Of Rajahs and Hornbills: A timeline of Brooke Sarawak

November-December 1905: The end of an era, and the start of one anew
Lily Brooke Kathleen Hudden.jpg

The outskirts of Kuching, Kingdom Of Sarawak, 17 November 1905


Lily Brooke was close to breaking.

It wasn’t the fact that the present day marked the anniversary of her husband’s death, though that did crush her spirit. It wasn't the fact that her mother is still inconsolable, though that did made her anxious and frustrated as the only daughter. It wasn’t even that her two children, Walter and Elizabeth, now playing on the front verandah of the royal bungalow, were too young to understand how much they had lost.

No, it was because of the barge that would arrive tomorrow morning… bearing her late father and brother.

No, not only that. Despite it being four days since their deaths, her other brother is still avoiding her letters and telegrams. From the moment she heard the news and recovered from the grief, Lily reached out to her only surviving sibling, only to be answered with silence upon silence upon utter silence. She knew what it meant, and she knew Clayton was grieving in his own way, but she was afraid that her brother might not be sound of mind after watching her father’s…

No. He mustn’t. He can’t.

“Telegrams for Dayang Lily!” [A]

She almost jumped at the voice; the footsteps of the Malay postman halted before the gravel path and the front steps. Something about her emotions must have shown on her face, for his’ immediately turned concerning beneath his blue cap. “Dayang Lily, are you fine?”

She could her the children’s governess standing up to speak, and the Sikh garden-guards turning their heads at his outspokenness. “No, wait! it’s alright! It’s - um… alright. I’m fine.” She changed her language. “Surat saya? – My papers?”

Di sini – here.” The postman handed over a thick sheaf of wrapped paper. Something must have still shown on her face, for he also said after a moment, in halting English, “And my deep regrets. From all of us. Know that we are all sad, with you.” Then, he turned around and walked down the gravel path. Watching the man disappear into the day, Lily then turned her attention to the papers in her hands. The undersea cables between Sundaland and the wider world must have been repaired, for the Italians and French and the Russians in Phuket had cut them all off to cripple any sort of communication with Britain and India; Sarawak had been dearth of any news about the war in Europe for the past few months.

Still, she wondered what would entail such a response to herself; usually, it was her father and brothers whom received such papers. Then, she stilled.


DEEPEST CONDOLENCES FOR YOUR LOSS...

HENRY STUART JOHNSON


What? Lily was stunned. Henry? Uncle Henry? But it wasn’t that. As she went through the papers, it was clear why they were sent to her.


WISHING YOU WELL...

...MAY GOD WATCH OVER YOU

...YOUR FAMILY SHALL RISE FROM TRAGEDY...


At the end of each passage was inscribed the name of the sender, and they were from all across her extended family and friends from Great Britain. The Crookshanks, the Bampfyldes, the Nicols, the de Windts… and some were even prefaced with titles: The former Admiral of the Fleet; the Director of the London Museum of Natural History; even the bloody Barrington viscount of Ireland! [AA]

Somehow, the last paper surfaced so quickly to her eyes.


TAKE COURAGE ... LONG LIVE SARAWAK

HOPE BROOKE


“Mummy? What’s wrong?”

Lily turned aside, and realized that she could barely see her son through her tears.

With all the love of a mother, she folded her knees and hugged her Walter.

“It’s nothing dear. It’s nothing at all.”

But it was something. Even as rivulets began to flow down her face, even as she shook with sobs, an iron strength began to coalesce in her core, as if the letters were transferring their hope through her skin. A new fire began to course through Lily’s veins. She would not stay silent and no nothing. She wasn’t just a Dayang, or a sibling, she was a Brooke, and she would get her brother out of his moroseness even if it meant barging into his room, console his feelings, and then slap him to his senses.


********************


Charles_Brooke,_Rajah_of_Sarawak.jpg
ClarkeBrooke.png


Amarjit Kaur, Sarawak under Charles, (Lido Press, 1999)

…an estimated 60,000 people crammed the rivers and ports of Sarawak to witness the funeral procession sail back to Kuching. During a refuelling stop at Sibu, a parade of Chinese Methodists led a ceremony at the pier, praying their respects to the monarch who offered them a new home. Across the Sarawak River, scores of residents clambered up riverside palms to view the convoy, or rowed their sampans to accompany the fleet. When the bodies of Charles and his son Clarke finally arrived to the capital, an estimated 100,000 mourners – some travelling for over a week – crammed the narrow streets and shophouses of the city to the absolute limit.

