The Perilous Fight: America's 40 Years of Reckoning

640px-Flag_of_the_United_States_%28upside_down%29.svg.png

The Perilous Fight: America's 40 Years of Reckoning
A Timeline Exploring the Alternate History of America (and also the World) from 1918-1958

by King of the Uzbeks

Part 1: Twilight's Last Gleaming (1918-1928) (ongoing)
Part 2: The Towering Steep (1928-1938)
Part 3: The Gloom of the Grave (1938-1948)

Part 4: Where Freemen Shall Stand (1948-1958)
 
Last edited:
Pt 1: Twilight's Last Gleaming
Wake_Up_America_parade.jpg

O say can you see, by the dawn's early light,
What so proudly we hailed at the twilight's last gleaming,

maxresdefault.jpg

Whose broad stripes and bright stars through the perilous fight,
O'er the ramparts we watched, were so gallantly streaming?

Tulsa-1200x800.jpg

And the rocket's red glare, the bombs bursting in air,
Gave proof through the night that our flag was still there;

Arkansas-City-Mississippi-River-April-27-1927.jpg

O say does that star-spangled banner yet wave
O'er the land of the free and the home of the brave?​
 
Hello and welcome one and all to my first Major Alternate History Project in some time. The Perilous Fight is written in a somewhat experimental style. No chapters were delineated and I simply wrote as I researched,, lurching as I did so. This resulted in some odd rabbit holes, (I may have gone overboard with regards to Hungary), and pacing, (Supreme Court nominees jammed into one section despite being spread out over a decade) and threads that I forgot about later on (I can't tell you what I've forgotten about for obvious reasons).

Updates should be fairly regular for the time being, every Friday, but the length may vary. As I said much of part 1 is written, but if you have questions I might be able to squeeze some stuff in.
 
Chicago 1918
Thomas_Marshall_delivers_speech_in_Indianapolis_%28cropped1%29.jpg

"Your labor is in vain. Nobody was ever crazy enough to shoot at a vice-president. If you will go away and find somebody to shoot at me, I'll go down in history as the first vice-president who ever attracted enough attention even to have a crank shoot at him." - Thomas Marshall to a Police Bodyguard in Denver (IOTL)

Chicago. 1918.

This city is a tense one. And with good reason. For it is a city at war.

America has just passed the one-year anniversary of her entry into the Great War. Her industry is reoriented, bullets and rifles fly off the great assembly lines of the industrial midwest. The sons of America are sent off to the fields of Flanders. But the war rages on still, and not everyone is happy about it.

Chicago is home to a great many Americans who do not think entering the war was a good idea. The Irish for example are not particularly fond of how the war means an alliance with Great Britain, who had so recently struck down the Easter Rising. But they are not the ones who will trigger this crisis. No, for this we must turn elsewhere.

First, there are the Germans, naturally wary of entering a war against the fatherland. This has not been helped by the sudden rise in Anti-German activity. Theodore Roosevelt, that bastion of Progressive thought, rails against hyphenated Americans. The German-born conductor of the Chicago Symphony is forced to step down and sees Wagner replaced by Berlioz. German breweries are hit by anti-alcohol legislation. A German in St. Louis, who had attempted to enlist, is lynched. His murderers wear red, white, and blue to their acquittal. All across America, things are changing. Berlins become Marnes. Bismarcks become Pershings. Sauerkraut becomes liberty cabbage. All of this leads to charged atmosphere in Chicago, a city boasting a sizable contingent of German speakers.

Then there is the left. A smattering of socialists, communists, anarchists, and the rest of the blend that always lurks in the fringes. They oppose the war on principle. It is but a trick, they say, to divide the workers of the world, so that they may be forced to serve the bourgeois. They are not entirely correct, there is no secret cabal of capitalists working behind the scenes. But they are correct in that the capitalists are not the ones doing the bleeding and dying in France. And that is their true point. These types are naturally hated by just about everyone. They stand opposed to the tide of patriotic fervor that has swept the nation, and they stand opposed to the Capitalism many Americans hold close to their hearts. With the October Revolution in Russia and the Communist withdrawal from the war, they have become even more feared and hated than they were previously if that is even possible. Even the unions, in the form of the American Federation of Labor, despise them, and the Wobblies have little power in Chicago.

These forces are often at odds with one another and certainly are not united in the slightest. Opposed to them, however, are the forces of “Americanism,” whatever that most vague of words may mean. They range from ethnic voters more predisposed to support the war effort to middle-class types in it for Patriotism to the wealthy who profit from it. They are convinced that America is under siege and that only they can save it from the enemies abroad and at home. Many are progressives, already inclined towards assimilationist views of immigrants. The war has only high ended such nativism across America. 100 percent Americanism is now the order of the day.

