1921
Manhattan
For weeks, the Fusionist Party would caucus behind closed door, fighting among themselves prior to the "official" votes in Parliament itself. For years, the Fusionists had fought to achieve power but the assorted factions had not yet truly managed to agree on anything more than the rather general platform with which they won the election.
Radicals and arch-Unionists favored Eugene Debs.
Woodrow Wilson was considered the most experienced in governance. Among his greatest supporters was William McAdoo, his son in law and a Parliamentarian from Georgia. Wilson was much more of a cold intellectual and rarely gained the favor of the public as Debs or Smith could do. His faction was more "conservative" than the others.
Al Smith would carry dominate New York and Long Islands' Fusionist parties, vital for election, as well as carry the Catholic vote of the northeastern and middle Atlantic Dominions (Pennsylvania and Maryland, in particular). He also was a favorite of black and women voters in the party.
When the new Parliament was seated in April, the Fusionist Party was still not reconciled among themselves. Despite a thirty vote advantage, the lack of a unified direction could, in theory at least, result in a a Unity Party candidate winning the Parliamentary votes.
Making things more complex were the structural changes ongoing throughout the nation. Two issues in particular vexed both parties.
Women had been granted the vote in eleven dominions including New York, Pennsylvania and Chicago. At least a dozen more were expected to vote upon expanding the franchise in the next year or two. Though it was expected that women would just vote according to the wishes of their husband or father though this was already proving to be untrue.
Also, there was a strong temperance movement in the central Dominions and rural areas. Smith led the more Urban faction of the Fusionist Party who opposed the idea of prohibiting alcohol while McAdoo (though not necessarily his father-in-law Wilson) received much support from the Prohibitionists. It was conceivable that one of these factions may choose to support a Unity candidate if they did not get their way.
After the first initial votes went through Parliament, Coolidge naturally led as the Unity Party was united behind him. Debs, Smith and Wilson suddenly saw their "victory" being threatened. In the end, they managed to adjourn for a long weekend and met with the party brokers to seek a compromise. Knowing that party infighting may doom them, the three major leaders of the Fusionists agreed to a compromise:
James Cox would be "recommended" to the King as the new First Lord. A man everyone could get along with, Cox seemed the best bet to balance the factions and egos of his party.
Debs would be made Minister of the Interior and his ally William Lyon Mackenzie King of Mississauga would be given the vital Social Service Minister Position (King was tolerable to both Debs and Smith).
Wilson (who had an interest in foreign affairs) would be made Foreign Minister.
The Exchequer was another matter. Wilson wanted McAdoo for the position but both Debs and Smith utterly refused. Then Wilson recommended Franklin Roosevelt but, again, Roosevelt was hardly a favorite with Debs (who thought the New Yorkers was a rich snob) or Smith (who had feuded for years with Roosevelt).
In the end, Smith would be allowed to select a "capable" candidate if he was considered reasonable.
The decision would prove shocking as Smith chose Francis Perkins, one of only seven female Parliamentarians and one of his biggest supporters both as Governor of New York and later Parliament. Perkins had been elected to one of the Bronx seats in Parliament and Smith, mindful that the female vote may prove vital in 1925 should he seek the position himself, would press his friend to national prominence.
Thus, though the Unity Party had dreamed of "stealing" the next five years of the Executive, this was not to be and the Fusionist Party managed to vote James Cox as the new first Lord (again, nominally, as a "recommendation" though, by 1921, no one really believed that any King would reject such a recommendation).
James Cox
Woodrow Wilson
Eugene Debs
William Lyon Mackenzie King
Francis Perkins