The Best Laid Plans
Genoese regulars and militia. On the left, Corsican filogenovesi militia with their peaked caps and a Greek militiaman with his traditional vest and fustanella. In the center, Genoese garrison militiamen. On the right, Oltremontani soldiers and officers.
In such circumstances we must aim at utilizing the greater strength of the troops in guarding the heart of the Kingdom, from where all evil descends, in order to cause fear among the neighboring peoples and support parties sympathetic to the Republic; otherwise the greater will be their united forces, and they will feel themselves at liberty to be insolent.
- Domenico Maria Spinola to the Senate of Genoa, September 1741
The Genoese had been surprised by the abruptness of the Austrian evacuation, but they were not entirely unprepared. Since the first suggestions of withdrawal by the French in the autumn of 1740, the Deputation of Corsica - the special executive body of the Genoese government formed in 1731 to direct the republic’s strategy against the rebellion - and Commissioner-General
Domenico Maria Spinola had been busily debating and planning a course of action for the day when Corsica was finally returned to the sovereignty of the republic.
By the summer of 1741, the Genoese regular army stood at about 5,770 soldiers. On the surface this was not much different from the approximately five thousand men fielded by the regular army prior to the rebellion, but the long war had forced major structural changes to the army. Corsica, once a prime recruiting ground for the Genoese army, had been rendered almost useless for that purpose as a consequence of the uprising. Furthermore, the war had made it starkly clear that the army was organizationally obsolete; the practice of every company being an independent outfit, which had been scrapped on the continent generations ago in favor of a system of battalions and regiments, still endured in Genoa. Only in 1738 was a major reform pushed through the senate to reorganize the army on the basis of national battalions.
By 1740 there were ten such battalions, organized by the nationality of their troops: Six Italian, two Corsican, one German (or “Oltremontani”), and one Grison (“Grigioni”). Owing to the terms of pre-existing “capitulations,” or mercenary contracts, not all units were affected by the reforms. The Grison battalion was an amalgamation of the four Grison companies hired some years back and was really a “battalion” in name only. There were also three “elite” companies that retained their independence for the same reason - the German Palace Guard, the San Tommaso German company (named for one of the gates of the city), and the Fribourg Swiss company. None of these independent companies saw service in Corsica. Italian and Corsican battalions had a paper strength of 500 men and officers, composed of four companies of 108 fusiliers and a detached grenadier company of 60 men. The German and Grison battalions had their own structure, with around 600 and 800 men respectively.
By an ordinance of 1738, five of these ten battalions were to be permanently stationed in Corsica. As the Corsican battalions were considered ineligible for this service, the duty fell to the Italian battalions of colonels
Pietro Paolo Crettler,
Patrizio Geraldini, and
Gio Tommaso Varenne, the German battalion of
Federico Andergossen, and the Grison battalion of
Rodolfo Antonio Jost.
[1][A] In August of 1741, as a response to the sudden withdrawal of more than half of the Austrian contingent, half of the battalion of Colonel
Luca Ottavio Restori was also sent to Corsica. In total, the Genoese regular forces on the island by the time of the final withdrawal of French and Austrian forces in September amounted to at least 3,000 men, just under half of whom were foreigners.
For the Republic, this was a considerable force representing a majority of the entire regular army. Yet the French had deployed nearly 10,000 men to Corsica, and even then required several years to pacify the country. Proposals to move more Genoese regulars to Corsica were strongly opposed by the republic’s military and civilian leaders, who warned that the Ligurian fortresses and the garrison of Genoa itself were dangerously undermanned already. The republic was always worried about the aggressive ambitions of its neighbor Sardinia, and the need for adequate forces in Liguria became even greater after the landing of Spanish forces in Italy in November of 1741, as it became clear that the “Silesian War” was to be continental scope and might draw Genoa in as well.
