Margaret, Queen of Scotland and Norway, Queen consort of England (1283-1354)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi to all the members!!!!

After a short hiatus to my previous threads (due to more investigation to properly ended it), I decided to began this one dedicated to the "Maid of Norway", whose early death changed completely the history of Scotland (and also England, if we counted her betrothal).

There follows a recapitulation of the historical well-known events:

_________________________________

9 April 1283: Margaret, by birth Princess of the Scots and Queen consort of Norway, gave birth a daughter in the town of Tønsberg, Norway. The Queen died either during childbirth or by consequence of a post-partum infection. The little princess, named Margaret after her late mother, was raised at the court of her father, King Eric II Magnusson of Norway, nicknamed "Priest Hater" due to his unsuccessful relations with his local church hierarchy.

Due to the marriage contract of her parents (signed in December 1281), since her birth the newborn Norwegian princess became in the second-in-line to the throne of Scotland, and heiress apparent after the death of her only surviving maternal uncle, Prince Alexander, on 28 January 1284 without issue. A few days later, on 5 February at Scone, all thirteen earls of Scotland, twenty-four barons and the heads of the three main Gaelic kindreds of the West, Alexander of Argyll, Aonghas Mór of Islay and Alan MacRuari of Garmoran, agreed to recognise Margaret as "Lady and Right Heir" (domina et iure heredem) in default of male heirs:

"...we shall all receive our illustrious child Margaret, daughter of the daughter of our said lord king, Margaret of good memory, sometime queen of Norway, by the illustrious Lord Erik king of Norway; and as she descends with full legitimacy we shall receive her as our lady and right heir of our said lord king..."

Her maternal grandfather, King Alexander III of Scotland, concerned about the potential loss of independence of his Kingdom and the inminent English intervention, quickly arranged a second marriage for himself, with the French noblewoman Yolande de Dreux, in a way to distance from his neighbour King Edward I, and to emphasize Scottish independence from England. The wedding took place on 15 October 1285 at Jedburgh Abbey, but was short-lived: five months later, in the night between 18 and 19 March 1286, Alexander III died in a fall from his horse while riding in the dark to visit his wife at Kinghorn in Fife for her birthday.

The death of Alexander III plunged his strong and stabilized Kingdom into a period of uncertainty: although Margaret of Norway was now the heiress of Scotland and her father, with the help of Edward I, began to intensified his daughter's rights, soon Queen Yolande declared herself pregnant with the late King's unborn child, who, whatever was his gender, displaced Margaret in the line of succession.

On 2 April 1286 at Scone, Perth and Kinross, the Guardians of Scotland were elected by a parliament to govern the Kingdom pending the birth of the child; seven months later, on 25 November 1286 at Clackmannan, the Guardians reunited to witness the birth, but unfortunately Queen Yolande gave birth an stillborn child.

The stillbirth of Alexander III's posthumous child confirmed Margaret of Norway as the sole legal heiress of her grandfather and, according to the previous agreement at Scone, the rightful Queen of Scotland. However, within weeks John Balliol began the war to obtain the crown from himself; but he had to faced the opposition of the Bruce family, who captured strongholds in Galloway, and fighting in the name of the Maid of Norway, suppressed the rebellion with many important families like the Stewards supporting them. In 1289, the Guardians maintained the peace in Scotland between the competing claims of Margaret, Robert Bruce and John Balliol.

By that time, was clear that the Guardians of Scotland showed no desires to bring the Maid of Norway to the Kingdom; in fact, was King Eric II, who counting with the alliance with Edward I, who raised the matter again. Without taking any consideration or consult to the Guardians, was arranged between Eric II and Edward I the betrothal between Margaret and Prince Edward, heir of the English throne, with Pope Nicholas IV quickly granting a dispensation for consanguinity because they are they were first cousins once removed (Margaret was the great-granddaughter of King Henry III of England and Prince Edward his grandson). With their power weakened by the alliance Norway-England, the Guardians finally signed with Edward I the Treaty of Salisbury, which agreed that Margaret would be sent to Scotland before 1 November 1290, and that any agreement on her future marriage would be deferred until she was in Scotland.

King Edward I and the Guardians continued the negociations for the recognition of the betrothal between Margaret and Prince Edward, based on the collective assumption that Margaret would be queen and the young Edward king. However, all this plans were brought to nothing as Margaret died of the effects of sea-sickness in the Orkney Islands on 26 September 1290 while sailing to Scotland.

Until them, the narrative showed the historical events, but now....what happened if the infant-Queen survive her illness and arrived to Scotland?....

_________________________________



THE INFANT-QUEEN

sin titulo3.jpg

Birth of the Maid of Norway and death of her mother, Queen Margaret.

Having arrived to the Orkney Islands (at that time part of the Kingdom of Norway) with a large retinue, Princess Margaret became seriously ill, probably due to sea-sickness. Her life was in danger for some time, but by early October 1290 she recovered, although remained weak; for this, she was transported from St. Margaret's Hope to the town of Burwick, still in Orkney.

The Guardians of Scotland send an embassy leaded by William Fraser, Bishop of St. Andrews and Robert de Bruce, 6th Lord of Annandale -both staunch supporters of the Maid- to officially received her in Scotish soil; however, due to Margaret's illness, they were forced to waited in the village of Thurso for her.

