Recent content by MiniaAr

  1. Too big to succeed? 'Rightsize' an overextended nation or empire

    For me Napoleon should have stopped at the Peace of Amiens borders for France, with the Sister Republics (Batavian, Italian, Helvetic) remaining nominally indenpendent (and would have become fully independent once France would have faced unavoidable political instability in the XIXth century)...
  2. Partition of the Spanish Empire in 1668 between France and Austria

    Instead of creating an early Bourbon Two-Sicilies, what if Louis exchange the two Kingdoms/Double-Kingdom for the Duchy of Savoy and the County of Nice? This would be a very pragmatic move but Louis is probably not ready for a "Pré carré" strategy at this stage. (it seems that Vauban only...
  3. Is There a Napoleonic Unmentionable Sea Mammal Equivalent thread?

    A God of Destin would be a good timeline about this: https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/a-god-of-destin-a-napoleon-timeline.525393/ Sadly, there has been no update for a year.
  4. With the Crescent Above Us 2.0: An Ottoman Timeline

    Germany entering the war on the Ottoman side maybe?
  5. A God of Destin: A Napoleon Timeline

    Thank you for explaining your reasoning. If Napoleon wanted indeed a Great Power ally, and he chose Austria instead of Russia in OTL it makes some sense. However in this timeline, Napoleon seems even more unhinged in his peace deals than in history, and that's saying something. Would he really...
  6. What if Napoleon didn't invade Spain in 1808?

    You should be interested by this timeline with the exact POD: https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/l%E2%80%99aigle-triomphant-a-napoleonic-victory-tl.511932/
  7. A God of Destin: A Napoleon Timeline

    It's the second recent Napoleonic timeline that rewards Austria with Silesia as a thanks for waging war AGAINST the Grande Armée. Where is this trend coming from? Saxony already got Lusatia. Why not split Silesia between northern Silesia for Saxony and southern Silesia for the Duchy of Warsaw...
  8. A God of Destin: A Napoleon Timeline

    As @ Pempelune said, an independent Ireland seems very likely given that it actually revolted in the same generation and there is no centralised power in England to try and stop them. If this Ireland is becoming United is another question, given the various factions that might want to take...
  9. Trampled By the Ogre: A Napoleonic Victory Timeline

    Why would Austria get Silesia when they were members of the coalition against Napoleon that was just defeated? Doesn't it make more sense to give it to Saxony or partition it between Saxony and Warsaw who are loyal "allies"/ vassal states and Silesia would link the two geographically when they...
  10. L’Aigle Triomphant: A Napoleonic Victory TL

    I agree completely. Of course the UK is remaining the number one naval power for the forceeable future but it's not becoming the superpower it was for most of the remaining XIXth century for the simple reason that a Napoleonic France remaining in control of most if not all of Western Europe is...
  11. L’Aigle Triomphant: A Napoleonic Victory TL

    A UK that loses (or doesn't win) the Napoleonic wars is going to be less dominant on the Seas that she was IOTL. She won't be able to get to send a winning fleet to ALL the seas in the world. I think it's possible for the French navy to achieve local superiority in a couple of theaters, just as...
  12. L’Aigle Triomphant: A Napoleonic Victory TL

    Very interesting. Poland I the future is very likely to want a sea access, either through Danzig or via a piece of Hinterpommern that was left in the grand duchy of Brandenburg.
  13. AHC: Louis XII follows Machiavelli's advice.

    I think he could have kept Milan. One of the main piece of advice in the the Prince is that Louis XII should have kept the Venetian as allies instead of joining the League of Cambrai against them. I know that hindsight is 20/20 but the potential to add Brescia and Bergamo to the French Milanese...
  14. If Napoleon won, how big would Poland be?

    I'm sorry but not all of the board agrees that Napoleon couldn't beat Russia. With the strategy he applied, then yes. But if he reduces the amount of troops sent to the Duchy of Warsaw and doesn't formally ally with Austria and/or Prussia, then the Russians might not be spooked and actually...
  15. L’Aigle Triomphant: A Napoleonic Victory TL

    Is there a non married Bonaparte sister available at the time of the Aranjuez crisis?
Top