The Rise and Fall of the Amerikaner Republics

tumblr_lzkih0lycx1qeu6ilo1_400.jpg


King William the Silent of the Netherlands



Following the success of the Dutch revolt against the Spanish Empire, Spain recognized the Kingdom of the Netherland’s existence in 1588 in the Fifteen-Year Truce between the two nations. With the cessation of hostilities, William the Silent began to focus on repairing the damage that had occurred throughout the Seventeen Provinces of the Kingdom. Officially both King and elected Stadholder, William concentrated his efforts on uniting the Catholic and Protestant segments of the people. He understood that in order for the Netherlands to become prosperous as an independent nation that the people would have to stop looking at each other as religious enemies. To this end, by working with the States-General in the Dutch capital of Brussels, William saw that the Act of Conscience was passed, thereby permitting freedom of worship throughout the provinces.

The Act of Conscience resulted in a myriad of effect that could not have been intended by William when he was pushing for its passing in the States-General. Among other things, the primary effect was that members of the Jewish faith throughout Europe began to immigrate to the Kingdom of the Netherlands in search of a more tolerant life free from the sanctioned persecution that they had become accustomed to in their homelands. In particular, the Sephardic Jews of Spain and Portugal, including many Conversos and Cryptic-Jews, and Morocco found the Netherlands to be rather attractive, moving in larger numbers than their Ashkenazi counterparts. Once in the Netherlands, the Sephardic Jewish community became increasingly prevalent in the mercantile community of the various larger cities, specifically Amsterdam, Antwerp, Brussels, Ghent, Rotterdam, and Utrecht.

Consequently, many of the less prosperous members of the Reformed Church began to see the Act of Conscience in a bad light, referring to it as the Act of Perversion. For these staunch members of the Dutch Reformed Faith, the idea of potentially being governed by Catholics and Jews in the States-General was abhorrent. As a result, with the increasing prevalence of news from the Americas pouring in, many of the religious leaders of the Calvinist communities throughout the Netherlands began preaching of building a new ‘Jerusalem’ in the New World. Particularly among those lighting fires within the hearts and souls of their parishioners, Cornelius Abrams began giving a series of sermons in 1598 about the importance of moving away from temptation and the evils of ill governance that earned him a special place in the minds of the faithful, gaining him an audience throughout many communities as his words were recited in church after church.

Directly as a result of Abrams’ sermons, a group of fifty families began planning to settle in the New World and transform it into their own Eden. Over the course of the next two years, the families sold off their farms and possessions in order to pay for the cost of the ship that would transport them and their supplies to North America. Finally, in 1601, the Hollanders left from Amsterdam having convinced Abrams to escort them and help them build a new Jerusalem. Reaching the eastern coast of North America, the families came together in deciding the location for their new settlement, finally deciding upon an island, which they named Manhattan based upon their encounter with the a local Lenape tribe.

Setting out to build their first settlement on the island, one of the first things that the families did was to hold a religious ceremony dedicating their descendants in service to God for protecting them on their journey across the Atlantic. By the end of the next year, another ship had arrived at New Amsterdam, so named after the capital of the province the original settlers had come from, bringing with it more families and more supplies, including the first cattle. By now, word was spreading throughout the Netherlands that a puritanical way of life was beginning in the Americas. Many families began pooling their resources together in hopes of joining their Calvinist brethren along the Mauritius River (Hudson River). In fact, following in Abrams’ stride, many religious leaders began planning to lead their congregations to join him and found their own communities.

Over the next five years, ten more voyages were made to the New World with the sole purpose of carving out a place in their world for the dogmatic religious communities. Enticed by tales of abundance and salvation, many hoped that just by making the journey that they would join the ‘Elect’ and earn entrance into Heaven. As a result, by 1608 about four hundred families had settled either in New Amsterdam or along the Mauritius River.

