Rememberences of Map Contests Past

Thande, Musso dies (kinda weak map, but I liked the writeup. :D )

Who dies? Mussolini.

This plunges Italy into a civil war similar to that of Spain in OTL, with communists coming out of the woodwark and the remaining Fascist leadership unable to enforce the rule of law. The Spanish Civil War does also break out a year or two later, but is seen as a sideshow. Hitler uses the Italian conflict as another excuse to rearm, and the Western allies, fearful of Soviet puppets on their doorsteps, continue to see him as the lesser of two evils.

Czechoslovakia and Austria are anschluss'd 37-38 "to protect the German people from Bolshevist elements", as the Communists begin to gain the upper hand in the Italian Civil War with direct support from the Soviet Union. Finally in July 1939 the remaining Fascist leadership virtually invites the Germans in to take over. The Wehrmacht is sent in and the Luftwaffe bombs communist-dominated cities, eventually creating ATL Italian versions of Guernica. However, the new blitzkrieg tactics are of limited use in Italy's often rocky and defendable terrain, and communist guerillas help to bleed the Germans by the death of a thousand cuts.

Hitler blames all of this (with some justification) on the Soviets, and orders the German General Staff to draw up a plan for the invasion of Russia, Operation Barbarossa. At the same time, but not publicly (as at this point they still want the West on side), the Nazis plot the expansion of their racial purity laws into the east, and the idea of depopulating Russia and using it as lebensraum. Poland, Romania and Hungary are bullied into permitting the passage of German troops, but no attempts at an annexation of Poland are considered - the Nazis reason that this will be much easier to accomplish when there is no Soviet Union to worry about and Poland is surrounded, plus they cannot afford to fight a two-front war with the Western nations that have guaranteed Polish independence.

Meanwhile, the communist-leaning Republicans win the Spanish Civil War and Franco's Nationalists are exiled to Spain's colonies and the Balearics. They are propped up with small numbers of German troops, with the result that Germany effectively has bases in Spanish Morocco and Spanish Guinea.

German Intelligence fears that Stalin is already planning an attack of his own, but in October 1939 those forces go to Finland instead. The Finns put up a stiff resistance, aided by the Germans, British, French, and unofficially the Swedes. The Red Army bogs down in Finland and Stalin rages more about traitors and purges, but continues a slow, grinding advance.

In May 1940 the Germans launch Operation Barbarossa. The Wehrmacht is more cautious than OTL, due to the lack of experience with the Blitzkrieg, but the fact that the attack is launched earlier means that they manage to reach Moscow by December. The less well trained Red Army is largely encircled or destroyed, but occasional reports of heavy Soviet tanks, easily outmatching the German Panzer IIs and IIIs, circulate. The Germans take Moscow with heavy losses but find it a pyrrhic victory -as in 1812, the Russians use scorched-earth tactics to prevent Moscow being of any use to the enemy. The Germans' Army Group Centre suffers comparable losses to Napoleon's Grand Armée as they retreat to secured German positions, against Hitler's orders.

Stalin is killed in the battle of Moscow, sparking a succession dispute. Molotov attempts to seize power but is defeated by a junta of generals and marshals, fed up with Kremlin political interference, and their political head is none other than Leon Trotsky, having survived several attempted assassinations and returned from exile. The Soviets begin duplicating their industry east of the Urals (the move not being as complete as in OTL) and producing more of their T-34 and KV-1 heavy tanks. Unlike German hopes, the USSR does not disintegrate.

Meanwhile, reports of the Final Solution leaking out means that both France and Britain break diplomatic relations with Germany, and collaboration with the Nazis in Russia (particularly after Stalin's death) is practically nil, but Hitler is convinced by now that the war is practically won. He orders an invasion of France drawn up to reverse the losses of Versailles. Army High Command does so, though believing that the plan is for several years in the future.

At the same time, in 1942 thanks to the US and Europeans cutting off oil and steel supplies for the Chinese war effort, the Japanese attack British, French and American possessions in the Pacific and attempt to seize the Dutch East Indies. They manage to occupy large parts of the latter, Malaya and Indochina, but the British hold on to Singapore and the French to Kampuchea. The Japanese later stage an unsuccessful but destructive invasion of Burma. A mainly American force systematically destroys the IJN one battle at a time, illustrating America's industrial capacity, and Japan is conquered by 1946 (the USSR declaring war in 1945 and scooping up Manchuria, Korea and Hokkaido).

The Soviets slowly grind back the German war machine, assisted by the treasury of Italy, smuggled out of the country by the last few members of the communist government. Roosevelt is unable to convince the American people that Germany is a threat worth a preemptive attack, but the Jewish vote and other factors mean that the USSR is sold trucks and other nonmilitary units for low prices.

