Wrapped In Flames

Interlude VIII

Frankfort, Kentucky, June 24th, 1862

The men stood at attention in crisp grey uniforms freshly made in Nashville, the first new volunteer Kentucky regiment to serve under the banner of the Confederate States. Freshly raised in the last month. Nine hundred native Kentuckians in gray standing proudly with their equipment was enough to make John Breckinridge’s chest swell with pride as they received a congratulatory speech from the Confederate governor of Kentucky.

George Johnson was a man with a ruddy complexion and a crippled arm. Fifty-one years old he had not let that stop him from enlisting in the Confederate army as a private and serving at the battle at Elizabethtown, marching victoriously into Frankfort as a lowly foot soldier rather than riding in with great fanfare. This contrasted him starkly with the elected governor Beriah Magoffin who had fled, but separate from the State Legislature. Now the Confederates were setting up a new government to welcome the state into the new nation.

Breckinridge was hopeful this first regiment was a turning point in the nature of the state, showing that its people were willing to switch their allegiance. However, he reflected sourly, they did not control the entire state. His thoughts were interrupted as a brass band struck up the ‘quick step march’ and the new regiment marched off saluting smartly to the cheers of the assembled crowd.

“General,” Johnson said walking up to him as the crowd began to disperse “ride with me to the Governor’s office would you?” Breckinridge happily obliged. They mounted and joined their small escort to the governor’s residence. “Tell me general what do you think of the new regiment?”

“Green sir, but full of spirit.”

“It’s heartening that the people seem to be accepting our rule, this state is naturally made to line up with the Confederacy, there’s over two-hundred thousand slaves here. I’m sure once the abolitionist gang in Washington makes their true feelings known the people of Kentucky will support us whole heartedly.

“I would think that once Louisville falls the population will see our cause is sure to be triumphant.” Breckinridge said.

“How long do you think until that is general?” He asked. Breckinridge hesitated. “It’s alright, you can be honest with me. I expect to have something to say to my supporters here.”

“Well sir, being completely honest, the city is currently impregnable to our forces. Thomas’s entrenchments are strong, and we don’t have the heavy guns necessary to reduce him. Neither Beauregard nor Johnston has a proper siege train, and we don’t have the numbers to dislodge them by storm. I cannot say how long it would take to reduce the city by waiting.”
“That is not a comforting analysis general.”

“You ask for honesty sir, I can give nothing but my impression of the situation as it stands. Until we gain control of the rivers we cannot be secure. The battle at Columbus has given us an unenviable position on the Mississippi.”

“That will surely require resources from our own sate.”

“It will indeed sir, but as you say; I’m sure the people of Kentucky will rally to our cause. We do control nearly all the state now, and with our cavalry raiding into Ohio and Indiana we will have Union men tied down. The greater portion of their strength in the West is currently invading Canada.”

“British recognition would go a long way winning us support.” Johnson mused.

“It would indeed, but I cannot claim to know the minds of the British.” Breckinridge said ruefully. “Truly we need to hope that their support will draw off further Northern resources preventing them from focusing their strength against us. The more they push north the better things are for those of us here.”

Suddenly there was a shout from the roadway and a gray clad messenger came riding up. His horse was foaming at the mouth and the man was soaked with sweat. He puffed out his checks and saluted, Breckinridge returned it.

“Sir! I bring a message from General Beauregard!” He huffed out. “Island Number 10 has fallen!”

The news sent a shiver down Breckinridge’s spine. That left the Mississippi open all the way to Fort Pillow near Memphis. Memphis was the major Confederate naval yard on the Mississippi, if it fell the Confederates would be forced to rely on shipyards hundreds of miles away, they might never regain the initiative on the rivers! He thought the news over a few moments before turning to the governor.

“Sir, I’m afraid I must go organize my men, we will doubtless be needed at the front soon.”

220px-Gwjohnson_ky.jpg

Confederate Governor George W. Johnson

Washington D.C. June 29th, 1862

The weather was fine as the carriage rumbled through the streets of the capital with its cavalry escort trotting along behind. The president and his General of the Armies rode in relative comfort as the hot June sun beat down on them. The president was in a sunny mood as he talked with news of recent victory.

“So the secesh have been driven down the Mississippi eh?” Lincoln asked with a smile.

“Yes sir.” Joseph K. Mansfield, responded. “Island Number Ten has fallen to Wallace’s force. The rebels were strung out besieging Paducah and were not expecting it. From the river we can now threaten Memphis and Beauregard’s army has retreated from its siege of Paducah to establish a defensive line along the Cumberland River.”

“This is delightful news general. Perhaps we can expect by August the rebels will be driven from Kentucky entirely?”

“It is difficult to determine at this point, the rebel forces at Louisville have not moved and continue their investment of the city, but Thomas writes to remind us they have not the heavy guns to drive him out. Their cavalry is proving a major irritant with raids launched north and west to scatter our troops. More concerning is that Fort Donelson remains in rebel hands, guarding the way to the interior of Tennessee. I am sure that the rebels shall anchor their defences on that lynchpin in order to retain their interior communications.”

“Well I trust your judgement on the matter general, an old warhorse like yourself has seen enough blood and guts to know where and when the enemy will concentrate his efforts. Though speaking of the efforts of the enemy, should we be at all worried about Washington at this juncture?”

“I would think not sir. The city is well defended with forty-thousand men tied up in the entrenchments and fortifications here and on the Delaware, and McClellan and the Army of the Potomac sit well placed to shield us from any rebel assault at Centreville.”

“And how are the rebel dispositions?” Lincoln inquired. Mansfield paused as he considered his answer.

“We receive incomplete reports as to the enemy strengths sir. McClellan’s chief agent, that agent Pinkerton who claims to have foiled an assassination attempt on your life, continuously sends back reports of a rebel force some two-hundred thousand in strength near Bull Run, but I am skeptical of that report.”

“Why so?”

“Well sir if there were two-hundred thousand rebels I should doubt they would have chosen to retreat from the Bull Run battlefield at the start of May. However, I do not know enough about the rebel strength to properly assess this force, as it is entirely possible that they have amassed a great host on our doorstep. Not entirely probable, but certainly possible.”

“How would you interpret this information then sir?” Lincoln asked.

“Well sir, I do not believe that the rebel force exceeds some one-hundred thousand, perhaps one-hundred and fifty thousand. That would seem to match the numbers of men at Second Bull Run by all accounts, save perhaps Pinkerton and McClellan’s. They must have at least one-hundred thousand men staring back at McClellan. We do know reliably that twenty-thousand men are invested at Fort Monroe.”