And there is the Black population. The Great Migration is afoot. Hundreds of thousands of African Americans have moved North in recent years, fleeing the iron fist of Jim Crow and searching for work in the north. They have found that the north has just as many racists as the South. Segregation is still the norm, backed by laws forbidding the seeding of property to minorities. Black workers and white ethnic workers often compete for jobs, sparking tensions. Many whites see black demands for basic civil rights as creeping Communism. Some blacks do feel sympathy for the leftist program of liberation, but they have a complicated relationship with the Labor movement, having often been used as strikebreakers in the past.

And so Chicago is a city that is not only at war with the far away Kaiser, but it is also a city at war with itself. It is not unique in this regard, the tensions present here are present across the United States. Nor will it be the only place set alight but such tensions.

But it will be the first.

Liberty Bonds are special bonds sold by the Government to fund the war effort. Citizens purchase bonds and will be repaid later with interest once the war is over. Two rounds of bond selling raised over 5 billion dollars for the government. Even this great amount is disappointing for the government, who want more money to fuel the war. In April a new round of Liberty Bonds are approved, and the Government goes all in on the project.

The Committee on Public Information, the Government’s propaganda arm, spends millions to promote the new rounds of bonds. Posters are printed, buttons are made. Air shows are organized and guests pressured to buy bonds. Celebrities like Charlie Chaplin and Elsie Janis are recruited to give speeches and make films in support of the public buying bonds. Most effectively, the Girl and Boy Scouts start selling bonds, and who can deny a kid selling you on a far away war?

One of the rallies to sell bonds is scheduled in Chicago, and is in need of a keynote speaker. None of the celebrities being used were available, so it has to be a politician of some sort. All of the important ones have something better to do, and with midterms fast approaching no one with a future wants to wade into the muck of Illinois politics. So someone with no future is sent, the Vice President of the United States.

Thomas Riley Marshall. Born: March 14, 1854. North Manchester, Indiana.

His early years were dominated by his family’s efforts to avoid the violence endemic to the border region before, during, and after the American Civil War. In college, he became entangled in a libel lawsuit, getting sued by the author of Ben Hur and defended by future President Benjamin Harrison. Marshall was inspired by the incident to go into law. He used his practice as a springboard into the Indiana Governor’s mansion with an energetic and progressive campaign. Marshall had a famous wit and deployed it with abandon in stump speeches and it saw him become Governor in 1909. His term was dominated by efforts to expand the power of the Indiana Government, using methods up to and including rewriting the state constitution.

Although his efforts ultimately failed, he remained popular in Indiana. And in 1912 Woodrow Wilson offered Marshall a spot on the ticket, hoping to secure the swing state. Wilson assured Marshall that his input as Vice President would be valued, and Marshall accepted. Although Marshall would help carry Indiana in 1912, Wilson’s promise has proved empty. Marshall is excluded from actual decision making in Washington, and Wilson undermines his traditional role as liaison with the Senate. Marshall is kept on the ticket in 1916 but failed to deliver Indiana. By 1918 his relationship with the President is deeply strained.

Marshall speaks at a bipartisan event to sell war bonds in Grant Park, Chicago. April 15, 1918. Democrats and Republicans together for victory.

Conspicuously absent is Mayor William “Big Bill” Thompson. Yes, Thompson is a Republican, but this event is nonpartisan. That is, unless you oppose the war. Which Thompson doesn’t, he swears up and down that he’s a good American. But he has a long history of blaming the British Government for every problem under the sun. And he needs every Irish and German vote he can to keep his hold on the city. So he’s been neutral, too neutral some say. He refuses to meet a French delegation, and has failed to crack down on anti-war and anti-conscription activity. This has caused him to lose a Senate primary and gain the nickname “Kaiser Bill.”

So no, Thompson isn’t attending. Although he’ll soon wish he had. Both to cloak himself in the glory of near martyrdom and to avoid the allegations of treason.

At around 2:03 on April 15 a man pushes his way to the front of the crowd, who are busy laughing at the man once deemed “too funny to be President.” Eyewitness accounts confirm that it is a man, and that he is white but little else is confirmed.

The assassin raises his gun and fires three shots. Newspapers at the time record the man yelling “Down with Capitalism, Hoch der Kaiser!” Anyone with a passing familiarity with either anti-Capitalism or the Kaiser can tell you he did not say that. Or if he did it was a false flag. But that is what the papers say.

One shot grazes the arm of a city councilman. But the other two find their mark, and lodge themselves directly into the chest of Marshall. The crowd descends into chaos at the sounds of gunshot, and despite being in full view of those on stage, the shooter manages to melt back into the panicked crowd.

Trying to keep the crowd calm, Marshall makes one of his trademark self-deprecating jokes.

“Roosevelt kept going, but I am an Indiana Mule, not a Bull Moose, so please forgive the brief delay.”

His efforts are in vain, however. The chaos has begun, the paranoia has burst into the open. Word spreads like wildfire across the city. But Words are not Truth.