During the Maid's convalescence at Burwick, an English entourage, leaded by Prince Edmund, Earl of Lancaster and Edward I's brother, arrived there to escorted the Maid to her Kingdom; having send his own brother to conduced the infant-Queen to her domains, Edward I wanted to show his hegemony over Scotland and his interference in his politics.

Once the Scotish entourage knew about the intentions of Edward I to had his subjects escorted the Maid to her domains, they send fierce protests to the English King, claiming that the arrival of his embassy to Scotland was a clear violation to the Treaty of Salisbury, who guaranteed the independence of both the Scotish and English interests in exchange of the recognition of the betrothal of the Maid with Prince Edward.

King Edward I deliberately delayed to made a formal reply to the Guardians: by early December 1290, the already fully-recovered Margaret remained in Burwick with her Norwegian entourage, who, following the instructions of King Eric II, was eager to enter in Scotish soil.

Finally, after protracted negotiations (who confirmed the betrothal with the English prince) and the intervention of Pope Nicholas IV, only on 2 January 1291 and following the orders of their King, the English entourage leave Burwick. Now, Margaret was free to entered in Scotland.

::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

In the early hours of 2 January 1291, Princess Margaret of Norway, with her native entourage leaded by her paternal uncle Prince Haakon, Archbishop Jørund of Nidaros and Bishop Narve of Bergen, arrived in the village of Thurso, where the Scotish embassy formally received her as their Queen. Both retinues remained there for two days, until 4 January, when in a solemn ceremony, the infant-Queen was officially handed to the Lord of Annandale, who became in her guardian for the rest of her journey to Scone, where was scheduled to be the customary inauguration and coronation. From her fellow contrymen, only remained with her Archbishop Jørund and Bishop Narve (following instructions of Eric II as witnesses of the coronation) with their personal armies, and three Norwegian maids; from them, Margaret could only be surrounded by Scotish people, in order to be accustomed to the uses and language of her Kingdom.


TO BE CONTINUED.......
 
Last edited:
All Right!

This could head off the three Scottish Wars Of Independence. And John Balliol may never become king and his backers the Comyns remain in the shadows. With a legitimate heir, Edward Longshanks has no excuse to intervene in Scotland as he did, the bloody tyrant!
 
CORONATION AND INAUGURATION AT SCONE

Sin título.jpg

Coronation of Margaret, Maid of Norway, as Queen regnant of the Scots.

The journey from Thurso to Scone was lenghty due to the difficult terrain of the Scottish Highlands, and also because in every main town or village were the royal cortege passed, was enthusiastically received by the population, who saw in the Maid "and her whole presence the security of independence from the English and his ambitions".

Margaret received the homage and gifts of local rural lords and nobles from all the main towns and villages of the Highlands: Melvich, Altnaharra, Lairg, Dingwall, Inverness (the most important city of the Highlands and were the Maid stayed longer, receiving the homage of the powerful Clans Mackintosh, Davidson, Macpherson and Cameron, whose chiefs accompanied her the rest of her trip), Aviemore, Newtonmore, Dawlhinnie, Blair Atholl, Pitlochry and Blaigowre. From there, the entourage finally entered in the Scotish Lowlands and the final stage of the trip.

In the town of Perth, the infant-Queen was formally greeted by representants of the Bruce, Duncan, Macduff, Douglas, Scott, Ferguson, Innes, Keith, Leslie and Forbes clans, who accompanied her to the royal seat of Scone, where the now large entourage arrived on 12 March 1291.

At the dawn of the next day (13 March 1291), Margaret was crowned Queen regnant of Scotland following the catholic rites at Scone Abbey. Following custom, the Mormaer of Fife enjoyed the right of crowning the Kings of the Scots; however, because the current Mormaer Donnchadh IV MacDuff was an infant, the honour of crowning Margaret was delegated to both William Fraser (Bishop of St. Andrews, Primate of the Kingdom and custos -regent- of the Mormaerdom) and Girolamo da Tonengo, Papal Legate especially send by Pope Nicholas IV to attend the ceremony.

Inmediately, and escorted by both the Lord of Annandale and Bishop Fraser, the infant-Queen, with the full royal regalia, advanced in solemn procession to the Moot Hill, where she was seated in the legendary Stone of Scone (Stane o Scuin) and made the traditional "oath of loyalty, good government and fidelity to the traditions and laws of the Scots"; being at the top of the small hill, the monarch was standing symbolically upon all of Scotland. When this ceremony ended, the Maid was now officially inaugurated as Queen of Scotland and could be acclaimed by the Guardians, Chief clans, nobles and population as their sovereign.

The celebrations for the coronation and inauguration of the new Queen lasted a whole month, where nobles and chiefs from all the Kingdom arrived to paid homage to Margaret, who lived during this time with her household in the Abbot's Palace at Scone Abbey.

Once the month of festivities ended, Archbishop Jørund of Nidaros and Bishop Narve of Bergen leave Scone with their entourages for Norway; however, as a part of earlier agreements between King Eric II and the Guardians of Scotland, three Norwegian high-born women (Kristin Pedersdotter, Maria Nilsdotter and Bergljot Halvorsdotter) remained with the infant-Queen as their ladies-in-waiting, while Count Bjørnar Gyldenløve af Rossø (member of one of the most powerful and influential Norwegian noble families), remained in Scotland with an small retinue as a kind of "protector of the King Eric's interests" (according to historians, this would be the first documented embassy who resided in a country rather than returned to their homeland); however, the intervention of Count Bjørnar in the Scotish politics was minimal: the Guardians were the true rulers of the Kingdom on behalf of the Maid until her 18th birthday (in 1301) or until she married with Prince Edward, who could assumed the title of King by right of his wife.