“Yes and they can stay there until Christ returns for all I care.” Lincoln said with a smile.

“I am afraid sir that is unlikely, all the reports indicate that they shall not last another few weeks before they are forced to surrender. Supplies are running low, and rebel shelling is supported by their naval presence at Norfolk. Once that fortress falls save for the presence of our fleet the British and Confederates will have freedom of action in the lower bay.”

“There is little to be done save an evacuation of the garrison, but Welles believes that to be inadvisable, and with the sorry state of the navy after events in the Caribbean we have much to make up for.”

“It is a regret that eight thousand men must be sacrificed.” Mansfield said sadly.

“But it gives us much needed time to rebuild and rearm in relative security.” Lincoln said. “Do enough rifles get to the men?” Lincoln asked. Mansfield grimaced.

“Not near enough. Oh I concede some get through but they are primarily Austrian and Belgian guns of inferior quality which the men cast aside even for old muskets if given the chance. We are at the moment struggling to completely arm all the new recruits. It is a thorn in the side of the army’s progress I must admit.”

“The greater number of thorns we can push in the British side the happier I shall be. We must show the world we are succeeding, and we must convince those at home we are succeeding as well.”

“You seem concerned sir.” Mansfield said. Lincoln sighed.

“Ah general we have enemies enough in front of us, but it is the fire in our rear which I fear. The nation may rally behind my administration when Britain beats on us, but we must demonstrate success lest others who think they know better than I how to win this war.”

“The election is two years away though sir.” Mansfield said.

“Yes, but the elections for Congress and the various state elections are far closer.” Lincoln replied. “And who knows how far off the wars end is.”

“That is indeed a very good question sir.” Mansfield said as the carriage rumbled on. “Though I must also ask what policy are we to take with the news coming from Kentucky?” Lincoln again sighed.

“Is it that damn business of Hunter’s again?” He asked wearily. Mansfield nodded.

“I’m afraid so sir, the representatives from Kentucky and Missouri have been making noises at the War Department regarding our policy of arming black volunteers.”

“There has been no executive order to that effect.” Lincoln said.

“Yes, but we still receive news that from the West black volunteers are being recruited and armed, though Hunter would swear up and down on a stack of bibles that they are being trained and enrolled as nothing more than pioneers and drivers.”

“Would that the man had never brought up the negro.” Lincoln sighed. “Is there anything that can be done to dissuade him?”

“I have sent two orders for him to cease such activity until the state governments have examined the situation, but so far he has simply sent back the same reply.”

“In any other state such a problem would not exist, but in a state with over two-hundred thousand slaves of course such ideas will raise eyebrows and tensions.”

“Many in your own party sir are very supportive of the idea.” Mansfield said with a note of caution and Lincoln let out a heavy sigh.

“Yes as Mr. Stevens would say we have God on our side if we free the slaves. And while we might have God on our side we would lose Kentucky, and I must have Kentucky.” Lincoln said sharply.

“He could be replaced.” Mansfield said.

“Yes but by who general, by who?”

“I would recommend Grant sir.” Mansfield said. “He organized the planning for the assault on Island Number Ten, he led his men competently despite the reverse at Paducah and has already seen action before at New Madrid and made a good accounting of himself.”

“So the man fights then?”

“He does indeed sir, he does indeed.” Lincoln sat quietly for a moment, there being no sounds save for the bustle of Washington around them, the creaking of the carriage and the snorting of horses from the escort.

“Well then we shall make the necessary arrangements. Perhaps Hunter can be reassigned to a more quiet sector, and perhaps he need not simply disband these Negro companies either.” Lincoln said thoughtfully.
 
Last edited:

Saphroneth

Banned
According to one analysis I've seen, Pinkerton's estimates were based off the commissary reports for the Confederate army... but were about 10% over (because his calculator, the man doing the calculations, applied a correction of - 1/15 instead of - 15%).
There's also some complicated apples-to-oranges involved - do you count someone if he's in the supply chain? Sick? AWOL? AWL?

It's important - very important - to compare like-with-like.
 

TFSmith121

Banned
Not to pick nits, but:

Frankfort, Kentucky, June 24th, 1862

The men stood at attention in crisp grey uniforms freshly made in Nashville, the first volunteer Kentucky regiment to serve under the banner of the Confederate States. Freshly raised in the last month. Nine hundred native Kentuckians in gray standing proudly with their equipment was enough to make John Breckinridge’s chest swell with pride as they received a congratulatory speech from the Confederate governor of Kentucky..

Not to pick nits, but there were eight rebel regiments of infantry raised in or from Kentuckians in 1861; a Kentucky rebel regiment served in Virginia in 1861, and others saw active service in the West.

The number of rebel cavalry units raised in or from Kentuckians in 1861 is significant, as well.

The above point is, of course, totally separate from the realities that even when the rebels invaded Kentucky for the second (or third) time in 1861-63, the population was strongly unionist (as shown in the 1862 state and federal elections), did not turn out in significant numbers for the rebels (to the point Bragg et al complained about it), and, in fact, the state was credited with almost 76,000 enlistments in the US forces in 1861-65, including ~52,000 "white" and ~24,000 "colored" troops in the USVs and another ~25,000 in Union militias and home guards.

Total number who actually enlisted in the rebel forces is estmated at ~25,000 (low) to ~40,000 (high); the point being, Kentucky was much more a loyal state than a rebel one, and was at least as divided as Virginia.

See:
http://www.civilwar.org/hallowed-ground-magazine/spring-2010/civil-war-kentucky.html

Best,
 

Saphroneth

Banned
The Kentucky House elections are a little disingenuous to use, though, given how they seem to be cited as relying on voter intimidation.

Incidentally, the total Union votes cast in mid-Civil War would be 55% of the 1860 full turnout on House elections, and would come to little more than a third of the 1860 Presidential turnout.

Without better numbers I can't be sure, but it certainly looks like turnout crashed - which means the election is unusually non-representative.
 
The Kentucky House elections are a little disingenuous to use, though, given how they seem to be cited as relying on voter intimidation.

Incidentally, the total Union votes cast in mid-Civil War would be 55% of the 1860 full turnout on House elections, and would come to little more than a third of the 1860 Presidential turnout.

Without better numbers I can't be sure, but it certainly looks like turnout crashed - which means the election is unusually non-representative.

