Deus Vulted it Different: A real fourth Crusade

Chapter I:
A triumph on the Nile.

The Crusader forces were composed of the men from Montferrat, Blois, Champagne, Burgundy and Flanders. The majority rallied at Venice, aiming to land in Egypt and gain a foothold there. However, the Venetian Doge was jealous of Rhomaic wealth and had a long hatred towards them. Unfortunately for the Crusaders, they had little to no finances, so the Venetians requested that they pay by fighting. This resulted in capture of Zara (and from here is the POD). The Pope, after hearing what has happenned, has swiftly denounced such actions , and ordered the forces to return to the original plan. The Ventian fleet land in Shkoder, Dyrrhacium, Otranto, Crete (which was however seized and transferred nto Venetian hands) and Cyprus to reúpletish supplies.

A surprise night attack on Alexandria from the sea proved victorious. From there, a quick campaign secured the remaining parts of the Nile Delta within one year.
Baldwin IX, Count of Flanders was crowned as the first Christian King. At first, his realm encompassed only the Nile Delta without Cairo, and there were no more than 15 000 Latin Christians at the time, most of whom were part of the Crusading army. In the next year, a campaign has begun to conquer Cairo and the majority of Upper Egypt from the north; while the Nubians were to hit from the south, and secure the Aswan governorate. After the four month long siege of Cairo, the rest was secured quickly. King Baldwin declared, that any town which surrenders without hesitation will be spared, and all that will be demanded will be one coin per head. In case of resistance, however, the risks of a bloodbath were quite high.

For the first decade, King Baldwin has implemented some reforms, which dramatically changed the society. First of all, most land owned by Muslims was confiscasted and given to Christians (Latins were foavourised). Also all restrictions previously imposed on the Copts were diminsihed, and imposed on their Muslim neighbours. What was not forgotten, was seizure of weapons from Muslims.
Most of the land in Lower Egypt was owned either by the Crusaders, or by Egyptiotes (Alexandrian Greeks , or Jews. In the south, majority of land was transferred to the Copts, who became the landlords. Egypt experienced a drift towards the medieval European feudalism.
Venetians were given many priviliges in the trade, while the Jews and Greeks were offered land as compensation (before they were mostly preoccupied with trade). The Coptic Church was also given large fiefs, mainly in the western part of the Nile Delta. ( The so-called Patrimony of Saint Mark covering the rural outskirts of Alexandria)

At first, the Copts viewed the Crusaders with mistrust, fearing that if they collaborate with them, the Arab´s revenge will hit them heavily. However, as the Crusaders managed to hold the realm, and expressed sympathy for them, many have risen to become counts or knights.

The King officially supported the Coptic church , although he himself were a Catholic and brought also a Catholic bishop to serve him and his compnions. The Greek Patriarch was tolerated, and the King explicitly banned Arabic from the households from all of his vassals. The court languages were Old French and Latin, and the use of Coptic was encouraged heavily also by the the Patriarch. However, it was Greek that became the lingua franca, as for the crusaders it was easier to learn the language, while the Copts were also familiar with the language. However, a way was found to go around that obstacle. Aramaic, the language of the LORD himself has not been banned and was quite intelligible with Arabic itself.

The social mobility tied to conversion to Christianity was large enough for many to do so, however only the next generation was to be fully equal with the original Christians. In times of rage, or violence, quite a few minarets were torn down, and some tens of thousands of Muslims fled to Hejaz and Tunisia.
 
Last edited:
Pharaoh would be an inappropriate title for a Christian monarch of Egypt and would have no precedence in either the culture Baldwin is from or the Copts who come from a Greco-Roman influenced tradition. It's of pagan connotation and wouldn't fly - Baldwin would more likely crown himself as just King/Rex/Roi.

That said, cool beans.
 
Looks very promising. I can't wait for the future events, especially those connected with the situation of the Byzantine Empire.
I wonder how long new, crusader Kingdom of Egypt will survive.
 
Taking Egypt is the hard part, once you do that well... Rome held it for 6 centuries, and the Arabs held it from the conquests to this day.

