Moose Season: A Progressive Party Timeline

5: Xenophon Wilfley (32)

Xenophon P. Wilfley
“Who?”
Democratic Party
(1925-1925)

jF7TQLr.png

Xenophon Wilfley was not a man that anyone expected to become President of the United States. A lawyer and teacher, Wilfley was a minor election office official when he was chosen by the Governor of Missouri (a close friend of his) to become one of Missouri’s Senators following the death of William Stone in the B&O Railroad disaster of late 1915. Until the start of the 1920’s, Wilfley was an obscure Senator who seemed unlikely to be anything more than a footnote in a history book. However, Wilfley put forth a bill to modernize the postal service by connecting major cities with pneumatic tubes for delivering mail. Wilfley was able to gather a coalition of Democrats and Progressives, who liked the idea of putting veterans to work, and Republicans who saw the system as a means to continue mail service when railway workers were striking. The Pneumatic Parcel Post Act of 1922 was passed with large majorities in both houses of Congress and work soon began on the great series of tubes. Later in the year, Wilfley’s fellow Missouri Senator James Reed nominated him for the position of Senate President pro tempore when the Senate was deadlocked after the midterm elections. Despite being third in line for the Presidency, the post was seen as largely ceremonial and Wilfley, seen as a moderate who was willing to compromise, was confirmed with a large majority.

During the summer of 1924, Wilfley remained quiet on the matter of the Teapot Dome scandal, especially after being informed that Martin Madden, the Speaker of the House, was not a natural born citizen and would be unable to become President. After Vice President Edwin Denby resigned, Wilfley was effectively first in line to succeed Fall. During Fall’s impeachment trial, Wilfley abstained from voting in order not to seem too eager to take Fall’s place. Later interviews have suggested that Wilfley, like most Senators, thought that Fall was guilty and that he would have voted to remove him if he had the deciding vote.

Xenophon Wilfley took the oath of office on the steps of the Capitol in a ceremony that looked like there had been more than a day’s worth of planning. President Wilfley gave only a short speech, reflecting not only his ethereal presidency, but also the bitter cold of the January morning of his inauguration. Wilfley’s term was mostly uneventful and was mostly filled with fallout from Teapot Dome, including the indictment of Harry Sinclair on charges of bribing a public official. Given the political instability of the last 5 years, Wilfley felt that it was necessary to name a Vice President even for his short term. While it took a fair deal of persuasion, Wilfley was able to convince his friend William Jennings Bryan to come back to Washington for a month and a half. While many senators hesitated, Bryan was narrowly confirmed, mostly due to the fact that he would be serving such a short amount of time. Wilfley's decision not to pardon Fall has been discussed for nearly a century. At the time, no one criticized Wilfley due to Fall's image as a pariah; more recent works have suggested that Fall's later trial would (inadvertently on Wilfley's part) serve as a distraction for later administrations. Beyond stating that Fall deserved to face the consequences of his actions, Wilfley was silent on the subject. The end of the short Wilfley Presidency ushered in a new era marked by ideological whiplash that would last for the next quarter of a century.

Author's notes: I would like to thank history nerd for bringing Xenophon Wilfley to my attention. Back when I was searching for a filler president between Fall and the 33rd president, there was a thread which required someone whose name started with an X, and I knew that I would just have to use him. Also, I'm amazed that I can actually look up the weather from 1925 (thanks to findthebest.com). This will be the last update for at least the next week, if not more. Even though the next update will cover a short amount of time, there's a lot to cover and I have school work that needs to be done.

It's likely the progressives will win.:)

My lips (or fingers, I guess) are sealed.
 
Last edited:
6: Robert M. La Follette, Sr. (33)

Robert M. La Follette, Sr.
“Fighting Bob”
Progressive Party
(1925-1925)

x4f02vC.png


Following the creation of the Progressive Party in 1912 by Former President Roosevelt, Robert La Follette was left between a proverbial rock and hard spot. Many progressives in both the Republican and Democratic Parties had joined the Progressive Party by the 1916 election once it was clear that the Progressive Party was not a mere one-trick-moose. La Follette and much of the Wisconsin Republican Party were some of the last bastions of outspoken progressiveness in the Republican Party mainly due to La Follette’s loathing of Theodore Roosevelt, on whom he blamed for his loss in the 1912 convention. Following Roosevelt’s death in 1919, Progressive Party leaders began courting La Follette and the Wisconsin progressives, who had a near stranglehold on the Wisconsin Republican Party. Unlike in 1916, when he had given a near endorsement to Debs (stating that he was the best candidate, but not going so far as to officially endorse him), he did not choose any side in 1920. By early 1921, La Follette was convinced that the Progressive party was here to stay, saw an opening to fill the void left by Roosevelt, and thus finally chose to join the Progressives. Almost as soon as he joined, he began preparations for a run in 1924. Combined with Fall’s numerous scandals and years of preparation, La Follette secured the Progressive nomination with relative ease; he chose Wyoming Senator John Kendrick, who had originally brought Teapot Dome to his attention, as his running mate.

