest and control of the island, but for scarcity of ships, only the half was authorized for the initial assault(5), the rest will have come later.

The 16th July 1866, an Italian fleet composed by 24 ships (included the just arrived Affondatore) sailed from Ancona with objective the fortified island of Lissa. Using map prepared years earlier(6), Persano and his officers prepared their plan, thinking that the target could be conquered with a surprise attack. The commander divided his fleet in 5 squad, one with the role of scout, three for the attack on the three port of the island and the fifth, composed by some gunboat, with the assignment to cut the telegraph line and shut down a nearby observation post so to isolate the place.

Unfortunately the gunboats were discovered during their mission by Austrian officers that immediately relied the information to Tegetthoff; while the Italian captain never had the possibility to reveal that they were discovered. The Austrian command denied at the Vice Admiral the permission to sail unless he was certain that this was not an Italian faint, so Persano for sheer luck gained two precious day.

The Attack
The morning of the 18th, the Italian fleet launched his assault at Lissa. The fleet was divided as expected by the plan and started the bombardment of objectives just before noon. The bombardment lasted till dusk, destroying or severely damaging great part of the batteries of the island, still there were a strong resistance from the Lissa garrison and the general weather condition and the nightfall advised against landing the troops.

At 10.00 of the 19, Persano decided to attempt to land his forces on Lissa, even with the sea not in perfect condition as for now the only good news was that some reinforcement troops had just arrived from Ancona. Under heavy fusilier fire but with the cover of all the fleet artillery the first Italian soldiers landed, starting the conquest of target.

For all the day the Italian fleet supported the troops bombarding the remaining Austrian holdout and by sunset over Lissa stood the Tricolore; all that at the cost of 79 deaths and 239 wounded for the Italians.
At the dawn of the next day the scout Esploratore discovered the Austrian fleet approaching the Italian position; the Lissa garrison had succeeded in warning Tegetthoff, the enemy was coming.

Battle plans
The Austrian admiral due to the inferior firepower of his ships, had planned to quickly advance towards a section of the Italian fleet, isolate her from the rest of the force, fire from short distance and ramming it, so to force her to retreat; for this reason Tegetthoff had given the order to concentrate all the fire a ship over a single target at the time.

Persano answered putting his armored ships in three column placed side by side and the minor unit behind them. A lot of time was lost due to the necessity of gather the units as they were scattered around the island.

At 11.00, the two forces finally faced each other, with the Austrian commander giving the order to attack the central line of the Italian formation, attempting in this manner to isolate Persano as his flagship the Re d’Italia was there.

Persano ordered to open fire against the enemy formation immediately, and while in general thanks to the excessive distance, the effectiveness of the Italians guns was limited, the Austrians suffered some important damage, like the ironclad Drache that was hit by at least 20 round losing propulsion and the bulk of his officers, so was forced to leave the engagement.

When Tegetthoff force engaged the Persano ships, the other two wing started an enveloping maneuver so to attack the Austrian ships from behind; especially the older that composed the rearguard.
The continuing exchange of fire between the ships and some difficult by the Italians to perform the maneuver gave at Hapsburg forces more time to pummel the outnumbered forces of Persano Division.

The Austrian initial attempt to ram the enemy ships failed due to evasive maneuver, the Affondatore attempted later the same maneuver against the frigate Novara, causing severe damage but failing to sink her.
At the same time, the Italian reserve, not understanding correctly Persano order entered in battle while the other wing ended their attempt at encirclement, the fight quickly devolved in a confused series of battle between small groups without real coordination. The wooden ship Kaiser attempt to ram the Re del Portogallo ended with the latter not only evading the attack maneuver but also use the occasion to try its own ramming against the Kaiser; the Austrian ship successfully avoided the Italians, but the Re del Portogallo guns still caused severe damage. The Kaiser was finally put out of commission by an attack of the Affondatore soon after the end of this particular engagement

After 2 hours of battle, Tegetthoff, taking in consideration the situation of ammunition and supply and the condition of the remaining ships, decided to retreat and return at their base. On the other side, Persano gladly let the Austrian depart as even him had almost finished the ammunition and his men were too tired to continue the fight or begin to pursuit the enemy.