The Vice President is shot. The Vice President is dead. The Vice President is alive. The President is shot. The President is dead. The President is dead? That means the war is over right? No no no the President of Austria or whatever getting killed is how this war got started says one. I thought it was because they sunk the Lusitania says another. It was those bastard Krauts that done him in. No wait, it was those dirty Bolsheviks down at the Union Hall. Well MY union supports the war. Maybe it was a Bolshevik German instead.

Round and round and round it goes. People pour out onto the streets and inevitably start blaming each other. Or the Germans. Or the Left. Or the Blacks. Blame someone, anyone. Blame turns to Screams. Screams turn to Punches. Punches turn to fire and broken windows.

The Chicago Riots have begun.

Meanwhile, the Vice President dies on the stage. He has spent 64 years alive. 4 years as Governor of Indiana. Just over 5 as Vice President of the United States. He is the second straight Vice President to die in office. Taft’s Number Two, John Sherman, died of Bright’s disease just days before the 1912 election. This is the first assassination of a sitting officeholder since the 1901 murder of William McKinley.

Marshall leaves behind a wife and an infant foster son. Perhaps he might have been saved, the doctors say, had someone gotten through the chaos at Grant Park soon enough. Not for certain, but he might have had a chance. Unlike reality, where he proves doomed.

A fate he shares with many others
 
Last edited:
Oh this is setting up a very interesting situation with Wilson after he has his stroke. I really like the premise so far!
 
the 1919 Red Summer and First Red Scare kicking off right in the middle of the war effort, kinda?

Would be fascinating for like the Harlem Hellfighters to hear about all their dreams of civil rights and racial equality through patriotic service turn to ash months before they would have mustered out and experienced it OTL.
 
Comments are always

Oh this is setting up a very interesting situation with Wilson after he has his stroke. I really like the premise so far!

Indeed it does.

the 1919 Red Summer and First Red Scare kicking off right in the middle of the war effort, kinda?

Would be fascinating for like the Harlem Hellfighters to hear about all their dreams of civil rights and racial equality through patriotic service turn to ash months before they would have mustered out and experienced it OTL.

Red Summer itself likely remains a ticking time bomb, outside of Chicago at least. Returning veterans were part of the cause. As for the Red Scare...
 
Blood in the Wind
Chicago_race_riot%2C_white_men%2C_boys_standing_in_front_of_vandalized_house.jpg

“Chicago is a city of neighborhoods, and I love that. It’s cool to have different foods from all over the world within a stone’s throw of my house.” – Bill Rayless (IOTL)

As panic grips the city, the police struggle to maintain order, or even conduct a reasonable investigation into the sudden murder of the Vice President. An M1911 pistol, until recently the standard sidearm in the US military, is found in a gutter several blocks away, and is tentatively identified as the weapon of the murder.

Rumor sweeps the city, with most blaming the Germans or the Left. Mobs of angry citizens attack various German neighborhoods, and many Germans fight back. Large parts of the city are burned. Police arrive at suspected Anarchist meeting sites, and find them already looted by overzealous gangs. The North Bank of the Chicago River becomes a de facto war zone, as Poles and Germans battle on its banks. Blood flows into the river at times, although it does not flow to the lake. The River's flow has been reversed for year now.

The police do not help matters when they make an arrest. A carpenter from the North Side. He’s the son of a German immigrant, a member of the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America, and was vaguely in the area the day of the shooting. That is enough to get him arrested, in the paranoid atmosphere. This arrest, and the seeming confirmation it was the act of a lone radical, calms city authorities. He will be released as it becomes apparent he was elsewhere in the city, trying to secure tickets to the White Sox opener the next day.

It does not calm the rioters. In fact, it makes things worse. The fact that he's a German causes another round of violence to break out along ethnic lines, exacerbated by war fever. The enemy lies within or so they say. The Carpenters have never been a particularly radical union as far as unions go, but they are still a union and therefore suspiciously radical in the eyes of many. Especially given the prevalence of Germans in their ranks. More violence erupts going after unionists of all stripes. AFL or IWW or otherwise it does not matter, they are targets. Russian and Jewish neighborhoods, which tend to have immigrants from Russia who do not call themselves Russian for obvious reasons, face violence now as suspicions about the Revolution trickle into the city.

However after about a week of unrest, things seem to be calming down. The city takes the sensible step of shutting down the street cars, slowing the spread of the rioting.

The various running battles have burnt themselves out. However on the 23rd, another barrel of gas is poured onto the fire.

A black man walking down the street on the South Side gets beaten by a group of Liberty Loan workers. They claim he is a Communist, although the slurs they shout at him suggest there are other motives. This situation escalates when the largely Irish police force declines to arrest those responsible.

The riots this time are mostly on the South Side, and feature whites attacking the Black Community. Due to recent segregation laws, almost the entire African American community is crammed into certain neighbors. Rich, middle class, poor, all are available for attack. Street gangs, generally Irish, have been waiting for an opportunity to go after the black community for months, and now they have their chance.

