Bin Laden is Dead and GM is Alive: An Alternate 2010 Midterm TL

Opening
“Welcome back, as we begin to look over the results of the 2010 midterms, opening up with the governor races' across the country. It is argued that the address by President Obama on the killing of Osama bin Laden on October 22nd played a pivotal part in the shifting of many races, but for now we'll go with the five closest races on Election Day; those being Florida, Maine, Minnesota, Ohio, and Wisconsin, and we'll open up with Florida first. The race between Florida was between that of Democrat Alex Sinks, the Chief Financial Officer of Florida, and Republican Rick Scott, venture capitalist. Charlie Crist's refusal to run for a third term set the election into motion, with Alex Sinks winning the Democratic nomination handily, while Rick Scott and Florida Attorney General Bill McCollum engaged in a constant and negative Republican primary, with Rick Scott winning the primary. For both Alex Sinks and Rick Scott, it was a very close campaign, with it being an indicative toss-up. As the results started to come in on the 2nd, by midnight, Rick Scott conceded to Alex Sinks over the phone placing her as Florida's 45th governor and first female governor. For her, the State Legislature will prove to be a problem controlled entirely by the Republicans, but not enough for a supermajority in the House, being one representative shy.

“Moving now to Maine, it was arguably more of a surprise, between Democrat Elizabeth Mitchell, President of the Maine Senate, Republican Paul LePage, Mayor of Waterville, and Independent Eliot Cutler, attorney and former staff member to Senator Edmund Muskie and adviser to President Carter. In the case of Mitchell, she found herself winning a very closely divided race, while LePage won by a large amount in his primary. The general election however, found Mitchell declining against LePage while Cutler himself started to gain, as attacks by both the Democrat and Republican candidate oriented towards Cutler to try and prevent a loss to him. As the results came in throughout the night, and into the morning it showed Cutler in the lead, but by a very slim margin. For now, Mayor Paul LePage has demanded a recount with the margin likely closing on the tens if not hundreds of votes, but it is expected that Eliot Cutler will be Maine's 74th governor and third independent. The state legislature is also of an interesting makeup, in that while the State Senate has found itself staunchly Republican, the House of Representatives has found itself in a tie between the Republicans and Democrats, with independent Benjamin Chipman of the 119th finding himself as the 'tiebreaker' as it were for the government. It will be interesting to see where it goes in Maine with this kind of situation.

“Shifting to Minnesota, we had the race between Democratic-Farmer-Labor Mark Dayton, former Senator, and Republican Tom Emmer, State Representative. Mark Dayton would wind up narrowly winning the party primary in a close race, while the announcement that Tim Pawlenty would not seek a third term would see an open field among Republicans with Tom Emmer winning the Republican primary. The general election found itself between Mark Dayton and Tom Emmer, with Mark Dayton consistently edging over Tom Emmer in polls and winning the election as Minnesota's 40th governor. He is the first Democrat since Rudy Perpich lost in the 1990 election, and will find himself in a secure position with the State Legislature remaining consistently Democrat despite fears it would flip Republican. Mark Dayton faces a better road ahead for Minnesota with a Democratic trifecta in place.

“Ohio found itself caught between Democrat Ted Strickland, incumbent Governor, and Republican John Kasich, former Representative. Strickland faced no challenge in his primary, while Kasich won his with no challenge. The race arguably found itself as a constant tossup between the two per polls, with polls in late October starting to show a slow uptick to Ted Strickland's numbers versus that of John Kasich as results were waited for. As the results came in, they moved to Kasich, but with Hamilton County and Cuyahoga County coming in Democrat, it started to rapidly shift and erode Kasich's lead as the results continued to come in. By 3AM, John Kasich had conceded the election to Ted Strickland, securing a second term for him as Governor of Ohio. The statehouse was a different story, with the Senate remaining in the hands of the Republicans, while the House was a different story. The House found itself under one of the closest margins, with it seeming to suggest the Democrats holding it by a single seat, but two seats will be heading towards recounts and could shift the House into either remaining Democrat or Republican, but it seems like both seats will stay the same. With the Democrats having maintained the Governorship, State Auditor, and the House, it will grant them majority control ahead of the next redistricting which will offer the Democrats something of a breather in Ohio.

“Finally arriving at Wisconsin, it saw a race between Democrat Tom Barrett, Mayor of Milwaukee, and Republican Scott Walker, Milwaukee County Executive. Tom Barrett won his primary when incumbent governor Jim Doyle announced he would not seek a third term, while Walker won the Republican primary handily. The general election would be somewhat tough with the emerging Tea Party Wave, and it would be, with Scott Walker having managing to win the Governorship at one of the closest margins yet in Wisconsin history. For Scott Walker, while he will face challenge from the state legislature, that despite the victory of Republicans in the State House, the Democrats in the State Senate (like those of the Ohio State House) found themselves barely holding onto the Senate by one vote. It will pose a significant challenge to Scott Walker moving forward and for now we'll have to see where that will take Wisconsin.