Spinola, seeking to do the best he could with limited resources, proposed to selectively occupy the island based on economic and strategic value. The great coastal bastions - Bastia, Calvi, Ajaccio, and Bonifacio - would of course have to be garrisoned. The rich provinces of the Balagna and the Nebbio were crucial, but were also considered less restive than the interior and could get away with fewer regular troops. In the interior, Genoese troops would be concentrated almost entirely in the Castagniccia and the Golo valley. This portion of the interior
Diqua was the most populous, the most economically valuable, and potentially the most troublesome, being the heart of the original rebellion. Accordingly, of the four “provinces” of Corsica, Bastia (whose province included the Castagniccia) would have the largest complement of soldiers, while the other provinces would simply have to make do with less. The cuts were particularly deep in the
Dila, which had fewer people and less economic value than the north, and was also more geographically difficult to control with a few centrally located garrisons. The commissioner of Ajaccio,
Bernardo Soprani, protested bitterly, and sent a long letter to Spinola and the Deputation detailing how the skeleton garrison he had been assigned would be wholly unable to control the province and to maintain overland routes of communication and supply into the north. He was not wrong, but the math was merciless - the soldiers were too few, the money was too tight, and the relative importance of the north was too great.
By the time of the final withdrawal, the situation on the ground was roughly as follows:
Bastia: Andergossen, Crettler, Jost (2 coys), Restori (2 coys) = 1,750 men
Calvi: Geraldini = 500 men
Ajaccio: Varenne (3 coys and grenadiers), Jost (1 coy) = 600 men
Bonifacio: Varenne (1 coy), Jost (1 coy) = 300 men
The paucity of soldiers in the south was sobering. 320 regulars were allotted to the garrison of Ajaccio itself, leaving only around 280 for the rest of the western
Dila. Bonifacio was held by 160 regulars, with another 60 in Sartena (the only garrisoned post in the inland
Dila), 60 spread amongst four coastal towers in the region, and a mere 20 soldiers to hold Porto Vecchio.
Further complicating matters was the propensity of Genoese soldiers, even regulars, to desert. Conditions for Genoese soldiers on Corsica were poor; a French officer reported that one such garrison was lacking nearly everything, with worn shoes, uniforms in an “ungodly” condition, and poorly-maintained muskets with worn-down flints and missing bayonets. Crettler’s battalion was described in late 1741 as “nearly naked” thanks to the corruption of government contractors, who had outfitted the unit with uniforms of thin and inferior fabric that were tattered and threadbare in less than a year. For soldiers stationed in the interior, the rugged terrain made desertion especially easy. (Coastal posts suffered less from this problem, but were haunted by malaria instead.) Desertion was made much worse, however, by the French. French recruiters not only turned a blind eye to the enlistment of Genoese deserters but actively solicited them to desert, offering recruitment bonuses and promising better conditions. Brigadier Villemur, who took command of the French forces after Marshal Lautrec’s departure, was under instructions to fill out the new
Regiment Royal-Corse, and neither he nor his superiors cared very much if a substantial number of the “Corsicans” in the battalion were actually Genoese, German, or Grison deserters. Although precise numbers of Genoese losses to desertion are unknown, the complaint of Colonel Jost is typical, who informed Spinola in early September that over the past two months the garrison of Morosaglia had lost 20% of its strength to desertion alone.
Spinola’s forces were not limited to regular units. Other quasi-regular units assisted in garrison duties, notably the Greek company of Ajaccio, small companies of Genoese citizen-militia at Calvi and Bonifacio, and the “dragoons of Bastia,” actually a few dozen mounted militiamen who served as a gendarmerie. The irregular
filogenovesi companies that the republic had once depended on, however, had been almost entirely disbanded during the French occupation for reasons of economy. In January of 1741 there were only 82 Corsican militiamen on the state’s payroll, most of whom were part of the anti-guerrilla “flying squadron” of Major
Domenico de Franceschi,
[2] which had been chasing
Johann Friedrich von Neuhoff zu Rauchenburg and other “bandits” for much of the year.
The question of whether more should be raised was a bitterly contentious one.
Filogenovesi militiamen were readily available and cheaper to maintain than regulars, but they were also ill-disciplined and of questionable military value. The Genoese had found that the republic’s “partisans” on Corsica were always more willing to accept payment than to actually fight; keeping a militia company on the government’s payroll was (usually) a good way to ensure the loyalty of the company’s hometown, but it seldom actually resulted in the creation of dependable forces that the government could use in military operations. Additionally, understanding the difficulty of his military position and thus the necessity of preventing rebellion in the first place, Spinola feared with good reason that armed republican irregulars would be motivated by vengeance and petty feuds to harass former “royalists” and thus stir up rebellious sentiment.