I think that the issue of whether Kentucky was more pro-Union or pro-Confederacy is immaterial to the issue of having just nine hundred men join the Confederate Army. Surely there were at least that many people in Kentucky who would support the Confederacy.
 
regarding Kentucky

eastern Kentucky, as well as eastern Tennessee along with parts of North Carolina and South Carolina are Scots Irish. They historically despised the planter class pre Civil War which is why a lot of them were Unionists (drawn from this book

http://www.amazon.com/American-Nations-History-Regional-Cultures/dp/0143122029

as from James Webb's book "Born Fighting: A History of the Scots Irish in America"

solid support for the Confederacy was found mostly in the river valleys, where the plantation economy took off. There was a lot of draft dodging in Appalachia, and a pretty respectable number of Unionist regiments in service with the Union Army recruited from there.

But with the British in the war, I can see those sitting on the fence or merely lukewarm throwing themselves into support for the South, while Unionists wait for a Yankee victory somewhere useful.

A lot people don't realize that the South had to actually create militias and home guards to keep an eye on or intimidate or drive out Unionists in nearly every state. They slaughtered a bunch of Germans who were pro Union who tried to flee Texas.
 

TFSmith121

Banned
The Rebs tried to organize boycotts of the elections in 1862

The Kentucky House elections are a little disingenuous to use, though, given how they seem to be cited as relying on voter intimidation.

Incidentally, the total Union votes cast in mid-Civil War would be 55% of the 1860 full turnout on House elections, and would come to little more than a third of the 1860 Presidential turnout.

Without better numbers I can't be sure, but it certainly looks like turnout crashed - which means the election is unusually non-representative.

Actually, the difference between Pro-Unionists and secessionists in 1861 and Republican and Democratic voters in 1862-65 is pretty significant, and trying to portray them as such is more than a little disingenuous, don't you think?

Beyond that, the Rebs tried to organize boycotts of the 1862 elections in Kentucky; generally not a sign of political strength. Having said that, requiring citizens to swear allegiance in the middle of a civil war is hardly a crime.

Best,
 

TFSmith121

Banned
The point was more that there's a factual error

I think that the issue of whether Kentucky was more pro-Union or pro-Confederacy is immaterial to the issue of having just nine hundred men join the Confederate Army. Surely there were at least that many people in Kentucky who would support the Confederacy.

The point is more that there was a factual error, to the point that it leaps off the page to someone who is familiar with the realities of the U.S. and rebel mobilizations in Kentucky.

Best,
 
Actually, the difference between Pro-Unionists and secessionists in 1861 and Republican and Democratic voters in 1862-65 is pretty significant, and trying to portray them as such is more than a little disingenuous, don't you think?

Beyond that, the Rebs tried to organize boycotts of the 1862 elections in Kentucky; generally not a sign of political strength. Having said that, requiring citizens to swear allegiance in the middle of a civil war is hardly a crime.

Best,

this might help too

Union regiments raised in KY (80 regiments)
http://www.civilwararchive.com/unionky.htm

CSA regiments raised in or from KY (about the same) (some of these didn't actually move beyond paper by the way)
http://www.civilwararchive.com/Confedreg/confedky.htm

which really is the bottom line when you talk about support.

note that Union regiments are found from every state, including the ones that seceded from the Union

http://www.civilwararchive.com/regim.htm

while that cannot be said for CSA regiments

What really helped in Kentucky though is that the CSA was kind enough to invade Kentucky first
 

Saphroneth

Banned
I think that the issue of whether Kentucky was more pro-Union or pro-Confederacy is immaterial to the issue of having just nine hundred men join the Confederate Army. Surely there were at least that many people in Kentucky who would support the Confederacy.
There were probably at least that many in Vermont, frankly... that's a very small number. (It's easier to recruit from an area you have control over, though.)
 

TFSmith121

Banned
Rebels in Vermont?

There were probably at least that many in Vermont, frankly... that's a very small number. (It's easier to recruit from an area you have control over, though.)

Rebels in Vermont? And from Vermont?

Really ... Please, tell us more.
 
Last edited:
Not to pick nits, but there were eight rebel regiments of infantry raised in or from Kentuckians in 1861; a Kentucky rebel regiment served in Virginia in 1861, and others saw active service in the West.

The number of rebel cavalry units raised in or from Kentuckians in 1861 is significant, as well.

Seems there was a word missing in the opening sentences. Edited!
 
Chapter XVII:

We're tenting tonight on the old camp ground,
Give us a song to cheer
Our weary hearts, a song of home
And friends we love so dear.

Chorus:
Many are the hearts that are weary tonight,
Wishing for the war to cease;
Many are the hearts looking for the right
To see the dawn of peace.
Tenting tonight, tenting tonight,
Tenting on the old camp ground.

We are tenting tonight on the old camp ground.
The fires are flickering low.
Still are the sleepers that lie around,
As the sentinels come and go.

We've been fighting today on the old camp ground,
Many are lying near;
Some are dead, and some are dying,
Many are in tears.

Many are the hearts that are weary tonight,
Wishing for the war to cease;
Many are the hearts looking for the right,
To see the dawn of peace.
Dying tonight, dying tonight,
Dying on the old camp ground

‘Tenting on the Old Camp Ground’, Walter Kittredge, 1863


“…Grant’s orchestration of the fall of Island Number 10 perfectly illustrated just how overstretched, and overconfident the Confederate forces in the West had become. Johnston come the first of July had men now stretched in a defensive line from Frankfort to Fort Pillow in Tennessee. He placed the lynchpin of these defenses on Fort Donelson, whose defenses had been strengthened throughout the spring, and had Beauregard withdraw behind the Tennessee to the crucial crossings at Duck River. Johnston himself was forced to abandon his siege of Louisville and withdraw in the face of overwhelming numbers now fielded by Thomas at the city proper and to call Van Dorn and Price’s forces from their attempted invasion of Missouri in order to supplement the defenses of Memphis and hopefully replenish his own numbers which had been depleted by siege and battle.

Grant and Thomas now planned a joint offensive for their two forces to march on Nashville and enter into eastern Tennessee in accordance with Lincoln’s wishes from the previous winter. It was decided that Grant would lead his force down the Tennessee, bloodying Beauregard’s army and pushing it back into Nashville while Thomas would lead his forces from the north in the hopes of pushing Johnston into Nashville as well, bottling up the Confederate forces and trapping them in a siege opening the way for the invasion of the lower south.

