Operation Pluto
Map of the plans for Phase 1 of Operation: Pluto - CIA -
The easiness that the Nixon Administration had found itself basking in since the inauguration in mid January would end 4 months into Nixon's Presidency. In the evening of May 12th, just two days after meeting with Alan Shepard personally at the White House at an official ceremony, Richard Nixon would affirm the final go ahead for Operation Pluto, and would begin overseeing its deployment throughout the night.
Planning for the clandestine operation had initiated during the sunset of the Eisenhower Presidency, and since its inception, Operation Pluto had evolved greatly from its original design. Nixon, who had taken part in the planning and organization of the details pertaining to the carrying out of the operation, had made revisions and edits to the original drafts of the plans even during the election. Since his victory in 1960, he had taken progressively been given more of a leadership position in the meetings with CIA officials in the place of Eisenhower until the inauguration officially placed him in full authority. Now finalized after at least a full year of preparations, the design called for the CIA leaders to utilize Cuban Refugees trained and supplied by the United States to invade the Communist nation of Cuba. From there they would move forward to destabilize support for the Castro regime and, in allied cooperation with Anti-Castro resistance already on the island, overthrow the Cuban government in favor of a more American leaning system.
The President's alterations to Operation Pluto called for a force of 2,300 anti-Castro Cuban refugees, a notable increase from the limit set forth by Eisenhower of 1,500. Under Nixon's watchful eye, the plan had grown to be colossal in scope. For an action initially meant to minimize US involvement, the numbers requested by the President raised questions on practicality by many in the CIA wishing to keep American involvement a complete state secret. To limit any international outcry for the invasion, they believed it to be an absolute necessity that the US maintain strict plausible deniability, at least until a point in time when it would be politically acceptable for the United States to move in and assist the resistance forces.
On the night of May 13th, with overcast skies and no visible moon, American backed forces split into 6 infantry battalions and one paratrooper battalion approached their positions before the initial stages of the invasion began. With 2 battalions landing on Isla De Pinos just east of Presidio Modelo (A Cuban Prison housing a large number of political prisoners), and the remaining battalions making landfall in the ports and areas surrounding Trinidad, Cuba, the invasion commenced with a surprising thunder. In the outset of the landings 5 B-26’s launched attacks on ships near and around the waters surrounding Nueva Gerona on Isla de Pinos, sinking the El Baire, and crippling a few other Cuban patrol boats and warships. The B-26’s then flew towards the other landing site of Trinidad, Cuba. The bombers were able to offer a great service to the invasion by landing a few direct hits on Cuban positions but their effectiveness was short lived due to weather conditions that required them to return to their specified airfield after only a half hour.
Isla De Pinos
Presidio Modelo- the prison while it was still standing - 1958
2 paramilitary battalions made landfall near the prison 20 minutes before the other battalions reached Trinidad and landed nearly unnoticed in the dark. With their short lived head start, a portion of the forces made their way to the prison in order to occupy the facility that was in charge of housing many of the counter revolutionaries that had dared to speak against Fidel Castro. It was the hope that should these men be released they would, at least for a short time, reinforce the invasion and aid in the fight against the communist forces. Initial resistance on the way to the prison was far heavier than had been expected and soon the exchange of gunfire had gathered large attention across the islands. Reports were quickly making their way across connections within the Cuban military and soon, a large force was being raised to repel what was now a known invasion of the island. Paramilitary forces steadily gained ground throughout the prison complex as they fought, but in the heat of the battle a defensive measure that had gone unknown by CIA planners made itself known with a fiery vengeance.
The prison that actively held over 8,000 political prisoners had been previously plagued by numerous riots and hunger strikes since Fidel Castro flooded it with his rivals and those unwilling to lend support. The Cuban government, under order from Che Guevara, had stocked several tons of TNT underneath Presidio Modelo in the facility’s vast tunnel network as a fail-safe should the prison be overcome by its large number of inmates. Once Cuban National forces began to lose their footing within several buildings of the prison, the order was given to demolish the facility by using the fail-safe. A long series of explosions rocked the complex and lit up the night sky as numerous sections of the complex collapsed inwards and imploded. Massive casualties were suffered by any and all that found themselves inside, including 85% of the prisoners within the buildings, and 120 of the paramilitary forces that had been dispatched to take over the prison. Along with them, 50 Cuban nationals perished in the explosions.
