“Dear Theodosia, what to say to you? If you had seen through my eyes, the fields that have burned. The men that lie in them. I will see you soon and your husband as well.”
“Oh Philip when will I return? I feel as if never. This war may never end, but rest assure I will see again one day. Take care of your mother and wife.”
Letters written by Hamilton and Burr in 1814 to their children who wed in 1801
In the Spring of 1814, General Pike headed North once more but was not obstructed by Native attacks. Drummond had Hamilton to the North, Winfield to the East and Pike from the South. Quebec City had received reinforcements, veterans from Iberia, thanks to his victories in 1813, but they were there to defend. Drummond chose to go on the offensive once more. Hamilton and Winfield had fortified their position making the advancing Pike the best target.
Pike made camp on Guilloux’s Farm near Lake Simcoe on March 17, 1814. He had a little over 1,700 soldiers with 500 Quebecois militiamen. However, unknown to the Americans about half were loyal to the British. At 0400 and explosion went off at the commander’s tent. Three men had died, and five more were wounded. The three dead were Major General Dearborn, Lieutenant Benjamin Forsyth, and Private Matthew Indy, who was guarding the tent. Pike had taken a walk, who had trouble sleeping, before rushing back to his tent. A second explosion went off near their supplies deposit and then, “the Horsemen began to unveil themselves with thunderous footsteps.” The Quebecois released the American horses that stamped through the campsite. At 0430, British cavalry charged the campsite. Once they passed through the campsite, they turned around and hit once more. Short little raids through the camp lasted until the Americans were finally able to prop up a defense.
During that time, however, the British Quebecois fled the camp and awaited orders from Drummond. He advanced the Quebecois and ordered them to begin picking off the American officers. As the Americans pushed forward, the Quebecois held their ground until they were less than 30 feet from them. A whistle was blown, and the British advanced to the American’s surprise. After an exchange of volley, the Americans pulled back and began an organized retreat to the East towards Kingston. It was a partial victory for the British, the Americans would have overwhelming numbers at Kingston, and if Hamilton moved South, he could take Ottawa or destroy Drummond.
Battle of Guilloux’s Farm
After the Battle of Guilloux’s Farm, “an inquisition or witch hunt began against Quebecois who had been fighting the war long before the first American.” The Quebecois were ousted from American camps, disarmed and messages for aid were ignored. Clément Gosselin, still recovering from his wounds, tried to sway the distrust growing between the two groups to little avail. Though these acts would damage relations with Quebecois for the duration of the war, roughly fifty British conspirators were found and imprisoned. Hamilton issued an order officially segregating Americans and Quebecois that shared camps. Henri Aubury, only 11 at the time but had been serving since he was 9, recalled that “[Quebecois] farmers would grow the food that was given to [Quebecois] cooks and it would be served to every American before one of us. This was a great injustice.”
Hamilton saw the fragile alliance with the Quebecois begin to unwind but was too focused on achieving military against Drummond to resolve it. Instead, it was left to Aaron Burr. Burr was a capable officer, some arguing the best military mind of his generation, but military force would not bring about peace with the Quebecois. He instead turned to religion. Burr’s maternal grandfather was Jonathon Edwards, a Puritan preacher during the First Great Awakening most famous for his Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God sermon. Though Quebecois allied to the Americans were predominantly Catholic, there were few Catholic priest or even laymen to conduct a service. In most camps, during mass, the highest ranked officer would simply read a chapter from the Bible. Burr decided to go to nearly 200 Quebecois on April 3, 1814. He read the book of Daniel and began a dialogue of how the plight of Jews while stranded in Babylon was like that of the Quebecois. “As King Nebuchadnezzar kept the sons of Israel in chains miles away from home so does King George do to the sons of the New World. These chains shall be broken forthwith, and the Heavens will open across this land.”
Aaron Burr giving a sermon
Afterwards, Burr promised to bring Catholic priest from Boston and Maryland to conduct religious services out of his pocket. Dr. Nicole Boulet described this moment as, “a shift of nearly 300 years of tension between the Protestant and Catholic faith in the New World. Some point to the Quebec Act of 1774 as the beginning, but it was little more than an attempt to calm resistance and publish the southern colonies. Burr’s interaction and support of the Quebecois’ faith, regardless of his true views on Catholicism, began the merging of Quebecois and American identities.”