Following Democratic fatigue and a loss in confidence in the Republican Party, the American people were finally ready for a new political order. This initial victory for the Progressives in 1924 would cement the fifth party system* following years of instability resulting from the extended tripartisan era. While La Follette barely obtained a majority, his opposition had disintegrated on a national scale. In places with low support for one conservative party, the other was able to eke out wins not only on a presidential level, but also in down ballot races; this would not be enough to grind Washington to a halt, however.

Perhaps the biggest consequence of the breakdown of the Republican and Democratic Parties was the old party bosses’ loss of influence on national politics. While they still held sway over local and state governments, the rise of the Progressives meant that their divisions had only opened up more ways for the Progressives to take control.

tsxGF5s.png


Robert M. La Follette, Sr./John B. Kendrick 50.2% 309 EV
William G. McAdoo/Oscar W. Underwood 24.7% 178 EV
Frank O. Lowden/Herbert C. Hoover 24.5% 44 EV
Others 0.6% 0 EV

Following the brief Wilfley Presidency, Robert La Follette, Sr. was inaugurated in early March of 1925, with promises to end the corruption that wracked the Harding and Fall administrations as well as to push for reform. La Follette had been swept into office with Progressive majorities in both houses of Congress, giving him the opportunity to pass major progressive reforms. His first actions did not require legislative action, however. Since the McKinley administration, large portions of Latin America and the Caribbean had been occupied by US troops in repeated attempts to force local governments to accede to the desires of the American government and often, American business. Seeking to build a more isolationist foreign policy and to reduce the influence of large businesses, La Follette declared that United States foreign policy would be driven by what he called “Strength through Peace.” ** La Follette’s vision would guide foreign policy for the next decade and a half.

The first major bill signed by La Follette was the National Mining Safety Act of 1925, more commonly known as the Wilson-Robins Act, named after the two senators (both of whom were former miners) who wrote most of the guidelines. The Wilson-Robins Act was the first modification to mining safety in over thirty years. One of the major new rules increased the amount of ventilation required in coal mines, which would hopefully reduce the number of accidents. Equally important was the enforcement power given to the Bureau of Mines; without this vital power, the act would have been nearly toothless aside from fines imposed in the event of a fatal explosion. Senator Thomas Walsh, who played a part in removing President Fall, introduced a bill that would limit the value of gifts that any ambassador, cabinet official, member of Congress, federal judge (including the Supreme Court), or the President could accept. Walsh’s bill was passed by a nearly unanimous vote in both houses of Congress, where Fall’s impeachment was still fresh in the minds of many.

Chief Justice (and former President) William Howard Taft’s death in the summer of 1925 meant that La Follette had a chance to change the composition of the Supreme Court. He ultimately chose attorney Clarence Darrow, who shared La Follette’s passion for defending civil liberties. Darrow was swiftly confirmed by the Progressive controlled Senate.

La Follette’s brief, but promising, presidency came to an end shortly before Thanksgiving of 1925, when he died of a heart attack. *** His death meant that his successor was able to push for some more radical proposals until the next Congress was seated. Notably, former President Thomas Marshall also died on the 19th, only the second time that two presidents died on the same date.

Notes:

* Stretching from 1912 until 1944, the fifth party system was notable for the emergence of the Progressive Party as well as the coalescence of the Republican and large portions of the Democratic Party to form the Conservative Party in 1926. Some scholars say that the fourth party system lasted until the Progressive victory in 1924, and stating that the fifth party system instead started in 1924 and lasted until 1944.

** Apparently this was Dennis Kucinich’s slogan in 2008. I didn’t know that when I came up with it (I searched for it anyway, because it seemed catchy), but I guess that means it’s a good term.

*** RTL will be relieved to know that he had no “part” in La Follette’s death, nor that of La Follette’s successors.

Thanks to http://www.msha.gov/MSHAINFO/MSHAINF2.HTM for some information on historical mining safety regulations.

I would also like to apologize for the poor quality of the election map. I have fixed this as of 9/27/14.

That is a really cool presidential name, and one of the most unique choices for an althist American president.

With a name like Xenophon Wilfley, I couldn't help but find a place for him. I've never seen him used in an actual TL, only in one of those random list threads.
 
Last edited:
Due to school starting next week and the increased amount of time that this next update covers, it might be several weeks to a month before the next update. I will give one hint as to what I'll cover: Parity.
 
Good update, Fubart!:)

Thanks!

