The Wings of the Eagle are Broken and the Italian Civil War

mussolini-march-on-rome.jpg


The Wings of the Eagle are Broken and the Italian Civil War

The Blackshirts March on Rome is commonly seen as a horrible miscalculation by aspiring Fascist Benito Mussolini. But first to understand why he did it, we must understand the context.

In March 1919, Benito Mussolini founded the first "Italian Combat Leagues" (Fasci Italiani di Combattimento) at the beginning of the "two red years" (biennio rosso). He suffered a defeat in the election of November 1919. But, by the election of 1921, Mussolini gained entrance to Parliament.

Out of his "Fascist" party the "Blackshirts" (Squadristi) were formed. In August 1920, the Blackshirts were used to break the general strike which had started at the Alfa Romeo factory in Milan. In November 1920, after the assassination of Giordana (a right-wing municipal counsellor in Bologna), the Blackshirts were used as a repression tool by the state to crush the socialist movement (which included a strong anarcho-syndicalist component), especially in the Po Valley.

Trade unions were dissolved while left-wing mayors resigned. The fascists, included on Giovanni Giolitti's "National Union" lists at the May 1921 elections, then won 36 seats. Mussolini then withdrew his support to Giolitti and attempted to work out a temporary truce with the socialists by signing a "Pacification Pact" in summer 1921. This provoked a conflict with the most fanatical part of the movement, the "Squadristi" and their leaders the "Ras." In July 1921, Giolitti attempted without success to dissolve the squadristi. The contract with the socialists was then broken at its turn in November 1921, Mussolini adopted a nationalist program and founded the National Fascist Party, which boasted 700,000 members in July 1922. In August, an anti-fascist general strike was triggered, but failed to rally the Italian People's Party (Partito Popolare Italiano) and was repressed by the fascists. A few days before the march, Mussolini consulted with the U.S. Ambassador Richard Washburn Child about whether the U.S. government would object to Fascist participation in a future Italian government. Child encouraged him to go ahead. When Mussolini learned that Prime Minister Luigi Facta had given Gabriele d'Annunzio the mission to organize a large demonstration on 4 November 1922 to celebrate the national victory during the war, he decided on the March to accelerate the process and sidestep any possible competition.

On October 24th, 1922 Mussolini declared, in front of 60,000 people at the Fascist Congress in Naples "Our Position is simple, we want to rule Italy". Two days later Prime Minister Luigi Facta was warned of the Fascist's intentions but Facta did not listen and believed Mussolini would rule peacefully beside him, oh how wrong he was. As the Fascists gathered outside Rome Facta, who by this time resigned but still held power, asked the King to declare a State of Emergency. The King initially refused but signed the order after a 3 hour argument with Facta.

The March itself included only about 30,000 Fascists but the King feared a forced seizure of power so when the Blackshirts, led by Mussolini, walked into Rome to present their demands the King ordered the police to open fire. The exchange was short and brief but deadly and is commonly seen as the beginning of the War. The final toll came to 3 policemen dead next to 8 Blackshirts, among them was Benito Mussolini.
 
I'm sorry that this is completely tangential, but does this mean that the Munich Beer Hall Putsch never happens, and thus the Nazis remain an obscure Nationalist party in Bavaria?
 
Oh, yea but still, Hitler and his Nazis will probably be mentioned. I cant stress probably enough though. I don't know if I will go into detail about the Fascist/Nazi movements world-wide.
 
Point made. Again, what happens to Hitler and his Nazi party is to be decided on later. Also I was thinking of approaching the War with a first person angle, what do you guys think?
 
Oh, yea but still, Hitler and his Nazis will probably be mentioned. I cant stress probably enough though. I don't know if I will go into detail about the Fascist/Nazi movements world-wide.

If no Nazis, possibly another form of militaristic far right, like those 'stalhelms'(?)...

Question, what are the repercutions to the neighboors of Italy and the international relations of Italy with them? like any left Irredentism and all?
 