Soon between the Guardians began disputes about how could be directed the education of the Queen: while one part (Robert de Bruce, Bishop William Fraser of St. Andrews and James Stewart -5th High Steward-) believed that Margaret must be carefully prepared for rule by her own, the other part (Bishop Robert Wishart of Glasgow, John II Comyn, Lord of Badenoch, Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan -the last two certainly influenced by John Balliol-) wanted to gave the Queen a typical education for Scotish noble females in the Middle Ages: embroidering, dancing and riding.


TO BE CONTINUED......
 
Last edited:
EDUCATION OF THE QUEEN

The Edinburgh Castle.jpg

Modern view of Edinburgh Castle, main residence of Queen Margaret.

Finally, the power and prestige of Robert de Bruce, united with the support of the church hierarchy (who wanted to preserve their independence from the English church following the Queen's marriage), was decided that Margaret must received both a manly education in the government affairs and the education expected from high-born females in the Middle Ages.

The Guardians determined that the Queen and her household -who included minstrels, huntsmen, grooms, ladies-in-waiting, a chaplain and several minor servants- would be settled at Edinburgh Castle, who became in Margaret's official residence.

During the following years, the Queen had an intense and careful education about history, geography, politics and "all the old arts of government reserved to the Kings of that time"; in addition, she learned about embroidery, dancing and the use of foreign languages (reportedly, besides her native Norwegian, Margaret mastered the old Scottish, French -who was used in the court and with foreign monarchies- and English languages).

Since her early years, Margaret enjoyed horse riding and hunting; according to the later Chronica Gentis Scotorum, wrote by the priest John of Fordun, the Queen

"...spend several weeks of the year residing in Rothesay Castle hunting deers and foxes at the hills of the Isle of Bute, riding in her favorite mare, called Gold (òir) due to her beautiful fur, shone like the sun..."

In her 13th birthday, on April 1296, Margaret began to officially presided the Parliament of the Kingdom, who was divided into three estates:

  • First estate: of prelates (bishops and abbots)

  • Second estate: nobility (dukes, marquises, earls, viscounts, etc.)

  • Third estate: Burgh Commissioners (representatives chosen by the royal burghs)
The Guardians (leaded by Robert de Bruce and Bishop Fraser) belonged to the first and second estates, and thus had the majority in the Parliament and control over their discussions; because of her youth, the Queen barely had a real interference in the discussions or politics of the Guardians, who became in the power behind the throne and true rulers of the Kingdom.

However, Margaret began to show more interest and firmness in the government affairs in the following years, moreover when in 1299 John Balliol, supported by his brother-in-law John II Comyn, Lord of Badenoch, began a campaign against the "rule of a foreign female, weak due to her gender" and threatened to began a civil war to obtain the crown, whom he "believed by God's will rightfuly belonged to him because he was born in the Kingdom and had royal blood" (his mother, Dervorguilla of Galloway, was a granddaughter of Prince David of Scotland, 8th Earl of Huntingdon, in turn brother of King William I).

The Guardians of the Kingdom hesitated about how to react to Balliol's claims: while some (including Robert de Bruce, 6th Lord of Annandale and his eldest son and heir, Robert de Bruce the Younger, Earl of Carrick following the death of his mother in 1292) believed that he must be convicted by treason, others (leaded by John II Comyn himself) wanted an open war to defend the rights of John Balliol.

At the end, was the Queen who had the last word in this matter: without any consultation to the Guardians and by her direct command, in the night of 12-13 November 1299, a militar contingent leaded by the young Earl of Carrick taken by surprise Galloway Castle (from where Balliol began to contact foreign help for his cause) and captured John Balliol, John II Comyn with their families and main allies.

The rebels were sent to Edinburgh Castle, where they remained imprisoned in underground dungeons for two weeks, until 29 November, when the Queen, presiding by herself the royal court and with the Lord of Annandale and the new Bishop of St. Andrews, William de Lamberton at her side, declared both John Balliol and John II Comyn guilty of treason "against the person of the Queen and thus against the Kingdom of Scotland".

Both were condemned to death, but at the end the Queen changed the sentence to life imprisonment at the fortress of Clatchard Craig, where they had to remain "without any comunication with the exterior or their relatives". In a gesture of magnanimity, Margaret allowed the heirs of Balliol and Comyn to retain their titles, under the condition to solemnly renounced to any rights or claims over the throne for themselves and their descendants. The rest of Balliol's allies were forced to renewed their oath of fidelity to the Queen.

Modern historians currently debated if was in fact Margaret who really took the decision to capture John Balliol and his allies, or was the Earl of Carrick who in fact acted without any royal consent; however, was widely noted that since this time, the Queen began to sign herself all the royal charters and acts without the signature of the Guardians (who until them were always co-signatories with Margaret) and using her personal Seal who combined the arms of Scotland and Norway (in the monastic donations) and the Royal Seal with the arms of Scotland (in the official acts and charters).