However, as things often go the beginning of the offensive was delayed by politicking in Washington. Hunter as department commander had been recruiting from amongst the free black and contraband populations with the intent of utilizing them as ‘teamsters, hospital, attendants, and company cooks, saving for men to carry the musket’ while also quietly arming two regiments of black pioneers for garrison duty.

This measure distressed Lincoln greatly, for though he was supportive of utilizing blacks in the army in a non-combat role, the arming of blacks (who in many cases were fugitive slaves) caused considerable consternation in the border states and Lincoln needed to keep them on side, especially with a Confederate government having established itself in Frankfort. As such he maneuvered to have Hunter replaced, sent off to command the newly created Department of the Northwest while Grant was promoted to command the Department.

Grant began with a reshuffling of his commands. Wallace would remain in charge of the newly constituted ‘Army of the Mississippi’ which had taken Island Number 10 and would push on southwards, while Thomas would retain his role in commanding the Army of the Cumberland. Replacing Grant in the newly christened Army of Kentucky was placed under McClerland’s command with Charles F. Smith replacing him.


Army of the Mississppi(XXI Corps):

MG Lew Wallace commanding

First Division BG Morgan L. Smith

Second Division BG John M. Thayer

Army of Kentucky:

MG John A. McClerland commanding

XXII Corps BG Charles F Smith

XXIII Corps BG Marcellus M. Crocker

Army of the Cumberland(XXIV Corps)

MG George Thomas

First Division: BG Thomas L. Crittenden

Second Division: BG Thomas J. Wood

Third Division: BG George W. Morgan

The Battle of Duck River:

Battle_of_Fort_Henry.png

The fall of Fort Henry

With his forces reshuffled Grant’s plan proceeded with McClerland advancing against Fort Donelson. The Fort proved to be a difficult nut to crack even with the aid of Foot’s flotilla with the guns managing to sink the USS St. Louis before they were finally silenced by batteries on the river and ashore leading to the surrender of the fortifications on July 4th. McClerland wired Washington stating “I present, with great humility, a gift for the American people this Fourth of July, the opening of Tennessee”.

From here he proceeded to advance against the Confederate defenses at Nashville, the important shipping terminus on the Cumberland. As the state capital it was also a symbolic objective for the Union in their drive to reclaim Tennessee. Beauregard had fallen back to Duck River, the greatest major natural obstacle to the Union, destroying the bridges across the river and establishing his headquarters south of Shelbyville, even destroying the vital rail viaduct across the river. From there he established dugouts and artillery positions and settled in to repel an expected Union crossing.

He did not need to wait long, as McClerland’s forces closed in. McClerland, having conferred with Grant on their objectives agreed that forcing a crossing near Shelbyville at Silvan Mill and the bridge with Smith’s Corps, while the remainder of his forces would push on to the South of the town and attempt to force the river at Scullcamp Ford and Lacey’s Ford with Crocker’s Corps. From there it was hoped they would cut Nashville off from Chattanooga and its critical life line to the rest of the Confederacy.

However the delays at Fort Donelson, however brief, had allowed Beauregard to site his defenses well leaving no spot where his guns could not engage the enemy. So when the expected assaults did come on July the 13th they met with bloody results. Beauregard’s artillery shredded the advancing blue columns, and at Scullcamp Ford guns on the heights were able to harass even the Federal artillery causing a general withdrawal. The attacks all along the line floundered in the face of determined Confederate resistance as one Confederate soldier later wrote “time and time again the Federal troops crossed that ground, only to be driven back in the face of our guns.” Mounting casualties led to Grant calling off the offensive after two days. He now placed his hopes on Thomas in the north.


Battles of Munfordville and Perryville:

Thomas had, thanks in large owing to his numerical superiority, seen off Johnston’s siege of Louisville and northern Kentucky had largely fallen back into Union hands. The Confederates had fallen back, taking in tow with them their state government as it fled from Franktown. Johnston had taken his core force consisting of his First Corps under Major General Benjamin F. Cheatham (replacing the deceased Polk) Second Corps under Major General William J. Hardee. They were expected to be joined by Breckinridge’s Third Corps. However, he was delayed by the fight at Perryville and so it was two understrength corps which were to stand up to Thomas’s assault.

Johnston had arrayed his forces at Munfordville, a strategic road and railway communications town which controlled the way to Bowling Green, and by extension, Nashville. Thomas advanced against the town from the north, with his Third Division under Morgan advancing from the West to strike the Confederates from all directions. Morgan proceeded down the Springfield turnpike and in doing so ran into Breckinridge’s forces advancing from Frankfort. This mere skirmish at first escalated into a full scale battle as Breckinridge committed his leading divisions to stall Morgan’s column while he brought up his artillery on Peters Hill. Though both sides were numerically equal in strength, Breckinridge’s control of the high ground won the day and forced Morgan’s withdrawal.

Thomas’s assault on Munfordville met with a similar fate. Without pressure on Johnston’s left the assault on the Confederates bogged down into a brutal stalemate and Thomas was forced to retire on the 17th.

Grant soon learned of the failure of both of his assaults, and in his usual way was undaunted. And instead of ordering his forces to retire, he opted to keep Pressure on the Confederate forces in front of him by pinning Beauregard’s forces at Duck River and keeping pressure on Johnston at Munfordville to prevent him from supporting Beauregard south of Nashville.

However, Johnston refused to be caught up in a trap and devised an audacious plan. He intended to keep Breckinridge’s forces in Munfordville to hold Thomas in place while he moved Cheatham and Hardee’s Corps south into Alabama to link up with Van Dorn and strike at the Federal rear and relieve pressure on Nashville. His intent was to force the Union forces back up the Tennessee River while leaving himself room to advance up through Bowling Green to deter any future assault by Thomas. The plan was complicated in the extreme, but if it worked the Confederates would be in a relatively secure position in Tennessee.

To do so he began digging serious entrenchments in front of Munfordville and made them as menacing as possible; intending to give Thomas pause before he moved. Earthworks bristling with both real and fake artillery were established, and he made sure that Thomas only got brief glimpses of his forces moving into the earthworks, while under cover of darkness drawing down his Corps a little more each day, marching them south beyond the view of Thomas’s scouts.