The most common tactic is fire.

Dozens of arsons occur, all across the South Side. Homes and businesses set alight. Those that aren’t burned are smashed. Men and women are beaten and worse. The Black Community does their best to fight back, but they will suffer by far the most from these riots.

The riots proceed at their renewed high for four days. But Chicago is a vital city to the war effort, both in terms of its factories and being a key railway hub. It cannot be allowed to fall into chaos for long. Something must be done.

Hoping to preempt a need for Federal Intervention, Illinois Governor Frank Orren Lowden steps into the fray. Lowden is a fairly conservative Republican, both in terms of economic views, and in his willingness to use state power to clamp down on the left. He has previously taken action against “pro-German” groups in Chicago that local police failed to pursue. Now, the police are happy to accept his aid. Their control of the situation has long since slipped away.

The National Guard Lowden sends into Chicago is, to put it bluntly, not the cream of the crop. Most of the true soldiers are fighting in the trenches an ocean away. Nonetheless, there are now 3,000 men marching into Chicago. They deploy around heavily black areas. They prove surprisingly effective at stopping the rioting, providing a barrier between the African Americans and those attacking them.

The damage to the city over the week or so of rioting is tremendous. Millions of dollars worth of property is destroyed. Many blacks are left homeless by the fires. African American servicemen will return home from the war to find that their families have been forced to leave Chicago, often heading back south.

In terms of direct human cost, some 68 people are killed. Most of them, 41, are African Americans killed during the later stages of the rioting. 15 were whites killed by blacks, while the remaining 13 were killed during the earlier rioting on the North Side. Hundreds more are wounded.

The one two punch of the assassination of the Vice President and an explosion of violence in America’s second largest city causes uproar and panic across the nation. Clearly the nefarious Germans are sowing chaos to win the war. Or possibly Communists. Or Anarchists. Or all three.

The Marshall Asassination and Chicago Riots induce an increase in pressure on groups unenthusiastic about the war, regardless of if their motivation is ethnic or ideological. But there is also change afoot in the halls of Congress, where legislation to crack down on sedition is being considered.
 
Very, very curious to see where this goes! I'm imagining all that social tension around WW1 blows up in everyone's faces, but I'm excited to see the specifics!
 
Inter Arma Enim Silent Leges
resource_0005_Layer%201_3.jpg

“In times of war, the law falls silent.” - Lots of People, IOTL. Let's go with Star Trek Deep Space Nine

In 1917, the United States Congress, with urging from President Wilson, passes the Espionage Act. The act is aimed at stopping foreign espionage from interfering with the emerging American war effort. The law makes conveying information to hamper the war effort or aid American enemies punishable by death or imprisonment. It also makes it criminal to lie to impede the war effort, or attempt to interfere with military recruitment, under punishment of imprisonment or fines.

President Wilson wanted the bill to include provisions allowing Presidential censorship of newspapers and other publications. However this provision failed in the Senate by just one vote. Congress did grant the ability to the Postmaster General to restrict the mailing rights of newspapers and journals opposing the war effort or otherwise being disloyal. The exact definition of disloyalty is up in the air.


Congress also passed in 1917 the Trading With the Enemy Act, which blocks trade with nations the United States was at war with. Seizure of German, and later Austrian, property in America follows shortly thereafter. Both personal and business property are subject to seizure. This act also allows some Government control of news, requiring that German language publications submit English translations to the authority.

Enforcement of these acts falls harshly on two groups. Germans, and left wing groups.

Prior to the war, German-Americans were considered a 'model minority,' of sorts. They are White, Protestant, and closer to Anglo-Saxon than most other groups. Many, although not all, farm rather than becoming the type of urban city dweller who lurked in the fears of many Americans. Urban Germans on the East Coast tend to vote for Democrats with other immigrant groups, while Midwestern Germans tend to be more Republican, and so neither party has much incentive to crack down. The United States possessed a fairly substantial German population even before independence.

Thus, even those who pushed for the need for immigrants to assimilate considered the Germans the lowest hanging fruit. Although this is more in theory than in practice. The Upper Midwest in particular has large numbers of residents for whom German was their first language. German-Language Papers such as the Illinois Staats-Zeitung, the New Yorker Staats-Zeitung, and the Westliche Post are powerful institutions in their own right.

The Left, however, has never been a model for mainstream Americana. The Left, of course, is hardly worthy of capitalization. There are faults and divisions running every which way. There are various independent radical groups, often tied to this immigrant group or that immigrant group. There are anarchists, who for obvious reasons lacked a central body. The largest group however, are the Socialists. The Socialist Party of America had been founded in 1901, but have always been riddled with debates about how much to engage with electoral politics. Radicals more inclined to direct action and Syndicalism drifted towards the Industrial Workers of the World and away from the party. This does not mean radicals like Eugene Debs who remained in the Party have stopped feuding with moderate “Sewer Socialists” like Victor Berger, however.