Forgive me if I'm wrong, but I thought Mussolini stayed behind (just in case) while the Quadrumvirs (Balbo, Bianchi, De Bono & De Vecchi) actually led the March. If so, Il Duce wouldn't have been there to have been shot, he would have been boarding the fastest method of transport out of Italy the moment he heard.
 
3rdcdnbrig_snipers_campochi.jpg

Italian Forces battle Blackshirts in Genoa
Opening Moves
Let us have a dagger between our teeth, a bomb in our hands, and an infinite scorn in our hearts.- Benito Mussolini (1883-1922)​

When news of the Roman Massacre leaked out into the world chaos ensued. The Congress in Naples moved North to Asti in the Po Valley of Northern Italy, where Fascist Blackshirts had seized control. The Congress elected Gabriele D'Annuzio as the new Duce until the war was over. In his acceptance speech D'Annuzio declared war on King Victor of Italy, declaring his government illegal. He also appointed Emilio De Bono, hero of the First World War, as Grand Marshal of Italy. De Bono, approaching 52, was reluctant at first but accepted when Balbo said he could resign after the War. De Bono's first action as Grand Marshal was consolidating Fascist forces in the Po Valley in Modena . He then put them through rigorous training for the rest of the Winter. Trained in guerrilla warfare, assassination, spying, and urban fighting they became a Army in their own right.

De_Bono1.jpg

Emilio De Bono in 1929​

Meanwhile in Rome King Victor faced a crisis like no other since the Division of Italy in the Medieval times. Numerous Fascists within the government and Army resigned soon after Mussolini's death leaving holes in the chain of command. Across Italy Fascist militias were launching raids, the Fascists had seized de facto control of the Po Valley and Libyian Govenor, Now Duce of Italy, had seized Libya for the Blackshirts so he was in a tough spot. With the Blackshirts in Lybia and the Po Valley seemingly inactive the King used this as his chance to secure the rest of Italy. When Fascists in Venice tried to take the city the King mowed them down, routing the Blackshirts and forcing them to abandon the city and scoring Italy's first victory in the war.* The King also took this as his chance to secure forigen neutrality in the War. In the winter and early spring of 1923 he met with France, Germany, Switzerland, Austria and Yugoslavia and got their assurances of neutrality. The King returned to Rome and met with Pope Pius XI and asked for his blessing in the War, Pius responded with "Lets see how this plays out first".

italian_army_national_arch.jpg

Italian Army Marching in Rome 1924

 
Last edited:
Sorry to point out a little problem...the 'March of Rome' was a huge bluff and all or nothing attempt.
In reality the entire fascist leaderships was there (and in this case even Mussolini) at the time, plus great part of the supporter and if the army go against them they are one single target, basically instant decapitation followed by a couple of months of clean up.
Plus if the goverment seem to go against the fascist expect that the socialist will sense blood in the water and start to 'make visit' to the blackshirts start to make them suffer.

Even with Mussolini as a 'Martyr symbol' the remaining fascist leaderships will be greatly fractured, Del Bono is too old, without enough carisma and largely inept, maybe D'Annunzio is better
Balbo is good, but even if he escape Rome he will face a lot of people in his same party that want his job, maybe not initially but soon.

In all honestly any military attempt to quell the fascist march will be basically a Beer Putsch on steroid but in the end the fascist are destined to fail epically...the aftermath will be interesting with the 'socialist menace' looming over the King head (but ironically eliminating the fascist will please a lot of the moderate socialist and help the royal cause)

The army is still greatly (between 80 and 90%) loyal to the king so no big support there.

In Libya due to the Senussi rebellion the italian control just the big city of the coast, so without any external support i doubt that they resist too much or even attempt to rebel, they have much more important thing to do...like stay alive.
 
Sorry to point out a little problem...the 'March of Rome' was a huge bluff and all or nothing attempt.
In reality the entire fascist leaderships was there (and in this case even Mussolini) at the time, plus great part of the supporter and if the army go against them they are one single target, basically instant decapitation followed by a couple of months of clean up.
Plus if the goverment seem to go against the fascist expect that the socialist will sense blood in the water and start to 'make visit' to the blackshirts start to make them suffer.