Calling their combined communities New Holland, the settlers attempted to eke out as amicable a relationship with the local Native Americans as they could at first, trading with them for crops and furs and learning the local languages. A few of the bachelors that made the journey to the settlements even went so far as to take native wives and bring them to live on their farms. However, this more-or-less peaceful situation would not continue to last in its present state as more and more Dutch, Flemish and Walloon families began to settle along the Mauritius River Valley in the coming years.




tordai%20ogy%20korosfoi%20kriesch%20aladar.jpg


Calvinist Sermon Promising Salvation in the New World
 
Vroom-Dutch-ships-ramming-Spanish-galleys-1602.jpg


Battle between Spanish and Dutch fleets


With the end of the Fifteen-Year Truce, Spain and the Netherlands were again at war, leading many would-be settlers to reconsider making the hazardous voyage to New Holland. Nevertheless, the tiny colony managed to reach a population of two thousand by 1615. By this time, many families had spread out, some choosing to resettle away from the Mauritius River Valley. However, as the congregation was at the center of all of the settlers’ lives, practically all of the scattered settlements were established within a minimal distance of a church. As a result, by 1615 there were small Calvinist communities dotting Wilhelmus Island (Long Island). Yes, as the communities spread out, they found themselves falling victim to inter-family rivalries due to jealousy over what was perceived to be more valuable lands. The churches, driven by sermons from Abrams, who had centered himself in New Amsterdam, strived to end the feuds and return a sense of calm and propriety to the families, but their condemnations could only go so far.

Meanwhile, with the resumption of hostilities between Spain and the Netherlands, Dutch ships were prowling the Atlantic and Caribbean in search of ships carrying Spanish gold. Several Spanish treasure fleets were indeed intercepted by Dutch ships leading to the formation of several mercantile companies, each of which wanted to profit off of the possibility of seized Spanish gold. In Antwerp, several powerful Dutch families founded the Dutch West India Company with the hope of not only seizing Spanish treasure fleets, but also Spanish-controlled islands in the West Indies. Additionally, families in Amsterdam, not to be outdone by their brethren in the south, established the Dutch Antilles Company with similar purposes to the DWIC. Similar, but smaller, ventures were established in Ghent and Rotterdam bearing the names of the American Company and the New Netherlands Company respectively.

Due to the economic interests of these several companies, several official settling attempts were propagated between 1615 and 1620, resulting in the islands of Aruba, Bonaire, Curaçao, Guadeloupe, Martinica, St. Croix, and St. Maarten falling into Dutch hands with the DWIC capturing the first four and the latter three falling into the hands of the DAC. Not wanting to enter into a mercantile dogfight with the other companies, the American Company established its colonial hub in New Amsterdam in an attempt to prosper off of the fur trade. In order to do so, the heads of the company had to agree to stay out of the lives of the settlers and honor the new charter granted to New Holland by the newly crowned King, Maurice.

Not to be outdone by the other companies, the New Netherlands Company paid for a number of mercenaries and military companies to invade Brazil. Despite being smaller in size than the DWIC and DAC, the NNC managed to arrange for a considerable military force to land in Brazil, then controlled by Spain through its dynastic union with Portugal. Though the odds had been against them, the military expedition proved successful and over the course of the next decade and a half, the NNC spread its reach by conquest over more and more of Brazil. Ultimately, in 1637 Rio de Janeiro fell and with its fall Spain capitulated and recognized the Dutch conquest of the Portuguese colony.

Following its successes, the New Netherlands Company’s profits increased dramatically in comparison to those of the other companies as a result of the sugar and coffee trade. However, unlike the other companies, the NNC was not solely devoted to economic expansion and saw the capture of Brazil as an opportunity to provide a new place for Dutchmen to settle regardless of their religious affiliations. Consequently, the more liberally-minded Protestants, in addition to Catholics and Jews, viewed Brazil, aptly renamed New Netherlands by the NNC, as their promised land, as opposed to New Holland, which appeared as too religiously conservative and dogmatic.