In 1943, after being pushed out of ruined Kursk and Stalingrad and their siege of Leningrad relieved by the Red Army pocketed in Finland at the start of the war, Hitler gives orders to gain some propaganda victories. Specifically he orders the total annexation of Poland and the Final Solution, so far carried out purely by fascist Polish proxies on a limited basis, to come to fruition. In response to this insane order, a secret group forms within the German army to...discuss a future without Hitler, led by Manstein, Guderian and Rommel. In response to the invasion of Poland and reports of the Final Solution, Britain and France declare war on Germany in November 1943. Based on analysis of the eastern war, France has abandoned its former defensive doctrine. In April 1944, French and BEF armies beat off a German attack - though one panzer force does make an embarrassing penetration through the 'impossible' Ardennes - and into the Saarland and Rhineland. The fresh RAF and ADA dominate the skies against the depleted and mostly deployed to the east Luftwaffe.

With the Soviets marching through Poland in 1945, the coup takes place. Hitler and other senior Nazis are assassinated and a military junta takes over under Manstein. A quick peace is reached with the West, the Nazi past is disowned (similar to Khruschev and Stalin in OTL) and, beating back the Soviet armies one last time, the Treaty of Warsaw surrenders all of eastern Europe and East Prussia to the Soviets. Bohemia-Moravia is "Finlandised" as we would say, while Finland becomes Soviet.

This map depicts the resulting cold war, with limited independence movements in the Far East, a Dominion of India with separate princely states, and a Trotskyite reformed "International Union of Socialist Republics" with a less centralised structure and no separate allied states, all one union. The German military regime has promised to restore Weimar democracy by 1960. There is a European Defence Pact, somewhat developed from the Anti-Comintern Pact, which includes Scandinavia due to the proximity of Soviet Finland.

mc-2-1-2png-png.27391


attachment.php
 
Last edited:
Highlander:

Here is my entry.

Hitler is killed early in 1935, much to the shock of his close allies and supporters. Nonetheless, they see this as a sign and decide to not make a large military confrontation if possible. Instead they chose to promote their agenda diplomatically and politicaly, taking small military action whenever necessary. A few years later, Mussolini's Italy descends into civil war, and he is disposed of. The powers in the region rush in to stake their claim but Germany wins over all, splitting the country up into four regions.

At this time we see that several German states are actively seeking independance and are likely to get it.

europe11zg1.jpg
 
EdT:

Here's mine... (Note: The original text is in Russian, but through the miracle of trans-dimensional technology it appears in English )

PoD: In the spring of 1935, FDR dies suddenly in his sleep of a massive stroke. John Nance Garner’s Presidency is a relative success and he successfully wins re-election the following year, although he is never as popular as his former boss. Little changes in Europe, and the war begins on schedule; the first major wartime divergence comes in 1940, when the Garner Administration’s efforts to ‘lend-lease’ equipment to Britain are emasculated by an impassioned speech by the leading Republican Candidate for the November elections, Senator William Borah.

The subsequent Republican victory delays US intervention in Europe for a time, and Borah’s subsequent death only months after inauguration makes him a martyr, impelling the isolationist Vice-President Thomas Dewey into power and rendering American entry almost impossible. War comes to America however; Japan’s surprise attack on Manila harbour draws the US into a Pacific struggle. With the fighting in the west occupying their minds, the US public becomes even less willing to aid Britain and the USSR against Nazi Germany.

In the end, the fighting peters out in the mid 1940’s. Japan is crushed by overwhelming force in 1945, as the US Marines bludgeon their way onto the Home Islands; for all the destruction in Asia however, Germany suffers worse. Pushed back in Africa and the Eastern Front, the Wehrmacht is eventually ground to a pulp by the combination of the massed bombing of the RAF and the manpower of the Red Army. Finally, in the Spring of 1947 Germany collapses amidst a hail of ‘Tube Alloys’; the Soviet flag cannot be raised above the Reichstag, because most of Berlin is a radioactive crater. An emergency British thrust across the Channel ensures that the Allied armies meet each other at the Rhine.

Soon Eastern Europe, the Balkans and much of Scandinavia are entrenched in the Soviet Sphere; in 1949, the brief Italian civil war forces the King to flee to Sicily and ensures that that country comes under the thumb of Moscow as well. By 1950, the Darlan regime in France is tottering and Soviet influence has almost reached its zenith; while the ‘Paris Spring’ in 1959 would bring Moscow’s unquestioned power on the continent to an end, for now the slogan on this propaganda poster is justified;


attachment.php


ussr-jpg.27405
 
Last edited:
TheLoneAmigo:

Yamamoto dies in 1935; without his influence, Japan ends up in a war with the United States much earlier - in 1938, before the tripartite pact. They do well enough; managing to keep the American military beast firmly focused on Asia for three years. Lend-Lease is greatly reduced, and America never gets involved in the war in Europe. Eventually, the Germans develop the first atomic weapons and devastate Britain and Russia with atomic fire in 1946. In 1950, they begin to tighten their grip on the African continent, fighting brush wars with American-funded partisans across the continet.

attachment.php


reichsafrika-jpg.27423
 
Last edited:
Diamond:

POD: Heinz Guderian dies in a training accident in 1935.