President Nixon in a candid photo after learning of lives lost in the explosions at the prison. - 1961 - The Nixon Library
Taped Conversation Between President Nixon, Paul Nitze, and Others in the Cabinet Room of the West Wing – May 13th 1961:
Nixon: I want an update the second we have one about the landings in Trinidad. Try and get me them as soon as we can possibly get them… and then when we—What is it Paul?
Nitze: Mr. President we’ve had a development.
Nixon: What kind of development? *hesitance in his voice*
Nitze: The forces at Isla de Pinos have suffered a major setback. We're still getting information on just how serious it is.
Nixon: Dammit Paul, tell me what the hell is going on?, setback..development… Tell me what the hell happened!?
Nitze: The forces were fighting inside of the prison, and the Cubans... They've wiped out the whole prison and they've taken a lot of our men with it.
Nixon: Wiped Out!?! How in the hell did they just wipe it out Paul!?
Nitze: What we've managed to piece together is that they had explosives throughout the entire prison complex… most likely in some kind of tunnel network running under and between the buildings.
Nixon: Son of a bitch….*fists hitting desk* How did none of you know those were there! Did someone over in your offices have their fucking tie on too tight? did they even bother to read the goddamn reports, because we both know they couldn't have kept something like that a secret over there!
Nitze: Sir, we still have a sizeable force on the island,… But… it is unlikely that we will see much more advancement on the island. Trinidad on the..
Nixon: Just stop, tell me, do I need to send reinforcements?
Nitze: No… What has happened on the island shouldn’t give the Cubans enough time to mobilize the necessary people at a place such as Trinidad before the landings.
Nixon: *sighs and sits down again* Because of this poor planning we just sent a lot of men to their deaths... You can tell the son of a bitch that signed off on this intelligence... you can tell him to expect a transfer to Alaska or some damn place.
Nitze: Understood Mr. President. This is still heavily in our side of ball park. They’ll get those bastards for us.
Nixon: I need a few minutes… Meet me back here in twenty minutes with the newest updates…
*end tape*
While not killing the majority of the paramilitary forces on the island, it dealt a heavy blow to the morale of those surviving the blasts. Quickly, they began engaging larger amounts of National resistance as word and alert spread of the attack and invasion, and it became clear that what remained was an uphill battle for the 2 battalions on the island. When news was broadcast to the White House regarding the incident it deeply upset and enraged President Nixon, and he departed to the Oval Office for a small intermission complaining of a severe headache. Thinking that the invasion would be discovered due to the explosions and heightened sense of alert, Nixon began contemplating ordering the involvement of American air forces and the USS Essex carrier group, which was already in the Caribbean. Military advisers persuaded him upon his return against making any decisions regarding increased military presence in Cuba for the time being. To which Nixon, expressing hesitance and mistrust, agreed to until he had more information.
Trinidad
Cuban Forces attempting to Repel the invasion at Trinidad - 1961
The 4 infantry battalions along with the paratrooper battalion landed in Trinidad Cuba. With the landings on Isla de Pinos throwing Cuban defenses into a rushing frenzy to gain the upper hand on the island, initial confrontations with Cuban Nationals in Trinidad went unreported. Immediately before the landing, 24 CIA lent B-26 bombers flew over three Cuban air fields and with the cover of night lending to their favor, bombed numerous hangars housing Cuban planes. The bombings, were moderately successful scoring in all 10 destroyed Cuban military aircraft, and 12 civilian aircraft. Although what was destroyed was but a small dent in the air power held by Cuba, only 7 B-26’s were shot down by direct enemy fire and one was lost while flying over the water due to damage sustained during its run. With anti-Castro forces having made landfall more or less undetected, and maintaining a relative element of surprise despite events elsewhere, paramilitary forces secured the beachhead within the initial hours of their landing. Trinidad had been selected for several specific reasons; one being its ease in creating a beachhead and the other being the ability to easily make contact with Anti-Castro rebels in the region to reinforce the invasion. American backed forces soon made contact with these counter-revolutionary cells in the area, of which leant themselves into the fight against Castro and his Communist forces. As the night drug on, word of Trinidad eventually rippled its way across Cuba and by the next morning National forces were on the counter attack. Having taken an easily defensible beachhead, the paramilitary forces held their positions and readied themselves to fight.
