Recent content by Archdevil

  1. The most competent IJA and IJN officers

    Adding Mikawa for Savo Island
  2. 'the Victorious': Seleucus Nicator and the world after Alexander

    I am getting curious about the rise of Argeus here! His story sounds like a king beyond the water type of story.
  3. The second biggest one-hit wonder group or individual? (other than Zager & Evans or the Starland Vocal Band)

    The band can be found performing the song on youtube in Union style uniforms, so...
  4. Admiral turn POTUS

    Leahy?
  5. Was Albert Speer’s sentence at Nuremberg justified?

    In my opinion also Von Papen and others of his ilk should have been shot on general principle for their spectacular lack of judgement.
  6. Soviet low level air defense missiles: too little too late ?

    Soviet SAM systems seemed pretty effective in countering Israeli ground attack sorties in 1973. When properly employed of course, but that goes for every weapon system. The combination of SA-6 and ZSU 23-4 was apparently very complementary.
  7. Can a Fritz X sink an Illustrious class carrier?

    No armored deck is going to stop a Fritz-X. It was used to sink the Italian battleship Roma, significantly larger then Warspite, after it hit a main gun magazine. A similar hit on a carrier (munition's storage) would be just as crippling.
  8. Best late cold war era NATO tank?

    The Americans tried to find export countries among NATO allies for the Abrams during the late 1970s/early 1980s but at the time the Abrams in its M1 shape was clearly the inferior choice compared to the Leo2 due to its (by that time) rather anemic 105 mm tank gun.* When offered the M1, the...
  9. Name of a United France-Spain

    Would be confusing
  10. The Great stadholder, Dutch 18th century

    Nice TL! Is the title Great Stadtholder analogous to the Great Elector?
  11. Arab conquest of Spain was a failure

    The Visigoths were indeed not the posterboys of 'political stability'. If the Arab invasion would have been delayed by one reason or the other, the most likely result would be a Frankish takeover of the entire peninsula, which would have provided a much tougher nut to crack for the Arab/Moorish...
  12. Significant battles Middle Ages

    Fontenoy (841)
  13. Darius defends the Cilician gates against Alexander, what could happen?

    The Persian plateau is also very mountainous (it's in the name), so I don't see the Macedonians coming away with a massive advantage here. In fact, the Persians (remnants really, after Gaugamela) proved quite capable of holding up the entire Macedonian army at the Persian Gates several years...
  14. Fav small nation in history that had a chance for greatness but didnt

    While that's nice information, Sneek never had a major harbor, expect one suited for the lake it is situated on, perhaps.
Top