With the oceans still unsafe and their body conditions degraded, it was decided that Charles Anthoni Johnson Brooke, the White Rajah and war leader who reigned for 37 years, and Clarke Willis Brooke, the crown prince whom was supposed to inherit that legacy, would be buried in Sarawak. Laid to rest in the very soil the family had ruled.

Their funerals themselves were a spectacle to behold. The wood-built cathedral of St. Thomas was packed to overflowing, with the Chinese and Dayak congregations sitting side-to-side with their European fellows. Westwards, the imam of Kuching’s Grand Mosque led a Friday funeral khutbah to a worshipping crowd that equally overflowed onto the riverside cemetery. Across Sarawak, mourning and remembrance rituals were conducted across many Dayak longhouses, honouring their fallen warriors and to the semangat-filled leaders whom upheld the values of the land. Charles Brooke did much for Sarawak, but he and his eldest son had never united it as deeply as with their own deaths.

But it wasn’t only their deaths that Sarawak mourned. Despite being a regional player in the Great War, the kingdom felt the horrific consequences of industrial conflict first-hand. From the Italian bombardment of Bandar Charles, to the conquest and reconquest of the outlying archipelagos, to the horrific Askari atrocities along the Kinabatangan, the casualty rates among Sarawakians reached untold proportions never before seen in Bornean historiography. Over 8,000 Dayak warriors and Sarawak Rangers perished in the land battles of Borneo, along with over 4,000 sailors and seamen from both the kingdom’s navy and merchant marine. The civilian casualties were just as high, with up to an estimated 7,000 men, women, and children dying at the hands of Italian soldiers, Jeune Ecole bombardments, and Askari massacres.

All in all, the Kingdom of Sarawak with her 400,000-strong population lost an estimated 19,231 souls to the Great War. 4.7% of her entire people. While seemingly paltry when compared to the astronomical death tolls of Europe and Africa, the kingdom’s largest warrior-army ever fielded by the Brookes till then (the Kayan Expedition of 1863) comprised of over 15,000 men. In short, Sarawak not only lost her Rajah and prospective heir, but also the equivalent of an entire army to slaughter. Almost every Malay village and Dayak longhouse across the lowlands were affected, losing either a sailor, a porter, a warrior, or a Ranger to the carnage.

With this, it is no small wonder why, to this day, Sarawak is one of the few nations of Asia that holds a Remembrance Day for their fallen from the War.


Saratok War Memorial.jpg


Photograph of a commemoration ceremony for a Great War memorial at Saratok, 1921.

But the deaths of Charles and Clarke also heralded a deeper, more subtle finality: the end of an era. Though his death saw eulogies and obituaries scrawled upon the broadsheets of the region, many newspapers overlooked how Sarawak became an awkward, near-absolutist state under Rajah Charles’ rule. Indeed, one could argue that, for a state on the cusp of the twentieth century, Sarawakian government resembled that of medieval Europe. From the Astana, chieftains and headmen made their way to see Charles Brooke, paying their respects and espousing their troubles in an altered form of paying court.

Despite the kingdom bearing a Resident-Councillor system of rule that engendered consensus among the river basins, absolute power began to accrue on the person of the monarch, with Charles having a final say in new laws, taxes, and bills across the land. The Council Negri – the assembly of chieftains, headmen, and European residents – was nothing more than an advisory body, assembled only once in three years to be nothing more than a rubber stamp to enforce Charles’ will. His position as head of the Kuching High Court also saw undue influence in law, being able to enact punishments and sentences on important cases.

But in matters of war and peace, the Rajah was truly paramount. The expansion of Sarawak saw Charles Brooke adopting the roles of general, commander, arbitrator, and envoy on both the national and international stage. Not only did he cobbled peace treaties and declare war on recalcitrant tribes on his own, but fought on the front lines with his Dayak-Malay auxiliaries and carved up the Bruneian Empire through repeated intrusions of territory, and often personally. The Italian writer Emilio Salgari was not wholly exaggerating when he noted, “…The White Rajah of Borneo personifies the saying: ‘L'état, C'est Moi’ – The State, I Am.’”

The Great War heralded this end. It also trumpeted another closure; that of the patronizing way the kingdom was ruled. Though the late 19th century saw a rise in settled towns, a native merchant class, new infrastructure, and increased transport, Rajah Charles still viewed the Dayaks and Malays as not worthy of the industrial age. In short, he and his sons saw the preservation of traditional society as a moral, near-sacred duty. While this thinking averted Sarawak from the mass exploitation concurrent with colonialism elsewhere, it also left the state severely behind on development; there were no general hospitals, nor a modern naval command, or even a standing army. Education was still under the purview of churches and mosques, while railways were spare and only used to transport ore from regional mines to the docks. Past the material towns, the rainforest beyond still covered over 90% of Sarawak, wild and verdant.