“Pennsylvania and Illinois also saw something of expectations, with Representative Joe Sestak winning the Senate election there after having defeated Pat Toomey in the general and Arian Specter in the primary. In Illinois, State Treasurer Alexi Giannoulias winning the race against Senator Mark Kirk. Per the results from both Pennsylvania and Illinois, we can project the 112th Congress to have a Democratic-controlled Senate, with 53 Democrats, 45 Republicans, and 2 Independents, and a Republican-controlled House, with 228 Republicans and 207 Democrats. For President Obama, it will be somewhat less of a challenge than expected, with only twenty-one Representatives between the Democrats and Republicans in the House, and maintaining the control of the Senate.”
 

Sabot Cat

Banned
Fantastic! It's amazing what a small shift in the results could cause, and considering the Democrats retained control of the Senate and did unexpectedly better in Congress in general, I wonder if the narrative about the 2010 elections would be significantly different than OTL, and what impacts that would have for this TL. I look forward to more! :)
 
Who are the 14 Dems that won?

These are the 14 Democrats who held their seats: Bobby Bright (AL-2), Melissa Bean (IL-8), Daniel Seals (IL-10), Jim Oberstar (MN-8), Dean Titus (NV-3), Ann McLane Kuster (NH-2), John Adler (NJ-3), Michael McMahon (NY-13), Dan Maffei (NY-25), Bob Etheridge (NC-2), Stephanie Herseth Sendlin (SD-At Large), Solomon Ortiz (TX-27), Tom Perriello (VA-5), Alan Mollohan (WV-1)
 
Herseth Sandlin hangs on- that's good, I've met her once before and she was a pretty good Representative. Shame she lost in OTL, but well, South Dakota.
 
I: Lame Ducks
A little short, but intended to be posted prior to the board being shut down for maintenance. ;)

I: Lame Ducks


SENATE VOTES YES ON DREAM ACT, HEADING TO PRESIDENT'S DESK

December 14th, 2010

(CNN)-In something regarded as amazing, if not shocking, the Senate has voted yes on closing cloture for concurring on a House amendment in a 60-40 vote, followed by with the same exact partisan lines in voting yes on the DREAM Act. Senators Graham (R-SC), Hagan (D-NC), Kirk (R-IL), Manchin (D-WV), and McCain (R-AZ) all of whom were expected to be wavering on the bill and likely vote no, voted yes for the bill. It was believed that significant backroom negotiations played a part in such passage of the bill, with significant speculation aimed at an increasing defense budget for 2011 based off Graham, Hagan and McCain's votes and possibly some kind of appointment for Kirk following his loss against Giannoulias in the midterm elections.

"Republicans that voted for the DREAM Act lied to voters. McCain's a traitor to the cause, says he supports a fence, then voted yes on this."-@AndrewBreitbart

“It is with great celebration that the Senate passes the DREAM Act. Here's to seeing President Obama's signature on it.”-@DickLugar

“Obama signs DREAM Act. Calls it 'an honor' and 'Americans who served our country despite being undocumented, can finally become citizens'.”-@AP​

“The DREAM Act (an acronym for Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors) passage in the Senate on December 14th, arguably represented a shocking development considering the makeup of the Senate for Democrats and the expectations that it would fail to pass the Senate. The DREAM Act, as passed by the 110th Congress, established an age cap of 29 for whom undocumented immigrants could apply. The bill was one of the strictest proposals to date, but it's passage was still being met with derision and attacks against the Obama Administration and the three Republicans (Senators Lindsey Graham (R-SC), Mark Kirk (R-IL), and John McCain (R-AZ)) whom voted for it. To such an extent, it is not surprising for the actions that would follow in Arizona in the 112th Congress.”-The War of Media, A Look at the 2008-2020 Elections

This is MSNBC, with breaking news out of Arizona. Representatives Gabrielle Giffords has been shot at a local meeting with constituents, with her status being unknown at this. We will keep you up to date on this unfolding event out of Arizona.”
 
Last edited:
How can Mark Kirk vote on the dream act if he lost the senate election? :p He actually strangely ran behind in the vote for immediate replacement of Burris so he wouldn't have won the special ballot to finish out the term if he lost the election totally. Though there oddly could have been a weird result where Alexi won to finish out the term but Kirk won the ballot for the next term...
 
How can Mark Kirk vote on the dream act if he lost the senate election? :p He actually strangely ran behind in the vote for immediate replacement of Burris so he wouldn't have won the special ballot to finish out the term most likely. Though there oddly could have been a weird result whete Alexi won to finish out the term but Kirk won the ballot for the next term...

