AH Challenge: Surviving French North America

How can France retain large colonies in North America? It can be based in Quebec, Louisiana, or anywhere else, but large swathes of the continent need to be French.

Also: what would such a place be like? Would they attract as many settlers as the same region OTL? Would native Americans be treated differently? How would France be effected by control of a settler colony across the Atlantic?
 
Have the french begin colonizing north american coast from the Saint-Laurent to Florida a century earlier than they did (let's say from the 1530's on).

This gives them 3 generations in advance on the english. "The place is already taken" could be the titre of a timeline I'm planning to wrote about soon.
 
By the time of the Seven Years' War it is already far too late; at that time the British population in North America vastly outnumbered the French population, to the extent that when they fought the British in that time-period the French regarded it as a victory even to keep what they had because they understood just how badly the odds were against them by that point.

Personally I would go with a 17th-century PoD. For most of the 17th century the English (not yet British—the Acts of Union hadn't happened yet) didn't even have their northern and southern colonies linked. Early in the 17th century you could quite possibly have one of the two main English colonial areas (i.e. New England and the South) be taken over outright by one of the other colonial powers, as England took over New Netherland in OTL; with such small populations it would be fairly easy. With the English threat decreased, then you just need France to adopt a more English-style method of colonisation (that is, relying more on European settlers displacing Native Americans, rather than on alliances with Native Americans and limited European presence which is the ultimately inferior strategy France pursued in OTL). There are plenty of people who have come up with plenty of ways to do this: one of the most commonly mentioned is the idea of making French America a place for religious dissidents—specifically Huguenots—as English America (and later British America) was. The seigneurial system almost certainly has to go.
 
Have the french begin colonizing north american coast from the Saint-Laurent to Florida a century earlier than they did (let's say from the 1530's on).

This gives them 3 generations in advance on the english. "The place is already taken" could be the titre of a timeline I'm planning to wrote about soon.

France did found a settlement at Charlesbourg-Royal, in the region of modern-day Québec City, in 1541. But it was abandoned soon thereafter. If it had succeeded, France could have probably expanded its settlements in the region for a few decades without any other European threats - although the Wars of Religion likely would have slowed the colonial movement. Still, through natural increase there might have been a sizable French population in North America by 1600.
 
Last edited:
A surviving New Amsterdam would split the British colonies between New England and South and divide Britain's attention. It would also radically change the history of North America in the 18th Century so there might not even be a Seven Years' War to begin with and thus no loss of New France. At least not right away. As mentioned there was a population problem and France would need to settle their colonies more extensively.
 
Top