MoF 22: The Mouse That Roared Voting Thread

Whose map was best?

  • Jman

    Votes: 25 36.8%

  • Teleology

    Votes: 4 5.9%

  • Akkismat

    Votes: 34 50.0%

  • The Kiat

    Votes: 4 5.9%

  • Mark 4 Morrel Barrel

    Votes: 1 1.5%
  • Total voters
    68
  • Poll closed .
iori

iori

Given how few entries this one got, perhaps I should'nt make MoF topic suggestions anymore. :p


My vote went to Jman, while Akissmat's was superior in terms of graphics and such, it was confusing and had to much going on, whereas Jman's, while not simplistic, was easy to understand.
 

Akkismat

Iori said:
My vote went to Jman, while Akissmat's was superior in terms of graphics and such, it was confusing and had to much going on, whereas Jman's, while not simplistic, was easy to understand.
Click to expand...

Hi Iori, sorry to hear you found my map confusing and non-simplistic.
Just wondering: What did you find confusing exactly?
The ATL-setting, the battle map, the campaign map, the combination of a battle map with a campaign map?
 
LSCatilina

LSCatilina

I like Akissmat map, but i think the colors choice are not quite good, difficult to see clearly and quickly.
Aslo, it is really in the subject of the map? I mean, Macedonia+Corinth League it's quite powerful against italic cities, even more or less strongly united. This very good map deserves, i think, a little more explanation, to enjoy all this AH work.

My vote to Jman, for originality and clearty.
 

Akkismat

LSCatilina said:
I like Akissmat map, but i think the colors choice are not quite good, difficult to see clearly and quickly.
Aslo, it is really in the subject of the map? I mean, Macedonia+Corinth League it's quite powerful against italic cities, even more or less strongly united. This very good map deserves, i think, a little more explanation, to enjoy all this AH work.

My vote to Jman, for originality and clearty.
Click to expand...


Hi, appreciate the feedback.
I tried to make the map a bit plainish with a focus on the different leagues and nations. I thought making the campaign map stand out too much would clash with the battle map next to it. I will keep the critique regarding colouring in mind with my next designs.

About the Macedonia+Corinth vs. Italic Cities: I forgot to mention anywhere, I just found out, that I pictured the mapped Italician campaign of Alexander to be after an extensive Asian campaign. So want I wanted to picture actually is a Asia-conquering Alexander coming back to "liberate/pacify" the Italian cities, with a focus on the small Latin League (together with it's allies) against the Alexandrians. In this ATL, Alexander should have defeated the Italians with ease, but what I wanted to show is that even with the 5 battles won by Alexander, he still lost the war against the Latin League.
 

Faralis

Bah, I cant vote for Uriel´s badass Pope ... Akkismat, its my chosen one, then. I hope he will not start flying or something like that ...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top
Top