It was this kingdom that Clayton Brooke found himself the ruler of, and he did not take it well. While most chieftains noted his stoicism upon receiving his father and brother’s bodies at Sandakan, Clayton became emotionally distant from his fellows and his family, not even receiving any word from family friends or his mother and sister. The open slap that Lily Brooke gave to him upon his arrival at the Astana was a shocking show of familial discord, but so was the hug she gave him after.

It was only later on, into the following year, that the true extent of Clayton’s misgivings became fully known. But in the days following his father and brother’s funeral, such matters were eclipsed by another issue on everyone’s lips: the succession….


********************


203px-Coat_of_arms_of_the_Kingdom_of_Sarawak.svg.png


The Astana, Kuching, Kingdom of Sarawak, 1 December 1905

Clayton Brooke had felt nervousness throughout his life, but this was a new one.

“How are you feeling?” his sister asked, her hat and lipstick seeming to mask her lips shifting form.

“Like my stomach would drop out.”

“It’s only for the day-” Lil started, but a shout of “ATTENTION!!” broke off their chat. With solemnity, the pair began to walk down the Astana steps with their mother following behind, flanked all the while by a procession of Sikh guards and Sarawak Rangers. A retinue of Supreme Council members, local chieftains, and ex-Bruneian lords (“no… Sarawakian.” Clayton corrected to himself) followed behind.

The river jetty was already prepared when they arrived, with the ferry being bedecked in ribbons of yellow: the Malay colour of royalty. At the sight, Clayton held his breath. I shouldn’t be here. But with a nudging from his sister beside him, he found himself swinging his legs aboard. Then, in a seeming blink of an eye, the party found itself on the opposite bank, docking before a watching crowd by the riverfront.

I’m not ready for this, Clayton thought, and for one mad moment, he envisioned himself vaulting over his seat and swimming back to his private quarters in the royal residence. But just as quickly as the idea came, it faded, and he found himself walking into a horse-drawn carriage past a crowd of Sarawakians shouting “Tuan Rajah! Tuan Rajah!”.

I am no Rajah. I wasn’t even trained to be one. For all the twins appeared from the outside, and for all they had experienced and learnt as administrators, it was no question that Clarke Brooke was the more favoured in leadership. Daring, more headstrong, he was the one invited to the Supreme Council meetings, learning beside his father on the matters of state. Clarke was the heir who was supposed to lead Sarawak, and he was instructed on how to do so for quite some time. Not me.

But both father and brother are gone.

The carriage halted.

Clayton stepped out to an endless sea of people. The great Padang of Kuching – the open stretch of land between the High Court and the museum [1] – was brimming with souls whom came to see the unprecedented ceremony. Faces from Borneo, East Asia, Europe, and even Arabia were all mixed together in a jumble of colours, feathers, and sun-kissed parasols. It was a Friday, and the Muslim community were especially notable among the crowd, stretching out onto the local Grand Mosque. Nearby, a makeshift orchestra of Malay brassworks, Chinese strings, and Dayak reeds belted out the Sarawak anthem.

But it was what Clayton saw up ahead that truly froze him: the pavilion, stage, dais, and podium all awaiting. And beside all that, the Chief Executioner of the High Court, bearing the sword of Rajah James. [2]

Instantly, Clayton recalled his sister’s words before the Supreme Council. “The people need a symbol to show that all will be well. Something like this has not been done before, but it would go a long way to instil confidence in Sarawak. And amongst our neighbours.

“Breathe.” His sister whispered, and the Rajah-to-be realized that he had been holding his breath. Swallowing his nervousness, Clayton let himself be moved with the ceremony, accepting the sword of James Brooke before affixing it to his waist. Then, he climbed onto the podium to face the people. His people.

And amongst them all, he saw a face. A face that showed concern, hope, and determination for the man. Clayton looked, and felt his hesitation slipping away.

When James Brooke became Rajah, there was hardly any ceremony. When Charles Brooke ascended, he swore an oath before the Council Negri from the Astana. Now, Clayton would etch a new mark in Sarawak history.

Here we go.


********************


brooke sword copy.jpg

The first sentence of Rajah Clayton’s accession oath:


“Kita, Clayton George Brooke, bersumpah diatas semua kitab suci untuk membaktikan Nyawa keatas kemakmuran rakyat sebagai Rajah negara Sarawak!”

