Recent content by Socrates

  1. If C16th Castille/Aragon/Portugal can convert Iberia to Catholicism, could a religious French monarchy do the same in the Maghreb in C19th?

    France had her demographic transition very early. It is debated whether it was caused by the Revolution or happened a decade or two before. Either way, a POD around 1750 or so to push them in a more theocratic direction could do it. More French settlers and more zealotry in conversion/ethnic...
  2. AHC: Make Russian an accepted part of the west.

    Sorry, I don't engage with people that start by insulting people.
  3. AHC: Make Russian an accepted part of the west.

    If Nemtsov follows Yeltsin, Russia would probably have followed a similar development path to Poland. Democracy, Christian culture and reasonable economic development is enough to be seen as Western.
  4. AHC: Make Russian an accepted part of the west.

    People used to say similar things about Japan.
  5. If C16th Castille/Aragon/Portugal can convert Iberia to Catholicism, could a religious French monarchy do the same in the Maghreb in C19th?

    Why would converting the Maghreb in the 19th C be more expensive than converting Iberia in the 16th C? Everything I have read so far comes down to (a) culture has changed so religion is less important to Europeans and (b) there are Muslim neighbors that would fight it. But (a) can be changed by...
  6. If C16th Castille/Aragon/Portugal can convert Iberia to Catholicism, could a religious French monarchy do the same in the Maghreb in C19th?

    Prior to the Reconquista, Al-Andalus was about 80% Muslim. These lands became captured by Christian kingdoms, who through a combination of bribery, blackmail and expulsion converted the country to being devoutly Catholic. By the time France conquered Algeria IOTL, the country had been through...
  7. Too big to succeed? 'Rightsize' an overextended nation or empire

    An Atlantic Empire of the British Isles and North America would have been very viable logistically once you have steam ships. Just need to get the right constitutional balance.
  8. WI: France ignores the Austro-Prussian Rivalry and fully focuses on Britain during the Seven Years War

    This is all correct. Also, Hannover was not British, so it was only of interest to anti-British forces to the extent the King cared about the place. George III felt no connection, so a succesful invasion would give little leverage.
  9. What could Austria Hungary could of done to fix its Over Diversity and National instability in its Ethnic army, and government.

    The Habsburgs actively embraced identifying people in their empire as a single nationality based on their primary language. Do that for long enough and people start identifying that way. In reality, huge numbers in the empire had ancestry from multiple places and spoke multiple languages. They...
  10. AHQ: Why did monotheism generally replace polytheism?

    Islam had huge success in India. India was a mammoth population with deeply embedded, institutionally strong religion and yet the Muslims still managed to convert a third of the population. Don't understand your point about Buddhism at all.
  11. AHQ: Why did monotheism generally replace polytheism?

    I think this is exactly right, and also a big part of why Islam spread so much. As an economist and a big student of economic history, I think a lot of people don't appreciate how modern middle class societies have such a different social structure to most of history. Prior to 1600, the vast...
  12. Plausible long term statuses for Asian/African territories in a United British Empire with no ARW

    This is a lot of the thinking in my first post and would welcome debate. I think they could hang on to small population places like Malaya, Ceylon, Formosa. But trying to hold on to places like China, India is a fool's errand even for a mega-Britain. Though imperial hubris is likely to mean they...
  13. Plausible long term statuses for Asian/African territories in a United British Empire with no ARW

    What resources will be pushed into North America? North America would be a net source of resources for a united imperial power. And, as I said, the conquests of India, Nigeria, Malaysia in OTL weren't pushed from London. They are people on the ground trying their luck. And more people on the...
  14. Plausible long term statuses for Asian/African territories in a United British Empire with no ARW

    Britain already has a heavily growing population from Florida to Nova Scotia. The native population north of the Rio Grande has been decimated by disease and far lower technology. The imperialist mentality of the Anglo settlers is going to grab the land and I can't see who else would get in...
Top