With this rather bleak military situation, it should come as no surprise that the matter which the Deputation and Spinola considered most critical for maintaining control on the island, more important than any military strategy or infantry battalion, was
Il Regolamento - “the Regulation,” meaning the body of law by which the Corsicans would be ruled. The government of Genoa had promulgated two previous Regulations, in 1733 and in 1738, each of which had obviously failed to gain the support of the Corsican people. Clearly the new Regulation would have to go further in terms of the reforms it offered if it had any hope of keeping the peace. How much reform was needed to achieve that end, however, was a subject of much debate.
Unlike the French, the Genoese could not afford to simply turn the island in to a tax-free zone and send the bill for their occupying forces to someone else. A report by the Deputation in the spring of 1741 concluded that the cost of the rebellion to the Genoese state since 1730 was a staggering 20 million lire, which at present troop levels would increase by at least 800,000 lire every year.
[3] To the government, which was already carrying a heavy debt burden, this was plainly unsustainable. The Senate accepted that much of this cost was “extraordinary” and an unavoidable burden upon the public debt, at least until Corsica was safe enough to allow the reduction of the occupation forces to pre-rebellion levels (assumed to be around 500 regular soldiers). They insisted, however, that the new Regulation provide enough revenue to pay for the “ordinary” upkeep of the island, which is to say that the island ought to cover the costs of its own administrative, judicial, and military apparatus. From a Genoese perspective, this was eminently sensible - it was natural that a state should pay for its own government.
In August of 1741, a proposal was drawn up by the Deputation in consultation with other organs of the Genoese government. This was not so much a draft Regulation as a framework for further negotiations, both within the Genoese government and with the Corsicans themselves, and thus demonstrated how far the Deputation believed the state ought to be able to compromise to achieve its ends. The proposal was essentially a recognition that the government needed to be prepared to turn the clock back to the fateful year of 1715, when Genoa had passed laws to disarm the Corsicans and introduced the hated
due seini capitation to recoup the expected shortfall from the loss of revenue from sales of arms licenses. The Deputation endorsed the possibility of reducing the tax burden to pre-1715 levels and restoring the right of the Corsicans to bear arms, along with other proposed liberties and reforms. The next step was to see if such proposals would pass muster with the Corsicans themselves. To this end, the Deputation decided to reconvene the Council of Twelve, the advisory body of Corsican “nobles” which had been in
de facto abeyance since around 1730, when
Simone Fabiani - himself a member - had denounced the council and called for a boycott of the elections. New elections for this body were planned for March of 1742.
In the meantime, Spinola moved to execute his security plan. Two wrinkles yet remained, and they had names:
Gianpietro Gaffori and
Luca d’Ornano.
Aside, perhaps, from the Genoese themselves, nobody was less happy about the Austrian withdrawal than Marquis Luca d’Ornano, the self-appointed Regent of Corsica. The patronage of Grand Duke
Franz Stefan had made d’Ornano the most powerful Corsican on the island. With the Grand Duke’s political and financial support, he had been able to carve out and sustain an independent fiefdom in the south, retain a considerable arsenal while the rest of occupied Corsica was pressured to disarm, and attract a large armed following thanks to his position as a colonel in Tuscan service and the patronage he was able to dispense by way of his considerable stipend. The outbreak of war, however, had focused Franz Stefan’s attention elsewhere. Now that he was leading an army in Bohemia, the Grand Duke no longer had much time to spare for Corsican intrigues, and with the dire financial troubles of his wife
Maria Theresa, the Queen of Hungary, it no longer made much sense to be paying the salary of an absentee colonel in Corsica. D’Ornano had been pressured into allowing most of the “Regiment d’Ornano” to be transferred to Tuscany, as it was not diplomatically feasible for them to remain in Genoese territory indefinitely, and he had been led to believe that this force would be the nucleus of a Tuscan-Austrian takeover of Corsica to d’Ornano’s substantial benefit. As a result, however, he now found himself without his regiment and with his own salary in arrears. His power was certainly not broken; he retained considerable influence and his old network of clients, as well as a stash of arms, ammunition, and even artillery. He was still formally a Tuscan colonel, albeit an unpaid one, and claimed the regency of the Kingdom of Corsica. The King of Prussia, however, had ruined his plans to ride Franz Stefan’s coattails to glory.
