MoF 26: Guns, Germs and Steel

Guns Germs and Steel

The Challenge:

Make a map that depicts a world where Europe did not achieve global domination. The map may depict the globe, or a region of the world.

The Restrictions


The POD must be before renaissance, before the OTL European expansion into the New World. However no 'Land of Red and Gold' style crop packages outside of OTL, so no POD in pre-History. The POD must be through human activity. No ASB maps. If you have any doubts about these conditions please PM me.


This round shall finish on Saturday the 27th of November.

!THIS THREAD IS FOR POSTING OF ENTRIES ONLY!

Any discussion must take place in the main thread. If you post anything other than an entry to the contest here you will be disqualified from competing in this round of the contest.

Remember to vote in the previous round of MoF
 
Last edited:
A religious map of the world, circa present day. Atenism catches on in Egypt, and remains the state religion after Akenaten dies. In time, it becomes an evangelical religion, spurring geographically isolated Egypt to expand throughout the Mediterranean and Africa. Egypt wages war against the budding Greek and Italic city-states and conquers them, thus preventing the rise of the Roman Empire and ensuring that Europe north of the Mediterranean rim is a complete backwater, with the heart of civilization instead centered on the Nile.

Other successful religions include Baalism (based in a stronger alt-Carthage called Qartag, which was bolstered by the refugees of states conquered by the Egyptian Empire) which spreads to the Americas after the fractured successor-states of the Qartaginian Empire carve up the New World amongst themselves (eventually a religious reformation and a wave of revolutions frees the Americas from colonial domination), and Astrocism (apologies to Francis E. Dec for the name), a sort of alt-Zoroastrian religion with astrological preoccupations (Medina Astrocism is an alt-Islam, but not nearly as successful). Minor religions include Zentirism (apologies to D&D) which is polytheistic in theory but heavily favors the snake god Zentir in practice, Legalism (alt-Confucianism, sort of, but ITTL there's more of the flavor of Imperial Rome: worship who you want, but respect the deified emperor, or in this case the Holy Laws), Norse paganism similar to OTL (maybe a little bloodier), Japanese ancestor worship, a strange alt-Gnostic mystery religion in Tibet, and surviving native religions in various obscure corners of the globe (more so than OTL).

Map to follow...
 
Last edited:
The map...

religion.png
 
CoVEuropeBlankMap.jpg


Notes:

Venetia and Greece is basically a successor state of Byzantium, formerly a "Byzantium-in-exile".
Volgars are ATL "Bulgarians" who conquered Byzantium before being defeated and islamized by Arabians.
 
Last edited:
Hope this is ok:
Inspired by the years of Rice and Salt I decided to go for a more realistic approch. Firslty there is the fact that several patches of Europe were barely affected OTL, thus these regions shall survive. It was also annoying how Iceland was totally ignored so that has been fixed. The Plague was made worse through different human reactions that magnified it. More widespread rebellion only worsened things.
Currently Tehran and the Native Coaliton are locked in a cold war with the Buddhist-Christian alliance and Istanbul.

rsr.png
 
The Battle of Chalons changed everything. The defeat of the Romans brought the effective end to the last great European power besides the Russians, another one would not rise till 501 after Mol'tak'anash. The Huns ravaged the empire without end, and Rome itself was sacked. Things did not approve after Attila death, his empire broke apart without him and spiralled into endless civil war as Romans, Barbarians and Huns tried to make a new start. This would continue to be the status quo for the next couple hundred years. It was no wonder that the Muslims were able to make short work of the European only those in Greece and a collation of Germans were able to stop the tide. In Americas a discovery was made that changed ever thing. Mol'tal'anash discovered gunpowder and was able to make the first guns. This lead to the Aztec to conquering much of the Central Zengia. This discovery spread across the new world. Now many years later Zengian are colonizing Africa and Europe while Asians, Middle Eastern, and Africans are colonizing Zengia. War is common between everyone as they try to establish themselves as the premier world power. But Europe is making a comeback tired of being the pawns of others new powers in Europe threaten the status quo and have adapted the new technologies of colonizers, the once huge gap has shrunken drastically, as war between colonizers and subjects seems all the more likely.