I discovered the problem with the map: In order to make it, I use the election calculator on uselectionatlas.org I then take a screenshot and patch in Arizona's coastline and upload the whole thing as a PNG to imgur. Unfortunately, the base screenshot has an awful grey background that varies pixel by pixel, making it a pain in the @$$ to go back and restore the numbers to white (the grey background lowers the contrast, making it harder to read the numbers). I went through and changed it for this map. I'm using an older map for 1928 (originally made for this TL's predecessor) that does not seem to have this problem. My best guess is that the 1928 map was made using my tablet and a different browser, resulting in a nice white background with plenty of contrast. I have reuploaded the map for 1924; hopefully it is more readable.
 
Thanks!

I discovered the problem with the map: In order to make it, I use the election calculator on uselectionatlas.org I then take a screenshot and patch in Arizona's coastline and upload the whole thing as a PNG to imgur. Unfortunately, the base screenshot has an awful grey background that varies pixel by pixel, making it a pain in the @$$ to go back and restore the numbers to white (the grey background lowers the contrast, making it harder to read the numbers). I went through and changed it for this map. I'm using an older map for 1928 (originally made for this TL's predecessor) that does not seem to have this problem. My best guess is that the 1928 map was made using my tablet and a different browser, resulting in a nice white background with plenty of contrast. I have reuploaded the map for 1924; hopefully it is more readable.

The map looks readable for me. :)
 
Nice timeline you got here. I have to say, I was dying of laughter reading the horrible luck of RTL. I was hoping he was around for Follettes death, but alas I guess he can't have that much bad luck.
 
Nice timeline you got here. I have to say, I was dying of laughter reading the horrible luck of RTL. I was hoping he was around for Follettes death, but alas I guess he can't have that much bad luck.

Thanks! I figure that RTL eventually figured out that he should stay away from the president. La Follette's death is similar to his OTL death, just pushed back a few months. I haven't forgotten about this, but I haven't had the time (or energy) to do anything more than brainstorming for the next presidency.
 
Some constructive criticsm: why was there some historical revisionism regarding to the events in Russia? Would you need a POD for that?

I'm not sure if I would need a PoD, but there was definitely an attempt to kill Rasputin, which in part led to the changes there. I just made it successful to see how it could alter history. I will say that this may not be the most accurate TL in terms of what happens abroad with respect to the butterfly effect (I'm really focusing on the US and only bringing up foreign stuff when it's important).

Also, I'm hoping to finish up the next update soon.
 
7: John B. Kendrick (34)

John B. Kendrick
“Ambitious, but mostly rubbish”
Progressive Party
(1925-1929)

pk7JKFU.png


On the morning of his hastily arranged inauguration, John Benjamin Kendrick became the fourth person to hold the office of President of the United States in a single calendar year, and the sixth person to do so in five years. His first job was to select a vice president; Kendrick ultimately chose New York Senator Franklin Roosevelt for the spot. While his predecessor had mixed feelings about the new Pneumatic Parcel Post system, President Kendrick was far more supportive and even appointed former President Wilfley as Postmaster General in order to oversee his old pet project.

The Wallace-Frazier Act, passed in late 1925, was meant to assist farmers who had been struggling since the end of price controls during World War I. Under this system, the federal government would guarantee minimum prices for many crops and animal products, with large portions of excess crops and animals being destroyed to keep prices from having to be kept higher than long term average prices (based on prices from the 1910’s). While the act enjoyed large support among farmers who saw a new age of prosperity, urbanites decried the act as a waste of money used as a ploy to attract farmers’ votes.

For the first time in US history, a former president went on trial. Following Albert Fall’s impeachment, investigations into his finances as part of the Teapot Dome Scandal continued. In early 1926, the so-called “Trial of the Century” took place in Washington, D.C., extending into the summer. The trial became one of the first mass media events and was broadcast on radio stations throughout the country, with millions of Americans listening to portions of the trial. Fall was sentenced to serve 5 years in prison for bribery and obstruction of justice.

While the Progressives did gain some seats in mid-western states, they lost many more seats in other parts of the country. The Senate results were the same, without the benefit of gaining any seats. When a few minor party seats and those progressives who still stuck with the Democratic and Republican parties despite their increasing isolation, the conservative Democrats and Republicans together held modest majorities in both houses of Congress. This effectively halted further radical reforms led by President Kendrick. While some modest proposals were passed, they were far weaker than those originally proposed by La Follette and Kendrick.

Despite losing their majorities in the 1926 midterm elections, the Progressives were still seen as the dominant party in American politics because the conservatives of the Republican and Democratic parties were split. In the months after the conservatives took back Congress, leaders from both parties met behind closed doors to discuss a coalition. After several weeks and several truckloads of tobacco products, Democratic and Republican leaders announced that the two parties would form a tentative coalition that would run a single presidential ticket in the 1928 election. Further committees would determine which parties would have influence over which areas; the Solid South would remain under the influence of the former Democratic Party, the West would remain under the control of the Republican Party, while other areas were divvied up according to local politics.