The Italian fleet remained in position until the evening, so to recover any shipwrecked sailors and in case the Austrian had returned. The morning after, Persano sent the more damaged ship, still in condition to navigate, to Ancona with wounded and the prisoner and more importantly with the news of the first victory of the Italian Navy.

In the end, the Italian suffered the loss of two armoured ships ( San Martino and Regina Maria Pia) and severe damage at many other unit, not counting the loss of almost 700 men; the K.u.K. (Austrian Navy) instead lost 5 ships (plus another that needed to be scrapped after the battle) and more than 1000 men

France meddling
Just after a couple of days after the Austrian defeat at Sadowa, Napoleon III started to send diplomatic feelers to both Prussia and Austria, offering his service to settle the conflict. This started a series of diplomatic conflict both internal and external in the various faction of this war.

Bismarck promptly agreed at the French mediation and made public is two demand; the exclusion of the Austrian Empire from the affair of the German Confederacy and Prussian control of the German territories north of the river Meno. The only add done by the French Emperor were the clause about the integrity of the Austrian Empire except Veneto and the possibility of the German states south of the Meno to form their confederacy.
The motivation of the Prussian chancellor for this very lenient term, instead of the massive territorial gain Bohemia-Moravia that the Prussian King originally envisioned, were to avoid the creation of 'Great Germany' and the struggle to absorb the catholic south. The so called 'Little Germany' plan, caused a serious rift between Bismarck and king Wilhelm due to the different final objective of the two me; legend says that Bismarck menaced to throw himself out of the window if his plan was not accepted...and the king without saying a word open one.

Naturally this proposal was not received well in Florence, not only limited the Italian gain at Veneto but the prize itself was to be given at Italy indirectly, as Austria demanded to cede the territory to France and later Paris will have turned to the Italians.
For this reason La Marmora was greatly pressured by both Cavour and the King, to immediately resume the offensive in both Veneto and Trentino and at the same time the Prime minister ordered at the Navy to begin the operation to engage the Austrian Fleet otherwise they will be both relieved of their command.

While both Bismarck and Franz Joseph greatly resisted the Italian attempt to acquire more territory than originally planned, more precisely the already conquered Trentino dragging the negotiation to standstill and at the same time the chancellor was on a battle of will with his own king about his desire to expand Prussia, desire rekindled by Cavour similar intent.

In a shocking move, Bismarck announced the 21 that he accepted unilaterally the French plan, with only the adding of the provision that Austria-Hungary will be forced to cede to Prussia a slice of Silesia so to placate King Wilhelm, and that an armistice was agreed starting 26 July.

The reaction of King and the rest of the Italian government was intense and furious, Cavour, still bedridden due to a relapse of malaria (the prime minister refused to step down till his doctor give him the permission to continue his work and basically directed the war effort from the bed of his family house) menaced to continue the war alone till the Italian legitimate aspiration will be fulfilled. At the same time he frantically hoped to strengthen his position with a more clear military victory as even the United Kingdom had expresses his doubt about the Italian right to acquire more land, now the Kingdom of Italy was diplomatically isolated.

The victory at Lissa greatly improved the Italian position, with the Italian Army already in possession of the land originally agreed and also of Trentino and now with a foothold in Dalmatia; the Viennese court was afraid that continuing the conflict will cause the Croats and the Magyar to start a rebellion and in general the morale of the army was low due to the defeat in both front.
The diplomatic breakout happened the 23, the day after Lissa, with a note of the Italian government directed to both Bismarck and Napoleon III that stated they agree in demanding only the Kingdom of Lombardy-Veneto as the pact signed, but that they consider Dalmatia as a part of it due to the ties with the Republic of Venetia and naturally, both territory and the Iron Crow symbol of the Kingdom will need to be given directly to the Kingdom of Italy and not through intermediary.
In his diaries Camillo Benso Count of Cavour, declared that this was his intention from the beginning, as he fully know that ceding Trentino was a too great humiliation for Vienna and his momentary Prussian ally will have not permitted, still Trento was worthy an attempt.

Both Bismarck and Napoleon III reluctantly decided to get along with this diplomatic fiction after some though, as it permit to close the conflict and even the Hapsburg government accepted the deal as it was less humiliating than give away Trentino a long standing imperial territory, after all, Dalmatia was much more difficult to defend and can be easily retaken.