Here is the Map of Europe

Guns Germs and Steel map of world were europe is weak europe.png
 
Al Tlalitac Empire

(An idea I had at work the other day... The POD here goes back to a failure of reconquista and a divided Iberia. There is still a Grenada, and there are still barbarians from the North occasionally invading the Iberia. So Europe did not "discover" the New World; instead, mariners from the Maghreb did.)

The Al Tlalitac Empire was founded in the year 1607. Its beginnings go back a century before. Sailors from the Old World traded with the Indian nations along the Gulf Coast dating back to the 1550s, when Moorish sailors first crossed the ocean and discovered a New World. The Maghrebi extend in North America was small, much like the Vikings in Greenland and Vinland.

Nations on the Gulf Coast were trapped between the sea and the brutal Aztecs further inland. Many of the nations were vassals, and more fell to the Aztecs during their coastal expansions of the 1560s. Moors established trading posts at Maghrebad, Mohammedia and Tejabad, selling their wares for Mexican gold. Among the items traded were a few firearms, but more importantly the art of metalsmithy.

With an influx of Indians into the Maghrebi trading posts, true towns began to develop. Moors intermarried with Indians, and many of the natives who had business dealings with the Moors converted to Islam, as well as learned to speak and read Arabic. Arabic served as an alternative common langauge among the various tribes.

By 1601, the Aztec Emperor saw the Maghrebi as a threat, and launched campaigns against them. Maghrebad was sacked and most of its inhabitants marched back to the city of Mexico, where they were sacraficed to the Aztec's gods. One of the Indians to escape the Aztecs was a man named Tlalitac. Upon learning his brother's fate on the alter of the Sun God, Tlalitac swore vengance and declared a Jihad against the Aztecs.

With the support of Moorish colonists further north, Tlalitac rallied various subject tribes of the Aztecs. With superior iron armor and spears, the Jihad easily defeated Aztec outposts in the year 1604 along the Gulf Coast, which in turn caused the defection of more of the Aztec's vassals and even allies. For two years, the Jihad battled the Aztecs in Eastern Mexico, until finally pushing them back to the Valley of Mexico. Aztec rule was so brutal that it lasted only until a powerful man united the oppressed against their tormentor.

Along with steel weapons, Tlalitac's Moorish allies brought along cannon, to lay siege to Mexico. The siege lasted for seven months, and did not come to an end until the Moors dismantled their ships, and shipped them up to the great lake surrounding Mexico, and rebuilt them. This allowed for an amphibious assualt against the weakened and famished Aztec Capital. The Capital fell after five days of bloodletting, during which virtually the entire population was wiped out.

Captives and survivors were given the choice to convert or die. The Priests did not even have this choice, as they were summarily beheaded before the ruins of their temples. After the fall, Tlalitac ordered the city razed to the ground, and not to leave two stones atop each other, that every Idol in the city be melted down or shattered. The great lake was filled in by the rubble. Gold from the city was divided among the allied conquerors.

Atop the ruins of Mexico, Tlalitac declared himself Emperor of an Islamic Empire, and that all under his rule will worship Allah and not the Gods of old. The new Empire will rule under the Sharia, and no more would subject tribes be held in bondage or under the Aztec tyranny. Over the course of his life, Tlalitac expanded his Empire to the Pacific Coast, as well as north to the Al Misippi River. The Empire was nearly destroyed after his death in 1621, when his sons fought a bitter civil war for control of the Empire.