Without Guderian's bringing together of the various tactics then taking form, there is no strategy of Blitzkrieg. Germany's various annexations of Austria, the Sudetenland, etc, go more or less according to schedule, but there is no Phony War - Poland is not invaded in 1939. Instead, by some herculean efforts, Hitler's generals manage to convince him to wait and build up Germany's strength some more.

France finds itself increasingly isolated in Europe, as Britain has its hands full handling a full-scale uprising in Ireland (instigated, some say, by German agents). French communism grows in popularity, as many people see an alliance with the Soviet Union as the only way to off-set German might. In 1945, France finally goes Red, in a mostly bloodless coup.

War erupts the next year, and Germany once again finds herself fighting a two-front war against France and Russia. But this time, there is no Britain to help even the odds, and both Italy and Germany have had six more years than OTL to improve their militaries (equipment- and manpower-wise; strategically, things are little changed from the first Great War).

In this timeline, the Maginot Line does what it was intended to do - stop a German invasion cold. In the spring of 1950, three and half years into the Second Great War, the Western Front is a nightmare of mud, blood, and death. In the east, the Germans have swallowed huge chunks of Soviet territory, but their advance has stalled, and in places is being slowly rolled back.

Hitler is in ill health; rumors abound that he is on death's door, and various factions throughout the Reich prepare to seize the reins of power if and when the Fuhrer dies.

And in secret labs in the Reich, scientists led by Werner Heisenberg are perhaps a year away from completing work on a new type of bomb, one which will alter the course of world events forever...

mc1acopyrw4.png
 
Susano's

Charles de Gaulle dies in 1935.

Now personally, I do not think he himself plaid much of a role in WW2. The Resistance was not that important a factor. However, in this timeline the anti-German forces have no leader after 1940. Rear Admiral Emile Muselier fled with the ship Voisin to Great Britain, but he did not manage to inspire a large following. Furthermore, he fell out with Great Britain after the British sunk the Vichy France fleet. In reaction to that, the French freed Edouard Daladier and Paul Reynald, the two last Prime Ministers of the 4th Republic, but this was soon proven to be a bad move: They were rather unpopular, and also could not get along with each other, or with Muselier. As a result, there is not much „Free France“ in this timeline. Worse, the constant problems the British have with their French exile leaders inspire Hitler, who now works to win the French as an ally. True, they are not Germanic, but Romance is still better than Slavic, especially if they can fight the Bolshevist menace.

Hence the Fuhrer starts a policy of gradually restoring souvereignity to (Vichy) France. An exception to that is Brittany, which due to German pressure gains considerable autonomy in a divida et impera fashion, and Nord-Pas de Calais, which remains German occupied and administered. By 1943, France is a full axis member, and substiantially contributes troops to the Russian campaign, which also receievs more Italian, Hungarian and Romanian troops (and even some few Slovakian and Croatian troops) due to France's new political weight in the Axis. Barbarossa is thus hugely more popular, and Moscow, Stalingrad and Leningrad all fall during 1943. Stalin is killed, and the USSR falls into disarray. The Axis troops still meet resistance, of course, but it is uncoordinated and badly supplied. The Caucasus Republics are granted indepenance, and Georgia is made a kingdom under a German prince as an act of appeasment on Hitler's part towards the conservative-reactionary forces within Germany.

Of course this all does not effect the USA in the slightest, and also not the German declaration of war on America. And thus, 1944, while the Germans ever march on in Russia, the Americans, British, Canadians, Australians and New Zealanders land in France. It has been determined before that France is to be treated as a hostile nation, and not as a nation to liberate. Hence, Franco now sees his opportunity to seize a bit French land, and joins in with the Allies. Nontheless, resistance is heavy. The Axis has more support now, and does not need worry so much about the East. French and German troops mount heavy resistance to the Allies, leadng to devasting battles. Wishing to spare himsel, Prince Umberto Of Italy acts to stage a coup against Mussolini: On 9 June, his father Victor Immanuel II. abdicates, on 10 June he assumes the throne without much ceremony, and on 14 June, Mussolini is ousted and allied troops are called in. The coup happens much smoother as IOTL – there is no confusion in the Italian Armed Forces, which largely support their new king, as he has made sure of before. As IOTL, though, German special forces free Mussolini, and establish a republic under his leadership in North Italy. At the same time, the Allies use Italy (and even more importantly, Albania) as a base of operations to support Tito in Yugoslavia, and to stage the liberation of Greece.

