Germany does a few different languages within it's bordersWith a PoD around 1400, would it have been possible for the various German dialects to evolve into distinct Germanic languages, like Bavarian, Saxon, etc.? Perhaps if the king of France was elected Holy Roman Emperor?
Question for y'all -
Isn't High German the standard German?
But Germany was unified by Prussia, and wasn't the Brandenburgian core pretty far north, and thus part of the Low German continuum?
A couple of corrections or points; I'm not sure to what Chinese dialects you are referring to when you say some aren't conclusively gfenetically related, that's not really the case, at least at a family-level, we know for sure than they are Sino-Tibetan and it appaears that virtually all can be traced to Old Chinese at its earliest, with most being from Middle Chinese.A language is a dialect with an army to back up the claim. Which is why when languages like Ukrainian and Belorussian don't have nation-states they were (and by many still are) classified as dialects; but when independence is achieved or widely promoted the "evidence" for language-hood is more convincing. It's often a political game. Chinese "dialects" are by no means dialects nor mutually intelligible and some aren't even conclusively genetically related!, but good luck saying language instead of dialect given the political clout of the PRC (and the RoC isn't going to be on your side in this debate either).
In conclusion- the ONLY way to have them be different languages is to have separate nations. A united Germany will do everything to pressure that they are dialects; with NO change to the dialects simply giving them independent nation-states will suddenly make them separate languages. eg- Austria, Luxembourg (somehow it isn't "German" *eyeroll*).
"High German" has two separate meanings. One refers to the southern dialects (in the geographical highlands) and another to Standard German (which is "high" in terms of prestige).
The Luther Bible really began the emergence of a Standard German form. This was a couple of centuries before the rise of Prussia.
Well Prussian land were mostly Low German, but ultimately the standard language was more close to Middle German varities and one can see the effect of its usage in the modern dialectal border even that regard traditional Berlin dialect as middle German:Question for y'all -
Isn't High German the standard German?
But Germany was unified by Prussia, and wasn't the Brandenburgian core pretty far north, and thus part of the Low German continuum?
Austria doesn't have its own language, just its own pronunciation and spelling standard, not to far from American vs British English.
In theory every German region has its own dialects; so Austria, Alsace, Switzerland and Luxemburg are not special in that regard, the difference in how they are considered is literally 100% caused by politics.That's true for standard/Viennese Austrian German, but don't rural Austrians speak Bavarian? (i.e. the same language is spoken across both regions)