The Libyan desert is a good barrier and in any case North Africa is likely to end uo conquerred by Sicily or whatever (with no Latin Empire, even if the annoy end up in power there they won't get involved in the east, so the Sicilian Vespers will be very different if they even haopen at all). To the south, the Christian kingdoms are weak and probably friendly while to the east there is the kingdom of Jerusalem.

If it falls it will fall to the Mongols or an Alt!Tamerlane. I think the Mongols are the most likely candidate.

TBH I think Venice would seize Crete or at least establush a client state and get away with it. The Empire is in dire straits even without the Sack.

This might prompt a palace coup against the Angeloi (good riddance).
 
This resulted in capture of Zara (and from here is the POD). The Pope, after hearing what has happenned, has swiftly denounced such actions , and ordered the forces to return to the original plan. The Ventian fleet land in Shkoder, Dyrrhacium, Otranto and Cyprus to reúpletish supplies.

A surprise night attack on Alexandria from the sea proved victorious.

Could you elaborate on the POD? In OTL Innocent condemned the attack on Zara, threatened excommunications if they didn't return to the original plan, etc, but Peter of Capua hid the letters from the other crusaders, so none of them knew about the condemnations. What's changed so that Peter of Capua doesn't do this?
 
@Cuāuhtemōc good point to make, I fixed it.
@The Undead Martyr yes was thinking of it before, but I thought they would be "nice"..seems they really werent. Fixed.

@Mosak.: Most importantly, Boniface of Montferat doesnt go back to Venice to visit his cousin Philip of Swabia. That means the Rhomaic (Byzantine) pretender doesnt give the Crusader leaders false promises, and therefore the campaigning Crusaders are not faced with this offer.
 
Chapter II: Chaos on the Bosporus.
Alexios IV Angelos, a claimant to the imperial throne , living in the Venetian exile hoped to depose the emperor Alexios III Angelos. Receiving some help from the Kingdom of Sicily and Venice, he attempted to perform a coup d´etat. However, the Italians, seeing the newly gained opportunities in Egypt, were reluctantly to give large support to him. Therefore, his attmept was a complete failure, and he was sent to a monastery. As of Alexios III, he remained emperor until 1211, when he was succeeded by Alexios V. Doukas (who ruled for 3 years).
The empire being without a legitimate successor resulted again into disputes. The two claimants. Theodore I. Laskaris and Alexios Komnenos. The former has managed to gain control over the majority of the Empire, the latter over the Black Sea coast. This realm has managed to to hold on quite long, being known to the historians as the Empire of Trebizond. being separated by Turkish holdings from the rest of the empire, this area managed to remain independent for some 40 years

Emperor John III Doukas Vatatzes (1222-1254) was a particularly skilled emperor, who managed to recover Trebizond (after 40 years of independence) and supported Greek rebels in Crete.
 
Chapter III: The Fifth Crusade
A few years later, with Egypt under Crusader control, it was agreed, that with the southern flank secured, it was time to retake Jerusalem. The plans have begun right after seeing the success , and many fanatical preachers in Europe were speaking of "now or never" is the time to retake Jerusalem. After Pope Inocent III published the papal bull Quia maior, preparations have begun in France, the HRE, and Hungary.
The plan was to sail to Crete, from there to Cyprus, Alexandria and Acre. In Alexandria, the plans were to be consulted with the Egyptian King Peter.
As the roughly 32 thousand force arrived in Egypt, and another 15 000 local Egyptian troops gathered, it was decided that the European forces will try to reconquer Jerusalem, and much of its kingdom all the way to Kerak and the Red Sea. Meanwhile, the Egyptian Crusaders were to secure the Mediterranean coast of the Sinai, Gaza and Saint Catherines Monastery.

Their foes were the Ayyubid Sultanate, controlling most of Syria, Jordan, and parts of the Holy Land, as well as northern Iraq , Hejaz and Yemen ( which were however loosely controlled.) Cyrenaica and the Kharga oasis were pretty much independent, ruled by local emirs. The capital of the Ayyubid was Damascus, and the various emirates were held together in a sort of confederation.