The war has further complicated matters. Unlike several European Parties, the Socialist Party has condemned the war as capitalist and refuses to support it. However some prominent members have left to support the war, depriving the party of members, funds, and talent. Meanwhile, while the Party sees a surge in vote share in certain areas, Socialists have lost what little mainstream acceptance they have. In 1918 the Russian Revolution further divides the party between those who wholeheartedly embrace the Bolshevik model and those who are more skeptical.

Leftists in the United States have always faced repression. And the federal government has played its role, breaking strike after strike. But Washington had always been a hammer of last resort. The day to day repressions, the beatings, the scabs, the arrests, have always been handled at a state or local level, or by hired goons from the companies themselves. Just capitalists and local interests serving their own self interest.

But now things have changed. The Federal Government is entering the fray in the name of National Security.

The Espionage Act saw a wide expansion of government interference but it is not enough.

Complaints have already been rising about the ineffectiveness of the Justice Department's enforcement of the Espionage Act. This is perhaps unfair, seeing as the Justice Department is as anti-German and anti-Communist as anyone else. But in the wake of Marshall's death, something must be done.

The 1918 Amendments to the Espionage Act, commonly called the Sedition Act, contain the following provisions.
  1. Move prosecutions under the Espionage Act into special War Department Tribunals (although the Secretary of War can remand cases to the Justice Department)
  2. Implements a system of prior review for Newspapers
  3. Makes the killing of the President, Vice President, Cabinet Members, Supreme Court Justices, and Members of Congress Federal Crimes.
  4. Raises the penalties for threatening Government officials
  5. Makes false statements that interfere with the war effort illegal
  6. Makes obstructing bond sales or enlistments illegal
  7. Makes inciting disloyalty in national forces illegal
  8. Makes abusive or contemptuous actions towards the flag, government, military, constitution etc illegal.
  9. Makes urging prohibited acts a crime.
These provisions only are made effective during wartime, unlike the prior Espionage Act.

The irony of course, is that the law passed only around 7 months before the 11/11 Armistice is signed. Relatively few arrests are made, the most prominent being Eugene Debs of the Socialist Party. His case is booted back to the Justice Department by a War Department that really has better things to do than set up tribunals. Attorney General Gregory instructs the Justice Department not to act without his approval, although enforcement remains patchwork.

When news of German capitulation comes, most assume the act ceased to be in force. After all, the war was over and America has won! Certainly Gregory thinks so.

However no treaty has been signed. And Gregory is not going to be Attorney General much longer…
 
When news of German capitulation comes, most assume the act ceased to be in force. After all, the war was over and America has won! Certainly Gregory thinks so.

However no treaty has been signed. And Gregory is not going to be Attorney General much longer…

Gregory: "I mean... Now there's no need to keep escalating things at home, right?"
Federal Government: *Oppressive laughter.*
Gregory: "...This cannot possibly be good."
 
Ruby Red, Emerald Green
IMG_0359.jpeg

“Arise ye pris’ners of starvation
Arise ye wretched of the earth” - The Internationale

Alexander Mitchell Palmer is a Quaker.

He is born a Quaker in 1872. And apparently he keeps the faith of his family throughout his education and legal career. As a young, progressive, Congressman he is offered the position of Secretary of War in the incoming Wilson administration. Palmer however turns the position down, citing his faith. Although some of this may be his desire for the Attorney General position.

A failed Senate run in 1914 leaves him jobless. But in 1917 the war comes, and although Palmer seems willing to abandon the non-violence to join the fight directly, Wilson instead appoints him to the position of Alien Property Custodian, in charge of managing German assets seized by the American Government.

Palmer’s management is not above partisaness or the prejudice of the time. Palmer appoins loyal Democrats to positions under his control, and makes sure his actions got good press in the newspapers. He is also eager to stoke the flames of resentment about German property ownership in America. He presses for the sale of German owned industries, such as some metals and the brewing business, to prevent foreign domination.

In March 1919 Thomas Watt Gregory leaves the position of Attorney General. Other possibilities are considered, but Palmer’s patronage, progressive, and patronage connections win the day. Wilson selects him. And he will be approved by the Senate.

Initially, however, he will be criticized for being too lax in his enforcement of anti-dissident measures, despite the war being over. He declines to continue collaboration with vigilante groups, and fails to put as much vigor behind attempts to root out the radicals that were surely hiding behind every corner. Critics need to do little more than point to Seattle.

The Pacific Northwest had some of the most radical working class in America. The docks, lumber mills, and mines have proven fertile ground for the radical Syndicalists of the International Workers of the World. Not everyone is a Wobbly of course, some remain in good standing members of the American Federation of Labor. But the leadership of the AFL is not always in good standing with the rank and file, who are considerably more combative than leadership.

As the War ends, so does the wartime truce on labor action (not that the IWW ever recognized that). And the workers begin to suffer from the post-War depression, as the economy adjusts to peace. And they cannot help but notice the bosses are not feeling the pain quite so much.