- “We, Clayton George Brooke, swear on all the sacred scriptures to dedicate Our lives to the people’s prosperity as Rajah of the nation of Sarawak!” [3]​

____________________

Notes:

+
The picture I used for Lily Brooke is actually Kathleen Hudden, the wife of Anthony Brooke IOTL.

[A]
'Dayang' is an old Malay term that used to mean "servant" or "lady-in-waiting" in an esteemed household. However, the word in Brunei picked up noble connotations and was later used to denote royalty and nobility, meaning "High Lady" or "Princess". Sarawak, being a conquerer of much of Brunei, retained the term and used it for their own, both IOTL and ITTL.

[AA]
The names and families in the telegrams are all connected to Sarawak in some way. Some are based in OTL and some are ITTL.

a) Henry Stuart Johnson is the brother of Charles Brooke and of John Brooke Johnson, the first crown prince of Sarawak under Rajah James (or at least until he allowed the Dutch to retake the Sentarum Floodplains). While he died in 1904 IOTL, he lives just long enough in this timeline to get some comforting words out to his niece.

b)
The Crookshanks are the family of Arthur Chichester Crookshank, a cousin of James Brooke who became the Rajah’s chief secretary from the 1840’s to the 1870’s IOTL. He remains mostly unchanged in this timeline (somehow, there’s no public genealogy that I could find online about him).

c)
The Bampfyldes are the family of Charles Agar Bampfylde, a son of a British Major whom worked in the Sarawak Civil Service and as Resident of the Kuching Division throughout Rajah Charles’ reign. After retiring in 1903, he became the kingdom’s political agent in Great Britain, a duty that he still serves ITTL.

d)
The Nicols are the family of James Dyce Nicol, a Scottish Liberal politician whom funded Sarawak’s early phase under Rajah James and was director of the Borneo Company Ltd, the monopolistic corporation that’s handling the kingdom’s gold mines. ITTL, the family haven’t forgotten their Bornean investments.

e)
The de Windts are Margaret Brooke’s extended family and siblings. While there was some friction between the parents and her due to her marriage, members of the family did serve in Sarawak as Residents, civil servants, or aide-de-camps under Rajah Charles. Indeed, Margaret’s brother Harry de Windt worked in the kingdom for a few years as aide-de-camp before becoming an explorer in his own right.

f)
The (Former) Admiral of the Fleet: a five-star officer rank and the highest rank of the Royal Navy. A few British admirals with this rank served in Sarawak or with James and Charles Brooke, such as Sir Thomas Cochrane and Sir Henry Keppel. ITTL, it was these men that covered for Sarawak’s naval losses and secretly aided the kingdom during the Great War.

g)
[the] Director of the London Museum of Natural History: The eponymous museum in London contains (even OTL) many specimens collected by naturalists in Sarawak, including from Alfred Russel Wallace, a friend of the Brooke family and a major backer of the Sarawak Museum in Kuching. Because of this history, the director and Wallace himself send their condolences.

h)
[even the] bloody Barrington viscount of Ireland! : aka. Walter Barrington, the 9th Viscount of Barrington of Ardglass in the County of Down, in what is today Northern Ireland. As a member of the British and Irish aristocracy, he never thought much of the White Rajahs in his life, until…

i)
…Hope Brooke aka. John Charles Evelyn Hope Brooke came along. He is a son of John Brooke Johnson (the first heir to Sarawak) and married viscount Barrington’s daughter, Violet Mary Barrington, in 1892, making the Barrington family in-laws to the Brooke dynasty. I decided to keep the marriage ITTL because:

aa) it’s waaaay too odd to be knocked-off, and
bb) the other aristocratic family I wanted to include (the Brooke Baronets) didn’t have any marriageable girls from the 1890’s to 1905.​

1.
You can still visit the open field at Kuching today, though the front portion – behind the courthouse – has been built over into today’s Plaza Merdeka shopping mall.

2.
The sword of James Brooke was a cutlass that he personally used during his years at Sarawak. IOTL, it was presented to each succeeding ruler on their accession and displayed on important ceremonies. ITTL, it is one of the symbols of royal regalia that Clayton must arm for his accession. The photo of the sword was one I took myself from my visit to Kuching.

3.
Incredibly, we still have the accession oath of Charles Vyner Brooke, (the OTL third Rajah of Sarawak) of which I tweaked the words around. During Vyner’s accession, he was coronated inside the Sarawak Club, a private building for the officers of the kingdom. ITTL, the pain of the Great War and the deaths of Rajah Charles and the crown prince Clarke would push the Astana for a more public coronation ceremony in downtown Kuching. This would ensure the public that Sarawak and the Brooke family would continue, no matter what. And yes, this would set a precedent.

