Krall
Banned
Sorry this thread is up so late - I usually read the descriptions of every entry before posting the voting thread, and tried to do the same thing with the timelines for this round (I got through most of them, but the length of "Boers and Griquas and Prisoners. Oh My!" made me reconsider my dedication).
Anyway, as the entries for this round consist of both timelines and map entries, I must ask you to consider both the timelines themselves and the maps when deciding whose entry was best - though your vote will not be disqualified if you decide to judge them based just on the maps or just on the timelines.
Here's a list of all the timelines written and entered for this round:
Nok Steel, by Jonathan Edelstein and Kaiphranos
Big Apple Crossrail: A Gap To Mind, by Dr. Nodelescu
The Purple Reigns Supreme, by B_Munro and Baconheimer
Look On My Works, by islander
The Lion's Roar, by Soverihn and Krall
The Crown of the Baltic, by Makemakean and Ares96
Boers and Griquas and Prisoners. Oh My!, by Reagent and Alex Richards
Even though this round had to be extended, and most entries were submitted very close to the deadline, I still think this was a very successful round! 7 entries is pretty good normally, but it's amazing when you consider that everyone had to make full timelines in addition to their maps. Every single entrant put in an admirable amount of effort into their writing, research, and cartography, and I'd like to thank all of you for making this rather experimental round a success! Thank you all!
Entries thread:
https://www.alternatehistory.com/discussion/showthread.php?t=319327
Main thread:
https://www.alternatehistory.com/discussion/showthread.php?t=170373
Edit: I just noticed I spelt "Jonathan" wrong in the poll - sorry about that.
Edit: Oh, and please note that you're not permitted to edit or add to your timelines during the voting period for this contest. Replies, questions and answers in the thread are all fine, but adding parts to the timeline itself or adding additional material like maps or other illustrations is not allowed.
Anyway, as the entries for this round consist of both timelines and map entries, I must ask you to consider both the timelines themselves and the maps when deciding whose entry was best - though your vote will not be disqualified if you decide to judge them based just on the maps or just on the timelines.
Here's a list of all the timelines written and entered for this round:
Nok Steel, by Jonathan Edelstein and Kaiphranos
Big Apple Crossrail: A Gap To Mind, by Dr. Nodelescu
The Purple Reigns Supreme, by B_Munro and Baconheimer
Look On My Works, by islander
The Lion's Roar, by Soverihn and Krall
The Crown of the Baltic, by Makemakean and Ares96
Boers and Griquas and Prisoners. Oh My!, by Reagent and Alex Richards
Even though this round had to be extended, and most entries were submitted very close to the deadline, I still think this was a very successful round! 7 entries is pretty good normally, but it's amazing when you consider that everyone had to make full timelines in addition to their maps. Every single entrant put in an admirable amount of effort into their writing, research, and cartography, and I'd like to thank all of you for making this rather experimental round a success! Thank you all!
Entries thread:
https://www.alternatehistory.com/discussion/showthread.php?t=319327
Main thread:
https://www.alternatehistory.com/discussion/showthread.php?t=170373
Edit: I just noticed I spelt "Jonathan" wrong in the poll - sorry about that.
Edit: Oh, and please note that you're not permitted to edit or add to your timelines during the voting period for this contest. Replies, questions and answers in the thread are all fine, but adding parts to the timeline itself or adding additional material like maps or other illustrations is not allowed.
Last edited: