This may be broad, but what is comedy like in the USA ITTL? Is absurdism, black comedy or dry humor (like OTL's British comedy) popular in the US? Does comedy even exist in the US of TTL given how it was highly influenced by Germany? (badum-ch)
Comedy in the United States, as in our would, was shaped by vaudeville in the early 20th Century, which also gave the United States some of its earliest film and radio stars. I don’t know if the same comedic writers and performers who influenced the genre in OTL existed and had similar careers in TTL.
While comedy was a popular genre across different artistic mediums in the United States, it was also impacted by a wider culture that was more conformist and militarized than in our world. This is not a culture that would have been particularly welcoming by the late 20th Century to comedians like Lenny Bruce, Richard Pryor, or George Carlin from OTL.
US comedies in the 20th Century weren’t absent entirely of critiques or mockery of society and the powers-that-be, but usually didn’t reach a point of mocking and deconstructing all elements of US society, Black comedies are present in US culture, and were particularly pronounced in the 1970s during the height of the American Nihilist cultural trend. One genre where black comedies tend to be more pronounced by 2023 is speculative fiction. Greg Bliss, the author considered by cultural historians to be the effective founder of the modern spec fic genre, included aspects in some of his novels and short stories that would be recognized from OTL as being rooted in this kind of cynical humor.
Many of the best comedies in the United States are analogous in themes or plot to works like
Noises Off or
It’s a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World from OTL. In other words, works that imagine what would happen if everything that could go wrong in a “normal” society were to happen all at once. In some of these kinds of works, there’s also a degree of bitterness and sadness, such as the film
North Orleans, which was written and directed by Annabelle Marchbanks and released in 2001.
By 2023, there is some overlap in different artistic mediums in the United Stares between the genres of comedy and horror. The play
Insect, which was written and directed by playwright John Lastra and premiered in 2018, was intended as a kind of psychological horror story, in imagining the total destruction and collapse of one person because of insane circumstances. While the play was a surprise success on Broadway and on later national tours, some critics and audience members interpreted
Insect as a comedy instead of horror, to Lastra’s frustration. The play
Insect would inspire similar works of psychological horror, and also works that played up the dark comedic aspects of this horror sub-genre.