It was an arduous march, covering over 400 miles through rough terrain and a crossing of the Cumberland River, but he managed to link up with all the troops Van Dorn could spare from covering Memphis under Stirling Price on August 22nd…


Battle_of_Munfordville.jpg

The disastrous Union assault at Munfordville

Battle of Columbia:

…Crocker had established his headquarters at Mount Pleasant where he had most of his forces arrayed covering the crossings near Columbia and Williamsport. Though Price’s cavalry had been a minor irritant throughout much of August he was far more concerned with the worn down state of his men following the hard marching and the twin battles at Fort Donelson and Duck River in July. He expected little trouble, all reliable intelligence put Johnston’s main force at Munfordville. Besides, Beauregard was entrenched behind the river with inferior numbers to both his and Smith’s Corps.

As such he was completely unaware of the concentration of 42,000 Confederate troops at Florence, which put Columbus directly in their sights. Grant too was unaware that Johnston had stolen a march on him and was planning for a renewed assault against Beauregard and (he assumed) Johnston’s defences at Nashville. However, a curious situation soon came to light as pickets captured a man who had been attempting to swim across the river. He carried with him orders instructing Beauregard to strike south towards Union positions at Columbia. Curious Crocker reported this to Grant who dismissed it as a feint, believing that Beauregard might attempt a raid on Smith’s positions to the north.

Si it was that pandemonium ensued when Johnston struck north the next day. Pickets at Waynesboro and Lawrenceburg were overwhelmed as Price’s Division struck north to cut off Crocker from Smith. Crocker himself was captured in his own headquarters when Confederate cavalry overwhelmed his pickets and stole upon his positions from the rear. Whole regiments routed in panic or simply surrendered before any semblance of resistance began to form before the Confederate assault. To make matters worse, Beauregard also attacked across the river, putting pressure on Crocker’s beleaguered corps from both sides.

However, while the battle raged Smith’s unengaged Corps was able to take Price from the flank, ,which had not been secured and was thus hanging in the air unhinging the left of the Confederate line. It was at this moment that the tide truly turned. Beauregard had not enough men to keep Smith’s force engaged to the north while Johnston’s men were unable to continue their advance on the Union forces in front of them and they were forced to retire.
Though the battle ended in a Confederate defeat; it in some ways served Johnston’s purposes. Grant, having had the leadership of a Corps decapitated had to scramble to find officers to lead the now rudderless XXIII Corps so the pressure on Nashville was lessened for a time, but soon Thomas would discover the weakness of the Confederate positions in the north, and Breckinridge was forced to retire to Bowling Green while Johnston would scramble to reinforce him come September 1st…”
Guns of the Mississippi, Samuel Jackson, University of Lexington, 1997
 
Well that was a cluster and no mistake. Both sides have been damaged although the Confederate position is rather wonky due to the stretched lines and other aspects. This could be the start of the Union forces finally being stretched too thin with this and Canada, or a painful Confederate retreat.
 
General Thomas makes an appearance. And the war continues to be supremely confused. I like that no one side is winning, it's like a real war.
 
Chapter: XVIII

"A major strike at the enemies Western possessions could indeed be mounted if sufficient shipping were acquired. San Francisco could be its only intended target, as the seizure of the port would make out western North American possessions secure, threaten the American settlement of the Oregon Territory, and once and for all end the threat of American cruizers in the Pacific." - Somerset to Palmerston Janurary 1862

"Starkly contrasting the truly titanic battles raging on the eastern face of the North American continent, those which took place on the Pacific Coast were relatively minor. Comparisons are often drawn to the British actions in the Russian War in the Pacific or the Baltic seas, and in terms of men, materials, and strategies involved these are rather apt analogies.

The British presence in the Pacific was not substantial numbering some 11 infantry battalions, the greatest commitment being three regiments in New Zealand for the purpose of keeping the peace between the Maori and the British settlers on the islands. Otherwise three battalions were also engaged in China against the threat of the Taiping rebels who menaced the important trade port of Shanghai. The remainder were scattered on various postings across the Pacific in important coaling bases and other imperial possessions. The British presence on the West Coast of the North American continent was even less than that, with the forces there numbering only some 130 Royal Engineers in the colonies proper and some 150 Royal Marines on station with the Pacific Squadron.

The British settled presence was also small. The two British colonies of Vancouver Island and British Columbia had between them roughly 51,000 inhabitants, nearly half of whom were migratory workers and claims stakers searching for gold in the foot hills and river valleys of British Columbia. The settled populations were concentrated in the coastal regions and fertile valleys, with the colonial capital of Vancouver, Victoria, having the largest population at almost 5,000 souls. By contrast, the settled population which made up the American Department of the Pacific (the modern states of California, Oregon, Nevada, and Columbia) was over 450,000, with 380,000 in California alone. The great American port of San Francisco boasted a population of 57,000 citizens.

The Americans had a much larger force to draw upon than their British adversaries with some 4,600 men stretch across the Department of the Pacific, but these were largely tied down in various postings and keeping law and order across the lawless regions or skirmishing with Amerindian bands in the interior. To be fully effective these forces would have to be concentrated at a focal point, while further volunteers would need to be called upon to fill the gaps left by a withdrawal of the regulars.

While the Americans boasted a greater concentration on land at sea the story could not have been more different. The American Pacific Squadron operating from Mare Island had at its disposal only seven warships, and only three modern steam sloops, two paddle sloops, and two sail sloops. In contrast the British had three steam frigates, three screw corvettes, two screw sloops, two paddle sloops, two gunboats, as well as one sail sloop, for a total of 13 warships. Clearly the early edge rested with the Royal Navy.

Commanding these various elements were a series of capable officers and civilian administrators.

On the British side the colonial government rested in the hands of Sir James Douglas, the son of a Glasgow merchant and planter and of mixed race (though he appeared majority white) was a career fur trader who had worked his way up from the bottom rungs of the Hudson`s Bay Company as a trapper and clerk to become the governor of the colony, having practically chased his predecessor from his position. Despite the presence of an elected Legislative Assembly all practical power rested in the hands of Douglas, who was an appointee. He was very protective of his position as the colonies senior administrator and ran the colony with a tight fist while governing British Columbia mainly from Victoria, earning derision from his detractors as though he was running the colony like a family compact, especially on the mainland.

a_01228.jpg

Sir James Douglas

Commanding the landward forces available to the British was Colonel Richard Clement Moody as the head of the British Columbia Detachment of the Royal Engineers. Moody, a career officer, educated at Woolwich had been posted on various duties throughout Britain`s colonial possessions, mainly in the West Indies and the Falklands and a tenure as professor of fortifications at Woolwich. He had been appointed to lead the British Columbia Detachment of 150 Royal Engineers[1] as well as chief commissioner of lands and lieutenant governor of British Columbia in 1858. Commanding the Royal Navy’s Pacific Squadron was Rear-Admiral Thomas Maitland. He had entered the navy in 1816 serving in postings throughout the empire, and had served in the First Anglo-Chinese War as Captain of the flagship Wellesley in 1837. He then moved on to command the RN gunnery school aboard HMS Excellent from 1854-1857 before coming to command the Pacific Squadron aboard the steam frigate Bacchante.