Drummond pursued Pike to the West attempting for force a surrender before he could link up with Winfield. Most of Drummond spies in the American camp were either hanged or kicked out by his chance and he was not informed that Winfield had left with his main force to meet Pike. He was informed that the Americans had almost 3,000 men once the two armies meet. The numbers were against him, but if he were to attack them just as they meet there would be too much confusion for a credible defense to be made. Unfortunately, Drummond, the Americans had over 5,000 men, more than twice his force. They also had Colonel Richard Johnson’s cavalry or Flying Dragons with them. Drummond’s cavalry had been worn out during the Battle of Guilloux’s Farm and was undermanned and lacked the leadership for another battle. At Bowmanville, the Flying Dragons disseminated the British cavalry with the first ten minutes they then swung around attack Drummond’s artillery but were quickly repulsed. Though no cannons were destroyed, roughly a third of their crews were unfit for duty or missing.
Colonel Richard Johnson’s Flying Dragons
His militiamen, a quarter of his force, broke on his left flank and fled the battle. With no other choice, Drummond relinquished the field and retreated. He hoped now to take up a defense in Ottawa until Quebec could strike or if the invasion through Florida were successful perhaps the Americans would abandon the North. However, when news of Drummond’s defeat made it to him, he began his siege of Ottawa. Drummond arrived too late, his only hope was to try and break the siege, but he needed time to think of a plan.
George II and Jackson meet at San Luis de Talimali on May 6, 1814, to discuss a plan for the British invasion. Jackson believed that the British would invade near the southernmost tip of Florida and that they should march south to halt them. George II disagreed noting that the Pa-hay-okee meaning Grassy Waters by the Seminoles would cripple any invading force going through it. George II attempt better relations with the Natives to avoid the same issues with the Creeks. He believed that staying place was the best option until the British made their move as they had lost no territory yet there was little to fear.
George II understood Jackson’s devotion to attack and serve his country. Jackson was self-made man and struggled his entire life and had achieved much. As Lawrence Jorge had struggled back during the War for American Dominion. The only way to move up in the war was to fight and win, but George II was not willing to risk his men by meeting the British. He ordered fortification to be built.
To the surprise of many, including the US Navy, the British landed on Safe Harbor, the old port refuge from pirates. Scouts reported that 12,000 British soldiers were headed to retake St. Augustine and then take Savanah. George II had almost 10,000 men with him; his greatest advantage was that the British did not have Ferguson Rifles. Martin Ferguson, son of the Loyalist Patrick Ferguson, had been convinced to begin selling to the Americans after he was captured. At least 3,000 were equipped with the superior weapon.
MM soldiers were noted for the gold or silver eagles on their uniforms during the Second Quebecois War
The British were slow at first, but with aid by the Creeks, they knew where the Americans were heading. The two forces met near the St. John River on May 23, 1814. Unlike the British soldiers he had fought in Quebec, these were veterans of the Iberian War led by Major General Edward Pakenham. George II had hoped to go on the defensive, but Jackson had ordered skirmishers to begin to harass the British, so Pakenham responded with cannon fire. The British were stationed above a hill and could see the field of battle. The Americans had to march through the marshes and soldiers would, “hit a club of dirt against their boats before taking a step and having water up to their calves.”
The American firepower eventually forced the British off the hill, but they were too exhausted to continue the push. Jackson lead a cavalry attack on the British left flank but was repelled. Both the British and Americans left the field the next neither side claimed a victory. The Americans had suffered over 2,000 casualties. Battle of St. Johns River would be nicknamed Battle of Muggy Blood. With the British not too far from the Americans pushing North, George II he needed more men, but he knew Arnold would need convincing. Hamilton was in no situation to be sending truth men to Florida unless Arnold asked. The best person to get George II the reinforcement was his wife.
She took a trip to Washington with her three children. Lucy Washington has been outshined by both her husband and her children. Many characteristics that her daughter, Martha would develop would come from her, including her ability to walk the minefield of politics. She, however, unlike George II, was not as willing to prove to others that she was most talented in the room, she already knew that. “The hassle of bringing two young boys and a teething girl across state lines was never a joyful occasion for me, but rather the grandfatherly figure they were to meet.”
Arnold canceled the meeting he was having when news of the Washington family was coming to the Capital. He doodled over the Washington children just as much as he did his grandchildren, but a trip from Connecticut was much further than Mount Vernon. He told them old war stories and brought them treats. She too added the story of how her husband cared for Arnold after he was wounded. Benedict, Lucy’s middle child, asked, “Mr. President when is father coming home?” Arnold did not know, and they were soon sent off to bed. Lucy continued to argue for George II pleading for their friendship and the good the Washingtons had done for the country. For Arnold Quebec was the key to end the war and George II knew that too. If Quebec was under Old Glory, but he died he would think it well. His wife would not allow that. Arnold agreed to send him men. No one is sure what she said, but journalist would spread rumors about Lucy having an affair with Arnold. She denied such claims.
Samuel Milhouse as Benedict Arnold in Prince of America