EDIT: Okay, I did not realize noting stuff using the alphabet would embold the whole update! Also tweaked a few words and errors.
 
Last edited:
I've been reading this TL from the very beginning, and I have to say the storytelling was superb. :) I can't wait to see what the future holds for the Kingdom of Sarawak under the reign of Rajah Clayton; I wouldn't be surprised if the kingdom survives all the way up to the present day.
 
I've been reading this TL from the very beginning, and I have to say the storytelling was superb. :) I can't wait to see what the future holds for the Kingdom of Sarawak under the reign of Rajah Clayton; I wouldn't be surprised if the kingdom survives all the way up to the present day.

Thank you! I'm always a bit apprehensive of my storytelling skills, since it pales to some of the literary masterpieces on this site and others. I'm even thinking the latest update is a tad too thick and should've been divided into two separate installments. Finding it enjoyable to others really makes my day. :D

As for whether or not Sarawak survives to the present day, there's over a hundred years to go through first. Now that Sarawak's part in the Great War is mostly over, I can finally turn my attention to other parts of the world, starting with Southeast Asia.
 
Thank you! I'm always a bit apprehensive of my storytelling skills, since it pales to some of the literary masterpieces on this site and others. I'm even thinking the latest update is a tad too thick and should've been divided into two separate installments. Finding it enjoyable to others really makes my day. :D

As for whether or not Sarawak survives to the present day, there's over a hundred years to go through first. Now that Sarawak's part in the Great War is mostly over, I can finally turn my attention to other parts of the world, starting with Southeast Asia.

All right, I will look forward to it.
 
A wonderful chapter. It seems the kingdom stands at a crossroads.

The war is not over yet. With Italy kicked out of Borneo, there might be few enemies who can affect Sarawak immediately, but if their side loses, they are still in for serious problems.
 
I'm even thinking the latest update is a tad too thick and should've been divided into two separate installments.

No, the length was fine - it was one complete narrative arc.

Sarawak could go several different directions under Clayton. He'll be a weak monarch at first and may not even want to be a strong one, so a retreat from Charles' absolutism seems guaranteed. The question is "retreat to where" - will there be some real democratization (possibly led by the war veterans), will some powerful minister or warlord establish himself as the man behind the throne, or a bit of both? Lily's place in all this will also be uncertain - Sarawakian society still seems too traditional at this point for a woman to take an open role in government, but it's clear that Clayton will rely on her.
 
A wonderful chapter. It seems the kingdom stands at a crossroads.


The war is not over yet. With Italy kicked out of Borneo, there might be few enemies who can affect Sarawak immediately, but if their side loses, they are still in for serious problems.

It all depends on how the Great War is faring on the rest of the world, now. Globally, attention is focused on Europe, Africa, and maybe even the Caribbean. Closer to home, everyone’s eying at Indochina, Papua, and Russian Phuket – though the latter island’s status may be moot by the time of Clayton’s coronation.

As for Sarawak’s future, everyone’s holding their breath.

No, the length was fine - it was one complete narrative arc.


Sarawak could go several different directions under Clayton. He'll be a weak monarch at first and may not even want to be a strong one, so a retreat from Charles' absolutism seems guaranteed. The question is "retreat to where" - will there be some real democratization (possibly led by the war veterans), will some powerful minister or warlord establish himself as the man behind the throne, or a bit of both? Lily's place in all this will also be uncertain - Sarawakian society still seems too traditional at this point for a woman to take an open role in government, but it's clear that Clayton will rely on her.

Thank you!

The future of Sarawak is wellspring of possibilities. There’s a few hints that Clayton won’t be like his father or elder brother: He wasn’t educated in the finer notions of statecraft like Clarke, and his feelings of inadequacy hints at a deep discomfort of his new position. But with that said, he’s also capable of leadership as the Sandakan campaign showed, so there is a chance that he may grow into the role of Rajah. As per @Icedaemon, Sarawak is truly standing at a crossroads.

Lily Brooke is another wildcard. Unlike her brothers, she is not educated in statecraft or administration whatsoever. But she also possesses an attitude that hints at a willingness to pick up the pieces and patch things together, even if they’re a bit eyebrow-raising. The open slap and hug she gave to Clayton at the Astana says as much of her character as helping her brother become the Rajah he could be.

You are right in that Sarawakian society is still traditional, so whatever the case, her actions will be magnified by local lenses.

And so it begins. All hail Rajah Clayton of Sarawak. Long may he reign.

From the mountains to the seas, may he give the kingdom recovery and prosperity.