Hitler sees this as a call to clean house, also administratively. Alsace-Lorraine, Luxembourg, North Schleswig, Flemish Belgium, the Netherlands, the General Governate and some conquests in the East are officially annexed, and the „Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia“ fully integrated into the Reich. Wallonia is created as a vasall state - much smaller than IOTL Wallonia, as of course Hitoer has quite extended the borders of Flemish Belgium, but it gains Nord-Pas de Calais as compensation. Forced resettlements start.

1945 the USA uses nuclear bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. However, at that time Germany already has the bomb, too, due to scientifical cooperation between Germany, France and Italy. Germany shows that to the world by using it at Kirov. The world thus dances near the abyss of nuclear destruction. In October, USA and UK threaten to nuke Germany should its armies cross a line consisting of the rivers Volga, Kerzhenets, Sukhona and Severnaya Dvina. Naturally, Hitler does not pay much heed to that, and consequently, the Allies and Germany exchange three nukes each. The latest Allied bomb hits Nuremberg at a time of a NSDAP rally. Conspirators in the Wehrmacht use that: While naturally not every NSDAP grandee has been killed at Nuremberg, the conspirators proclaim just that, and kill those who have not themselves. Within two months, Germany and its occupied territories are under control of the „Kommitee für Öffentliche Sicherheit“ (Committee for Public Safety/Security) of the Wehrmacht. Already during the Putsch, the conspirators agreed on an armistice with the Allies, who in turn agreed to that out of fear of an all-out nuclear war. This is the First Armistice of Stockholm, 14. November 1945.

The KÖS begins reordering Germany, stopping the Final Solution and other atrocities (but keeping the camps out of fear their secret could leak out). It keeps all trappings and symbols of the Nazi state, but de facto de-nazifies the country. Not towards democracy, of course, but the Party itself and the SS basically lose all power, while the regular administration is strengthened, and the worst and/or most high-ranking party members are purged in a Stalinesque maneer. Of course, the Waffen-SS units in the field are a kind of problem, and indeed they begin to de facto build up an own state on the Crimea. KÖS and SS eventually come to an agreement, in which the former recognises „Neugotenland“ as an independant state, and the latter promises to not cause the KÖS any trouble. The remaining occupied lands in the east are annexed as special administrative parts – mostly the Reichskommisariate continue to exist, but there is also an autonomous state created for the Cossacks and Kalmyks, and the Baltic Lands are returned to a rule of the local German nobility in a „Generalkomturei“ (a name reminiscent of the Teutonic Order).

Furthermore, the German Sphere of Influence is reordered. An agreement is made with France, in which it gains some NW Italian territories still occupied by Germany, and Sardinia (with which the Allies simply had not bothered). Croatia had managed to become more and more souvereign itself as Italiana nd German troops where more and more needed elsewhere, a process the KÖS now finishes, so that Croatia can fight against Tito. Thus Croatia turns from a vasall to a full ally. The occupied Thracia is awarded to Bulgaria (except the border strip Greece won from turkey in WW1, which together with some East Aegean Islands is gifted to Turkey), which also secures some Greek border territories. In rteurn, bulgaria now actively fights the allied advance in Greece. Hungary finally is given the German occupied Serbian Banat. Quisling in Norway is toppled, and a new vasal state is established there, the „People's State“ of Norway. This is a direct counter of the allied landing in South Norway, where the monarchy has been restored. On allied side, borders change, too, as Spain gets Rouissilion (and the French Head of State's position as Co-Prince of Andorra goes to the Spanish Head of State), and Greece Epirus from Albania.

Finally, on 6th January 1946, the Second Armistice of Stockholm is signed, pacifiyng all of Europe (except the Soviet-German front and the Yugoslavian partisans) for the moment. The Secodn Armistice is built on the first, includes allies on both sides, and also regulates complicated topics like limited transfer of PoWs, rules for future engagments, etc. The military leadership of Germany gets to present itself as something new and more honest than their precedessors. This (coupled, of course, with thge still present German threat) works, and the Western Allies put pressure on the Soviets to also make an armistice with the Germans. As the new FCSR is completly dependant upon them, they finally, agree, and the Third Armistice of Stockholm of the 27th April 1946 sets the German-Soviet front/border at the Four Rivers Line. The FCSR is the consolidated soviet state, much less centralist than its precedessor. Basically, it is kind of like the communits having said: „Okay, we got a bad start, let's try this again from the beginning“, and the result is the FCSR.