Armistice of Cormons
The formal armistice between the Austro-Hungarian Empire and the Kingdom of Italy was signed the 9th August 1866 by General Agostino Petitti Bagliani di Loreto for Italy and General Carl Moring for Austria-Hungary. This treaty freeze the military situation with the Italians holding Trento and Lissa and in control of Veneto until the Isonzo, with the troops of the 'quadrilatero fortress' barely holding.

Treaty of Vienna
The formal peace treaty between the two nations was signed the 1st October 1866, established the cession of Veneto, and annexed Dalmatia directly to Italy. Some attempt of Napoleon III to be part of the peace process were politely deflected as Cavour and the King wanted that Italy not sharing the laurels of victory with anyone else and Vienna was persuaded in keep the diplomatic talks by some rumor about Garibaldi refusing to retreat his volunteers from Trentino and start an anti-Hapsburg guerilla, in reality the General, as stated in his famous answer to the King order to return in Italy, that he had no intention to disobeys orders.


(1)OTL the government (lead by La Marmora) barely give at the Navy, a couple of weeks
(2) OTL he was assigned Edoardo D’Amico...and the two men greatly despised each other.
(3)OTL only 8 ships were ready and no shot was fired, this it’s just a sign of the Italian navy being a little better.
(4)OTL only 1 division was sent.
(5)OTL only 600 men were assigned
 
Holy relative Italy-wank! Dalmatia makes a nice addition indeed! Also the weaker ties between Italy and France will definitely lead to the two of them not really liking each other, so I'm looking forward to an almost eternal German-Italian alliance.
 

In the case of Dalmatia, I imagine it's parting will be both a blessing and a curse to Austria (or more accurately Austria-Hungary; there's no way the Hungarians will be silent about Italy substantially beating Austria ITTL). On one hand, the territory can be easily defended by the Italians if Austria-Hungary tries to take it back. On the other, I can't see Rome will have it easy trying to integrate the region into the state, especially with Cavour gone. I don't even want to think of the language issues alone between Rome and Zadar! :eek:

Holy relative Italy-wank! Dalmatia makes a nice addition indeed! Also the weaker ties between Italy and France will definitely lead to the two of them not really liking each other, so I'm looking forward to an almost eternal German-Italian alliance.

Maybe. History has shown that the enemies of today could very well be the friends of tomorrow, and vice verca. Italy might not feel so hot towards France for now, but who knows how will the two nations see each other in the medium-ish future, especially with ITTL Italy being under Cavour for far longer than OTL.

So are the educational facilities in Sawarak only at primary level?Any plans to establish higher education facilities?

To a point, yes. Sarawak's education facilities are very much informal with no government backing (though with some cash patronage) as well as being split into multiple sectors. There's the missionary schools (for reading and writing English), the traditional Sarawak Malay pondok and madrasah (Islamic teachings through the Jawi script) and the Sumatran Malay centers at Kuching (A bit on religion, but more on Malay as a language and Jawi as a writing script).

For now, the government has no plans to introduce secondary education as it would run counter to the ideal of preserving the Dayak culture of the region, as well as having the potential of creating a Brooke-skeptical population. However, this doesn't mean the Sarawakians wouldn't just build secondary schools of their own...
 
In the case of Dalmatia, I imagine it's parting will be both a blessing and a curse to Austria (or more accurately Austria-Hungary; there's no way the Hungarians will be silent about Italy substantially beating Austria ITTL). On one hand, the territory can be easily defended by the Italians if Austria-Hungary tries to take it back. On the other, I can't see Rome will have it easy trying to integrate the region into the state, especially with Cavour gone. I don't even want to think of the language issues alone between Rome and Zadar! :eek:

They will probably try to encourage migration in Dalmatia from veneto and South Italy but otherwise it will be a big headhance for the italian goverment, try to italianize the slav majority will be very hard and will create a lot of resentment but there is a limit at what any italian politicians can ignore so to continue the 'quiet life'...what i can say :i'm a bastard:D.
We can see a massive or at least big emigration of the local population back on A-H or in other places.

Maybe. History has shown that the enemies of today could very well be the friends of tomorrow, and vice verca. Italy might not feel so hot towards France for now, but who knows how will the two nations see each other in the medium-ish future, especially with ITTL Italy being under Cavour for far longer than OTL.