Rebel forces on the beaches of Trinidad fighting Castro's army - 1961
When the sun rose on the first full day of the invasion, Cuban forces in the area fell under the direct control of Fidel Castro himself. The proclaimed “Hero” of Cuba had been a leader as well as a fighter in his crusade against Batista, and Castro planned for this defense to be led no differently. Cuba was his country, and despite protests by his brother and other generals, he decided to personally command his forces from the front-lines.
Throughout the day, the Cuban forces hammered at the dissenters of their revolution and the casualties the rebels were taking began to climb. The out-manned and outgunned rebels were fighting tooth and nail to make any headway into Trinidad. By the afternoon, most rebels had been beaten back and were now entrenching themselves in makeshift foxholes on the beach and surrounding areas. Fidel Castro’s strategy had seemingly been the right one, as under his leadership the counter-revolutionaries had begun to lose valuable ground on the beachhead, and unsustainable losses for those standing against him were all but certain with the passage of time. But fate had different plans for this day in history. As Fidel Castro directed forces from a tree line, a mortar round fired by a member of Castro’s own forces landed directly to the left of Fidel Castro. The resulting impact and explosion killed 6 of Castro’s officers instantly and wounded several other men nearby. Fidel Castro himself was blown onto his back and was quickly dragged behind the cover of trees by Cuban infantry that had run to the scene. Mortally wounded, Castro stayed on the ground and weakly clawed at a large piece of shrapnel that had lodged itself into his neck and partially severed his external carotid artery. His last seconds were those of silence as his colder growing body bled out onto the ground for the country he had painstakingly led in a revolution. As death consumed him, the limp body of Cuba’s former leader was removed from the battleground and never recovered, but the rumor of his death quickly spread among the men fighting in his name. The useful and important information of Castro’s death would not be verified by Washington or forces in Trinidad for several days as conflicting reports bounced back and forth among the government’s leaders. The confusion of Castro's fate also greatly limited the initial effectiveness of any additional Cuban response, as the chain of command was now missing its most pivotal link. With many unsure of the rumors validity, few were willing to quickly step up to the helm.
Fidel Castro, the President of Cuba, addressing troops on the battleground next to Trinidad; 1961.
Cuban forces in Trinidad however, quickly grew aware of Castro’s death and their morale plummeted as their leader was now no longer among them. Many of them now wondered just how the nation would move on without him and some began falling back from the battle in order to regroup. The realization for Cuban forces soon set in that there was no immediate commander for the fight against the rebels, with the first few in the local chain wiped out from the explosion that also killed Fidel. This created a situation in which it was incredibly difficult for National forces to coordinate further movements in their defensive operations. Although forces fought strongly despite some withdrawing, the Counter-revolutionaries, with help from already instilled anti-castro cells, began to ever slowly gain the upper hand in Trinidad, with many moving into the nearby mountains to gain a further defensive hold of the area.
With reports from Trinidad streaming in after Castro’s death of a slight advancement in the invasion, Nixon slowly stood down from the urgency and sever stress he had felt just hours beforehand. A small sigh of relief could be exhaled by those in the White House for the time being with Nixon’s decision of keeping American forces out of the fight for the time being paying off. Operation Pluto had succeeded in its initial objective of establishing a beachhead in Cuba. The hope was that this success would inspire further revolt against the Communist government.
Retaliation
While Fidel Castro’s body grew colder behind the front lines of a slowly advancing counter-revolutionary force, those that had assumed power with Castro began to become increasingly aware of his death and the ramifications that would come from his loss. With the fight having just begun against the anti-Cuban forces, which at this time had been obviously determined to have been American backed, the leadership in what used to be Castro’s Cuba was in for a fight against the American led rebels and their fight to remain solid in the wake of Fidel’s death. The main concern of the leadership was to remain popular with the people that had loved Fidel and the revolution he embodied. For now, the situation was incredibly fragile.
