alternatehistory.com
Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
New profile posts
New threadmarks
Latest activity
Members
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
Word Count:
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Members
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Ran's latest activity
Ran
reacted to
GrimmJow007's post
in the thread
Sequel de Mayo (Cinco de Mayo, Vol. II)
with
Like
.
This slows down Russia's economic development, not stops it.
46 minutes ago
Ran
reacted to
EasternRomanEmpire's post
in the thread
What if the Republic of German-Austria was successful.
with
Like
.
Revanchism? Please, Fascists aren't going to come to power just because Austria unified with Germany; the conditions in France aren't...
Today at 1:26 AM
Ran
reacted to
Dunbar's post
in the thread
Sequel de Mayo (Cinco de Mayo, Vol. II)
with
Like
.
I think it's the best of bad options. If the French plan goes perfectly they take the Rhine and then what, Germany still has access to...
Yesterday at 3:59 PM
Ran
reacted to
Jan Olbracht's post
in the thread
No Nazism (and maybe no WWII) - What is the ultimate fate of the Second Polish Republic?
with
Like
.
Like Palestine mixed with 1930s Ukraine. Central Poland was already overpopulated. Combine expulsion of western Poles with loss of the...
Yesterday at 1:12 PM
Ran
reacted to
Zygmunt Stary's post
in the thread
No Nazism (and maybe no WWII) - What is the ultimate fate of the Second Polish Republic?
with
Like
.
Even with 1914 border restored, there is still room for rump Polish state existing, so not like Palestine, but rather Ukraine between...
Yesterday at 1:11 PM
Ran
reacted to
Jan Olbracht's post
in the thread
No Nazism (and maybe no WWII) - What is the ultimate fate of the Second Polish Republic?
with
Like
.
Nope. Russian Empire at least has not planned expulsion of millions of Poles to make room for Russian settlers. When ww1 started Poles...
Yesterday at 1:11 PM
Ran
reacted to
Flavius Iulius Maiorianus's post
in the thread
No Nazism (and maybe no WWII) - What is the ultimate fate of the Second Polish Republic?
with
Like
.
No, the KPD never had the popular support to win anything, and any coup would simply be crushed. The rise of the NSDAP was incredibly...
Yesterday at 1:10 PM
Ran
reacted to
Flavius Iulius Maiorianus's post
in the thread
No Nazism (and maybe no WWII) - What is the ultimate fate of the Second Polish Republic?
with
Like
.
At least while Stalin is alive, Poland probably doesn't get invaded at all. It's not impossible, but I see it as less likely than not...
Yesterday at 1:10 PM
Ran
reacted to
Flavius Iulius Maiorianus's post
in the thread
No Nazism (and maybe no WWII) - What is the ultimate fate of the Second Polish Republic?
with
Like
.
True, although in the case of a Habsburg king on the Polish throne, A-H might cede Galicia to the new state. It would at least be better...
Yesterday at 1:09 PM
Ran
reacted to
athgtq16129's post
in the thread
No Nazism (and maybe no WWII) - What is the ultimate fate of the Second Polish Republic?
with
Like
.
Would a diminished Poland that was invaded by the Soviets, but not Germany (who only annexed Danzig and a small part of Silesia, and the...
Yesterday at 1:09 PM
Ran
reacted to
KingSweden24's post
in the thread
Sequel de Mayo (Cinco de Mayo, Vol. II)
with
Like
.
"...quite famously, the Emperor, especially as Crown Prince, had been amongst the greatest skeptics of a general war on Austria's part...
Yesterday at 12:32 PM
Ran
reacted to
Lalli's post
in the thread
What if Nikita Khrushchev never became the leader of the Soviet Union?
with
Like
.
Depends POD and who would take power after Stalin. Molotov I see bit unlikely. Malenkov would be most plausible and almost managed to...
Yesterday at 1:44 AM
Ran
reacted to
GuildedAgeNostalgia's post
in the thread
What if Nikita Khrushchev never became the leader of the Soviet Union?
with
Like
.
Molotov was too old at that point to be anything but a power broker. Beria doesn't have the support. Malenkov is probably the most...
Yesterday at 1:44 AM
Ran
reacted to
Cudymcar's post
in the thread
What if Nikita Khrushchev never became the leader of the Soviet Union?
with
Like
.
Someone has to replace Khrushchev as an Ukrainian leader (1938-1949), most probably Postyshev. And then someone has to replace purged...
Yesterday at 1:43 AM
Ran
reacted to
Mildtryth's post
in the thread
What if WWI ended in 1916 with a status quo ante bellum?
with
Like
.
I know that. And Serbia was well within its rights to refuse, but what I'm trying to get at is the difficulty of avoiding a war without...
Monday at 8:20 PM
Members
Top