As the Crusader forces approached Jerusalem, they found the city ruined and abandoned. The defenders destroyed its walls and fled, leaving it undefensible. Therefore, a third of the total force was detatched to hold the city, while the rest moves inland to secure Judea. The army engaged in battles at Hebron and Jericho. Afterwards, the Germans were sent to secure the coastal area to Ascalon while the Hungarians and French moved northwards, conquerring Samaria, where they faced the Ayyubid forces at Beisan. Despite considerable casualties, ,they have managed to win the battle.
The next phase involved the monastic orders, whose target was to take control of the area beyond the Dead Sea, most importantly Kerak and Montreal, as well as Aila on the Red Sea.

On the other hand, the Egyptian army faces minor skirmishes, but no major encounter, except the siege of Gaza. This lasted for quite some time, but resulted in a victory, after the German forces have reached the area.

Finally, a last campaign began to secure Oultrejordain and parts of Lebanon. Here they met heavy resistance from the Emirate of Baalbek. All in all, the campaign was a large success, and it restored the original borders of the Kingdom of Jerusalem at the time of the 1st Crusade, as well as secured the Sinai peninsula. Furthermore, some 5 000 more knights settled in the newly conquered areas of the Kingdom of Jerusalem. Unfortunately, disputes around the future ownership of the Sinai between Jerusalem and Egypt were difficult to overcome. Both claimed it as their own, and tensions on the issue resulted in hostility between the realms.
 
Chapter IV: Cultural outcomes
Of course, the results of the Crusades had important cultural impact. The establishment of Crusader kingdom in Egypt resulted in cultural exchange between western Europe and the Upper Nile. Most importantly, European technology and knowledge expanded into Makuria and Ethiopia, and to a lesser extent also to Alodia and other areas of the Ethiopian Highlands (Kaffa, Ennarea). On the other hand, coffee makes its way to Egypt and western Europe.
In addition, Italian, mostly Venetian merchants have managed to control trade between Egypt and Europe. Their trade network gradually expands, with trading posts being established on the African coast of the Red Sea. The last of these in Soqotra, which becomes a merchant republic, cooperating with Italians. Being Christian, although Nestorian, and given its strategic position, it is seen as key on the road to India.
Venetian merchants begin talking about a possible Suez canal, however the question is as of who would build it.

In the Kingdom of Jerusalem, the Franks (mainly French, also Italian) made no more than 20% of the population. The more rural ones tended to become gradually intermixed with Syrian or Greek Orthodox. Some theologians argued that the "language of the Saviour himself ought to become the tongue of court and the Kingdom" ,however Western Aramaic experienced only limited revival in Galilee and parts of Samaria. The Jews and Samaritans recieved some privileges, and were allowed to live in special neighborhoods of Jerusalem.
All in all, the population of the kingdom could have looked like this:
  1. Franks:20%
  2. Orthodox 25%
  3. Maronites:6%
  4. Druze:5%
  5. Jews and Samaritans:3%
  6. Armenians and other Christian 2 %
  7. Muslims,mostly Sunni 39%.
 
Last edited:
Number Six
The northern Crusader states, that is Antioch and Tripoli, lobied for another Crusade. The goal was to either take Edessa, Aleppo,Damascus, or what was chosen to do, to take the Orontes valley.
This was to be the last Crusade for the Holy Land
Meanwhile the Sinai dispute was to be decided by the Pope. The decision was simple: In the interim, the area was to be administered by Egypt, until Jerusalem conquers Cyrenaica for them. Then, Sinai would be given to Jerusalem.

The campaign of 1228 began by stopping at Cyprus. There they meddled with local politics as in OTL, and then landed near Antioch. The much larger than OTL force was to march up the Orontes river. After some skirmishes, they manage to conquer Homs and Hamah. After heavy resistance, both cities were captured, while the defenders left to Tadmur and Aleppo.
The Crusaders were aided by a Maronite light infantry, who penetrated into the Zahle valley. Simultaneously, the forces of Jerusalem take Auranitis.
The newly gained areas were organized as Duchy of Emessa. Zahle was added to it as well.
By this time the Duchy of Emesa had some 45%of Antiochian Greek Christians.