Marquis Gianpietro Gaffori’s position was much weaker, but his real estate was far more valuable. His collaboration with the French and Austrians had allowed him to remain in place at Corti, officially in a civilian capacity as the town’s
podesta, and the occupying forces had respected his demands to prohibit Genoese troops from occupying the town. Thus, while Spinola had been able to phase in his garrisons throughout the Castagniccia over the course of the French withdrawal, Corti was left solely in Gaffori’s hands when the Austrians abruptly evacuated in September. The Genoese, for good reason, considered Corti to be the lynchpin of the Corsican interior: it was not only the strongest fortress in inland Corsica, but its position near the confluence of the Golo and Tavignano valleys gave it an unparalleled strategic importance. Spinola’s plan called for a strong occupation force at Corti, arguing that without it the Castagniccia could not be made secure. Gaffori’s control of the town and its citadel, as well as what remained of the arsenal, appeared to give him a significant bargaining chip. His “forces,” however, were weak - as a civilian administrator he had retained no large armed following as d’Ornano had, and could count on no more than the militia of the town, whose citizens respected Gaffori but were not necessarily willing to forfeit peace and amnesty to protect the independence of the
podesta.
Spinola, eager to preserve peace, sought to co-opt these men. In early September, just weeks before the final withdrawal of French and Austrian forces, the commissioner-general had invited both of them to a consultation at Bastia. Both refused the summons, claiming that they had insufficient assurances of Genoese good will. While Spinola could wait for d’Ornano to come around, however, he needed Corti, and when he learned of the Austrian withdrawal from the town he felt he had no choice but to occupy it whether Gaffori trusted his “good will” or not. On the 23rd of September, four days after the Austrian withdrawal, Spinola ordered Colonel Andergossen to assemble 700 men and take command of Corti - peacefully if possible, and by force if not.
Spinola had good reasons to hurry. In mid-September, before the Austrians were even gone,
Matthias von Drost had returned from Livorno in a felucca and landed south of Fiumorbo with a handful of followers and 200 muskets. (The withdrawal of French forces from Corsica had also meant the withdrawal of the French naval squadron, and correspondingly the weakening of the blockade.) He quickly moved inland to Alta Rocca and Zicavo, preaching resistance, distributing arms and ammunition to royalist sympathizers, and bearing a letter he had received from Theodore promising his return and detailing (in a typically optimistic and exaggerated fashion) his imminent success in gaining the support of Britain. Drost was followed not long thereafter by dozens of exiles, which in the
Dila included Lieutenant-General
Michele Durazzo and the
Lusinchi brothers. Despite their history, they were not necessarily eager to start a new rebellion; peace and amnesty had their attractions, and many were skeptical of Theodore’s promises from afar. There was no harm in being prepared, however, and the paucity of Genoese forces in the south meant that the mountain communities of the
Dila could gather arms, organize men, and stockpile supplies without fear of Genoese intervention. If indeed Gaffori was contemplating rebellion, Spinola had no desire to allow him reinforce his position at Corti in a similar manner.
Outer fortress walls of Corti, looking north
Aware of the weakness of his position, Gaffori responded receptively to Spinola’s subsequent appeals. He stated that he was prepared to hand over Corti without a fuss so long as he and the other citizens were not harassed or subject to seizures or confiscations for the benefit of the garrison. When Andergossen approached the town on the 29th - he had been slightly delayed by the need to gather some forces from Calvi province - Gaffori rode out to meet him personally along with his wife
Faustina Matra and one of his lieutenants, Captain
Giannettini. In a letter to Spinola, Andergossen described Gaffori as “gracious” and the people of Corti as having a “good disposition.” Andergossen even offered Gaffori a job, as his garrison had no surgeon and Gaffori was a Genoese-educated physician.
Andergossen was not worried about any internal unrest; he feared external attack. Finding the state of the town’s defenses to be lamentable, he conferred with his engineer, Captain
Medoni, and with him developed a plan to create a secure perimeter enclosing the citadel with new, stronger works of stone and brick. Spinola, however, had no money for such constructions, and Gaffori objected to any use of civilians as forced labor, citing Spinola’s promises to not put the populace at the whims of the garrison. Andergossen was forced to abandon this plan, and suggested instead that the fortifications be made with earthworks and fascine. Medoni, however, found that the ground was too rocky to accomplish this.