In Seattle the most contentious group is clearly the longshoremen who work the docks. In most cases the word 'Bolshevik' is an inaccurate insult, and even here they are hardly card carrying members of the Russian Communist Party. But when the American government tries to load weapons into ships for Whites in Siberia, the longshoremen of Seattle won't touch the stuff. So clearly this is an area on edge at the moment.

But it is not the longshoremen who will kick off events. It is the shipbuilders. As soon as the armistice hits, they demand a pay raise. The owners refuse, and now there is a strike in the shipyards.

The owners try the old divide and conquer trick, offering higher wages for some but not for others. This doesn't work, and everyone is back to square one. The shipyard owners hem and haw, not wanting to cave but not wanting the continuing hassle of a strike.

Into the fray steps, or rather telegrams, Charles Piez, an engineer turned executive. Currently he is heading the Emergency Fleet Corporation, the government agency which handled the merchant marine during the war. Although drawing down, Piez still has enormous power in the industry. And he lays out simple terms. Anyone who raises wages gets frozen out from government contracts.

There is just one issue, a small thing really.

He sends the ultimatum to the Trade Metals Council, which should get every shipyard owner in the loop as quickly as possible.

Except the owners are all members of the Trade Metals Association. The Trade Metals Council is the Union outfit.

Oops.

The Trade Metals Council is, understandably, rather miffed at this display of government favoritism towards the bosses. And so they go to all the Unions of Seattle with a bold proposal: a General Strike. All the workers in the city off the job.

The other Unions, despite the efforts of the AFL, agree to the plan.

On February 6 the City of Seattle, the largest in the State of Washington and the 20th largest in the United States, grinds to a halt.

A Strike Committee is hastily organized, charged with maintaining discipline among the Workers but also ensuring no one dies. The Firemen stay on the job, while washerwoman will wash hospital equipment but nothing else, which, given the ongoing flu pandemic. Food kitchens are established, delivering meals to those in need, including the majority of striking workers. The city is closed, but it is peaceful.

Not that you would know it, listening to the right. Leading the charge is Seattle Mayor Ole Hanson, a dyed in the wool Republican. He warns of Bolshevik Revolution in the United States, waving around examples of radical literature that have been floating around the city. He adds thousands of deputies to the police force including students from the University of Washington, with the aim of replacing every striking worker he can.

But it is not the outside pressure that will end the strike in under a week. It is pressure from the labor movement itself. The wider movement has never been behind this ‘general strike’ business and begins to move against it. The AFL and the national unions lean on the locals. And then lean some more. The Strike Committee rejects a plan to go back to work from the Executive Strike Committee. But then the streetcar workers go back to work. And the newsies. And the teamsters. And by the 11th the General Strike has collapsed.

Ole Hanson becomes a national hero, and will in fact soon resign his office to go on a (quite lucrative) speaking tour. But there is one last gristle in the teeth of victory.

The longshoremen are holding out. Picket lines now line the docks. Even the shipyards that started this affair are back to work. But the longshoremen will not yield.

Hanson’s threats during the General Strike to flood in the police proved to be bluffs. But he is happy to cry havoc against the longshoremen. On the 13th the police, and some civilians, descend upon the picket lines with a savage brutality. Five are killed, a hundred are wounded. And finally the docks reopen.

The General Strike is over. But the General Panic has just begun.

The Overman Committee was established in 1918 to examine nefarious German schemes to take over the world, such as running breweries. Chaired by Lee Overman, a segregationist grandee from North Carolina, it finds its purview expanding in the wake of the Strike. Now any sort of subversive activity is fair game.

They hear testimony from all sorts, including a great deal about the Russian Revolution. Mostly from Russian exiles, who are eager to pain a portrait of an illiterate country duped and than oppressed by the vile Bolsheviks. Much attention is given to the alleged communal use of women in the ‘free love’ Soviet Union. A lot of attention. For purely research purposes.

But this is an American committee, and so there are American issues to be considered.

Like how many Jews are Communists!

Oh yes, the Overman Committee is very interested in how many Russian Communists had Jewish ancestry. Why? Because reasons. Like protecting America from Jewish Communists.

At some point someone whispers hastily in Overman's ear and he 'clarifies' that he only blames apostate Jews, which fails to quiet many people's nerves.

The Overman Committee will also spend its time poking around the other bugbear of the right: academics. The nation's intelligentsia is, according to the Committee, rife with disloyal elements. Professors with left wing leanings. Reds working as writers. Students disobeying their elders. Terrible horrifying stuff.

Meanwhile, tens of thousands of Americans are dying of the flu.

The Spanish Flu is so named because it was first reported in Spain. And therefore obviously originated in Spain. Nice going Spain, that's the second pandemic you've started in the past 500 years. Please don't look into Camp Funston in Kansas. Or wartime censorship preventing reporting. Please really you don't need to. The Spanish are behind it.