In the meanwhile, the Allies order France into occupation zones. Except for Brittany: If it now was to be re-integrated into France, Brittany surely would ebcome a bastion of pro-German sentiment. Also, France is to be treated as defeated nation anyways, so 25th February 1946, the Republic of Brittany is declared. Furthermore, as it seems clear Denmark will not be freed any time soon, Iceland, greenland, the Faroers and (originally Norwegian) Jan Mayen are taken together into an exile-Danish federation, the Danish Federal Free State. The 4 starts of its flags do not stand for thsoe 4 territories, by the way, but for the four peoples of the federation – Danish, Icelanders, Faroese and Greenlanders (Inuit).

Now that there is peace all across Europe, negotiations start for peace, or at least an even more encompassing armistice. During this negotiations, a coup supported by Germany and Turkey happen in Iraq, which seriously threatens the peace even in Europe. In the end, a compromise is found. Great britain allows Iraq to shift to the Axis side, mainly because the coup was swift and very sucessful, ousting the British occupation troops in a broad sweep, but it loses much land to Syria (by now a British mandate. Also, in Algeria, José Aboulker is very sucessful with his liberation movements, fighting against both the Allies and Vichy French forces. But eventually, 23rd August the Third Stockholm Armistice is made. The Axis, clearly weaker, make some territorial cocnessions. The German occupied territories in NW France and NW Italy are given up, Allied occupied France nwo directly borders Wallonia, and the Kingdom of Italy now directly borders the French Republic (by now officially the Fourth Republic with a new, semi-democratic constitution and seat of government in Lyons). Also, to calm british worries about a German rpesence at the Channel, a „Neutral Free State of Calais“ is created, including Cambrai as an exclave (frontline went right through it, and both sides wanted to maintain its old city). And furthermore, Tito's „Socialist Fedreation of Yugoslavia and Albania“ is recognised by all sides, a thorn in the Axis's side, geographically. In return, ethnic Germans are transported back from Siberia and given into the hands of the Reich, which settles them at the Volga March. Aboulker's „Republic of African France“ is recogniced by all sides, too.

While peace is progressing in Europe, in the Middle East there is war. Turkey, Iraq and Azerbaijan have allied in the Trabzon Pact, and on 14th August invaded Armenia and Persia. Armenia is quickly overran, while Persia receives substantial US/UK-help. Further complicating the situation is a media awareness campaign by private groups and persons in the USA and UK about the KZs and the Final Solution. Anti-German rage reaches a new height, but the reality of the nculear threat remains, so war is not renewed. In the meanwhile, all sides massively stock up nukes. So far, the USA, the UK, Germany and France are nuclear powers, while the FCSR, a newly created Spanish-Italian pact, Canada and ANZAC together and even also the SFYA have nuclear programm. This nuclear tension helps progress peace, though. The Trabzon War soon threatens to spill over to Europe again, and British-American plans to create an „Israel“ and a pro-Axis coup in Egypt do not quite help, either. Negotiations for a new trety soon begin again. The Fifth Stockholm Armistice is signed 5th February 1947. It includes the Middle East, resettlement plans for the remaining Jews and Gypsies in Germany and its sphere of influence, and it sets guidelines for negotiations for a final peace treaty. Though initially neutral Calais was planned to be a location for just that, it is too near to the other side for everybody, and so everybody stays in Stockholm.

Of course, those negotiations are not without problems, either. On the allied side, the Italians and Spanish join their zones to the Bizone. On 10th May Franco declares the Kingdom of Spain – a „Kingdom“ with vacant throne similar to Horthy's Hungary, with him as regent. On 12th May, the Bishop of Urgel abdicates as Co-Prince of Andorra, leaving Franco as remaining Prince of Andorra, a position he transfers to the non-existant king, too. And on 16th May, the Bizone is declared to be the Kingdom of France in „personal union“ with Spain – an affront to the French Republic. Furthermore on Axis side, the State of Israel is created 30th May 1947, toegther with the Free City of Jerusalem on the same date. On Axis side, the Germans launch the Romanian Expedition in June, after they have discovered that the Romanians and the Allied had secretly conspired to have Romania switch sides. Romania is dissolved: Hungary regains even more of Transylvania, Bulgaria even more of Dobrudja, and the rest is split in Wallachia and Moldavia.The expedition is swift and hugely sucessful. Despite this setbacks for peace, negotiations continue. As there de facto is already peace, most aspects are about honour/prestige and how to keep peace.