Despite this first political success of the Queen, her proclamation of majority took place on 9 April 1300 on her 18th birthday, as was previously scheduled. From them, Margaret began to rule by herself, although always adviced by the Lord of Annandale and the former Guardians.

Soon, the rumours of an affair between Margaret and the Earl of Carrick (some contemporary sources even believed that they secretly married) worried King Edward I of England, who began the preparations for his son's wedding with the Queen of Scotland.


TO BE CONTINUED.....
 
Last edited:
Gimme more :O

This is looking like a timeline which has a lot of potential. Will there be any inheiritance of perhaps Norway in the 1319s when Magnus Magnusson dies by any son of Margrete perhaps?
 
My knowledge on this area is very limited, but with the changes in this TL, could Scotland remain independent for much longer? Maybe it becomes a diplomatic union as opposed to conquest that brings Scotland and the Isles together?
 
INTRIGUES AT THE SCOTTISH COURT

Gal_nations_edward_i.jpg

King Edward I of England, long-time enemy of the Maid of Norway.

Following the provisions of the Treaty of Salisbury, signed in 1290, the marriage of the Queen of Scotland with the English Prince Edward was arranged; although was specified there that even though a wife's possessions should become the husband's upon marriage, in this case it would not and

"....both Kingdoms of England and Scotland remained separated and divided from each other according to its rightful boundaries, free in itself and without subjection....and both Churches of Scotland and England were to remain separated, and the rights and obligations of the nobles and subjects of each Kingdom would be respected, like the parliaments of both countries were to remain separate and not be held outside of their respective country."

The death of King Eric II of Norway in 1299 without male issue and the accession to the throne of his younger brother as King Haakon V, weakened the ties between Scotland and Norway, and the influence of the latter over the Scottish affairs on behalf of the Maid.

Without the paternal guidance of his ally King Eric II over his daughter, Edward I felt that the betrothal between his son and the Maid, with the long-hoping union (at least personal) of both countries was seriously in danger.

King Haakon V tried by all means to maintain the Norwegian influence over Scotland (and indirectly his alliance with England); for this task, he used Eric II's second wife -since 1293- Isabel de Bruce (daughter of the 6th Lord of Annandale and thus sister of the Earl of Carrick) and her daughter, Princess Ingeborg of Norway, half-sister and only legitimate sibling of the Maid. In her name and her daughter's, the Dowager Queen began to wrote several letters to the Maid, asking to "kept the bonds and ties who since the times of our beloved Lord King Eric united both countries".

Due to her closeness with the Bruce family and also being sensitive to the petitions of her stepmother and half-sister, on mid-August 1300 Queen Margaret finally agreed to made a formal reply to her uncle King Haakon V, reafirming "the natural alliance and bonds who kept our countries always in peace". In addition, the Maid invited Dowager Queen Isabel and Princess Ingeborg to live in Scotland at the Queen's court "where they received all the honours and respect due to their ranks". Following the advices of the English King, Haakon V agreed to send both Isabel and Ingeborg to Scotland, who arrived to Edinburgh Castle "in great style and with a large treasure" on mid-September 1301.

It's uncertain why Queen Margaret asked the presence of her stepmother and half-sister at her court; modern historiography, however, believed that this was made in order to eliminate from Norway any potential rights that the Maid's half-sister could have over the throne, moreover after King Haakon V, from his marriage with Euphemia of Rügen, had only female issue, a daughter also named Ingeborg, born in early 1301 and who proved to be his only legitimate offspring. This could be, according to them, the first political move of Queen Margaret in her future fight for the Norwegian throne.

With the arrival of Dowager Queen Isabel and Princess Ingeborg, the called Norwegian Household (Norse menyie) became considerably reforced and most involved in court intrigues: Count Bjørnar Gyldenløve, believed that, being Dowager Queen Isabel the sister of the Earl of Carrick (the Maid's reputed favorite), she could be a decisive influence in the approachment to the English, who was the objective of the Count following the orders of King Haakon V. However, the Dowager Queen, since the beginning, decisively took the side of her father the Lord of Annandale, who wanted to obtain the annulment of the betrothal of the Queen and the English prince on behalf of his own son the Earl of Carrick; according to The Continuator of Florence of Worcester

"....the Lord of Annandale put his heart and soul in his ambition to saw his heir, the handsome and brave Earl of Carrick, as husband of the Queen and master of the Kingdom....however not all the Scots supported the Earl, moreover because was clear that the Queen had deep and tender feelings for him."

When by early November 1301 arrived to London news that the Lord of Annandale, in the Queen's name, began his preparations to go to Rome with the purpose to obtain from Pope Boniface VIII the annulment of the dispensation for the marriage between the English prince and the Maid, Edward I reacted furiously and quickly: by the end of that month, a large army leaded by the King himself, moved to the district of Carlisle, just a few miles away to the boundaries with the Kingdom of Scotland.

In the meanwhile, arrived to Edinburgh Castle a message from the English King: if "the Queen of the Scots didn't kept the word gave for her and the Guardians of her realm in the Treaty of Salisbury, he was ready to entered in the Kingdom of Scotland to claim by force the payment of his son's honor".