... Huh, I didn't know that. *ponders if to make change or to leave Mark Kirk as Senator having somehow won*
 
II: Congressional Crosshairs
II: Congressional Crosshairs

From what we can confirm at this time is that Representative Giffords is in the hospital, with critical wounds. It is known at least four have died in this shooting, including John M. Roll, Chief Judge for the United States District Court for Arizona. We will be keeping you up to the date with the latest.”-January 8th, CNN

“I am horrified by the violent attack on Representative Gabrielle Giffords and many other innocent people by a wicked person who has no sense of justice or compassion... Whoever did this; whatever their reason, they are a disgrace to Arizona, this country and the human race, and they deserve and will receive the contempt of all decent people and the strongest punishment of the law.”-Statement by Senator John S. McCain, 1/8/11 [This was OTL]

On January 8th, 2011, Representative Gabrielle Giffords (AZ-8) was holding a constituent meeting known as 'Congress on Your Corner' at a Safeway in La Toscana Village mall. Sitting at a table with between twenty to thirty constituents, Jared Lee Loughner pulled out a pistol and fired. Whether Loughner missed or that Daniel Hernandez Jr. saw the gun and moved first will never be known, Daniel Hernandez Jr., an intern for Representative Giffords found himself shot directly in the head, with Loughner following near immediately in shooting Representative Giffords in the chest and would continue for a total of twenty shot. Loughner would find himself hit in the back of the head with a folding chair by a bystander before Bill Badger (a retired US Army Colonel) would tackle him to the ground. Jared Lee Loughner would be arrested, but for the moment the focus was on those who were shot.

Representative Giffords, Christina Taylor-Green, and Daniel Hernandez Jr. would be brought to the hospital, but both Christina Taylor-Green and Daniel Hernandez Jr. would be found dead on arrival at the hospital. For Giffords, she would be rushed to the operating room to be stabilized and would remain in critical care throughout the night. As Representative Giffords found herself in slow recovery, questions found themselves raised over the kind of political vitriol in the United States most especially as a result of the 2010 midterms. This would be addressed most heavily with Governor Palin's 'Take Back the 20', which entitled the twenty House districts that the Republicans won in the 2008 Presidential election that voted for the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA). The twenty House districts* included Representative Giffords district, and were highlighted most specifically because of the crosshairs aimed at the twenty House districts. Despite a video being aired by Palin saying it was not her fault and that the gunman had committed such actions herself.

The political climate throughout the country would be directly impacted as a result of the actions, with both Democrats and Republican calling for a cooling of rhetoric and return to political bipartisanship. It would be seen with an op-ed by Paul Krugman of the rise in toxic and hateful political rhetoric. Votes in the House would be suspended for a week, bringing Congressional business to nearly a halt in memorial for those who had died. A national moment of silence would be held at 11:00AM EST on January 10th. President Obama would arrive in Tucson on January 12th and would meet with Representative Giffords (then awake and recovering) before making a speech in Tucson to honor those who had died and to address the hopes of healing and national unity:

“But at a time when our discourse has become so sharply polarized -– at a time when we are far too eager to lay the blame for all that ails the world at the feet of those who happen to think differently than we do – it’s important for us to pause for a moment and make sure that we’re talking with each other in a way that heals, not in a way that wounds.

“Scripture tells us that there is evil in the world, and that terrible things happen for reasons that defy human understanding. In the words of Job, “When I looked for light, then came darkness.” Bad things happen, and we have to guard against simple explanations in the aftermath.”

*The twenty districts (and Representatives) were: Vic Snyder (AR-2), Ann Kirkpatrick (AZ-1), Harry E. Mitchell (AZ-5), Gabrielle Giffords (AZ-8), John Salazar (CO-3), Betsy Markey (CO-4), Allen Boyd (FL-2), Suzanne M. Kosmas (FL-24), Brad Ellsworth (IN-8), Baron P. Hill (IN-9), Earl Pomeroy (ND-AL), Charlie Wilson (OH-6), John Boccieri (OH-16), Kathy Dahlkemper (PA-3), Christopher Carney (PA-10), John M. Spratt Jr. (SC-5), Bart Gordon (TN-6), Tom Perriello (VA-5), Alan B. Mollohan (WV-1), and Nick J. Rahall II (WV-3). Only Ann Kirkpatrick, Gabrielle Giffords, Tom Perriello, Alan B. Mollohan, and Nick J. Rahall II would retain their seats as Democratic-controlled.
 

Zachanassian

Gone Fishin'
So, fewer people died (four rather than six), and Giffords was shot in the chest rather than the head. So Giffords might recover quicker, and not resign her seat?
 
Top