As of 1961, Fidel’s brother Raúl Castro had been assigned command of forces in the east, based in Santiago de Cuba. Che Guevara commanded western forces, based in Pinar del Río. Major Juan Bosque commanded forces in the central provinces, based in Santa Clara. Raúl Morales was head of the air force. Sergio del Valle Jiménez was Director of Headquarters Operations at Point One in Havana. Efigenio Ameijeiras was the Head of the Revolutionary National Police, and Ramiro Menéndez was Minister of the Interior and head of state security. Of these men, it was understood that Raul Castro, Fidel’s brother, was now the leader of the nation.
When Che Guevara learned of the invasion and Fidel Castro’s subsequent death at the command of the defending forces, he launched his forces into full defensive combat readiness, and sent the order to arm every civilian that was healthy and able enough to carry a rifle. Further demanding the creation of a guerilla army that could retreat into hiding should the invasion gain ground at the control of the United States. Raul Castro on the other hand regrouped the Cuban military nearby Santiago de Cuba and prepared for the first retaliatory strikes against the nation’s enemies.
While those in Washington watched as the invasion from Operation Pluto grew in scale after its initial success due to counter-revolutionary aid, Raul Castro, heavily shaken by the loss of his brother and the recent events, made the decision to not attack the rebels in Trinidad but to attack something much larger. Holding the belief that American involvement was coming no matter what the Cuban government did in relation to a retaliatory strike, Castro designated the American military base at Guantanamo Bay to be the site of the Cuban counter-attack. The goal, was to take as many American assets out with the attack as could be accomplished in order to weaken American involvement if only slightly.
In the morning of May 17th, Raul Castro’s forces arrived at the Guantanamo Bay Naval Station, accompanied by heavy Cuban air support, and would nearly immediately launch a fully open attack aimed at crippling the Naval Base as quickly as possible. The American’s stationed at the site, already on heavy alert due to the events in Trinidad and Isla de Pinos, were still caught slightly by surprise by the ferocity the attack was accompanied with. Before air support was fully rallied and in the air, Cuban air forces successfully bombed several aircraft hangars and hit several areas that were occupied by the families of military personnel. American aircraft with the aid of anti-aircraft fire brought down a majority of the planes, but many were shocked to see the pilots of the damaged Cuban aircraft pilot their planes into the very targets they were bombing. With these initial bombings still underway, ground forces began attacks on the outer areas of base, and were met with heavy resistance by American defenders. Within 20 minutes American forces had enough power in the air to regain aerial dominance. As the battle of Guantanamo Bay continued into midday, heavy casualties were witnessed on both sides, but with a clear American victory in the wake. While the attack failed to remove the United States from being an imminent threat on the island, a delusion sought by Raul Castro in a decision of counter-reaction, it did send a message straight up the spine of the American chain of command that landed itself squarely on the Commander in Chief.
As Nixon was briefed on the events surrounding the attack on Guantanamo Bay, he ordered an immediate evacuation of every non-essential person living on the base which primarily referred to the families that lived along with personnel on the base. Nixon also made the decision to bring in US Navy Task Force 81.8 that were currently stationed in the Cayman Islands and redirected them to anchor off the Cuban coast near Guantanamo Bay. Task Force 81.8, commanded by Rear Admiral John E. Clark was made up of the Aircraft Carriers USS Essex and the USS Boxer, with destroyers USS Hank, USS John W. Weeks, USS Purdy, USS Wren, and submarines USS Cobbler and USS Treadfin. Additionally reporting to the area were USS Bache, USS Beale, USS Conway, USS Cony, USS Eaton, USS Murray, and USS Waller, the very same ships that had originally safeguarded the transportation of the Paramilitary groups that invaded Trinidad and other areas during Operation: Pluto. Although nothing it terms of warfare were immediately carried out with the naval power being brought in, it became clear that Nixon intended to not only avenge American lives lost in the attack of Guantanamo Bay, but to bring troops into Cuba in full force to help rid the island of Communist rule, and Nixon made this no secret in the White House.
Taped Oval Office Conversation Regarding Guantanamo Bay- 1961:
*tape switched on during conversation*
Robert Finch: ........ivilians, and we've counted up to 32 military casualties as of about an hour ago.
Nixon: I... Jesus Christ… They are going to pay for this…..