In the end, Calais does get its role in the peace process, as some protocols are signed there. The Peace of Stockholm and Calais of the 25th September 1947 officially ends World War II in Europe. The moribound Leage of Nations is replaced with the Organisation of Collective Peace Maintenance (Organisation der Kollektiven Friedenswahrung), seated in Calais, which uses a much more pragmatic and less idealtsic-pompous approach. Wallachia and Moldavia are officially recognised by everybody, and the Kingdom of France is „accepted“, that is, nobody will do anything it.The only true territorialc hanges happen in the Middle Eats, where the peace treaty also officiallly ends the Trabzon War.

The nations and blocs now have time for interior worries, and for reconstruction, of course. The Anglophone allies would liek to create an own state in France, but they are deeply divided about how it is supposed to look. The British and Canadians favour an Orleanist Monarchy, the Americans and Australians a Democratic Republic as ideological counter to both Lyons and the Kingdom of France. They do manage to build up a interzone French Civil Adminsitration, with interzonal tariffs and monetary union, but they do not manage to create a souvereign state. That they thus keep their part of France under occupation of course only fuels Lyons' propaganda. Armenia gets a further German Prince to become King. Mussolini's Social Republic of Italy works to become self-reliant again, but is plagued by internal problems. Turkey and Azerbaijan unite in the aftermath of the Trabzon war, connected now by formerly Persian Azerbaijan. Of course, this unification is rather Turkey abosbring Azerbaijan. Spain and Italy gain the bomb in June 1948, and three months afterwards, with help of data spies stole from those two countries, so does the SFYA. Canada and ANZAC have the bomb by this time already. Cooperation with China leads to the new People's Republic there and the FCSR gaining nuclear technology in February 1949. Generally the FCSR is getting connected more and more to China, due to the huge chinese ressource base they so desperatly need. It is difficult to tell which side domines which in that alliance, as the PRC in return needs soviet technology. But it is foreseeable that Mao will slowly gain the upper hand in the alliance...

(Map sunk, like many others, with Imageshack of old.)

nucleareuropelc1.jpg
 
Last edited:
Who won that one? I'll get back to you on that.

Round 2, different 19th century colonization of a continent with post-1500 PODs.

EdT:

Well, here's my effort...

PoD: 1521. While leading the siege of Tenochtitlan, Hernan Cortes comes down with a nasty dose of fever. He recovers, and goes on to successfully take the city. However, the feverish dreams he had while confined to his tent make a great impression on him, and he realises that his destiny is not to be Mexico's conqueror, but its Emperor!

It doesn't last of course, but for seven glorious years Hernando I rules his realm with an iron fist, destroying several expeditions sent to defeat him and even gaining recognition from an angry Pope Clement VII in the aftermath of the sack of Rome. The Spanish only have to be successful once though, and eventually in 1528 an expedition led by Álvar Cabeza de Vaca smashes the Mexican army and takes back the country for the King of Spain. The precedent has been set though, and in the 1550s Jiménez de Quesada conquers the Incas and declares himself Emperor. The King is occupied at home, and things snowball; before long, a chain of independent states established by various adventurers stretch from the middle Andes to the Sonoran Desert.

By 1870 (when this map is set), South America is rather different to OTL's. Britain, France, the Netherlands and Portugal have all established colonies on the continent, while the successor states to the original Conquistador Kingdoms remain in the north and east. Spain retains a presence in the New World, but only in her settler colonies along the *Hudson and *Potomac rivers...

On the map, of particular note are:

The Guyranay Commonwealth, which is the spectacularly strange result of combining Puritans, Guarani Indians and something similar to OTLs "Reducciones";

New Zealand, which retains its name from its period of Dutch rule before the English grabbed it in the early 18th century;

Antarctica (Officially known as "France Antarctique"), a haven for French Hugenouts and a refuge for the Monarchy during the German revolutionary wars of 1812-1846;

Tawantinsuyu, still ruled by a member of the Quesada dynasty four centuries after its inception;

and Klein Wenedig, a cospopolitan state whose long-held status as a haven for scoundrels, refugees and criminals of all nations and creeds has left it with some of the most robust democratic traditions in the world.

samerica2-jpg.28033


attachment.php
 
Last edited:
Nicole FNA Imajin:

The POD is that the Dutch do not settle on the Cape of Good Hope, but the Separatists, and later the Puritans, do. The colony is rather successful, however, British moves to re-assert royal control in the 1700s (as the Cape becomes more and more strategically important) lead to some of the most devout settlers moving inland, founding the Holy Union, a very insular state. However, political differences grow, leading to the colony splitting into the more insular Northern Theocracy, and the more liberal (by Puritan standards) Southern Theocracy in 1832.