220px-Richard_Clement_Moody_(1859).JPG

Richard Clement Moody

Commanding the Department of the Pacific south of the 49th parallel was the sixty year old Brigadier General George Wright. A West Point graduate Wright had served in combat against the Seminole and in the Mexican War earning distinction at Molino del Rey afterwards where he was promoted to colonel. He had served on the West Coast since 1855 and was promoted to Brigadier of Volunteers on the recommendation of his predecessor Edwin Vose Sumner upon Sumner’s return to the East. Now commanding the unified Department of the Pacific his main duties were protecting the frontier, keeping watch on secessionists, moving troops eastwards, and safeguarding the coasts. In this last duty he was aided by Flag Officer John B. Montgomery commanding the Pacific Squadron. He had served in the previous conflict between the British from the early days of the conflict and during the Mexican-American War had captured the town of Yerba Buena without a shot being fired. He had commanded the sloop of war Portsmouth and the steam frigate Roanoke before being promoted to command of the Pacific Squadron in 1859. Beneath him was Charles H. Bell another 1812 conflict veteran who had served on Lake Ontario, who would command the defensive squadron in the Bay when Montgomery moved ashore.

220px-George_Wright_(Army_General).jpg
220px-John_B._Montgomery.jpg
Charles_H_Bell.jpg

Wright, Montgomery, and Bell

Due to the vast distances involved news of the outbreak of war was slow in reaching the combatants on either side. The Americans in California theoretically had a near instant link to Washington with the first transcontinental telegraph, but the line had been damaged by the Great Flood of 1862 meaning that news of the outbreak of war did not reach San Francisco until March. Maitland and Douglas did not learn of the wars outbreak until the beginning of April with the arrival of HMS Tartar.

For their part the Americans were faced with a number of immediate problems. The terrible flooding over the winter of 1862 had bankrupt the state of California with the government unable to pay its own employees, let alone spare funds for emergency spending on defence[2]. There was also the matter of the gold so desperately needed for the war effort; unable to be shipped overseas it now had to be shipped overland and it would be necessary to furbish volunteers to guard these convoys. There was also a conflict between state and federal government over the matter of paying both volunteers and civilian contractors. The common means of exchange had been the use of specie in the economy, but the Federal Government had suspended the use of specie in transactions and civilian contractors refused to take paper money, of which there was precious little to spare in the state to begin with. Announcements that the Army could only pay in government notes had led to walk offs on the construction of batteries and fortifications, so in the immediate aftermath of the outbreak of war precious little work was done on the defences.

Wright for his part was optimistic writing “The General Government has but a small amount of funds at present available for defensive works on this coast, but I apprehend no embarrassment on this account, not for a moment doubting that the loyal and Union-loving people of California will most cheerfully respond to any call which may be made on them, whether for money or men to defend their State from foes without or traitors within.” And this seemed to be true. Governor Leland Stanford’s call for men had produced over 2,000 men under arms to augment the Federal forces in the region, the other governors followed suit and throughout the spring Wright was able to move over 3,000 men to San Francisco. He realized that “In case of war with a maritime nation, the immediate attention of the enemy would most certainly be directed to this city, the great entrepot of our possessions on the Pacific coast.” and as such directed his efforts to the protection of the city. By July he had gathered some 5,000 regulars and militia in entrenchments around the city. Batteries were established at Lime Point and Raccoon Straight, with supporting batteries at Angel and Yerba Buena islands and at Point San Jose. These combined with the guns at Fort Point and Alcatraz brought the total number of guns to 154.

However, these defences were not quite as solid as their builders might have hoped. Training with the 8inch Columbiads on Alcatraz had to be suspended when one exploded seriously damaging a second gun in the process as the artillery commander there, Major Henry S. Burton, feared his guns might be further damaged by repeated firing. Fort Points guns were not all mounted and the supporting earthworks turned out to be the primary supporting batteries as the emplacements to mount guns on the fort itself were not yet complete. The state of the defences were so poor by June that Bell gloomily wrote “The British have amassed a substantial squadron based out of Esquimalt and the French are steadily strengthening their presence off the Mexican Pacific shore. In the present state of the defences of this harbor one half of this force could command the city of San Francisco, and take possession of this yard.”[3].

Like on the East Coast however, it was hoped the British could be drawn off with the use of commerce raiders. First to depart were the sailing sloops St. Mary’s and Cyane, they were soon followed by the armed steamers California, Oregon, and Panama, and a number of smaller vessels were able to depart before Maitland’s squadron was able to close in.

In British Columbia the reaction from the colonial government was at first, panic. Douglas had a similar reaction during the Russian War when the Tsar had deployed a regiment to Alaska and demanded a British regiment from China, but had been ignored. However, during the abortive Pig War of 1859 the Colonial Office had seen that some proactive measure was necessary and 500 stands of arms had been shipped to the colony to arm volunteers in 1861. Moody was given command of the volunteers and various police forces, while Douglas handed out weapons and company guns, arming some 550[4] volunteers. With Moody’s engineers and Royal Marines from the fleet under Captain George Bazalgette there were some 800 men under arms in the colony by May.

Maitland’s first task was to gather his squadron, which was a substantial striking force, at Victoria. This took time as his ships were scattered across the breadth of the Pacific, and the need to hunt commerce raiders would be a significant drain on his resources. By early June though he had amassed his ships at Esquimalt he had the frigates Bacchante(51), and Topaze(51), the corvettes Clio(22) and Tartar(20) as well as the gunboats Forward(4) and Grappler(4).

The remainder of his squadron was scattered as pickets or hunting American cruisers across the Pacific. His main body was now prepared to sail against San Francisco, where he would establish a blockade of the Bay which he established come the 15th of July.

For the defence of the Bay Montgomery had under his command the modern steam sloops Lancaster(22), Wyoming(6), Narragansett(5), and the paddle steamer Saranac(9). This squadron paled in comparison to the British force arrayed against them, and so Montgomery had pressed a number of steam tugs and revenue cutters (such as the USS Active) into service as a squadron of extemporized warships under Bell’s command. To further aid in the defense of the harbor various booms and hazards were erected in the approaches to the bay, and the former warship turned marine barracks USS Independence was hauled out to serve as a floating battery[6]. It was hoped that these measures would prevent the British from commanding the Bay.