As a result, settlement of New Holland tapered off somewhat due to the new flow of settlers to the New Netherlands. Additionally, the allure of establishing one’s family on a Brazilian plantation proved to be a large draw for many Dutch, Flemish, Walloon and Jewish families. With the freedom of religion brought by the NNC’s conquest, the stranglehold over the lives of the Portuguese colonists by the Catholic Church also came to an end. Nevertheless, protests and hostilities did arise on numerous occasions, causing the NNC to hire more mercenaries in order to pacify the region. After several brutal crackdowns against the Portuguese revolts, the angst that had built up began to dissipate as the settlers began to enjoy the other freedoms brought by the Company and even began to intermarry with Dutch families. Following the pacification, the colony was slowly 'Batavianized' as place names began to be renamed in favor of Dutch-sounding ones. Cities such as Rio de Janeiro, Sao Paulo, Salvador, Belem and Recife became Mauritius, St. Paulus, Oranjestad, Willemstad and Mauritsstad respectively.



m_078_lg.jpg


Map depicting a New Netherlands sugar plantation
 
Hmmm. I am quite interested.

Good, good. The idea of having an American version of South Africa's Afrikaners has been at the back of my mind for a few weeks now. So, I'm glad it's catching other people's interests :)

how much of the Amercias do you plan to be Dutch?

Just Brazil in South America, various Caribbean islands, and New Holland in North America, which will more or less have the same borders as the New Netherlands of OTL stretching from Connecticut to Maryland [before England takes it in the ATL Anglo-Dutch wars]
 
Good, good. The idea of having an American version of South Africa's Afrikaners has been at the back of my mind for a few weeks now. So, I'm glad it's catching other people's interests :)

Which do you think will more readily develop a *Afrikaans-type language, the Brazilian colony or New Holland? The former would probably have a decent amount of Portuguese influence, and the latter likely from French and English (maybe just to the same extent as Dutch in OTL, though).

Just Brazil in South America, various Caribbean islands, and New Holland in North America, which will more or less have the same borders as the New Netherlands of OTL stretching from Connecticut to Maryland [before England takes it in the ATL Anglo-Dutch wars]

Interesting, so where does that leave the English/British and French colonies in the New World? I can't see London or Paris taking a totally Dutch New World lying down.
 
Which do you think will more readily develop a *Afrikaans-type language, the Brazilian colony or New Holland? The former would probably have a decent amount of Portuguese influence, and the latter likely from French and English (maybe just to the same extent as Dutch in OTL, though).

Well, the Netherlands is going to keep Brazil and so the Portuguese influence will be minimized over the next few centuries and there's not going to be anything disrupting the Dutch control so I don't think the language will diverge that much there other than picking up Portuguese words and phrases.

New Holland, on the other hand, is going to be cut off from the Netherlands when it's captured by the English, thereby limiting Dutch influence to the area. Not to mention, as the colony is primarily being settled by religious communities and fur traders, it's not going to have the same constant connection that Brazil will have with the metropole. Eventually German and French Calvinists are going to settle in New Holland, as well, helping to slowly alter the language in New Holland.

Interesting, so where does that leave the English/British and French colonies in the New World? I can't see London or Paris taking a totally Dutch New World lying down.

I was planning on mentioning the French and English colonies in the next post. They're going to be mostly similar to OTL aside from there being no English Catholics settling in Maryland.

So the Dutch become the dominant power in North America instead of the British?

Nope. The English are going to capture New Holland eventually.
 
I was just thinking about getting Dutch settlers into North America, so this timeline is great

The real question is, what happens in South Africa?
 
A Dutch Brazil. That's just odd to picture:p.

Will Brazil still develop a very mixed and diverse society?

Also most people in colonial Brazil spoke a creole of Tupi and Portuguese rather than strait Portuguese until the 18th century.
 
I was just thinking about getting Dutch settlers into North America, so this timeline is great

The real question is, what happens in South Africa?

I'd say Portugal colonizes there, but that would have to wait until a possible split of the Iberian dynastic union. The Dutch could still settle there, but I don't want to make them too powerful. Do y'all have any desires for who to found Cape Town?

A Dutch Brazil. That's just odd to picture:p.
Will Brazil still develop a very mixed and diverse society?
Also most people in colonial Brazil spoke a creole of Tupi and Portuguese rather than strait Portuguese until the 18th century.

Well, if the DWIC had managed to hold on to it in OTL it wouldn't be so odd. However, they managed to fumble that one XD So it's all for good measure that I have a made up company handling Brazil instead of the DWIC.