Racial factors are less important. In New England, with a much larger white and Indian population, no race has a clear majority. In the Theocracies, religion matters much more than anything else- as long as you're of the proper faith, they don't care what color you are- of course, it's also rather difficult to convert, leaving the majority of Church-goers as the white settlers even with a large black majority. Zululand is almost totally black.

puritansouth-png.28042


attachment.php
 
Last edited:
Diamond:

Okay, I had to save this as a JPEG to get it small enough to load, even on Imageshack, but everything still looks legible... I think.

Anyway, the POD for this is sometime in the late 1550s or early 1560s. Spain's King Philip II is a little more reckless, a bit more of a despot, and suffers some staggering losses when he tries to unite all of Italy under Spanish rule in 1575.

Italy unites alright, but not under Spain - the northern Italian cities band together to form the Italian League and drive Spain completely from the peninsula. In the process they anger the Pope, and several northern Italian leaders are excommunicated, giving Protestantism a huge boost in the north, especially in Genoa, Milan, and Venice, who ironically find common cause after centuries of feuding with each other.

Spain and the Italian League war on and off over the next century. The League builds ties with both England and the Ottoman Empire (oh, there is no Battle of Lepanto here, and the O.E. is still a major threat to Austria and Europe).

By 1800, the Italian League has grown to encompass all of Italy, Corsica, Sardinia, Malta, Crete, and Dalmatia, along with various other bits and pieces around the Mediterranean. They've also built a Suez Canal in conjunction with the Ottoman Empire, and have snatched all of Spain's East Asian colonies, including the Philippines.

The current year is 1848, and tensions are high between the Italian League and the Ottoman Empire ever since the League unilaterally annexed the whole Canal Zone five years ago.

2faritalia3qa0.jpg
 
Susano, with much blab:

So, several things changed in East Asia. The Portuguese were able to recover several holdings from the Dutch, and there is a Ming Exile state on Borneo. The Ottomans, though hardly present in the region, were able to explot conflicts in the region: The Spanish-Ming-Muslim three way struggle on Mindanao, which ended in all sides recognicing the Ottoman protectorate, for example. Likewise, after several Dutch and British attempts to get Aceh in their fold, the Sultan chooses the conviniently far away Ottomans as protetcorate power, but still has to cede its south to the Dutch and British. As there was no Seven

Russia, Amurland: Still large, but internally much, much weaker this TL, they could not muster much resistance against the Prussian-Danish forts in the Amur Region, and eventually sold the land, which with the founding of Germany became German.

Korea: Korea played a major role in the Chinese Ming/Qing Civil War of the 17th century, but faded into global obsucrity afterwards again. After Russia, China, Japan and the UK all had their eyes on the Kingdom, Germany managed to play all sides off each other, and to gain Korea as a protectorate. Even though the Kingdom is not souvereigned, it has a high degree of internal and cultural autonomy, and Koreans also settle in Amurland and Taiwan.

Japan: After a dynastical struggle in the 19th century, into which the European powers were heaviyl involved, of course, the country remains split. Germany protected one faction to establish itself on Hokkaido (and allowed it to also gain Sakhalin) to have a buffer and protection for Amurland. The main Japanese state, with its court and capital at Kyoto, tendentially is more friendly to Great Britain, but goes at great lengths to keep independance. Still, no Mejii restoration this TL.

Quing China: Just as IOTL, Quing China is a weak giant, unable to hold off the European powers. Plagued by constant uorisings and rebellions, it is even weaker than IOTL, and in fact more or less only held together by the European powers, who fear the radicalness of the revolutions. The European powers greatly exploit this weakness, establishing colonies and holdings (permanent and not "for 99 years" or somesuch) at Chinas coasts.

Tibet The Tibetans used the Quing weakness to establish their independance. Over time, they recovered more and more Tibetan settled lands, until most ethnically Tibetan lands were in their hands. This was greatly supported by the Brits, by whom Tibet is greatly influenced.

Formosa: Major battleground of the Chinese Civil War of the 17th century. As result, the Dutchw ere expelled, but neither Ming nor Quing managed to hold the by then devasted island. Hence, Prussia-Denmark invoked the concept of terra nullis, and gained possession of it. Thus it became German when the German Empire was founded. The island is mostly settled by Germans and Koreans, with minorities of Formosian natives and Chinese Min Speakers.

Philippines: Sold by Spain to Germany 1868. Gifted by Germany to Denmark two years after Denmark's independance as part of the deal to part on friendly terms.

Yunnan: Broke away from China in 1844 after a new serie of uprisings and revolutions en par with IOTL Taiping Revolution. Had to eventually submit to Siamese dominance.

Burman States and Tribes: The Brits conquered most of the Burman State, and what remained in the highlands were states and tribes of Burmanese, Karne,S han, Mon and other ethnicities.

