DBWI: Urban Projects That Never Should've Been Built

kernals12

Banned
City planners, like all humans, are prone to making mistakes. And many of these mistakes haunt us to this day.

LOC_30548u_CROP.0.jpg

For example, the decision to tear up Lower Manhattan to build a highway and then top it off with hideous Brutalist apartments.

What are yours?
 

kernals12

Banned
And let's not forget the decision to raze much of Central Paris to put in this crap
101-1.jpg

We lost lots of beautiful Haussmann architecture for these concrete monstrosities
Le-Corbusiers-Plan-Voisin-for-Paris-Le-Corbusier-from-Urbanisme-Paris-1922.png
 
I still can't believe it took us 10+ years to rebuild the World Trade Center and we ended up with... this. The glass skeleton.

hudson_river.jpg
 
And let's not forget the decision to raze much of Central Paris to put in this crap
We lost lots of beautiful Haussmann architecture for these concrete monstrosities
Le-Corbusiers-Plan-Voisin-for-Paris-Le-Corbusier-from-Urbanisme-Paris-1922.png
Actually, the Germans destroyed Paris when the Allies were on the verge of winning it (and killed thousands of Parisians; it's one of the worst tragedies on French soil--ironically, the Eiffel Tower was one of the few things spared), so blame the Nazis for this; it was still a bad decision by the postwar French government...
 
Birmingham? Nice? Clearly not from the same timeline. I had a flight transfer through there once and it was the same grey sprawl of concrete, billboards and strip malls as the rest of the southern half of england.
 
What. well it has not had munch devlopmuent since the 30s but is still nice with what it had. Also are we forme the same timeline or not.

OOC. are you aware this is a DBWI and not a standerdid therd or are we doing some intertimeline stuff. sorry for the missepspeelings.
 
Ummm the ugly pyramidesque building that ruined Jerusalem’s skyline?

I mean, I kind of get it, though - the Egyptian refugees were harkening back to the pyramids that were destroyed by nukes in '83. The United Islamic Republic's Reconstruction Commission has signed off on worse things, like the rather morbid memorial to the war dead in former Tel Aviv. That thing's hideous (not that Tel Aviv was exactly pretty during the Israeli days - very blandly bureaucratic).
 

sprite

Donor
The Illinois. When they cleared out Cabrini-Green and put all Chicago of public housing into a poorly built badly maintained tower.
 
If we're fixing Paris, we should be undoing that Straight Seinne (inSeinne?) monstrosity.:eek: Which idiot thought this was a good idea?:rolleyes:

seinne straightening proposal (alternatehistory).jpg

For those of you who like the Champs-Élysées on the water: get over it.
 
Remember the days when Center City wasn't this Forbidden City-style monstrosity and South treet wasn't utterly obliterated to make room for the smoggy gargantuan hellscape of the Crosstown Expressway? Remember the days before Girard Avenue was needlessly turned into yet another clone of the Vine? Pepperidge Farm remembers.

img11.jpg


Christ it's depressing - once the Big Three were built everywhere outside of Center City and the Northeast went to shit. No wonder Liberty County broke off from Philly in the '80s, and no wonder UPenn moved out to Villanova in the '70s.
 
What are you talking about? Next are you going to tell me the Thames should be made curvy again?
J_REVELEYS_PLAN_3.jpg
Absolutely!

All this tampering with nature is nuts.

What's next, diverting the Caspian Sea & turning it into farmland?:rolleyes: Even the Soviets can't be that crazy.:rolleyes:

Wait for it, somebody will say diverting rivers through the Rockies is a good idea.:rolleyes: L.A. will get to import Canadian water & export its earthquakes.:eek::rolleyes:

OOC: there was a proposal to divert rivers south, rejected in part because it would've caused 'quakes...
 

kernals12

Banned
Absolutely!

All this tampering with nature is nuts.

What's next, diverting the Caspian Sea & turning it into farmland?:rolleyes: Even the Soviets can't be that crazy.:rolleyes:

Wait for it, somebody will say diverting rivers through the Rockies is a good idea.:rolleyes: L.A. will get to import Canadian water & export its earthquakes.:eek::rolleyes:

OOC: there was a proposal to divert rivers south, rejected in part because it would've caused 'quakes...
OOC: You mean NAWAPA? The problem with that had nothing to do with earthquakes, it's that Canadians were not interested in flooding 800 miles of trench in British Columbia to water lawns in Southern California.
 
Top