The worst outbreak came last fall, right as the war was winding down aboard. Over two hundred thousand people died in the United States that fall. And it mostly hits young, healthy men like soldiers. This next wave is not quite so brutal but is still deadly. Restrictions on Public Gatherings reemerge, and masks are once again in vogue. There are, of course, dissenters. Blah blah blah government tyranny. Blah blah blah the Public Health Service are the real villains.

The real real villains, according to Luigi Galleani are the Capitalists. Galleani is, by the way, an anarchist from Italy. Following less than amicable relations with the Italian and Egyptian Police Galleani immigrated to the United States. Here he has built up a small, but dedicated, band of anarchists aiming to overthrow the government and capitalism. He is a big big big fan of 'propaganda of the deed,' aka killing prominent people to inspire the working classes. During the war he hightailed it to Mexico to avoid the draft, and so has avoided the crackdowns thus far. But he has plans to celebrate his return.

And what better date is there than May 1? That most glorious day in celebration of the workers martyred right here in America? Not that treacherous September Labor Day.

The plan?

Send bombs to several prominent American personages. Blow up said prominent American personages. Liberate the working class.

Easy.
 
...this is going to be one of those "the First Red Scare gets turned up to eleven" scenarios isn't it?

I mean, much of that was OTL, as far as I can tell, but still, I have a sense this won't end well.
 
Very interesting Uzbek!

This is one of those periods of great flux, with all the unrest and rioting and panic and overreach, that is equal parts scary and fun to read about. Seems like your America is going to be a not-so-nice place for the foreseeable future.
 

Deleted member 191087

Fun update looks like there is going to be a bloody red scare this time around.
Well, in a way, it seems like this America will go ”red“ within the coming years.

Red from all the blood of some high prominent figures but mostly of course from the radicals and ”their estranged but equally dangerous cousins” (aka minorities).
 
Neither snow nor rain nor heat nor gloom of night...
Mitchell_Palmer_house_in_Washington_DC_2132_R_Street_NW_after_bomb_attack_June_2_1919.jpg

Hand on the bomb that spits shrapnel
Arrange the crackers, grasp the "Stars" (grasp the "Stars")
Propagate the revolutionary idea
The great libertarian one that broke the chains

Soon we anarchists will rush
To fight for victory or death
With petrol and dynamite
Each class and government to destroy and defeat.- Italian Anarchist Song, IOTL

The bombs themselves are fairly simple. Target opens package at a tab that says "Open Here." This pulls a spring that drops some sulphuric acid out of a vial. Acid eats through a blasting cap. Blasting cap detonates. Dynamite below blasting cap detonates. Target goes boom. Liberate the working class.

Of course, ever since the Marshall Assassination, the authorities have been extra suspicious of radicals. But that just teaches Galleani and Co that they need to be extra careful. Everything needs to be perfect. Every spring coiled, every postage stamp paid.

Of course, May 1st is not only a holiday for Italian Anarchists. The entire Labor Movement and indeed the entire Left is gearing up for the day. The first May Day since the War ended. The Second May Day since the Bolshevik Revolution.

Of course, the right is well aware of these facts as well. As is the Government. The police are out in force. As are Victory/Liberty Loan supporters, who see it as their duty to fight anti-Americanism wherever they find it.

This sort of tension is not new. The forces of capital have never exactly been friendly to a say celebrating the international working class. The Haymarket Affair had given the date to May 1st in the first place. In 1894, frustration over unemployment had boiled over into a riot in Cleveland. But since then, May Day has been a peaceful, if tense, affair.

But that all changes this year.

Cleveland, again, proves itself a flashpoint. It is here that Eugene Debs, an acknowledged leader of the left, has been tried for violations of the Sedition Act. And the Socialist Candidate for Mayor, Charles Ruthenberg, is eager to drum up support. A March ensues, bearing both American and Red Flags. First they scuffle with some Liberty Loans type who want the red flags, but they press forward to the main square, only to find the police. Who also want the flags. Matters are not helped by Former Treasury Secretary William Gibbs McAdoo, President Wilson’s son in law, being in town and giving a speech to the Liberty Loan men, who then go out in search of Socialists to beat up.

The main scuffle remains at Public Square, however, where the Socialists are very firmly not giving up their red flags, thank you very much. The police move in and soon there are fistfights happening all over. And then it becomes an all out riot in the heart of the city. Pretty much every window along the square is smashed in at some point, and people from around Cleveland rush into join the fray.

Marches elsewhere, in particular New York and Boston, start tense but peaceful. But soon there are some squabbles at the edges. And then some pushing and shoving. And maybe it would have stayed that way had news of the bombings not hit.

The Galleanist Plot is impressive in its scope, bombs mailed to dozens of prominent Americans across the nation. Some have arrived early, but through luck none have gone off, Ole Hanson’s staff opened their package at the wrong end. Unfortunately for the targets, the Post Office fails to respond in time.

