communist germany

  1. Western Reaction to a Communist Germany and Britain

    Let's say that the great war drags on another year and Germany successfully turns communist while this happens in the UK, how do the US and France respond? Would France have a revolution themselves, or would the conservative government successfully suppress it and drift towards fascism. If...
  2. jhuro

    If Germany and Russia both go red, is Eastern Europe doomed to be partitioned?

    If by say 1921 there exists a communist Germany on one side and the Soviet Union on the other, is there any way for Czechoslovakia, Poland, and the Baltics* to survive as fortress nations? Or will they inevitably be partitioned/ turned into satellite communist regimes? *I’m including a remnant...
  3. jhuro

    Could the Entente realistically hold onto the Rhineland if Germany goes communist in 1919

    Let’s assume the German Revolution ends with a Sparticist Germany occurring concurrently with the Soviet Union. It would strategic sense for the Entente to seize the Rhineland as defensive buffer, but between domestic turmoil and economic woes could they actually hold it, or would they retreat...
  4. WI: UK and Germany went Communist

    What if Germany went Communist in 1919 (I have no idea what ideas to bring to the how so lets please focus on the aftermath if they got lucky) and Britain revolts in 1926? Could Communism spread anywhere else in the near term? What becomes of the UK's colonies? How does France respond to having...
  5. AltoRegnant

    DBAHC: Communist Russia, Fascist Germany

    OTL, one of the most pivotal events in the 20th Century was BorisBrasol 's victory in the Russian Civil War. The resultant White Scare that dominated Europe in the 20s sidelined the German right, especially the monarchists and the NDSP, especially after Russia backed the Beer Hall Push. All of...
  6. Bomster

    Communist/Radical Socialist Germany after WW1?

    During WW1, Germans underwent much hardship. Young men dying in the trenches, people going hungry because of the Entente blockade, and the eventual defeat. The German Empire was ended by pressure both foreign and domestic, and part of that domestic pressure was a flurry of socialist uprisings...
  7. Aloha

    AHC: Germany, Italy, and Japan all communist

    I know this might sound hard to achieve, but how can you get the three countries that would come to form the Axis Powers in OTL to become communist at a similar space of time before a potential WW2 (if it would exist in this scenario), while still having the USSR exist? Try not to go "ASB" or...
  8. jhuro

    When could a Red Germany build an atomic bomb?

    Let's say the 1919 German revolution succeeds, with the Entente too cash-strapped exhausted to stop both Germany and Russia from going communist. During the interwar period the Germans and Soviets intervene in Poland and Hungary, and by the late 30s another world war breaks out, with them...
  9. Willy

    Communist Germany 1918

    I know it may seem a bit out there, but I've seen more ridiculous propositions on the website. What if the communist revolutionaries in Germany after WW1 succeeded in a takeover of Germany? How would WW2 play out? Would it even happen? What about the cold war? For this example let's say Bavaria...
  10. AHC: Have the KPD seize power in Germany by 1933 instead of the NSDAP

    Okay, so our goal here is to have the German Communist power get into power in Germany instead of the Nazi party. The POD should ideally be in the late 1920s or even-earlier 1930s, but, for the sake of parallelism, they must seize power in 1933, though the day or even month need not be the same...
  11. AHC/WI: National Bolshevist Germany

    Okay, so this thread has two parts: the first part is a challenge - make Germany NazBol, although the specific type of NazBol may vary. National Bolshevism is commonly regarded as a bizarre, unholy love child of Communism and Fascism, and it sort of is, but there's a surprising amount of...
  12. Aloha

    Could Communist Germany have defeated Fascist Russia?

    Basically the hypothetical German victory over the USSR but with the ideologies reversed. Is it possible for a Communist Germany to defeat a Fascist Russia, assuming it doesn't join the Allies? Perhaps a larger communist expansion before the war? Or they form an alliance to get rid of their...
  13. Cmastashizzlerizzle

    AHC/WI: communist Germany and fascist Russia

    So ww2 is a war everybody knows and ww2 wouldn’t be the same with the ideologies we so closely associate with it so what if we reverse them? Getting Germany to be communist and Russia to be fascist (note: when I say fascist they don’t necessarily need to be fascist fascist just of a nazi like...
  14. Aloha

    German People's Republic vs Soviet Union

    Spartacist Rebellion succeeds and Germany becomes communist, and the Bolsheviks defeats the Whites like in OTL. What if they were both communist at around the same time, but.... fought? While the idea of a German-Russian alliance is one of my very favourite alternate history subjects, would an...
  15. Aloha

    DBAHC: Fascism widely considered a greater evil than Communism

    Both fascism and communism are unpopular ideologies, but the general consensus seems to be that communism is the greater of the two evils as of post-SGW. As we all know, The Second Great War was fought between the Allied Powers and the Comintern (comprising of the USSR, People's Republic of...
  16. Whiteshore

    AHC: Wilhelm II executed

    Your challenge, with a POD after August 1, 1914, is for Kaiser Wilhelm II to end up executed like how "Hanging the Kaiser" was a popular slogan in the Entente countries. It doesn't matter whether his execution is carried out by domestic revolutionaries (perhaps a more radical 1918 Revolution...
  17. Aloha

    DBAHC: Hitler doesn't go communist

    As we all know, Adolf Hitler became the Volksführer of the "German People's Republic" in 1935. A proud communist, his actions led to the "Second Great War" with Germany, USSR, Hungary and China fighting on one side and Japan, France, Italy, and the UK on the other/Allied side, ending in a...
  18. How to get Germany communist

    How could all of Germany have gone communist? And how would this red Germany look like? The more different the ways to do it are, the better. Any POD is allowed.
  19. ETGalaxy

    DBWI: Could the German Civil War be averted?

    I've seen a lot of threads that try to theorize about the Soviet Federation of Germany won the German Civil War (1930-1935) but could the Civil War be completely avoided? If so, what effects would this have? Would the German Republic still eventually restore the Kaiser regardless? I think it's a...
  20. Whiteshore

    Leadership of a Communist Germany

    In a scenario where the Spartakists successfully took power in 1918-19, creating a German People's Republic, who would be the leaders of such a Communist Germany be? Would there be a single dictator on top or would it be more of a "government by committee" dealie where the leader of such a...
Top