Correct, even because there has not been a massive diplomatic failure between Paris and Rome, just Cavour being more succesfull in dodge Nappy III attempt to intrude himself on the peace process.
 
1870's: The Sulu Affair
IWDxPiK.png

Mary Schneider, The colonial affairs of South-East Asia (Ender Publishing; 2009)

The 1870's saw an upswing in Great Power politics across the East Indies, and nowhere was this more apparent than in the geopolitical dance that was the "Sulu Affair".

The Sultanate of Sulu was always been a bit of a wayward polity in the East Indies, what with their endorsement of piracy and slavery, their paradoxical willingness to trade with any Power, and their penchant for forging alliances just as easily as breaking them. Over the decades, numerous Spanish, British, Dutch, and Sarawak officials have tried to court the royal capital of Jolo, hoping to align the sultanate in their favour – only to be spun around and sent back with their promises either bring ignored, broken, or outright changed. This was particularly acute for the Spanish, whom had long viewed the southern Philippines as an area of influence and – at times – a place of conquest. However, by the closing years of the 1860’s the sultanate was as free as ever, trading openly with its colonial neighbours (barring Spain) with numerous commerce treaties signed with nations as far away as France and even the United States.

The Spanish tried numerous times to bring the polity to heel, including bombarding the capital back during the 1850's. In the ensuing peace treaty, Sulu submitted to being under the influence of Manila (a decision every other Power ignored for trade reasons) but soon reverted back to piracy and paradoxical trading just a few years later. By mid-1872 the Spanish had enough. Concerned with the expansion of Brooke power in North-west Borneo, Manila began sending increasingly hard-worded letters to the royal court to submit to Spanish sovereignty and to only allow Spanish trade in the Sulu Archipelago. Spanish officials also began clamouring the DEI, Singapore, and Sarawak to stop trading with Sulu – a decision that did not go well with the three parties.

The reaction in Jolo was one of predictable defiance and as a result, the Spanish Navy began imposing a blockade on the sultanate by early November. From the outset, it was an order that was hard to enforce; the South China Sea was no longer the empty expanse of the previous centuries and there were many trading ships that were willing to run through the blockade in search of increased profits. Besides that, London also called for the Spanish to be lenient on the issue; the Sulu Archipelago straddled an important gateway to New Guinea and the Pacific islands, as well as featuring in the much-discussed Australia-Japan shipping course. The British also objected to the blockade as being against free-trade policy.

However, the aforementioned factors paled in comparison to the new player that inadvertently arrived on the scene in early 1873: the German Empire.

On January 14, Sultan Mohammed Jamalul Alam sent his most trusted emissaries to the consulates of British Singapore, requesting for an international intervention of his archipelagic sultanate. In this, his emissaries implored for help from Sarawak, the British, the Dutch…and the Germans. A lot of eyebrows were raised at the final suggestion. Germany was, until then, a complete newcomer to the power-politics of the East Indies. However, there were German companies operating in Singapore for decades prior to 1873, and some of them did make contact with the Sulu royal court until the blockade. There was also the fact that the Germans were relatively new to the East Indies’ political scene, and thus had none of the political baggage of the British or the Dutch.


Harbour_in_Singapore,_circa_1870.jpg


British Singapore in 1870, one of the largest trade hubs of the East Indies and a hotbed of secret diplomacy.


From this, everyone instantly became wary of what a German intervention in Sulu would result, and not without good reason. After all, it was only a few years ago that the German Empire’s predecessor, the North German Confederation, trounced the French Empire in a decisive war, drastically changing the balance of power in Continental Europe. Since then, there have been several colonial lobbyists in Prussia clamouring for a German colony to mark itself as true Great Power, on par with England and Italy. In the words of the Dutch Consul in Singapore, “If Rome could have its own piece of the East, then why not Berlin?”

Incredibly, the German Consul agreed to the suggestion and quickly dispatched a nearby gunboat to investigate the issue. This prompted a flurry of correspondence between London and Amsterdam with Berlin, on which the latter quickly stated that it had no intention of building a colony on North Borneo or Sulu (though it does have some ideas on the islands of New Guinea). From Germany’s perspective, it was simply investigating a trade issue from a nearby archipelagic kingdom. This quickly opened a diplomatic bridge between the three Powers, and it was from this that the Sulu Affair was born.