And, well, it's going to have to be diverse in the sense that the Dutch are going to have to open up immigration to Germans in order to settle it. And, throw in the African influences from slavery and the Amerindian influences, as well. So, yeah it's going to have to be similar to OTL Brazil... Though, I don't want it to face the same troubles it did in OTL so there will continue to be large scale immigration from Europe in the 1800s and 1900s making it somewhat 'whiter.'
 
Do y'all have any desires for who to found Cape Town?

Portuguese are a good bet. They could import grapes, set up some nice vinyards, and pursue a policy of integration [1] while defending their access to the Indies.

I was thinking it could also be an alternative to Australia for the *British to ship convicts too, if they get it.


So, yeah it's going to have to be similar to OTL Brazil... Though, I don't want it to face the same troubles it did in OTL so there will continue to be large scale immigration from Europe in the 1800s and 1900s making it somewhat 'whiter.'

I think I understand what you're trying to get at, but I still feel that some clarification is in order.




[1] i.e. gettin' it on across racial lines. Oh yeah.
 
Last edited:
I think I understand what you're trying to get at, but I still feel that some clarification is in order.

In OTL, Brazil didn't get as much European immigration as it could have due to its political/economic issues. So avoiding the issues that detracted from larger levels of immigration would lead to a 'whiter' Brazil.
 
In OTL, Brazil didn't get as much European immigration as it could have due to its political/economic issues. So avoiding the issues that detracted from larger levels of immigration would lead to a 'whiter' Brazil.
Slavery-based countries/economies gain less immigration.

While after the end of slavery, Brazil pursued a process of 'whitening' in similar manner to several other countries. It received large amounts of migrants (several tens of thousands per year) from the end of slavery to the mid-20th century.

I don't think Brazil could be much whiter unless it extended further to the south or abolished slavery earlier, or Europe is devastated so much people have to leave.
 
The problem's keeping (or even taking) Brazil. There's also wankishly fast expansion, I feel, especially since fast cargo travel of the day was a whopping 10mph and treasuries and men were limited.

Why think its owner, Spain, one the Great Powers of its day, with a bigger and better navy and army would take this lying down? They'd send forces easily able to route them both at sea and land.

And I feel you're being overoptimistic about their chances given they had no maps. And long expeditions like this had a way of losing ships at the sea tech of the day.

Britain and the Dutch could colonize North America because they no competition on the ground or sea. It gets alot harder if you try to muscle in another Power's turf, especially a more established one like Spain.
 
Wut about Denmark? I read a timeline once, were they got all of Southern India and the idea of them getting a half-decent colonial empire intrigued me.

Denmark would definitely be interesting, too. I'll have to decide soon since I'll be posting an update or two later today.

American Voortrekkers? Color me very interested.

:D

I'm curious as to who shall play the role of the war-like Zulus to the Amerikaners; perhaps the Iroquois? Anyways great timeline!

Well, once they start out on their Great Trek they'll be moving away from the Iroquois, so you'll just have to wait for the ATL Zulus. ;)

The problem's keeping (or even taking) Brazil. There's also wankishly fast expansion, I feel, especially since fast cargo travel of the day was a whopping 10mph and treasuries and men were limited.

Why think its owner, Spain, one the Great Powers of its day, with a bigger and better navy and army would take this lying down? They'd send forces easily able to route them both at sea and land.

And I feel you're being overoptimistic about their chances given they had no maps. And long expeditions like this had a way of losing ships at the sea tech of the day.

Britain and the Dutch could colonize North America because they no competition on the ground or sea. It gets alot harder if you try to muscle in another Power's turf, especially a more established one like Spain.

Fifteen years during the Eighty Years War seems like an adequately plausible amount of time to conquer Brazil since Spain is preoccupied with a myriad of things and this is when the Dutch ruled the waves in OTL. It might not be uber plausible, but it's plausible enough for the purposes of this TL seeing as I didn't go into all the facets of the conquest of Brazil.
 

Faeelin

Banned
Why think its owner, Spain, one the Great Powers of its day, with a bigger and better navy and army would take this lying down? They'd send forces easily able to route them both at sea and land.

A bigger army maybe, but navy? Given the way everyone seemed to seize Spanish territories in the 17th century I'm not sure I could buy that.
 
Top