Siam: The only remaining independant Indochinese power. Encroached by the Bris in the South in Malaya, and the French in the West in Tenasserim, and later alo by the Italians in the East, Siam had an increasingly uncomfortable situation. German diplomay managed to secure Siam as an ally in this situation, and with German help, Siam gained dominance over Yunnan and the Burmanese territories. In return, it ceded a zone for an isthmus canal to be built to Germany. While Siam is very solidly in the German camp, it still has managed to remain independant of it, unlike Korea.

Tenasserim, Burma: There was no Seven Years War this timeline. India is split between French and British territories, and that spilt over to Burma, too...

Italian Indochina: Italy took Vietnam from China in the Italian-Chinese War of 1873, and Cambodia from Siamese suzeranity in 1877. Ever since 1873, the Italian Indochinese-Siamese border has been redrawn time and time again, but with Siam a German ally now, has now stabilised.

Hainan: Occupied by Great Britain 1875 as a counter to Italy's influence. Not officially ceded by China, Britain has nontheless built up a colonial administration.

Sultanate Aceh: For a long time, the last remaining power in the Eats Indian Archipelago, the only state not conquered by the Ming, the Dutch or the Portuguese. Still, the Dutch and the British had ambitions there. Inspired by the Ottoman protetcorate over Midnanao, the Sultan of Aceh put his state under the protection of the conviniently far away Ottomans. Nontheless, the south of his lands he had to cede to the British and Dutch in order to receive recognition for this step by them.

Malay and South Aceh: A complicated structure holding together the various forms of British holdings in the region - dependencies, colonies, protectorates, vasall states.

Dutch East India: The traditonal dutch holdings in the region.

Portuguese East India: The Portuguese had been the first European power in the region, havinge stablished settlements since the 16th century. However, they lost most their colonies to the Dutch during the Time of the Spanish-Portuguese personal union. However, ITTL, the Portuguese eventually were able tor ecover their most traditional holdings in the East Indian Archipelago, the Spice Islands.

Empire of the Ming in Exile: An outgrowth of the Southern Ming, the remnaints of the Ming Dynasty in the Ming/Quing War after the fall of Beijing. Even afterwards the war went on for decades, allowing the Southrn Ming to establish them on Formosa (though they eventually lost control there again) and Borneo during that time. The Ming capital was officially moved to Borneo 1674.

New Guinea: As the late comers in the colonial business, the Italians had to take what was left over, and in Asia that were the jungles of New Guinea. The southernmost coast is a colony of a colony, to be specific, of Great Britains colony in Australia.

Hm, seems like this time its actually attacheable. Ah, well, the advantages of gif.

attachment.php
easiaedit-copy-gif.28185
 
Last edited:
Highlander's, which did not require much explanation:

attachment.php
africa-jpg.28200


"the British mostly get beat out by France, Portugal and Germany."
 
Last edited:
And Atom:

POD: Cortez dies trying before reaching shore. The spanish never really get their acvt together, and eventually the franch step in and conuer mexico and the bulf area, but they never conquer the inca, instead just taking mexico's gold home. France is more succesful (I think) but England, Portugal, Denmark, Prussia, and the netherlands, also ammas colonial empires. Poland-lithuania lives on and Muscovy never conquers Novgorod, and they divide russian and the east of sibereia between themselves. The map is set in 1899

mapcontest2markii-png.28235


attachment.php
 
Last edited:
That round was won by Dutchie, with Diamond as runner-up.

So, round three: a fantasy continent with physical features. Not really impressive, and only 4 visible maps, so here's the winner, LordKraken.

mapcontest23tr6.png
 
I must add Thande did win the "Most Like a Cheesy 80s Video Game Map" award.

Round Four was battlefield maps.

EdT:

Mine is a scan from the 1947 edition of "Velhagen's Historical Atlas of America", showing the beginning of the Confederate Civil War, also known as the 3rd American Revolution. The timeline it comes from is a variant of the Turtledove 191 Timeline; here though the US has broken the Confederates rather more easily, with the result that the CSA is already on the ropes when the black revolt begins. The next few years will be confusing ones, as the USA balances trying to finish off Canada with protecting its southern border against the troubles occuring in the Confederacy, or what's left of it...

acw2-jpg.29038


attachment.php
 
Last edited:
And Thande:

Disclaimer: I drew all this myself, including the basemap, so that's why Badajoz may have one or two more or less bastions than in reality Apologies for JPG but PNG was too big.

This map is from Look to the West (or may be) because Scarecrow insisted. It depicts the Relief of Badajoz in 1806, when the besieged Spaniards, even as the the Republican French were on the verge of victory, were saved by the arrival of an Allied army consisting of British, Hanoverian and Imperial North American forces led by Sir John Moore

mc-2-4-4b-jpg.29046


attachment.php
 
Last edited:
Top