MotF 39: A People Out Of Place - Voting thread

• Jul 6, 2011

• #1

Krall

Banned

We had a nice range of good quality maps entered for this challenge, as well as a MotF first - an animated map! Let's hope the next MotF goes this well!

Entries thread:
https://www.alternatehistory.com/discussion/showthread.php?t=200235

Discussion thread:
https://www.alternatehistory.com/discussion/showthread.php?t=170373

 

• Jul 6, 2011

• #2

The Kiat

Toss up between Aesir and Scarecrow. Decisions, decisions.

 

• Jul 6, 2011

• #3

iori

Alot of great entries this round.

Ultimately for me it came down to Scarecrow's and Ares's.
My votes went to Ares, though I'm not so sure it fully met the requirements as the Goth did settle the area IOTL, with the last population (the Crimean Goths) not dying out until the 1700's.

 

• Jul 6, 2011

• #4

Turquoise Blue

I have decided finally, after much thought, to go with Scarecrow's Kentuckians as the winning People out of Place.

 

• Jul 6, 2011

• #5

Utgard96

Iori said:

Alot of great entries this round.

Ultimately for me it came down to Scarecrow's and Ares's.
My votes went to Ares, though I'm not so sure it fully met the requirements as the Goth did settle the area IOTL, with the last population (the Crimean Goths) not dying out until the 1700's.

Click to expand...

Ah, but their heartland is in OTL Romania, and besides, who says these are the Crimean Goths?

 

• Jul 6, 2011

• #6

Agemennon

I liked Jaydoh's best qualitatively, but Xwarq took it for me for originality.

 

• Jul 7, 2011

• #7

Scarecrow

I liked Zuvarq's map. It worked quite well IMHO.

 

• Jul 7, 2011

• #8

Petros >Peter Fergus<

One vote for Scarecrow.

Beautiful map, intriguing timeline. What more would you want?