With the intention of ending Spanish trade monopolization on the Sulu Archipelago, the Affair was as follows: supply bases would be built in Marudu Bay and the towns of Sandakan and Tawau, with easy access to Dutch Borneo, the Celebes, and the Kingdom of Sarawak. Shipping companies from Singapore and Labuan would resupply in these bases before setting out to run through the Spanish blockade. Once trade has been conducted, the ships would then sail back to the bases or to the nearby polities of the DEI and Sarawak to evade capture. Whilst this is happening, diplomats in Singapore and Europe would try to convince the Spanish (and Spanish Philippine) government to allow foreign trade with the sultanate, with no recognition of Spanish sovereignty if they were denied.


9o5OqqW.png


Graphic map of the trade routes, ports, and bases used by shipping companies during the Sulu Affair (Batavia not shown).


The Affair drove Spain and its Philippine government mad. Initially, the blockade-runners made Philippine enforcement of sovereignty over the sultanate a farce. Foreign goods continued to be sold in Jolo just as before (albeit at highly inflated prices) while money continued to flow out from Manila’s hands in maintaining the blockade. Any attempt to find out the supply bases would result in their occupants quickly traveling to Dutch or Sarawak-held territories, from which their governments would allow them sanctuary – and naval gunboat-backing – against their pursuers. Worse, guns and armaments began to flow to the sultanate as well and by early 1874 an anti-Spanish insurgency began to make itself known in the region.

Following this, the government in Manila quickly redoubled their efforts by sending more ships to enforce the blockade and more troops to combat the insurgency. The navy also began to interdict any foreign vessel that approaches the Sulu Archipelago and confiscate their cargo, culminating in the seizure of a German vessel and the internment of its sailors in August 1875, quickly followed by the capture of a British schooner in May 1876. Despite numerous appeals from Singapore, Manila would not hand over the captured vessels or the sailors, arguing first for the recognition of Spanish sovereignty and trading monopoly over the sultanate. In a massive comeback, the Spanish fleet conducted a punitive expedition on the capital of Jolo in August, bombarding the city yet again and stopping short of conquering it.


9Rp0Rr6.jpg


The burning of Jolo, sketched by a German missionary.


By 1877, the diplomatic mood between Manila and Singapore was one of a distrustful impasse, and there was little headway in Europe either. Spain had drifted from being a monarchy to a republic to back being a monarchy in a span of three years, and such political instability didn’t make for good progress for foreign affairs. However, by this point the effects of the diplomatic dance began showing itself in the ledgers of Singapore and Manila. Both sides had used considerable resources in enforcing (or in the case of the Anglo-Germans, disrupting) the blockade, producing unsustainable costs. Neither wanted the current status quo to continue any longer.

In early April, Madrid began revising its stance in the Sulu Affair, arguing whether it is possible to recognize Spanish posession of Sulu in exchange for relinquishing their claim over Northeast Borneo and allowing international trade in the region. It was also round this time that Sulu began sending out feelers to other Great Powers to help them check against the Spanish threat.The bombardment of Jolo had disillusioned the royal court against Anglo-German protection and the destruction of the sultanate's state apparatus had reduced the capital’s power to keep check over its outlying islands against any Spanish activities.

In retrospect, it's not much of a surprise that Sultan Jamalul Alam began looking at other candidates to seek protection at around that very moment…


____________________

Footnotes:

1) Despite being barely known today, there was a time when British Singapore and Spain actually got into a dispute over the sovereignty of Sulu before the 1880’s, with Germany somehow or other getting itself involved to some degree as well. The division between areas of influence, trade deals, and colonial ambition were the main concerns, and there were real reports of blockades, blockade-runners and captured ships in the 1870s too. ITTL, the more cagey British saw the rise of Spanish influence in Sulu as a provocation, spiralling the dispute into a full-fledged international Affair.
 
Last edited:

Gian

Banned
(As a Filipino-American myself), I would actually prefer Spain continue its stance to excercise soverignty over all of Sulu, including Sabah.
 