The Ninth of November would always be a fateful day in German history. It would be no different in the year 1927. After enduring eight years under communist rule, the German people were fed up with a drastically weakening currency and inferior living standards compared to the decades before World War One. From their headquarters in Munich, the National Socialist German Workers’ Organization launched a revolution to overthrow the Luxemburg Government; within just a few days, popular support began to favor the Nazis. Within a month, the Nazi party and its so-called “brownshirts” controlled large portions of the country and were in talks with East Prussia concerning the absorption of the latter country. Uprisings ahead of the “Brownshirts” softened the already disintegrating communist defense forces; by Christmas, 1927, the Nazis had effectively taken control of the country aside from a few small areas of resistance. Over the next year, the Nazi party under Max Erwin von Scheubner-Richter consolidated power, loosening many economic restrictions and paying minimal war debt payments for several years thereafter. In addition, von Scheubner-Richter exiled many of his own party members including Adolf Hitler, one of his fellow masterminds in the original Munich Uprising. Surviving British documents from the era suggest that the success of the National Socialist coup was in large part due to British aid in both strategy and weaponry. At least one of these documents makes a reference to a now lost cable which is believed to have detailed the Nazis’ further unreleased plans for Europe.

Following the passage of the Wallace-Frazier Act, agricultural prices increased and economic growth started to decline. By 1928, GDP growth was nearly zero percent and some economists were ringing alarm bells. Curiously, a few investors had welcomed the Wallace-Frazier Act, as it temporarily boosted some agricultural stocks. However, in the summer of 1928, the Supreme Court ruled that the Wallace-Frazier Act was unconstitutional. If the nation’s economy had been an egg that was starting to crack, the Supreme Court’s ruling went ahead and tossed the egg on the ground. Plummeting commodities prices led to rapid drops in the stock market.

Despite his low approval ratings, President Kendrick sought re-election and was essentially unchallenged for the nomination, winning every state except for Pennsylvania and Illinois, who voted for favorite sons Gifford Pinchot and Raymond Robins, respectively. The Democratic-Republican nomination was a much more closed process and at least one party leader later wrote that the smoke was so thick that it could almost be cut with a knife. Ultimately, after several ballots, Senator Peter Gerry of Rhode Island, a Democrat, was chosen to be the Presidential nominee, with Senator Charles Curtis of Kansas, a Republican chosen as the Vice-Presidential nominee. As the economy continued to decline, Kendrick’s chances of winning the election continued to slide. By November 5th, it was known that the following day’s election would result in the eighth presidency in the last decade and all that remained was to find out how many states Kendrick would lose. The 1928 election was the first in 20 years in which only two parties received electoral votes.

I34mmNq.png


Peter G. Gerry/Charles Curtis 57.3% 420 EV
John B. Kendrick/Franklin D. Roosevelt 41.3% 111 EV
Others 1.4% 0 EV


Tragedy struck in Argentina in mid-December when the President-elect and Vice President-elect were touring the country. Anarchists infuriated by the President-elect’s past comments concerning Marino and Spaldolini set explosive charges on the train tracks leading from the Pampas into Buenos Aires, which exploded as the train passed over them. In total, 45 passengers and 4 people near the tracks were killed; Democratic and Republican Party officials were awoken with the news that they would need to select a new vice presidential nominee before the Electoral College cast its votes on December 17th.

NOTES:
Finally. I've had an idea for this presidency for some time. I didn't want to go all "Progressives win forever and they are amazing." Economics wasn't my best(or favorite) subject, so if anyone has any comments about the declining economy, feel free to share them.

As to future updates, they will be rather slow, but I intend to (eventually) see this TL to the present.
 

. Later in the year, Wilfley’s fellow Missouri Senator James Reed nominated him for the position of Senate President pro tempore when the Senate was deadlocked after the midterm elections. Despite being third in line for the Presidency, the post was seen as largely ceremonial and Wilfley, seen as a moderate who was willing to compromise, was confirmed with a large majority.​
Actually no. The Secretary of State was next in line after the VP.

 
[/LEFT]
Actually no. The Secretary of State was next in line after the VP.


There was an amendment passed changing the line of succession.

Noting the deaths of two presidents and one vice president since the start of the century, Harding called for a constitutional amendment that would cement the line of succession and allow a president to choose a vice president in the event of a vacancy. By the end of the year, the text of the amendment had been finalized. In return for giving Harding free reign over his replacement vice president, Speaker of the House Martin Madden ensured that the Speaker of the House would be first in line, followed by the Senate President pro tempore and then the cabinet offices in the order of their creation.

Edit: I looked at the section again and it is rather vague as to the actual ratification, but it should be assumed that it was ratified by the time the Harding died.
 
Last edited:
Top