The Queen, in such desperate situation, tried to mastered an army to faced the inminent English invasion, but the Highlands clans were hesitant to help; they resented the favoritism showed to the Lowlands clans and mostly to the Bruce family: "we are ready to gave our swords and lives to our Queen, but we refuse do it for the Earl of Carrick", reportedly was the answer of the Chief of the powerful Chattan Clan.

Queen Margaret then wrote to the Kings of France and Norway asking from them militar help, but they delayed in their replies, who when arrived were clearly ambiguous. The internal disputes between the Lowland clans also caused insecurity and consternation in the Queen: many of them also refused to accept the increasingly power of the Bruce family.

Without any more choices, the Queen finally made a decision: on 1 December 1301 and in front of his whole court, Parliament and the former Guardians of the Kingdom, Margaret formally send a response to the English King: she would kept the terms of the Treaty of Salisbury, with the marriage between her and Prince Edward could be performed "when the King of England pleased to bring us his son to be our royal consort".


TO BE CONTINUED.....
 
Last edited:
Great start - just a few nit-picks

Thanks for a great start to what promises to be a very interesting TL. Heading off the ambitions of Edward Longshanks will be difficult, as he tries to influence Scotland through his son, and I'm looking forward to seeing how you deal with that.

I've just got a few small problems with some of the details: :eek:

...they were forced to waited in the village of John o' Groats for her.
...In the early hours of 2 January 1291, Princess Margaret of Norway, with her native entourage leaded by her paternal uncle Prince Haakon and Archbishop Jørund of Nidaros, arrived in the village of John o' Groats...
John O'Groats didn't exist in the 13th century (see http://www.visitjohnogroats.com/information/history-john-ogroats/). She would probably have sailed to Moray at least - possibly being met at Inverness or in Elgin. As sea travel was then a much better way of travelling long distances, it's actually more likely that she would have sailed further south along the east coast - possibly to St. Andrews or even up the Tay to Perth, which would put her very close to Scone.
If you really must have the Maid landing in Caithness, then Dornoch is probably the best place to use; Dornoch cathedral is 13th century, so there would have been suitable accommodation for her and those meeting her.

Norwegian Party (Nirribhis Pàrtaidh)
Gaelic wasn't the language of most Scots. The nobility would probably have spoken something similar to what we now call 'Scots' (alongside French and Latin). So if you want some non-English terms, best to use Scots instead. 'Norse menyie' could mean 'Norwegian household' or 'Norse ryals' would be 'Norwegian royals' or 'Norse weemen' would be 'Norwegian women' (if you wanted a less-respectful term).

"when the King of England pleased to bring us his son to be our husband and Lord".
There's no way a Queen (regnant) and her councillors would have asked for a 'husband and Lord' as that would imply that she would be subject to him in all things. '...our royal consort' would be better.

Sorry to be so picky - as I said above, this is a great start! :)
 
This is extremely interesting, I'll be following it!
I hoped that Margaret could have a happy marriage with the Early of Carrick, but this looks now impossible... Well, let's see how things develop.
 
Scottish and English churches

both Churches of Scotland and England were to remain separated
This was laid down by the pope in a papal bull of 1192 (titled Cum universi Christi jugo subjecti) which declared the Scottish Church (Ecclesia Scoticana) to be a 'special daughter of the see of Rome' - i.e. the bishops reported directly the pope, not to an archbishop.
This was as a result of a century-long controversy, so if you want to stir things up a bit, you could have the English church send a request to the pope to issue an update which puts the Scottish bishops under their control. Alternatively, the Archbishop of York could try to exert control without a new papal bull, leading to the Scottish bishops appealing to Rome (a less stringent version of the OTL Declaration of Arbroath maybe?).

Just an idea - feel free to ignore me - it's your TL! ;)
 
I hoped that Margaret could have a happy marriage with the Early of Carrick, but this looks now impossible... Well, let's see how things develop.

Maybe Edward Caernarvon will die earlier than OTL. That would free Margaret to marry Carrick, whilst not repudiating the terms of the Treaty of Birgham (sometimes called the Treaty of Salisbury, as in this TL). If there were any suspicions about Edward's death, his father (Longshanks) might not be too happy though... :rolleyes:
 
Thanks for a great start to what promises to be a very interesting TL. Heading off the ambitions of Edward Longshanks will be difficult, as he tries to influence Scotland through his son, and I'm looking forward to seeing how you deal with that.

I've just got a few small problems with some of the details: :eek:


John O'Groats didn't exist in the 13th century (see http://www.visitjohnogroats.com/information/history-john-ogroats/). She would probably have sailed to Moray at least - possibly being met at Inverness or in Elgin. As sea travel was then a much better way of travelling long distances, it's actually more likely that she would have sailed further south along the east coast - possibly to St. Andrews or even up the Tay to Perth, which would put her very close to Scone.
If you really must have the Maid landing in Caithness, then Dornoch is probably the best place to use; Dornoch cathedral is 13th century, so there would have been suitable accommodation for her and those meeting her.


Gaelic wasn't the language of most Scots. The nobility would probably have spoken something similar to what we now call 'Scots' (alongside French and Latin). So if you want some non-English terms, best to use Scots instead. 'Norse menyie' could mean 'Norwegian household' or 'Norse ryals' would be 'Norwegian royals' or 'Norse weemen' would be 'Norwegian women' (if you wanted a less-respectful term).