Following this, the government in Manila quickly redoubled their efforts by sending more ships to enforce the blockade and more troops to combat the insurgency. The navy also began to interdict any foreign vessel that approaches the Sulu Archipelago and confiscate their cargo, culminating in the seizure of a German vessel and the internment of its sailors in August 1875, quickly followed by the capture of a British schooner in May 1866. Despite numerous appeals from Singapore, Manila would not hand over the captured vessels or the sailors, arguing first for the recognition of Spanish sovereignty and trading monopoly over the sultanate. In a massive comeback, the Spanish fleet conducted a punitive expedition on the capital of Jolo in August 1876, bombarding the city yet again and stopping short of conquering it.

I'm pretty sure that that's supposed to be May 1876 XD

Otherwise an intriguing update, I'm looking forward to see how that affair will develop further.
 
Sulu reaped what it sowed.Is it wise for the reputation of any power to defend a well known piratical rogue state?

Let me guess,the only ones dumb enough are the Italians?
 
Last edited:
I'm pretty sure that that's supposed to be May 1876 XD

Otherwise an intriguing update, I'm looking forward to see how that affair will develop further.

Whoops! Thanks for noticing! :eek:

One of these days Sulu is going to run out of luck.

For all intents and purposes, the sultanate is playing its last cards by the end of this decade. Their capital is in ruins, their trade is being blocked, and the Spanish fleet are essentially starving them of funds and resources to continue being independent. That doesn't mean there won't a twist to this tale, though... ;)

Sulu reaped what it sowed.Is it wise for the reputation of any power to defend a well known piratical rogue state?

Let me guess,the only ones dumb enough are the Italians?

(As a Filipino-American myself), I would actually prefer Spain continue its stance to excercise soverignty over all of Sulu, including Sabah.

Maybe, or maybe not. Sulu still has commercial treaties with several other Great Powers (France, the United States) so there is a chance the sultan might turn to them for protection against Spain. The piracy and slavery might put off some lobbyists, but some would say a half-rotten loaf of bread is better than no bread at all. Then again, taking over Sulu is a very different thing than actually ruling it...

And yes, Italy is watching from the sidelines for the moment. ;)

Good update.:)

Keep it up, sketchdoodle!:)

Thanks!

After this, maybe a short update on New Guinea before I dive into 1877. Prestige colonies are one thing, but a colony that is next door to an established and disgruntled Power? That's another. :rolleyes:
 
Commercial treaties is one thing,but defending it?I seriously can't expect any self-respecting power to intervene in favour of Sulu unless Sulu promises to abstain from piracy and slavery,for the same reasons why nobody intervened in the American Civil War.Whatever commercial benefits from Sulu isn't worth fighting a war over.Nobody fought on behalf of Southern Cotton,which was back then one of the driving forces of industry,and there's no way someone would fight for the pittance gained from trading with Sulu.

I really think in the context of this timeline,Italy is the only one that's unscrupulous and dumb enough to do it.
 
Last edited:
Commercial treaties is one thing,but defending it?I seriously can't expect any self-respecting power to intervene in favour of Sulu unless Sulu promises to abstain from piracy and slavery,for the same reasons why nobody intervened in the American Civil War.

Although Sulu might promise exactly that, like Zanzibar did, with every bit as much intent of following through as Zanzibar had. At this point the Sultan will probably agree to nearly anything to buy himself a few more years.

I doubt Sulu will survive, but it might be able to make things interesting for the rest of the 1870s.
 
Although Sulu might promise exactly that, like Zanzibar did, with every bit as much intent of following through as Zanzibar had. At this point the Sultan will probably agree to nearly anything to buy himself a few more years.

I doubt Sulu will survive, but it might be able to make things interesting for the rest of the 1870s.

Except the Sultan has no credibility.Over the years, as soon as a diplomat left Sulu,the Sultan just breaks whatever he promised.The British,the Dutch,the Spanish and Sarawak all knows this clearly.

There's no way the US will back them considering this is a little more than ten years after the civil war(the veterans and the public would be outraged if the government helped a rogue piratical slaver state).France is still licking it's wounds.

The idiots in Sulu basically signed their own death warrant over the years.
 
Last edited:
Sulu is pretty much screwed at this point. But they'll survive.

What I'm worried about is the other sultanates in mainland Mindanao. They're pretty much a lot weaker than Sulu. The Spanish might turn their attention to them later on. There goes Cotabato...