However, the Assassins were left enclaved, between.Antioch, Tripoli and Emesa. The Prince of Antioch was planning a full out offensive to crush the Entity, and unite with Emesa, to proclaim the Kingdom of Syria.

Meanwhile Egyptian society was increasingly differentiating. Upper Egypt was increasingly Coptic, and the handful of Latins quickly adopted local customs.
Lower Egypt was more cosmopolitan, with the cities and villas being a mosaic of Latins, Greeks, and Jews, and the villages mostly Muslim. The Latins in the north were more reserved to the local culture, and gradually become more suspicious as the king tries to gain sympathy among the Copts.
 
The Rise of the Ilkhanate and the seventh and eighth Crusades
In the 1248, popular support for the Crusades waned, as many thought that most of what should have been achieved, was already done. However, the seventh Crusade was launched by the French kings,who wished to secure the whole of Syria.

At this point in time, the Mongols have subdued Persia and defeated the Seljuq sultanate after the Battle of Kose Dag. This has given the Rhomaians (Byzantines) a good moment to strike against the Seljuq Turks. Rhomaic troops proceeded fast to secure the area bordered by the Halys in the east and Taurus in the south. This area still had a significant Greek populace, although the Turks were still the plurality. The crusader states also offered to pay tribute to the Ilkhans.
In this environment, the French king Louis IX set out to conquer Damascus. Supported by contingents from the various states of the Outremer, he managed to effectively besiege the city. Meanwhile, minor contingents of the feudals have secured most of the countryside.After two months , the garrisson surrendered, under the terms of safe departure. This was aimed towards Palmyra, the last Arab fortres in the Levant.
For meanwhile, the Ilkhanate was campaigning in northern Syria, securing Jazira, and pushing towards Aleppo.
The last major Crusader campaign was against Tunis. The eight Crusade was aimed at securing Tunisia, Tripolitania, and liberating the remaining Christian population. The campaign of 1270 began by landing in Sicily, and from there they moved to the east coast of Tunisia. Landing near Sousse, they managed to conquer the city without much resistance. The original plans spoke of Muhammad I al-Mustansir being inclined towards conversion to Christianity. Accordingly the Crusade was to bring his conversion. As king Louis IX marched towards Tunis, he brought about this demand. Although at first reluctant, the Hafsid ruler agreed, upon condition that he be recognized by the Holy See as a sovereign and Christian king. He was baptised as Paul, and to many, a victory was achieved.
However, a civil war broke out, as Sunnis have risen against his conversion. The Crusading army, about to depart, was called to engage the rebels. The decisive engagement took place near Zaghouan. The battle ended undecisevely, and negotiations led to the rebels gaining the western one-third of the Hafsid domains.
Meanwhile, the Outremer armies seized Cyrenaica in a quick campaign, and the area was added to Egypt, in exchange for Jersusalem getting Cyprus.

By 1300 AD, a stable Ilkhanate-Rhomaic border ran halfway through Anatolia, while the northern Levant consisted of smaller Crusader principalites subject to the Ilkhanate. The southern Levant was held by the Kingdom of Jerusalem.

The success of the Crusaders was an impetus which led to the Ilkhans converting to Christianity, more specifically, to become adherents of the Church of the east. The Nestorian population was later boosted by Nestorians fleeing the Golden Horde and Chagatai after their conversion to Islam.
 
At least in North Africa and the Middle East. Muslim west Africa remains untouched.
West African Islam is paltry at best during this particular period. Islam expanded mainly due to trade and did so through Kings and Merchants. Those Kings and Merchants will be looking to Christianity TTL, which should be more rapid in spreading due to less stringent and unified tenets as Islam did.
 
Interesting TL so far - I wonder as much as the Islamic world is reeling from this, if we might see the Spanish Kingdoms finish the Reconquesta earlier.
 
Top