Tlalitac Empire.png
 
"I gave my name, and looked about. Deal table in the middle, plain chairs all round the walls, on one end a large shining map, marked with all the colours of a rainbow. There was a vast amount of red -- good to see at any time, because one knows that some real work is done in there, a deuce of a lot of blue, a little green, smears of orange, and, on the East Coast, a purple patch, to show where the jolly pioneers of progress drink the jolly lager-beer. However, I wasn't going into any of these. I was going into the yellow. Dead in the centre. And the river was there -- fascinating -- deadly -- like a snake. Ough!"-Into the Heart of Darkness, Chinụalụmọgụ Achebe, Yoruba National Press

MOF II.png
 
Okedokee: a world where The Hindu states of India avoided getting that "sea travel contaminates you" meme and eventually developed a more nuanced approach to the caste thing (although Untouchables are still in the sh*t). Islam is forestalled by a heretical offshoot of Judaism that is less successful at spreading outside the Arabian peninsula. Meanwhile, in Europe, the Pope gets squashed by stronger western Emperors and ceasaropapism in in like Flynn, only for the Mega-HRE to attract *Mongol invaders who find it a jucier-looking target than OTL's western Europe.

The Hindu Indians had their Age of Discovery, picked up the printing press and proper paper-making from the Chinese, and had their version of the Scientific Revolution, albiet a rather different animal from the OTL European one. A dominant and outward-looking India made Hinduism a religion of conversion, although its more about getting your Karma right than specifics of the number of arms or noses of God.

Technology is roughly 1930s, and things are a bit dieselpunk, with dirigibles, propellor aircraft, big-ass battleships, and lots of trains. (Television has recently arrived, and the Hindus are already making big-budget musical numbers :D )

India is of course seen as the Center of Civilization, although Hindu Indonesia and SE Asia is comparably advanced, as are some of their overseas colonies and settlements. The Persians, whose autocratic state (which does have an efficient test-taking bureaucracy, copied from the Chinese model) has managed to (mostly) keep up technologically through centuries of warfare, are developed enough to be considered "semi-civilized", as are the Chinese, who have recently had a revolution in which a modernizing militarist regime has taken over.

The Ishamelites Iudeans (to be distingushed from the Isaachite Iudeans, which form scattered populations in the Zarathustran and Hindu lands) are barbarians (that is a Greek-derived word, but the Indians have come up with their own terms of contempt for foreigners), as are the Christian Europeans, most of which live under either outright theocracies (the "protestant" antions arising from the ejection of the *Mongols) or absolutist ("catholic") monarchies with the church in their back pocket. Europeans were largely stuck in the 16th century sans a renaissance, but had enough organization and guns that, combined with their geographical distance, the Indians largely left them alone until the era of steam and rapid-firing guns arrived: the last century has been rather traumatic for the Europeans and their fellow Christians in North Africa ( a generally more easy-going bunch).

Several large Indian and Indonesian colonies have been established in the Americas, although Northeast America was distant enough and poor enough to have largely been left alone until fairly recently, allowing local Indians time to develop enough immunities to have a fighting chance, although they are further bedeviled by adventurous Europeans seeking their fortune and land in the mysterious "devil-worshippers continent" to the west. The Kechwana Empire, a former Indonesian colony, is unified under a new religion arising from a hybridization of Hindu and native Andean beliefs, and having kicked out their former colonial masters, are busy modernizing and have a acquisitive eye on still-Indonesian ("Yahyva") territories to the north and south.

Bruce
 
And here's the map to go with that.

Bruce

(PS - a few names stolen from maps by Diamond and a couple others. I am as ignorant as a potato of Indian languages)

ContestGuns.png
 
Last edited:
I still remember the day we left the Isles behind. I watched the Imperial Flag be replaced with the English flag that day, and that day, an era came to an end. Colonialism was gasping for breath. I would say that the end began when we allowed the Scots to leave, but this, this was when the funeral bell tolled. By 306, Imperialism was practically dead. Still, even for all the bad things that it caused, Britannia could have been worse. It could have been like Frankia.-Exert from The End of an Era, the memoirs of Viceroy Adulyadej, published 311 years After the Battle of Lisbon (2010 AD)

Thai Britain Independence Years.png
 
Last edited:
All add info in later
AGGASWHv2.png


For whatever reason the edit buttonwas missing. Basicly more nval travel means more diffusion of ideas and foods. Vinland survives and iron weapons diffuse throughout the new world. The Europeans try to colonize but are mostly unsucessful. In 1800 the british colonies along with occupied Vinland rebel. The Iroquois and Cherrokee help.
 
Top