(Can’t think of good quotes at the moment)
 
Well Dutch Borneo looks like a nice crown jewel to add to Sarawak. Be a shame if something were to... happen.

And the Dutch would immediately say "Do you really want the entire East Indies to be your enemy?"

Joking aside, Sarawak's immediate concern would be to repair and rebuild from the damage of the Great War and administer Italian Sabah occupied territory, and they just lost the equivalent of an army and navy just to fight against Italian Borneo. A campaign against the Dutch, even at the border regions, would strain the kingdom to near-unsustainable levels. It would also antagonize the British, whom would wonder why their Royal Navy is following the orders of Kuching against Batavian interests. Not even their five-star admirals could cover something that massive.

But, if the influence is political or economic... Sarawak may have a few tricks up its sleeve. The Brooke family are solid believers in traditional rights, the native merchant class is expanding, and I did mention some time back that a road is being hacked through the border to the Dutch-controlled Sentarum Floodplains. The interactions between Sarawakians and Dutch Borneans could get... interesting, in the long run.
 
Last edited:
Well Dutch Borneo looks like a nice crown jewel to add to Sarawak. Be a shame if something were to... happen.

Yeah I don't see a Brooke Borneo happening. I refer you to the maps on the "1905 The Great(World) War" chapter. Even if Sarawak gets its best territory deal from this (all of occupied Sabah and a juicy slice of Brunei); they will still control less territory than the Dutch. An as the war shows the Sarawakian military is ill equipped to fight even the colonial armies of the modern era. And I expect the DEI has better and far more experienced military forces than the newcomer Italians did in the region.

Also Rajah Clayton I think will be less focused on expansion. He has suffered tragedies in war and will not have the same view of it as the previous Rajahs I expect. He will fight to defend his country ad to put down rebellions, but he may be be willing to settle for what the peace will give Sarawak.

And in the immediate terms I expect there will be tensions in Sabah and some issues with newly British Brunei.

I would not be surprised if we are seeing the end of Sarawakian expansion. Though there might be some changes when decolonization starts rolling. Perhaps the Sentaurum floodplains sold back to Kuching by a Batavia struggling to hold the colonial Empire together, or the de jure protectorates becoming independent only to join Sarawak rather than the Indonesia equivalent?

But even with that I expect Borneo will never be synonymous with Sarawak.
 
Last edited:
Well Dutch Borneo looks like a nice crown jewel to add to Sarawak. Be a shame if something were to... happen.
In terms of conquering...good luck, by this time the Dutch were pretty well entrenched in a way the Italians never were. The only way I can the rest of Borneo joining Sarawak is if some kind of third power arbiter either gives it to Sarawak via a second world war or if some kind of Military power i.e Japan forcibly puts them together, again, via WW2. They're simply to behind in several factors to such as population or industrialization to be anything other than a secondary regional power. Cambodia may even have a larger population, and they have nowhere near as much landmass. Sarawak will most likely use the war as a way to unify the population and over the next several years may get away with regaining the floodplains but almost assuredly from negotiations rather than war. It's not all bad though, with the amount of oil they have coupled with their coastline and premier position in the most valuable trade network in the world, it's not like they need all of Borneo to be a regional power. Right now Clayton's main focus should be steady population growth, increased democracy, increasing literacy, building public hospitals, schools etc.
 
The only way I can the rest of Borneo joining Sarawak is if some kind of third power arbiter either gives it to Sarawak via a second world war or if some kind of Military power i.e Japan forcibly puts them together, again, via WW2
Surely the DEI Independence movement could go differently, and the rest of Borneo prefers a Brooke led government than being part of the Javanese Empire, as I believe some of the outlying bits of Indonesia tend to think of their government.

Not terribly likely, I don't suppose, but surely possible.
 
Perhaps in this timeline, because the Dutch do not end up occupied during alt-WWII (should that even occur at around the same time) and gradually lose influence over parts of their colonies, being forced to let go of pieces of the DEI a few at a time while clinging to others. Some of the independent sultanates in mid-Borneo start oppressing the Dayaks who go to Sarawak for aid?

I'd still expect the maximal territory of Sarawak to be around half the island, with maybe the sultanates directly southeast of original Sarawak also absorbed and the inland Dayak-majority areas choosing to be part of cosmopolitan Sarawak rather than an officially islamic state which would not respect their traditions.
 
Last edited:
Surely the DEI Independence movement could go differently, and the rest of Borneo prefers a Brooke led government than being part of the Javanese Empire, as I believe some of the outlying bits of Indonesia tend to think of their government.

