Your brutality wounds me! *dies*
There's two kinds of alternate historians. There's the ones who create an alternate history to the detail and then create maps to go with it and then there's the "bad" ones who work with certain specific ideas instead of creating an impenetrable wall of a backstory
I'm one of the bad alt. historians. As I've said many times, I explore an idea, make a map and then create a backstory to fit it
Hence why you vote for the entry with the solid background, I vote for the interesting idea
Each to their own. As Life of Brian taught us, you are all individuals!
*faint echo* we are all individuals!
And mind you, if I've learned one thing by studying history it's that all the things we consider obvious or matter of fact , all the reactions we'd expect people to exhibit tend to mean squat when push comes to shove
Again and again, history throws completely unexpected things in our faces and we're left wondering "where the hell did that come from"
while trying to clean up the mess and gore