The first British ‘victory’ came in the aftermath of the withdrawal of the American force on the San Juan Islands and the declaration of war as the Royal Marine detachment occupied the whole of the islands thus ending the dispute in Britain’s favor unequivocally. This move greatly pleased Douglas who hoped territorial concessions could be made on the United States in order to enlarge his own colony…

…To further advance an offensive against the Union coast however it was realized further resources would be needed. As the crisis had deepened in December and January planners in London had tossed various strategies back and forth. Originally it was seen as only necessary to mount a blockade of the bay to prevent the threat of commerce raiders ranging across the Pacific, but soon arguments over how long the war might last brought up the idea of mounting an action against San Francisco or a great raid into the interior. It was patently obvious such a raid would have to be made using strength from India lest Britain become further overextended in the region. And so the tedious negotiations began with Calcutta and London arguing over costs, resources available, and shipping. This became more hurried when news of the defeat at Rouse Point reached Britain and it was seen that something ought to be done against the West Coast to give the government in Washington pause.

Arguments for a scaled up raid were made, largely by Newcastle and the Admiralty, but Palmerston insisted on an expedition against San Francisco proper. In this he was supported by the Army, but few others. The Admiralty considered a blocking force enough, especially as news from the Atlantic coast trickled in and Britain appeared to have uncontested supremacy. The fall of Portland seemed to indicate though that an expedition could be mounted, but the need for a firmer negotiating position seemed it would be necessary to mount some kind of assault, and so the rather tentative compromise was reached. It would be a brigade sized force supported by the navy which would sail against the Union’s greatest Pacific possession.

Planning went on well into April when the orders went out and the slow process of gathering and shipping these troops was put into action. The main strength of the expedition would come from India while another battalion would be detached from China, and a second from New Zealand.

The force consisted of five infantry battalions, two from Bengal the 1/6th Regiment of Foot and the 75th, the 83rd From Bombay and the 99th from China. From New Zealand the 65th Regiment of Foot was detached to take part in the expedition as well. The force also received cavalry support from the 8th Hussars from India and artillery from the 14th Brigade Royal Artillery (A and D batteries). The force would also include some 400 sailors and Royal Marines acting as a naval brigade bringing the force to over 5,000 men.

The forces commander was also detached from New Zealand. Major General Sir Thomas Simson Pratt was a career service officer in the British Army commissioned on the 2nd of February 1814 as an ensign in the 37th Regiment of Foot he saw the tail end of the Napoleonic Wars in Holland. He was promoted through the ranks until he became lieutenant-colonel in 1841. He served in the First Anglo-Chinese War with the 26th Regiment of Foot commanding the land forces at the Second Battle of Chuenpee and the Battle of the Bogue Forts while leading his regiment at the Battle of Canton and at Shanghai. He would then serve as the deputy adjutant-general of Madras from 1843-56 then as commander of the forces in Australia from 1856-61. In 1861 he served as commander of the forces in New Zealand in the First Taranaki War, but his disagreements with the colonial government, and dissatisfaction amongst the colonists led to his replacement come May when he was chosen to head the California expedition.

Thomas_Simson_Pratt.jpg

Thomas Simson Pratt

The main force set out from India with the transports HMS Adventure and HMS Urgent each carrying a battalion and local shipping pressed into service to carry another as well as the cavalry and artillery under escort from HMS Alert(17) alongside the gunboat HMS Assurance(4) while the transport HMS Vulcan and the steam sloop Charbydis(21) brought the 99th from China. The two convoys met at Honolulu in Hawaii where they also took the forces from New Zealand under their wing where they would shepherd them to British Columbia.”
- A World on Fire: The Third Anglo-American War, Ashely Ledger, Random House, 2010

“The Kingdom of Hawaii was in 1862, in a state of flux. Though the islanders at this point still outnumbered the American settlers their population was decreasing almost yearly thanks to foreign diseases. Kamehameha IV was well aware of this fact and sought to attempt to limit the influence of the American settlers and missionaries on the island.

The King had long had an anti-American sentiment ever since his travels as a teenager. In his travels he had visited the nations of Europe and on the return trip travelled across America. There he experienced unbridled racism even in spite of his royal status which caused him great consternation. Writing after his trip recalling one such experience he said "I found he was the conductor, and took me for somebody's servant just because I had a darker skin than he had. Confounded fool;[this is] the first time that I have ever received such treatment, not in England or France or anywhere else...in England an African can pay his fare and sit alongside Queen Victoria. The Americans talk and think a great deal about their liberty, and strangers often find that too many liberties are taken of their comfort just because his hosts are a free people." Alexander’s anti-American feelings were well known amongst the populace, and as such the American settlers on the island had in 1856 attempted to organize to get an annexation treaty signed but had failed in doing so.

This had only further increased his distrust of the American population of the island. He sought to limit his dependence on the United States by seeking out ties with other foreign nations, especially Britain. It was at first in small ways that the king sought to curry favor with the British, extending preferable trade rights to British merchants, and by encouraging Anglican settlers to the islands, even writing to England to summon an Anglican bishop to come in order to facilitate the growth of the British settler population.
The arrival of the British fleet in July however brought matters to a head.

Though these British warships and British soldiers were only pausing to take on supplies and allow the men to stretch their legs while they waited for the remainder of the fleet, but the American settlers on the island saw it as the first step to British annexation. The king however saw it in a different light. This overt show of strength made him thoughtful and he saw an excellent opportunity to rid himself of the American threat once and for all.

The American commissioner to the kingdom, Thomas Dryer, complained bitterly of the British presence, formally requesting the king demand they move on. He pointed out that the kingdom had already declared neutrality in the war between the Federal government and the rebellious states, and that as a neutral he was honor bound to throw the British out. The king ignored this proclamation until Dryer warned that it would be constituted as an unfriendly act and the nation would suffer the consequences as a result.

Alexander understood the threat, and in response he requested that Hawaii become a British protectorate, writing to London at the end of July…”
The House of Kamehameha, Brandon Somers, Oxford Press, 1987


Kamehameha_IV_%2528PP-97-8-006%2529.jpg

King Kamehameha IV

“…by the end of July the expedition had arrived in British Columbia and the men and animals were given a few weeks to rest and regain their land legs after a long voyage and the brief stopover in Hawaii. Pratt took command and organized his forces while preparing to leave as soon as his men were rested.