There's no way a Queen (regnant) and her councillors would have asked for a 'husband and Lord' as that would imply that she would be subject to him in all things. '...our royal consort' would be better.

Sorry to be so picky - as I said above, this is a great start! :)

Thanks for your kind suggestions!!!!! and sorry for my bad knowledge of Scottish language (so be free to help me in this matter :))....please check the corrections, I hope you like it..... again thanks!!!!;):D:cool:
 
THE MARRIAGE BETWEEN TWO CROWNS

Sin título.jpg

Wedding and coronation of Margaret, Queen regnant of Scotland and Edward of Caernarfon, Count of Ponthieu and Prince of Wales.

With the acceptance of Queen Margaret to fulfill the terms of the Treaty of Salisbury on 1 December 1301, King Edward I retired his troops from Carlisle and returned to London, were he began the preparations of the marriage contract, who both parties agreed to sign simultaneously on 1 February 1302.

However, when the marriage contract roll arrived at Edinburgh Castle, the terms included there caused outrage in the Scottish court:

  • According to the English King, his son Prince Edward -Count of Ponthieu by right of his mother and recently invested as Prince of Wales- had to be crowned during the wedding ceremony as King of the Scots "with full prerogatives and authority to rule the said Kingdom without any interference or menace of the nobles of Scotland".

  • Queen Margaret had to renounced to her rights of government to her husband, who in his capacity of King could had the right to "grant prebends, lands or any kind of titles without the signature and consent of the said Queen his consort".

  • Thomas of Corbridge, the new Archbishop of York (who could joined the future King in his retinue to perform the wedding), had the right to obtain half of the revenues from all the abbeys, monasteries and churches of the Kingdom of Scotland to be send to England.
Logically, this terms were nothing to do with the Treaty of Salisbury of 1290, and the Queen, supported by the totality of the former Guardians of the Kingdom -leaded by Lord of Annandale and the Bishop of St. Andrews, William de Lamberton- firmly refused to accept these terms: for the first (and only) time, the whole former Guardians showed an united front againt the English.

Firstly, the Bishop of St. Andrews, as Primate of the Church of Scotland, send a formal protest to Rome (later called Lamberton Roll), using as base for his opposition the 1192 Papal Bull Cum universi Christi jugo subjecti, who specifically declared the Church of Scotland (Ecclesia Scoticana, who comprising the dioceses of St. Andrews, Glasgow, Dunkeld, Dunblane, Brechin, Aberdeen, Moray, Ross and Caithness) a "special daughter" of the Apostolic See with no intermediary; in consequence, either the English King or his church hierarchy had any right to request any part of the revenues or tithes who belonged to the Church of Scotland.

The Lord of Annandale, with the complete consensus of the former Guardians and the members of the Parliament, send a diplomatic protest to the English King, reafirming that the

"....rights who by the law of inheritance and tradition belonged to our Queen and his subjects....his consort could be respected and obey as the equal of our Queen, but following the terms of the said Treaty signed by the Lord King Edward of England and the Lord Guardians of the Kingdom of Scotland were conclusive and without appeal or disregarded....the Queen, as the only and legitimate descendant from the line of the Kings of Alba founded by Kenneth MacAlpin, was the only one who could had the right to be called our Queen and to rule over us".

Another important change that Robert of Bruce and the former Guardians wanted in the Treaty of Salisbury, before to agreed with the marriage, was the issue of the succession of the Kingdom of Scotland in the case of Queen Margaret's demise before her husband: although in the original Treaty signed in 1290 wasn't clearly specified the duration of the Scottish-English union after the Queen's death in her eldest son, Edward I believed that the rights of primogeniture of the couple's first-born son could be respected.

Queen Margaret firmly believed that she had the right to choose her own heir among her future male offspring, without distinction of primogeniture, and in this point she was supported by the Scottish clans and the former Guardians. The English King, not wanting to put again in danger the wedding of his son and the inminent union of both crowns, decided to put the decision of the succesion and church supremacy in the Papal arbitration

:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

Pope Boniface VIII, who was in the peak of his continued feud with King Philip IV of France (ally of the Kingdom of Scotland) was inclined to favored the English (reportedly, King Edward I guarantee the Pope his militar support if was needed); however, the fear of a more violent response from the French King if he threatened the integrity of his ally, and (more important to him) the change of the public opinion against him (in general, the local nobility wasn't in good terms with the English), were decisives factors for his decision, who was made public on 17 March 1302:

The Bull Cum universi Christi jugo subjecti was ratified, with all the appertaining rights; however, he ruled that Prince Edward, as King of Scotland

"must to be respected and obey as their Lord and King but without prejudice of the old customs and forms of government of the said Kingdom of Scotland, and without remove the rights of birth who belonged to the said Queen Margaret, who, as the anointed sovereign of the said Kingdom of Scotland, had the only right to choose the heir of her titles, rights and realm".

Although they became victorious in the confirmation of the independence of the local church against King Edward I, the Scottish were now compelled to received his son as their King, although with his power considerably limited. However, the most important triumph for the Scottish was the Papal confirmation of the Queen's rights to choose her heir among her future offspring. The English King, despite his personal outrage and objections to this matter, decided not to antagonize again with the Scottish court and agreed with the Papal arbitration, although he believed that the Queen would never displaced his blood from his rights and at the end, she could kept the union in her future first-born son.

:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

Following the Papal arbitration, the marriage contract (with the clarification about the succesion, much to the English' dismay) was finally signed simultaneously on 1 April 1302 in Edinburgh Castle (by Queen Margaret, the Lord of Annandale, the Bishop of St. Andrews, Dowager Queen Isabel of Norway and the rest of the Guardians in order of precedence) and in Windsor Castle (by King Edward I, his son Prince Edward, the King's second wife Queen Marguerite of France, the King's nephew Thomas, 2nd Earl of Lancaster, the Archbishop of York and the rest of main nobles and bishops by order of precedence).

The next day (2 April), the English royal entourage, leaded by the 2nd Earl of Lancaster, Arthur II, Duke of Brittany (another nephew of Edward I and the second husband of King Alexander III's widow, Yolande de Dreux) and the Archbishop of York, leave London "with several nobles and caskets with gold and silver, tapestries and books, all to made a good impression to the Scots, who were considered savages and uneducated (sauvage et sans instruction)".

Following the King's orders, the entourage made a quick journey without much stops, arriving to the town of Carlisle on 30 April 1302; according to the Chronica Gentis Scotorum by John of Fordun, the English "sent a groom to the same place were they previously send an army".

In Carlisle, the English were received by an Scottish delegation leaded by Bishop Lamberton and the Earl of Carrick. The Continuator of Florence of Worcester later recalled that

"...the said Earl of Carrick barely could kept a good face at the side of the handsome and well-proportioned Prince Edward....despite all his efforts, the jealousy had the said Earl felt was noted by the English and confirmed the malicious suspicious about his relations with the Queen of the Scots".

After a trip through Longtown, Langholm, Hawick, Selkirk, Galashiels and Dalkeith, the English-Scottish entourage finally arrived to Edinburgh on first hours of 10 May 1302. The reception, according to John of Fordun was "cold and without the pomp who was expected by the English".

Inmediately, the entourage parted to Edinburgh Castle, being formally greeted by Queen Margaret and her whole court. Reportedly "the Queen wasn't much impressed by the well-known beauty of the Prince of the English".

:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

Margaret, Queen of Scotland, and Edward of Caernarfon, Count of Ponthieu and Prince of Wales, were married at St Margaret's Chapel in Edinburgh Castle on 12 May 1302 by both the Bishop of St. Andrews and the Archbishop of York. During the ceremony, both Edward and Margaret were crowned King and Queen of Scotland.

The reports of the ceremony are scant: however, was known by contemporary sources that the whole court attended and Prince Edward entered in the Chapel with Dowager Queen Isabel of Norway and followed inmediately by his cousins the Earl of Lancaster and the Duke of Brittany, while Princess Ingeborg of Norway carried the train of her half-sister the Queen, who was in turn followed by her Norwegian ladies-in-waiting and the followed by the daughters of the Lord of Annandale.

Banquets, justs and celebrations for the wedding lasted for almost two weeks; by the end of the festivities (30 May), was arranged the betrothal of Princess Ingeborg of Norway with Prince John of Brittany, only son of Duke Arthur II born from his marriage with Yolande de Dreux, the former Dowager Queen of Scotland.


TO BE CONTINUED......
 
Last edited:
Please keep the posts coming! Having often wondered what would have happened had Margaret survived, I am absolutely loving this. Great job!
 
MOTHERHOOD AND THE GAVESTON AFFAIR

sin titulo 3.jpeg

Extract from the Chronica Gentis Scotorum of John of Fordun, who represented the birth of Prince Edward, eldest son of the King and Queen of the Scots.

Following their wedding, Edward and Margaret spent their first months of marriage in Stirling Castle. During the first months of cohabitation, Edward showed that he had similar tastes with his wife: the King-consort was interested in horses and horsebreeding, and became a good rider, and some times even accompanying the Queen in their customary hunting expeditions -although he was not particularly interested in either hunting or falconry-; he also liked dogs, in particular greyhounds, and showed great interest in raising them.

Another point of coincidence between the royal couple was the music: both Edward and Margaret enjoyed music, including the Welsh and native Scottish music; moreover, the King showed his wife the newly invented crwth instrument, as well as musical organs, and developed in her a great taste for them.

Being tall and muscular, and considered good looking by the standards of the period, the Queen "soon became infatuated" by her consort, although these feelings were short-lived, especially after seeing the rise of the recent favorite of her husband, the Gascon knight Pierre de Gabaston, mostly known by the anglicized form of his name, Piers Gaveston.

::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

A son of Arnaud de Gabaston -a Gascon knight in the service of Viscount Gaston VII of Béarn- and the wealthy heiress Claramonde de Marsan, Piers' father, thanks to the inheritance of his wife, became a vassal of the King of England -who by inheritance was Duke of Aquitaine-. Following the death of Claramonde in 1287, Arnaud became financially dependent on the English king in his fight to retain his late wife's inheritance from relatives and neighbours, and thus was constantly at his service.

In 1300, with his father and older brother, Piers arrived to England, entering in the household of Prince Edward -who according to contemporary sources was about the same age of him (coetanei)-; reportedly the King was impressed by Gaveston's conduct and martial skills, and wanted him to serve as a model for his son.

Prince Edward and Piers soon became inseparables, and this caused controversy and suspicions about the real nature of their friendship at the English court. Soon King Edward I was aware of this rumours, and any good will that he had over Piers Gaveston disappeared, becoming "enraged with the hear of that Gascon's name or presence in front of him".