On another point, it might result into a much faster colonization of Mindanao (Davao comes to mind), since the Manila will definitely do all it takes to keep it away from other powers as much as possible.
 
Sulu is pretty much screwed at this point. But they'll survive.

What I'm worried about is the other sultanates in mainland Mindanao. They're pretty much a lot weaker than Sulu. The Spanish might turn their attention to them later on. There goes Cotabato...

On another point, it might result into a much faster colonization of Mindanao (Davao comes to mind), since the Manila will definitely do all it takes to keep it away from other powers as much as possible.

More likely the sultanates will feel the brunt of any power ruling luzon. Sulu islands are anything but wealthy in the 1870s ATL or otl. Not worth the time or effort to invade. Mindanao in the other hand can be invade by land since you have Spanish settlements there since 1500s.

But I don't know what's has happened in manila if the mutiny in 1872 succeeded or didn't happen, butterflied away in ATL. But since the islands are still spanish. I assume it didn't happen or succeed.

By this time around, if I were spanish, I would be more worried about things that is happening in luzon than what's happening in mindanao.
 
Commercial treaties is one thing,but defending it?

Although Sulu might promise exactly that, like Zanzibar did, with every bit as much intent of following through as Zanzibar had. At this point the Sultan will probably agree to nearly anything to buy himself a few more years.

Except the Sultan has no credibility.Over the years, as soon as a diplomat left Sulu,the Sultan just breaks whatever he promised.The British,the Dutch,the Spanish and Sarawak all knows this clearly.[...]The idiots in Sulu basically signed their own death warrant over the years.

To this I say: Never underestimate the power of human stupidity. IOTL, the Sultan of Sulu did manage to strike a deal... with a syndicate headed by a British trader and the Austro-Hungarian Consul to Hong Kong. In exchange for a lease (or cede) for North Borneo, the sultanate would be paid back around 5000 Dollars per year. The Consul was even granted the title "Raja of Gaya and Sandakan", though that didn't win him any favors from Vienna.

The good and bad news ITTL is that while events regarding the Sulu Affair have changed, the underlying forces that guide them still somewhat the same as OTL. There are many interested colonial lobbyists in many countries that would actually go try and negotiate with a polity as dubious as Sulu. There are also many companies that would do the same thing, irrespective of their home government's stance on slavery and piracy. The only reason why the trading companies haven't made a deal with Jolo yet is because they know how farcical their deals would be to the royal court; they just wanted a place to sell their goods (though with dubious bankrolling by the officials at Singapore) , especially the armaments smugglers and merchants.

Of course, there are also companies and governments that don't know very much about Sulu and it's credibility. In other words, Jolo might be on it's way out, but not before courting any nation, company, and third-party officers and diplomats they could find. ;)

What I'm worried about is the other sultanates in mainland Mindanao. They're pretty much a lot weaker than Sulu. The Spanish might turn their attention to them later on. There goes Cotabato...

On another point, it might result into a much faster colonization of Mindanao (Davao comes to mind), since the Manila will definitely do all it takes to keep it away from other powers as much as possible.

It might happen. With more international attention (in a way) to the southern Philippines, Manila might try to colonize and "pacify" Mindanao earlier than OTL to prevent another Affair like the one happening at Sulu. However, that might cause enough international attention of it's own; Walls are porous in Southeast Asia, and especially in the compounds of diplomats in the various capitals...

But I don't know what's has happened in manila if the mutiny in 1872 succeeded or didn't happen, butterflied away in ATL. But since the islands are still spanish. I assume it didn't happen or succeed.[...]By this time around, if I were spanish, I would be more worried about things that is happening in luzon than what's happening in mindanao.

Well, I admit I am a bit rusty on Philippine history. Hmm... considering the significance of the Cavite Mutiny, I'll flip a coin and say it did happen with some variances from OTL. In fact, I wonder if the added pressure from watching over Luzon, dealing with Sulu, and greater interest in Mindanao would cause some unexpected changes in the colonial government. A harsher crackdown leading to more intellectuals fleeing the country? A repression on the Moros that would backfire if any foreign aid/protection/officials hear about it?

Filipino specialists, I need your help on this one!
 
Last edited:
Top