Finch: That much is obvious…
Nixon: At the very least we now have enough backing to go in and clear this thing up once and for all. There’s no way people will allow this kind of thing to happen, especially right off our coast line, I won’t stand for it... I'm not going to stand any longer while we try and pretend that we have nothing to do with Trinidad. Had we just gone in from the damn beginning this wouldn't have happened.
*audible shuffling*
Finch: We just got updated numbers on the casualties, 34 civilians.. 41 military personnel.
Nixon: alright... Put US forces in the Caribbean on full alert. We are at war. and we are going to show these bastards that they signed their death warrants when they decided to attacked our own. Nitze: We’re already working on a number of tactics Mr. President. I think we can all agree… that after the events of today… We no longer have to worry about support in becoming involved militarily on the island of Cuba.
Kennan: I agree. We’ve been attacked on our soil… we have the full and unquestionable right to respond with whatever force we deem necessary.
Nixon: We shouldn't have worried about that to start with. From this point on, I don't want to ever see a plan that has us dancing around and using inferior fighters when it is the obvious answer to simply become involved. This whole idea was garbage from the beginning and I should have seen that like I see it now. For the time being, I want the US Navy to surround that island. Nothing goes in or out.
Finch: You mean a blockade?
Nixon: Yes. I am not asking for approval or opinions either. Nitze: A redirection of some naval forces could easily allow for us to arrange a blockade off the coast of Cuba… If we’re going to war… they only have so much materials to fight back with… its not like they stand a chance in hell, they'll be entirely starved out in less than six months.
Nixon: Make sure our boys stay covered down there in Guantanamo… and I want to talk with the ones in charge down there now, to let them know that we’re not going to let this damn thing slide..
*End Conversation*
Details of the casualties in Guantanamo Bay came trickling in with a final total of 34 civilians determined to have perished in bombings, and 41 American military personnel killed in combat. As letters were typed out giving the nation’s utmost condolences to the families of those who had fallen and fires being put out in Guantanamo Bay, it became clear to America that the nation was heading into a war with a nation 90 miles to its South.
Nixon during his speech on the attack of Guantanamo Bay - 1961
Speech Regarding the Attack on Guantanamo Bay - May, 1961:
".... My Fellow Americans…, I have the solemn duty and responsibility, as your President, to report to you that 75 Americans lost their lives today....... in a ruthless and heartless attack carried out by the State of Cuba at 9:25 this morning. Today we have lost women, children, sons, daughters, husbands, and wives. Our military is full with brave Americans that risk their lives in the namesake of freedom, and today 41 of these heroes paid the ultimate price to uphold the freedom that they fought so valiantly for. It was today that I received reports that Cuban forces, in retaliation to rebels in the Cuban city of Trinidad, launched an attack on the United States Naval Base in Guantanamo Bay. It is with a heavy heart that I bring this news to the American people, and to the families of those we have lost today I send my utmost condolences and thanks to your family members that gave their lives so that we may live in freedom. It is my fullest and utmost intention to see those responsible for the loss of American lives brought not only to justice, but to be made to answer for their acts........ These acts of war against the United States will not be tolerated and we will not stand idle while lives have been cut down in an act of cowardice.
Let it be clear that the United States will not under any circumstance.... allow further aggression by Cuba. That is why as of this afternoon, I have ordered a full non-negotiable military blockade of the nation of Cuba and redirected naval forces in the Caribbean to focus in on the island nation. We will take action against those in power that ended so many American lives. And we will not rest until the government in Cuba answers for what they have done. Those we have lost today were of all ages, and they all fell resembling the ideals of the very nature and being that is the United States of America. This attack on our people today was an attack on this nation. We will not cease until justice is done for the 34 innocent members of families and the 41 men stationed in Guantanamo that we lost today. And we will not settle or negotiate for any less. Goodnight, and May you all see a safe tomorrow." -Richard Nixon - 1961
Those lost in Guantanamo after they were brought to the US
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Richard Nixon slates that the Cuban invasion take place as Originally planned OTL
2. Fidel Castro leading his troops during the invasion (as he did OTL)is killed by a stray mortar round
3. Fearing imminent invasion, Raul Castro attacks Guantanamo Bay.