Then, on August 27th the British appeared off the coast at Golden Gate. The appearance of British warships near the bay was not unusual, Maitland had previously tested the defences in short forays against the outer batteries and so the appearance of British warships did not cause much alarm at first. As the size of the fleet became evident and the transports peeled away general alarm set in and the defenses were mobilized in earnest.

Maitland brought his ships steaming through the bay firing as they came. In the lead was Tartar, with Maitland’s larger frigates following behind the two remaining corvettes following, and the gunboats taking up the rear. The transports angled away from the fleet heading towards the sandy beaches at Land’s End where the expeditionary force began landing in good order unopposed. The plan was to advance inland against Fort Point while Maitland’s squadron would bombard the position from the sea.

Though the landings got off to a good start with the infantry and cavalry landing in good order, they struggled to bring the artillery ashore, especially the heavier muzzle loading pieces and the naval artillery with the Naval Brigade, and although they made good time in the morning, under the soft sands the artillery became difficult to move up hill.

That being said the infantry and cavalry advanced in a staggered order with skirmishers leading behind the cavalry, there being no road from the beach to the fort it was a slog through sand dunes and patchy ground which got steadily worse to maneuver through. They did manage to reach the earthworks defending the landward side of the fort by 1pm however, the artillery was still being escorted to this position. The British made the best of it gathering into a battle line, when the American forces under Colonel Caleb Sibley marched from the entrenchments of San Francisco to meet them. The Hussars and Sibley’s cavalry skirmished repeatedly giving the British time to prepare, and the sandy terrain was no less difficult for Sibley to move his guns through.

In the opening stages of the fight the two sides met with roughly equal numbers (some 3,000 each) with the British waiting atop the dunes for the American force to arrive. The opening skirmishing heavily favored the British who opened fire from 300 yards as the blue coated infantry marched into battle across the dunes. It was in the opening skirmishing that Sibley was killed decapitating the command of the mixed force of regulars and militia. In the confusion his second in command was also slain and the blue coated infantry milled about unsure of its orders before mounting a desperate charge broken up by volley fire sending them reeling back across the dunes towards the city. The cavalry prevented a close pursuit and the British instead turned their attention to Fort Point.

In the Bay Maitland’s squadron steamed past the guns of the supporting batteries and opened fire on Fort Point. Maitland, a gunnery expert, had his squadron drilled extremely well and the British gunnery was excellent. On the American side, though they had the range, the reverse was true. The gunnery from Alcatraz was poor causing gaining more misses than hits, and true to the fears of her commanding officer the stress of repeated firing cause two more Columbiads to burst killing two men and wounding several others. The gunnery from Fort Point was somewhat better, managing a number of hits on Maitland’s squadron, but they were no match to the skill of the Royal Navy who pelted the earthworks with shot.

Bell’s squadron then intervened in an attempt to save the fortifications, and by 1pm the action had become general. In the melee that followed Bell himself was killed as Narragansett was pounded by the big frigates, Clio had run to ground and was burning and Topaze was severely damaged losing several of her guns. However, the outcome was never seriously in doubt, the skilled gunnery of the Royal Navy and the overwhelming advantage in guns they possessed over their foes meant that Bell’s squadron was either forced to strike, or flee to the second line of defence near the city proper. Maitland’s squadron cruised past and were able to silence the second line batteries and placed the city under his guns and demanded its surrender.

At Fort Point the British infantry and Naval Brigade had settled in and were bombarding the incomplete fortifications, drawing away the defenders from the naval action to the defense of their own fortification.

With no fleet to speak of, his ground forces in disarray, and the city under the guns of the Royal Navy Wright was forced to enter into negotiations with Maitland. It was agreed that the garrisons of Fort Point and Alcatraz would be allowed to withdraw with the infantry, cavalry, and artillery within the city would be allowed to withdraw to Sacramento (Pratt and Maitland lacking the numbers to compel the surrender of the trenches without bombardment and Wright unwilling to surrender his entire force) with their arms and ammunition. The city was surrendered in a solemn ceremony aboard Bacchante with both Maitland and Pratt in attendance as both Wright and the mayor, Henry F. Teschemacher, formally surrendered the city to the enemy.

Wright, the surviving sailors, and his remaining infantry withdrew from the city in good order the next morning, watched over by British troops who were soon occupying the earthworks the Americans had abandoned. On land Wright had lost some 1,300 men wounded, killed, and captured with the complete capture of the US Pacific Squadron, save for those cruisers still at large on the seas. Pratt and his expedition had lost 700 wounded and killed in the fighting while Maitland had lost some 200 at sea. Through that though he had now erased the threat of more cruisers floating across the Pacific and had seized the one great outpost on the US West Coast as well as the US Mint.

However, he was in no position to threaten the rest of the state, and although Pratt recommended a raid against Sacramento once the temporary truce ended Maitland felt that inland operations could not be considered. There was no immediate source of reinforcement available to him, and with the British needs expanding across the Pacific rather than shrinking it was unlikely they would receive support for some time. As such they began occupying the positions the Americans had vacated, and settled in to repulse the expected American assault.

For the Americans part, they set about gathering the strength to retake the city, or at least bottle up the British forces there. When news of the defeat reached Washington Lincoln exclaimed “My God, my God, what will the nation say?”
A World on Fire: The Third Anglo-American War, Ashely Ledger, Random House, 2010

[1] About a dozen had died or deserted by 1862

[2] The damage from the flooding was fairly extensive, killing 200,000 cattle and destroying perhaps a quarter of all the taxable property in the state. It left the government unable to pay its own employees for over a year.

[3] This is a variant of a quote he wrote in OTL edited to fit my needs of course. It comes from a fascinating piece on JSTOR which is a good primer on California’s defences during the Civil War.

[4] This includes some 50 Metis volunteers Douglas had armed before during times of trouble with company guns.

[5] Her sister warships Warren and Decatur were looked at for this choice but were found unsuitable to mount heavy guns.
 
At this point this TL and BROS are becoming mere inversions of each other.

Could we have something more interesting than that please?
 

Saphroneth

Banned
At this point this TL and BROS are becoming mere inversions of each other.

Could we have something more interesting than that please?
Seems fine to me. I mean, this was basically an assault on a port by a small number of troops, defended by a small number of troops, in which the superior force won but wasn't able to fully enforce a total victory.
 
Top