Recent content by Colonel Grubb

  1. Would Asia/the world of the twentieth century have been better off if Japan lost the Russo-Japan War, was stalemated, or deterred from attacking?

    The other butterfly is that the defeat of Japan in 1905 undermines the British options in the Far East and for dealing with the threat of a possibly revitalised Russia and it’s ambitions in Central Asia and the Middle East. Britain faces the reality of backing and rebuilding its ally to...
  2. Would Asia/the world of the twentieth century have been better off if Japan lost the Russo-Japan War, was stalemated, or deterred from attacking?

    From the early 1930s onwards, I’d agree with you. However there are any combination of events that could have enabled the continuation of democracy in Japan at the time. There are a few that whilst individually may not stop the drift towards authoritarianism, they represent significant social...
  3. Would Asia/the world of the twentieth century have been better off if Japan lost the Russo-Japan War, was stalemated, or deterred from attacking?

    Disagree strongly here. Victory in the Russo-Japanese war does not ordain Japan down some inevitable authoritarian warmongering imperialist path over the course of the next 30 years. Throughout the 1910s and 20s there were many factors that contributed to the eventual failing of democracy and...
  4. How would a League of Nations/UN founded before WW1 look like? What changes could it bring?

    I recall reading years ago a timeline where there was a gradual creation and set up of a permanent international council in Geneva in the aftermath of the Eight Nation alliance in the boxer rebellion that cemented the international Edwardian era status quo.
  5. 1920s Germany if they win ww1 what do you think would have been done with the imperial navy if they didn't scuttle their ships.

    Depends if they want to acknowledge British naval dominance, happy to be dominant on the continent, try and match it, or try and beat it. Britain will spam out the remaining 15 inch armed ships, then move to 16.5 and 18 inch options already in the works. Anything prewar or even early war is...
  6. USA doesn't join WW1 but Germany still loses?

    In addition to adding the Indian Army manpower and equipment (and experience), there was also the potential for using greater manpower from the British African colonies, and for the increasing use of mechanisation on the Western Front. I’ve posted this before, but is relevant here:
  7. Steve Irwin survives stingray attack

    I believe his media career would continue to expand - and he was already being well received and established in the US across several different markets. I believe his children would still follow that trajectory and work closely with him on his show/s and content. However what is more...
  8. East Germany’s “Afrika Korps” during the cold war

    Der Spiegel back in March 1980 already made the claim…
  9. How realistic of an option was France joining the commonwealth?

    Well if the Commonwealth offer is accepted, presumably this marks a shift in the trend of European development and cooperation between London and Paris, rather than Paris and Bonn.
  10. Balanced budget

    Government expenditure as a proportion of GDP over the last 20 years. Figure 2: total expenditure and the size of the economic response to COVID-19 Source - remarkably consistent across multiple governments...
  11. WI: The effects of the UK's defense spending slashed down to 3% by 1950?

    Yep. Getting an established and developing civil society, with improving literacy and an emerging middle class that can support democratic institutions along with the foundations of uncorrupt local government and business/commerce is critical to bedding democracy down and it becoming engrained...
  12. WI: The effects of the UK's defense spending slashed down to 3% by 1950?

    That's a policy that's not going to fly. Britain is still a global power, even if being challenged in many areas, and needs to compete, and nuclear weapons and technology (inc. the civilian side) are how you remain relevant post war. Not even worth it as a trip-wire force then. Or efforts are...
  13. Alternative to Singapore Strategy?

    You don’t need a fleet train in the American sense when you have secure bases/ports/anchorages all around the world to operate from... If you base anything out of Adelaide you may as well just build the bloody ships on the Murrumbidgee to keep them safe...🤪
  14. Alternative to Singapore Strategy?

    This is what happens when 'fleet base Darwin' (or Sydney/Freemantle/Rabaul/Trincomalee) is raised. It potentially protects fleet assets but means the effectiveness to respond is dramatically reduced. Who in 1921 or even 1931 would have reasonably seen the Japanese launching their attacks from...
  15. No Daylight Saving Time

    Yeah but at least the cows are getting milked at the right time
Top