Even with Mussolini as a 'Martyr symbol' the remaining fascist leaderships will be greatly fractured, Del Bono is too old, without enough carisma and largely inept, maybe D'Annunzio is better
Balbo is good, but even if he escape Rome he will face a lot of people in his same party that want his job, maybe not initially but soon.

In all honestly any military attempt to quell the fascist march will be basically a Beer Putsch on steroid but in the end the fascist are destined to fail epically...the aftermath will be interesting with the 'socialist menace' looming over the King head (but ironically eliminating the fascist will please a lot of the moderate socialist and help the royal cause)

The army is still greatly (between 80 and 90%) loyal to the king so no big support there.

In Libya due to the Senussi rebellion the italian control just the big city of the coast, so without any external support i doubt that they resist too much or even attempt to rebel, they have much more important thing to do...like stay alive.
Ok, I will do more research on who will lead the Blackshirts but I was getting to the Civil War. You might have spoiled the ending ;)
 
Ok I should have my computer back sometime next week or the week after, then I will continue the TL
 
Last edited:
I have gotten access to a computer so I will put out a short update on the Civil War
==========================================================

743506_original.jpg

Fascist Millitary Parade in Venice - 1924

War and Execution
I believe wholeheartedly that we are doing Gods work.- Duce Gabriele D'Annuzio, 1923​

The Italian Civil War is seen as a turning point for world history as it would make or break Fascist influence and legitimacy across the world. To get a jump on the Royalists 100.000 Italian Blackshirts marched toward attacked Bologna. The Royalists were caught off guard and pulled out of the city after only light fighting. The Fascists then marched North East and captured Venice after more heavy fighting but took heavy losses which prevented them from marching on Treviso. The loss of most of Northern Italy was a blow of sorts to the Kings government who claimed "The traitorous Fascists will be crushed within the month". Through the Summer of 1923 the Fascists managed to consolidate their hold on Northern Italy and tighten their siege of Treviso. D'Annuzio met with De Bono in July of 1923 and discussed their next move. Annuzio advocated pressing their advantage and March on Rome while De Bono was more realistic and pressured for Annuzio to allow for him to adopt a defensive line along the Reno River while the Fascists seek international recognition. They bickered for days before Annuzio relented and allowed for De Bono to go on the defensive.

Meanwhile in Rome the King met with his senior military advisers to discuss the War. There really wasn't much to discuss as most of the Army had stayed loyal to the King so most called it a publicity stunt. Either way at the end of the meeting Alfredo Guzzoni, promoted to Field Marshal of the Empire once more after many ether refused the title or defected, moved 1,000,000 men onto the Reno River to prepare for a full out assault. The attack went swimmingly and the Fascist forces were forced to retreat out of their makeshift defenses. Guzzoni followed up his success by beating the Fascists out of Bologna, Parma and Ferrara, before meeting a determined defense on the Po River.

The Fascists held an emergency meeting in Treviso, who recently surrendered, to talk about the War. It didn't take long before the Congress was split between people who wanted continued defense and those who wanted to go on the attack. The arguments went on for days before news reached Treviso that a new Royalist attack as managed to breach the line at a few places. The Defenders used this to their advantage and the Fascists continued to defend.

Unfortunately for them it was not enough and it wasn't long before the Royalists were knocking on Treviso's door. In a last ditch attempt to save himself and continue the cause of Italian Fascism, Gabriele D'Annuzio fled the city with a handful of Blackshirts to meet up with a German party[1]. As the days progressed he was soon followed by more Blackshirts as they fled to other countries like Austria and France. With their leader on run, army deserting en masse, and the Royalists about to take the city, the Congress surrendered. On December 31st, 1923 the Fascist leaders were hung after a show trial in Rome, the War was over.

[1] They will be more prominent later
 
Last edited:
Top