However, Piers managed to remained in the Prince's Household and became part of the entourage assigned by the King to escort his son to his wedding with Queen Margaret of Scotland in May 1302.

::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

With the announcement of the Queen's first pregnancy, in mid-September 1302, King-consort Edward, aimed by Gaveston, began to take an active role in the government affairs, helped by a group of trustworthy english noblemen, much to the dismay of the former Guardians and the Lord of Annandale, who saw how "the privileges and honors were given to that Gascon who didn't had either the intelligence or the high-born birth needed".

The influence that Piers Gaveston had over the King-consort was so notorious and scandalous that even some of the English advisors of Edward complained to his father; in response, an enraged King Edward I ordened Piers Gaveston return inmediately to London in early December 1302.

Fearing a terrible punishment, Piers Gaveston appealed to the mercy of "the good and magnanimous King of the Scots". The King-consort, in complete defiance to his father, not only refused to allowed the departure of his favorite but also, by Royal Ordinance date 7 January 1303, gave to Piers Gaveston the possession of Clackmannan Tower and the Banff, Craigmillar and Ardross Castles with all their adyacent lands. This grants caused outraged among the nobles, moreover because Banff was a former property of the Comyns who reverted to the Crown after their cooperation with Balliol's conspiracy in 1299, and Craigmillar was in possession of the monks of Dunfermline Abbey by especial grant of King David I in the 12th century.

Queen Margaret, in the last stages of her pregnancy and burdened by the constant petitions of the nobles to "stop the greed and arrogance of the Gascon favorite", reportedly refused three times to signed and put her seal over the roll of grants made by her husband, a requirement contemplated in their marriage contract:

"....any grant or revenue received or given by the said Prince of the English as Lord King was invalid without the consent and signature of the said Lady Queen Margaret."

Without the signature and seal of his wife, Edward was virtually powerless and this infuriated him: following the refusal to gave the lands to his favorite, the King-consort refused to speak to Margaret: according to the later Orygynale Cronykil of Scotland wrote by Andrew of Wyntoun in the mid- 15th century:

"....the quarrels and violents disputes between Queen Margaret and her consort, the English-born King Edward were often and in front of the court....the main cause of this disagreements was the great love that the King had over the Gascon knight Piers, who had the heart and will of the King in his hands..."

::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

In this atmosphere of disputes and constant arguments, Queen Margaret gave birth to her first child, a son, at Edinburgh Castle on 17 March 1302. The baptism of the heir of the Scottish throne and the second-in-line of the English one was celebrated at the Chapel of Rothesay Castle -the Queen's favorite hunting retreat- on 21 July, in a middle of magnificents festivities and celebrations throughout the Kingdom, because "Scotland finally had a male heir".

The little prince received the name of Edward -after both his father and grandfather: a controversial gesture who reportedly "displeased several nobles"-, with Kings Edward I of England, Haakon V of Norway and Philip IV of France as their godfathers and their respective consorts and Dowager Queen Isabel of Norway as their godmothers; however, because the Kings and Queens of England, Norway and France aren't physically presents at the ceremony, the Lord of Annandale served as proxy for the three monarchs ("a high honor for the said Lord", according to John of Fordun) and the Dowager Queen of Norway, as the only godparent present, had the privilege to hold the prince in the baptismal font, with the prince's half-aunt Princess Ingeborg carrying his tunic during the ceremony.

The baptism and celebrations for the little prince originated an approach between his parents, a happy event that King Edward I celebrated in London with the offering of a cloth of gold to the altar of Westminster Abbey "for the good birth of his grandson the Prince of the Scots, and the repair of the relations of his parents the King and Queen of the Scots" (Continuator of Florence of Worcester).

The rapprochement between the Scottish royal couple was noted when, after only eighteen months from his first childbirth, on 24 September 1303 at Stirling Castle, Queen Margaret gave birth a second child, a daughter, who was named Eleanor after her maternal grandmother, the late Eleanor of Castile, first wife of King Edward I. Because the Kingdom of Scotland had now a male heir, the baptism of the princess, celebrated on 1 January 1304 at St Margaret's Chapel of Edinburgh Castle, was a private affair, with Arthur II, Duke of Brittany and his wife Yolande of Dreux as godparents, and with the Lord of Annandale and Dowager Queen Isabel acting again as proxies.

Now with two children, the marriage between Edward and Margaret seems to gained a good understanding, although was noted by contemporary chroniclers that "never was love between them". As a proof of his intentions to had a happy family life, the King-consort send Piers Gaveston to London in mid-February 1304; however, this exile was short-lived.


TO BE CONTINUED......
 
Last edited:
OH, now this is a beauty of a Timeline. Hoping for a Union of crowns, but i figure that this will most likely happen similarly under this alt!Edward III.


Oh man, this is going to be good.:D:D:D
 
Interesting but I'm wondering why, since Queen Margaret and the Prince of Wales's firstborn son would be heir to both Scotland and England, they didn't attempt to have her bear her child at Berwick-on-Tweed so BOTH countries could claim he was born on their soil? Scotland's seems accepting of a woman born in Norway but I'm not sure England would be so accepting of a child born in Scotland. Just saying.
 
Top
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top