Not terribly likely, I don't suppose, but surely possible.
An interesting idea i suppose. I think something like that happening is very dependent on how prosperous and stable Sarawak can be during its post war phase. Im of the opinion that the nationalism that accompanies Independence movements usually need an "idea" behind it. OTL i beleive the memory of Majapahit was used as a unifying factor post-ww2. The Dayaks would need to see Sarawak as "their" state, or as the true state of Borneo, which is unlikely so long as the only control what was once Brunei territory.

Whats more likely in my opinion is that Clayton will focus more on reforms with some minor unrest happening as he does away with old traditions. There will be probobly NOT be any kind of military strongman as Clayton is experienced leading troops and proboly wouldnt allow the military to be run by a stranger (if hes smart). Sarawak will probobly go through a period of reflection as those that served and suffered build an identity around shared grief and heroism. There will probobly be lots of writings in the coming years about Sarawaks unique christian-muslim and even hindu, and sikh harmony. And who knows, i can even see movements in the future to NOT annex some parts of Borneo because they're "not like us". We'll just have to wait and see what the author has in store for us.
 
Yeah I don't see a Brooke Borneo happening. I refer you to the maps on the "1905 The Great(World) War" chapter. Even if Sarawak gets its best territory deal from this (all of occupied Sabah and a juicy slice of Brunei); they will still control less territory than the Dutch.
In terms of conquering...good luck, by this time the Dutch were pretty well entrenched in a way the Italians never were.

And the D.E.I's humongous navy could curb-stomp Sarawak's paltry fleet of 5 battleships and 13 river gunboats, of which half are now sunk or damaged as a result of warring with the Italians. The military and naval disparity between Kuching and Batavia is too great for the Brookes to overcome, even with all their jungle expertise and penchant for strategy augmentation. While the future of Borneo is still uncertain, a war for the whole island at this time is an exercise in stupidity, especially with other issues being more important.

At the moment, Batavia is focused on keeping itself above the Great War. Being openly neutral allows them to sell stuff to all sides, and the colonial Dutch government is scared shitless of what happened at Italian Sabah; Mass-decapitation is not something to be taken flippantly. As a side effect though, I can see colonial officials trying to sponsor Christian missionaries to convert the interior tribes of Dutch Borneo, hoping to wean them off their 'savage traditions' to prevent a repeat occurrence.

I would not be surprised if we are seeing the end of Sarawakian expansion. Though there might be some changes when decolonization starts rolling.
Surely the DEI Independence movement could go differently, and the rest of Borneo prefers a Brooke led government than being part of the Javanese Empire, as I believe some of the outlying bits of Indonesia tend to think of their government.
Perhaps in this timeline, because the Dutch do not end up occupied during alt-WWII (should that even occur at around the same time) and gradually lose influence over parts of their colonies, being forced to let go of pieces of the DEI a few at a time while clinging to others. Some of the independent sultanates in mid-Borneo start oppressing the Dayaks who go to Sarawak for aid?
An interesting idea i suppose. I think something like that happening is very dependent on how prosperous and stable Sarawak can be during its post war phase.

I'll only say for now that when decolonization finally sweeps Southeast Asia, a lot of things will change. An alternate World War II may happen, or may not, and Japan's path to militarism is dependent on a lot of variable factors that can change ITTL. One could say the same for Russia and China, too.

And speaking of sultanates and empires, I found something really incredible whilst searching through the Net for the history of Bornean Anglicanism (basically, I was trying to find a photo of Kuching's old St. Thomas Cathedral): a political map of Dutch Borneo in the 19th and early 20th centuries, with every sultanate, petty state, and chiefdom mapped out:

There's even a map of the Chinese kongsi republics, which I thought wasn't even mapped!

b1760-1920.gif
borneo-2.gif
 
OTL i beleive the memory of Majapahit was used as a unifying factor post-ww2. The Dayaks would need to see Sarawak as "their" state, or as the true state of Borneo, which is unlikely so long as the only control what was once Brunei territory.

Modern Indonesia does base its unifying factor on the old Majapahit, and there's a high chance Indonesian / Nusantaran nationalists ITTL will use the empire's glories to claim the whole archipelago as theirs; it's the only thread of commonality that links all the islands, ethnicities, and people groups.

As for Dutch views on the matter ITTL, they are trying to enforce colonial unity (and avert Islamic reformism) by encouraging standard Javanese language and writing across the whole archipelago, which will be... quite a thing to swallow for the Malay-influenced regions of Sumatra and West Borneo. o_O
 
mini-update: industrial openings (and troubles) in Johor
Johor Bahru 1906.jpg


Johor Bahru, Johor Sultanate, 6 January 1906

“… with this, I declare this factory ‘open’!!”