Although the ex-rebels being armed and agitated by Drost and the exiles in the
Dila were concerning, Andergossen’s more immediate concern was with the Niolesi. The Niolo had been one of the first districts evacuated by the French, and since it was a thinly-populated region of little economic value Spinola had excluded it from his plans of occupation. The chief beneficiary of this withdrawal was Lieutenant-General Rauschenburg. He had waged a gruelling guerrilla campaign for months, sometimes with fewer than twenty men at his side, but now it seemed that he had finally outlasted his enemies. Following the French withdrawal from the Niolo, Rauschenburg retired to the mountains with the remainder of his grizzled veterans, where he was welcomed by many Niolesi as a hero. Not all were happy to see him - French rule in the Niolo had been relatively harsh because of its status as the last district in the north to defy them, and there were fears that a warm welcome given to the unrepentant rebel general would invite Genoese retaliation. Although informed of Rauschenburg’s presence, Spinola lacked the men to root him out, and sending Franceschi’s irregular squadron into the heart of the Niolo seemed unlikely to end well.
Throughout October there were whispers of conspiracies and rebellion everywhere. Genoese officers spoke of rebel forces amassing in the mountains, of gunsmiths in Orezza producing stockpiles of arms, and of muskets and powder flowing into Livorno waiting to be transported to the island. A Genoese captain reported to Spinola that he had heard rumors that Gaffori, really a crypto-revolutionary, had at least 1,200 partisans in the mountains waiting to descend on the garrison of Corti. Another report alleged that a priest in the Balagna,
Giovanni Battista Croce di Lavatoggio, was telling his parishioners in his sermons that if the Bourbons won the ongoing war on the continent, Corsica would be given to Don
Felipe, the Spanish
infante. Spinola could not meet these rumored threats with either men or money, for he had none to spare, so he did the next best thing and sent muskets and ammunition to the commanders of the Castagniccian garrisons, telling them to arm the
filogenovesi if matters got out of hand.
Footnotes
[1] It is notable that not one of these colonels was Genoese, nor even Italian. While the Genoese battalions were “national” in the ranks, officers could be from anywhere, and the Genoese had difficulty finding capable officers from their own country. Naturally, Andergossen was German and Jost was Grison, as befitted their battalions. Of the colonels of Italian battalions on Corsica, however, Crettler was Swiss and the other two were Irishmen: “Patrizio Geraldini” was Patrick Fitzgerald and “Gio Tomasso Varenne” was John Thomas Warren. Only with the arrival of another battalion under Colonel Restori in late 1741 was this all-foreign lineup disrupted.
[2] De Franceschi is chiefly notable for having commanded the infamous "Company of Bandits," formed of criminals and bandits from Liguria, who were unleashed upon the Nebbio in the early years of Theodore's reign. He was reviled by many of the Corsicans but seemed to have had a knack for leading irregular forces.
[3] Given the enormous costs of the rebellion and its apparent insolubility from a political and military standpoint, the reader would not be unreasonable to wonder why Genoa persisted in trying to keep Corsica. Although allowing Corsican independence had never been considered by the Senate, the idea of selling the island to another power had been floated a few times since about 1732, only to be firmly rejected every time. Some have ascribed the government’s stubbornness to a vain refusal to abandon Genoa’s delusion of imperial grandeur, Corsica being the last remnant of a Genoese medieval thalassocracy that once stretched as far as the Crimea. There is a kernel of truth in this, but the dominant reason was more strategic than nostalgic. Although the Genoese were by the 18th century more famous for banking than trade, maritime commerce still dominated the economy of the city. That commerce depended on a friendly Corsica, as the island was ideally positioned to control maritime shipping coming to and from the port of Genoa. “Who is master of Corsica is master of Genoa,” wrote a Spanish ambassador in the 16th century, and the Genoese had never ceased to agree. Even if an “ally” of Genoa took possession of the island, such as Spain, the Genoese feared the republic would be reduced to little more than a puppet, captive to the whims of Corsica’s master.
Timeline Notes
[A] For some reason Andergossen is the only colonel whose given name I cannot find. I've decided to call him Frederick. That's a good name for a German, right?