On May 1st the results are explosive.

In New York, both police headquarters and city hall are rocked by explosions from bombs directed at the Commissioner and Mayor respectively. Neither man is harmed. Commissioner Enright is, ironically, overseeing the response to the May Day protests. Mayor Hylan does not open his own mail, although thankfully his clerk survives.

Washington D.C. is the site of one successful bombing, and one very important failed one.

Secretary of Labor William Wilson has not relation to President Woodrow Wilson, except that he serves in the latter's cabinet. Although a Union Man, an immigrant Mineworker, he is insufficiently radical for Anarchists. Afterall, he did support the government during wartime. Wilson is hit through the stomach by some shrapnel, and will die a slow death in a Washington Hospital.

The bomb mailed to Attorney General Palmer does not kill him, as he is near the back off the house when the package explodes. But it does kill his wife. Roberta Dixon Palmer is indeed the one opening the package, and so is killed instantly. Many expect Palmer to resign after this tragedy but he instead throws himself into his work.

The blast also sends shrapnel towards the nearby sidewalk, where it impales itself into the spine of a neighbor passing by, the Assistant Secretary of the Navy who will never walk again.

Word begins to spread quickly of the bombings, as it becomes apparent this is an organized attack. Telegrams are frantically sent across the nation, urging Americans not to open their mail. Newspaper boys and Postmen are sent on their routes at odd times, to try and retrieve any packages sent. This, and the general irregularities of the mail system manage to keep the majority of the bombs from killing anyone, but not all.

In Chicago, Kenesaw Mountain Landis is wondering if he can sneak off the bench early to catch a game when the package he opens kills him. His crime is overseeing the trials of anti-war activists from the Federal Court.

And someone, it's not entirely clear who, seriously botches the warnings in Jackson, Mississippi. The Mayor, Walter Scott, is killed at his home. As is the local newspaper editor, Frederick Bullmers, who will not die until the next day. Most egregiously, poor security at the Governor's mansion kills Governor Theordore Bilbo, along with a secretary and two servants.

Naturally this sets off a wave of panic in the City. Unfortunately this panic takes the form of a White Lynch Mob. 14 Black men are killed outright by the mob while another 21 Black men, woman, and children die as Jackson's black neighborhoods are burned to the ground. Violence spreads across Mississippi over the coming days. It is the beginning of a very long Summer of racist violence.

Bouncing back to the protests, news that bombs have gone off at the homes of key American figures makes a bad situation worse.

The situation in Cleveland is hampered by rumors about the situation that exaggerate it beyond a pretty bad truth. More citizens join the fray against the Socialists, who in turn begin to suffer infighting over the topic of abandoning the march at this point. By the end of the day, 10 will be dead. 1 counterprotester and 9 socialists. Newspapers will note, with a wink and a nod to the far right, that most of those arrested were foreign born.

Similar scenes emerge from across the East Coast, although none as bloody as Cleveland. 5 dead in New York, 2 in Boston. Chicago, largely burnt out already, has one death attributed to the protesters. Although he is later revealed to have gotten drunk after the fray and fallen into the river.

The number of deaths that can be attributed to reactions to the protests and bombing far outnumbers the number actually killed by the Left today. But most people do not care. The Left, filled to the brim with radical immigrants in their view, has just unleashed a wave of violence upon the United States.

Most of the bombs not yet delivered or opened are recovered, although a Rockefeller aide suffers burned eyebrows on May Fifth.

And where is the President during this critical moment?

In Paris.

In total fairness, Mr. Wilson is not idly touring the city of love. Rather he is busy hammering out the final details of the Treaty of Versailles, which will 100% stop all future wars guys please believe me. The Germans are aghast at things like returning land they stole, admitting responsibility for the war, paying reparations to Belgium, and letting Poland exist. In fact, they are being presented with these terms right now in early May.

But while Wilson is not exactly avoiding his Presidential duties, he's not exactly filling the American people with confidence at the moment. The patriotic fervor of the war is fading, and Americans are beginning to retreat back into their traditional isolationist shell. Having the President out of the country feels a bit like they're being abandoned. And they don't like what they are hearing about this post-war mega-alliance The League of Nations, whose mission statement is to not take over the world. It sounds suspiciously like foreign entanglements.

As Summer begins, the Justice Department begins a wide ranging search for the perpetrators of the bombings. This effort is headed up by one J. Edgar Hoover. Any attempts at a follow up bombing are quashed quickly as virtually every local haunt is swarmed with Feds, Local or State Police, or very angry locals. Galleani is arrested on the 12th of May, and although he will argue his innocence, he never really stands a chance. He will meet his end in the Electric Chair, along with two of his associates, the rest going into deep hiding or finding themselves deported without anyone realizing their involvement. Of course, many innocents are swept up in the sweep at well.

However, this is just the beginning.
 
Top