The hulking edifice of cement and brick shaded the mass of attendees as they clapped and posed for the photographers with their new-fangled tripods. But with that, Jaafar Muhammad braced himself for what was about to follow. As Chief Minister of Johor, it was his duty to stand in for the sultan whenever the monarch was unable to attend. However, that did not mean he enjoyed answering the questions chirped again and again by the gaggle of attended investors, especially regarding his old friend.

On the contrary, it was exasperating.

“Yes, he is still infirm from his stomach ailment.” Jaafar rattled. “– No, we do not know when he shall return to peak health – No, we do not know if he shall attend the next factory opening – Yes, he extends his regards to you too, Mr. Brenner – No, we are still not an official participant in this World War – Thank you all for coming. Thank you!”

And with that, the man extricated himself from the rabble and took off with his police escort, calling his shaded hansom cab to be driven through downtown Johor Bahru as quick as possible, back to the palace. A rickshaw would have been far slower, and the midday heat and wind would’ve been uncomfortable on such a vehicle. And besides, Jaafar liked the privacy.

Well, at least Abu Bakar would be happy about today, he mused. The idea of industrialising Johor was a long-running endeavour for both the sultan and himself, but the industry of Singapore and the southern island’s mass-imports have always proved a detriment to the plan. Now, with the Great War a serious local threat, and with the price of local goods rising, any industry that could improve British and Ottoman victory helps. Though I need to talk to him about our production standards. No need to sell the British and Turks improper or shoddy military kits.

But as he thought that, a new noise lifted Jaafar from his musings.

It came from up ahead, where the main road intersects with the neighbourhood where the European community held their businesses. From his position out the window, the two side-streets of Jalan Paris and Lebuh Kaisar [1] were enveloped in dust and smoke. He could hear shouts and hollering, and many street pedestrians craned their necks to see the scrum up ahead. The cab slowed to a halt.

“Is there anything wrong?” Jaafar asked the coachman, who said, “There seems to be some commotion up ahead, Tuan. Maybe a hartal ?” [2]

Impossible. But then, a scream split the air, and open flames began to rise from the district down ahead. Three Caucasian-looking men emerged from the smoke, running up the road while being followed by a rabble of surly-faced Indians, Arabs, and Malays. Jaafar only needed a second to reach a decision, calling out his escort to stop the pursuers and shouting “In here!!” to the three men. As soon as they all crammed onto the seats, he sounded another order for the coach to head back to the city’s police headquarters as fast as possible.

“As Chief Minister of this state, you all have my full protection. Can you tell me what happened?” he asked above the clattering of hooves.

“I’m Hermann, and this is Vernier and Mossé!” One replied, panting. “They are attacking all the French shops! They tried to escape to mine, and the mob began to attack mine too! I think it’s because of the recent news from Europe!”

Jaafar immediately understood. Another reason why we aren't officially in the War. Johor, unlike its Ottoman-aligned neighbour, was a sultanate of minorities. The Chinese population alone outnumbered the Malays and Indians combined, and the capital bears families that hail from Japan all the way to Scotland. But the pot has boiled over now. Looks like I’ll need to assemble the Royal Council.

But the police station was now up ahead, and Jaafar knew what to do first.


____________________


Notes:

I’m still working on the Southeast Asia instalment, so have a mini-narrative interlude for my lateness.

1. Jalan Paris and Lebuh Kaisar: Paris Street and Kaiser Avenue, respectively.

2. ‘Hartal’ is a Gujerati word that refers to strike action, often in a form of mass protest through the closing of shops and warehouses until the demands of strikers are satisfied. Though used mostly across South Asia, the word migrated to colonial Malaya due to the British colony’s large Indian minority, leading to the word becoming embedded in some colonial and post-colonial strikes such as the Penang hartal of 1967.
 
Last edited:
One participant who I am curious about in this mess is Australia, new born federation that it is.

In a nutshell, Australia is greeting this war with a bit of patriotic optimism and invasion anxiety. French Caledonia and New Guinea (especially Italian Papua) has long been a bit of a thorn in the federation's foreign policy so the first Australian battalions will be sent there. However, the same mountainous terrain that aided northern Sarawak will prove the same to French and Italian settlers, and the Australian government will find itself sending more and more men to a tropical hellpit. By this time, the optimism is long gone.

Domestically, the war has boosted local industry with the mining sector experiencing the most growth. Along with that, the shipyards of Cockatoo Island in Sydney are working overdrive to fulfill the rising mountain of orders from the Royal Navy, and a certain tropical adventurer-state.
 
Top